Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thread 27 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film?

790 replies

DisappointedReader · 25/06/2026 20:01

NO POSTS PLEASE UNTIL THREAD 26 IS FULL

Please see the OP of Thread 25 for all the links to The Observer's reporting and podcast series, our threads one to 24 and so on:
Thread 25 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film? | Mumsnet

New posters joining us in the genuine spirit of our civil discourse are always welcome. It would be helpful to get the background from some of Investigative Journalist Chloe Hadjimatheou's excellent exposé items before posting. Chloe's podcast series for The Observer 'The Walkers' covers most things:
The Walkers: The real Salt Path | The Observer
Another suggestion:
BBC Sounds - Secrets of the Salt Path - Available Episodes
To all - Please be extremely cautious when it comes to naming or implicating people and addresses not in the public eye or with no direct connection to the story, especially where details are unclear or still emerging. Remember, even Hollywood rabbits attract the odd flea: please do not engage with drive-by scolders who seem to have their own agenda and seek to derail. Avoid @'ing and quoting them as - from experience - this will only encourage them back to the threads. For nearly a year we have done amazingly well together for 26 very interesting, very serious and very silly, threads so far. I can't be here as much as I'd like so all help with keeping our discussion walking along in our usual reasonable and respectful fashion is very welcome.

We are still here after 26,000 posts and fast approaching our one year anniversary together on 6th July 2026, 12 months on from the start of our first thread in response to Our Chloe's somewhat stunning initial exposé. Little did we know what else would come out. Our longevity comes as both a total surprise and a pleasure (mostly!). We've seen charabancers come and go, come back again, delurk and join us for the first time. All are welcome. Threads have both filled up in a day and moved at a more stately pace. Thank you everyone for sharing your time, thoughts, opinions, experience, questions, sleuthing (there's that word!), kindness (there's that other word!) and great humour with me and with each other. As ever, as we embark on our 27th thread riding the community charabanc - this time all holding our brollies and fans aloft for much-needed shade and breeze - keep to the path, no saltiness, eat fudge and drink cider, (but not too much in the current heatwave).

NO POSTS PLEASE UNTIL THREAD 26 IS FULL:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5506717-thread-26-to-feel-disappointed-and-disgusted-and-vindicated-now-too-after-reading-this-in-the-observer-about-the-author-and-her-husband-from-the-salt-path-book-and-film?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
102
HatStickBoots · 06/10/2026 18:42

BrandiedAromatics · 06/10/2026 17:02

She's also completely lost the connection to the Wainwright 50 year anniversary and her inaccurate claim that they discussed doing the walk, in the year it was first published, when they first met (she was 10, Tim 12). What a load of cobblers!

Edited

Yes, thank you. I’d forgotten that detail! I don’t believe any of that early back story as she tells it now.

HatStickBoots · 06/10/2026 18:40

Completely agree with all of you. Yes, in her writing she has been very proud of her connection with Moth. They’re not like other couples she has boasted. The romanticised version of their relationship on the page made his imminent death all the more fraught with melancholy. Melodrama, she excels at but it’s frequent and exhausting and seems to be the driving factor in all her books and the successful manipulation of everyone she has ever met. The complete absence of it now shows (if ever more proof were needed) that it never meant a thing. She ought to be mentioning Moth, presenting a united front. Perhaps he is sick of it all and refuses to engage with it any longer. Perhaps he does want a divorce, which would make her ridiculous efforts to keep his interest absolutely null and void. What irony too. However, the IG posts have put forward the idea of a team, sticking together. The four hares. But only one hare engages with the audience 🤔

Oeufs · 06/10/2026 17:42

PullTheBricksDown · 06/10/2026 17:31

He won't have left her. Primarily because she's the one with the cash. But also because it's now a brand partnership as well as a romantic one. My theory about his disappearance is simply that it's less harmful to the brand for him to be out of sight, allowing RW to spin the latest segment of the tale, than for him to be out and about looking hale and hearty.

Well, wouldn't he get some of the dosh as a division of marital assets in a divorce?

I don't know UK divorce law, but wouldn't the courts potentially approach the division of marital assets of a long marriage, with a spouse past retirement age, hence no future earning potential, and in poor health (!) and no capacity for a mortgage, in order to ensure he's adequately housed and has an adequate income? Which might be quite a lump of cash, especially if 'maintaining the standard of living he'd had in the marriage was a consideration...?

PullTheBricksDown · 06/10/2026 17:31

He won't have left her. Primarily because she's the one with the cash. But also because it's now a brand partnership as well as a romantic one. My theory about his disappearance is simply that it's less harmful to the brand for him to be out of sight, allowing RW to spin the latest segment of the tale, than for him to be out and about looking hale and hearty.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/10/2026 17:12

Oeufs · 06/10/2026 17:09

It's just that you'd expect her to make the occasional wistful remark about lovely, dying Moth on her solo walking Instagram posts -- the poignancy of one pair of boots outside the tent where once there were two, the sadness of having enough space in the one-man tent etc.

(And, lest I sound incredibly insensitive, I'm not mocking the sadness and nostalgia of bereaved people, just people who are pre-emptively cosplaying bereavement for cash.)

Yes, the total absence of Moth is rather puzzling, isn't it? Considering that she absolutely worships the man, the fact that there isn't even the odd reference to him is strange. Maybe she wants people to think he's dead?

When a lot of people who truly believe the books must be quite concerned for his ongoing health, you'd think she'd at least want to reassure them that he's struggling on manfully, using walks to the end of the garden and back to sustain him. But it's as though he's been erased from her life altogether.

Maybe he has left her?

Oeufs · 06/10/2026 17:09

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/10/2026 16:20

I strongly suspect that Moth is being kept out of the public eye so she can stick to the 'he's ill, he's going to die and leave me alone, I have to come to terms with being without him' line for OWH.

I mean, it's not an ACTUAL lie; Moth has some ill health - nothing that wouldn't be expected in a man of his age, but it's illness nonetheless. He IS going to die, because absolutely everyone is, and musing about life as a widow is a perfectly natural activity for any woman at all who is married. So as long as she's made it vague enough, then I can see her swinging OWH that way.

After all, if nobody ever sees him, then how can they say whether he's ill or not?

It's just that you'd expect her to make the occasional wistful remark about lovely, dying Moth on her solo walking Instagram posts -- the poignancy of one pair of boots outside the tent where once there were two, the sadness of having enough space in the one-man tent etc.

(And, lest I sound incredibly insensitive, I'm not mocking the sadness and nostalgia of bereaved people, just people who are pre-emptively cosplaying bereavement for cash.)

BrandiedAromatics · 06/10/2026 17:02

HatStickBoots · 06/10/2026 16:50

Yes, the ol’ Schrödinger’s Moth debacle! 😄
I think it was a mistake to have delayed the publication of OWH because its potential to be another blockbuster for all the wrong reasons was surely at its highest? If Sal had held on to her temper instead of savagely losing it, but that’s not her way. However, delaying it gave the lawyers their chance to go through it and probably advise that if that version went out it would be a dreadful mistake. I imagine she’d continued to double down on the existing lies that were set out in the previous three books which had since been disputed. The mood of the book was a complete contrast to the happy, glowing mood of the author promoting it. That mysterious “you’ll have to wait and see!” could almost be said with a cheeky wink and is not the attitude that is portrayed on the back cover.

She's also completely lost the connection to the Wainwright 50 year anniversary and her inaccurate claim that they discussed doing the walk, in the year it was first published, when they first met (she was 10, Tim 12). What a load of cobblers!

HatStickBoots · 06/10/2026 16:50

Yes, the ol’ Schrödinger’s Moth debacle! 😄
I think it was a mistake to have delayed the publication of OWH because its potential to be another blockbuster for all the wrong reasons was surely at its highest? If Sal had held on to her temper instead of savagely losing it, but that’s not her way. However, delaying it gave the lawyers their chance to go through it and probably advise that if that version went out it would be a dreadful mistake. I imagine she’d continued to double down on the existing lies that were set out in the previous three books which had since been disputed. The mood of the book was a complete contrast to the happy, glowing mood of the author promoting it. That mysterious “you’ll have to wait and see!” could almost be said with a cheeky wink and is not the attitude that is portrayed on the back cover.

BrandiedAromatics · 06/10/2026 16:43

ABettybackintheday · 06/10/2026 16:11

.

You are most welcome 💮

BrandiedAromatics · 06/10/2026 16:38

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/10/2026 16:20

I strongly suspect that Moth is being kept out of the public eye so she can stick to the 'he's ill, he's going to die and leave me alone, I have to come to terms with being without him' line for OWH.

I mean, it's not an ACTUAL lie; Moth has some ill health - nothing that wouldn't be expected in a man of his age, but it's illness nonetheless. He IS going to die, because absolutely everyone is, and musing about life as a widow is a perfectly natural activity for any woman at all who is married. So as long as she's made it vague enough, then I can see her swinging OWH that way.

After all, if nobody ever sees him, then how can they say whether he's ill or not?

Yes, he had been mostly kept tucked away when RW was most in demand. It was the film premiere where Moth couldn't resist taking to the stage - but remember none of the journalists, even the local one in Cornwall, were allowed to ask him any questions.

One of the interviews I found the most gobsmacking was the one iirc at Waterstones, Canterbury. When RW confidently assures her captive audience that if Moth puts in a decent walk the positive effects can last him for a year, or some such. If you believe that then you believe anything ..... but I think they must have steadily dwindled.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/10/2026 16:20

I strongly suspect that Moth is being kept out of the public eye so she can stick to the 'he's ill, he's going to die and leave me alone, I have to come to terms with being without him' line for OWH.

I mean, it's not an ACTUAL lie; Moth has some ill health - nothing that wouldn't be expected in a man of his age, but it's illness nonetheless. He IS going to die, because absolutely everyone is, and musing about life as a widow is a perfectly natural activity for any woman at all who is married. So as long as she's made it vague enough, then I can see her swinging OWH that way.

After all, if nobody ever sees him, then how can they say whether he's ill or not?

ABettybackintheday · 06/10/2026 16:11

.

HatStickBoots · 06/10/2026 15:03

😂 please please please do the rewrite! 🙏🏻

On Winter Hill was true surely and nothing has changed? So why would it need to be rewritten? Actually there are so many elephants in the room now it’s difficult to put the kettle on and I think Moth’s been devoured by one of them!

Oeufs · 06/10/2026 14:25

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/10/2026 13:18

What worries me is that the new version of OWH probably won't address Our Chloe's expose. I suspect that Sal's way of dealing with it is to pretend it never happened, and that no reference will be made to it at all, except possibly in an obique 'bad people, jealous of my success, tried to make up things about me and I was miserable and so I had to go into hiding. Mental health, you know...' which is going to be the excuse for the late publication of OWH. Rather than the fact that she's had to rewrite it, removing all references to the agonising over Moth's imminent death and his rapidly failing health.

I have no idea how she's going to explain his absence in the walk. Maybe he has to stay home to mind the dog? But 'I had to do a solo walk in winter (despite any sane person knowing that winter is the worst possible time to do the C2C so it was never going to be a breeze) totally solo and musing over my solo state because my walking companion had to stay home because we couldn't get a dogsitter' isn't really a headline grabber, is it?

Grin

Yes, I mean, I have no idea what kind of sleight of hand a future book, if there is one, will need to pull off. I mean is there that much handwaving in the world to get past the whole 'I am a serial thief, embezzler and forger and a chronic liar who fabricated my equally light-fingered DH's illness -- sorry, did I not mention this before?' thing?

I mean, what do you do in SW's position?

(1) Publish your unpublished book as was and ignore it all

(2) Publish your unpublished book with a new introduction in which you make cryptic reference to meanies and smear campaigns and how you'd never claimed to have told the whole story of your life in TSP, and dammit, it was your emotional truth...

(3) Rewrite your unpublished book so that it looks as if you ran away solo to walk the Coast to Coast Path to lick your wounds after the meanies were mean, only that's not going to work because that walk was all about wading through snow, and the Observer story broke in July

(4) write an entirely different book about revisiting the SWCP by yourself, using your Instragram walk and cutting and pasting in as much of the leaden purple prose about nature as possible from OWH, and just deleting the bits about snow and cold

(5) write a memoir that bears some resemblance to RL past events as CH alleges them, but which makes you and TW out to be the blameless and adorable victims of other people's suspicion: Mum gave me that money and forgot! I just made a few accounting errors at the Hemmingses! I didn't skip bail, I just needed to get away and be in nature by myself for a while because I am a Shy Woodland Creature, remember! We THOUGHT Moth was dying, definitely! It was that tight-lipped consultant's fault! We didn't lose Pen y Maes because of my criminal past, we lost it for an entirely different reason I can't talk about! Bill Cole was totally unreasonable to try to force us to accept help to make the cider he'd employed us to make! We have trust issues and can't be around strangers!

God knows. Grin

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/10/2026 13:18

Oeufs · 06/10/2026 13:01

Well, they'll have to, won't they? I think that if they were going to release OWH, as written before the Observer story broke, they would have had to do it almost immediately, certainly within a few months of its original release date, and send out to distributors/bookshops some kind of extra introduction to be physically put into each copy, or something. And almost certainly SW doing a big mea culpa press campaign. Only she was 'too upset' by the allegations and was buying time.

But after so long a delay, I imagine the expectation is now that the next book will have to actually include the release of the Observer story, and not just be the long-delayed release of a book whose subject matter (a walk and a dying spouse) has been made obsolete by Chloe H.

Edited

What worries me is that the new version of OWH probably won't address Our Chloe's expose. I suspect that Sal's way of dealing with it is to pretend it never happened, and that no reference will be made to it at all, except possibly in an obique 'bad people, jealous of my success, tried to make up things about me and I was miserable and so I had to go into hiding. Mental health, you know...' which is going to be the excuse for the late publication of OWH. Rather than the fact that she's had to rewrite it, removing all references to the agonising over Moth's imminent death and his rapidly failing health.

I have no idea how she's going to explain his absence in the walk. Maybe he has to stay home to mind the dog? But 'I had to do a solo walk in winter (despite any sane person knowing that winter is the worst possible time to do the C2C so it was never going to be a breeze) totally solo and musing over my solo state because my walking companion had to stay home because we couldn't get a dogsitter' isn't really a headline grabber, is it?

Oeufs · 06/10/2026 13:01

ThompsonTwin · 06/10/2026 12:40

Is it economically viable for PRH to pulp all the old copies of OWH and enable SW to rewrite the book with an addendum, adding her gloss to the events of the last 15 months, in order to bring it all "up to date"?

Well, they'll have to, won't they? I think that if they were going to release OWH, as written before the Observer story broke, they would have had to do it almost immediately, certainly within a few months of its original release date, and send out to distributors/bookshops some kind of extra introduction to be physically put into each copy, or something. And almost certainly SW doing a big mea culpa press campaign. Only she was 'too upset' by the allegations and was buying time.

But after so long a delay, I imagine the expectation is now that the next book will have to actually include the release of the Observer story, and not just be the long-delayed release of a book whose subject matter (a walk and a dying spouse) has been made obsolete by Chloe H.

ThompsonTwin · 06/10/2026 12:40

Is it economically viable for PRH to pulp all the old copies of OWH and enable SW to rewrite the book with an addendum, adding her gloss to the events of the last 15 months, in order to bring it all "up to date"?

Oeufs · 06/10/2026 12:33

by not cancelling them, Penguin are promoting the idea that an author’s crimes, fraud, hypocrisy and lies don’t matter

I agree, but look at Jeffrey Archer! Found guilty of perjury and perverting the course of justice and sentenced to four years, he also admitted to insider trading though he was never prosecuted on the grounds of lack of evidence, he admitted to the theft of several suits from a shop in Toronto decades after it happened, was investigated for the misappropriation of funds from a charity he set up, was accused of fiddling his expense claims when he worked for a different UN childbirth charity, appears to have blagged his way into Oxford via faked A-levels and a faked US degree, was suspected of funding a coup in Africa, used sex workers etc etc etc.

In many cases he actually went after the newspapers who published these stories and won damages in court which he later had to repay when evidence emerged that the initial claims had been true.

And yet he continued to publish novels, short stories, diaries, plays and children's fiction between the mid-seventies and his death.

I suppose the difference is most of his output was (bad but inexplicably popular) fiction, rather than memoir that supposedly recounted true events.

HatStickBoots · 06/10/2026 11:29

Oeufs · 05/10/2026 21:16

I assume it came down to the legal cases and threatened legal cases, and the potential for future cases from Harper Collins employees who’d been harassed by Walliams being potentially bigger than any action he could take, and/or the cost of paying him off. They’d already paid out huge sums to employees who’d had to deal with his behaviour, plus a new, female CEO came in and decided to chop him, and later his back list.

Plus it must have made a difference that he’d already been fired from Britain’s Got Talent, and that there were recordings and transcripts of him sexualising female contestants. If they’d kept publishing him, they’d have been endorsing someone who had been fired/cancelled by another high-profile organisation. His books were a goldmine, but the potential damage was huge.

Whereas, if you except the medical research charity and Arvon, no one else is cancelling SW, and no one seems to be pursuing her legally. Bluntly, no one else is making PRH look bad for continuing to be associated with SW.

Very good points thank you. I agree that with DW there really wasn’t any choice. I do think that the Walkers have made fools of everybody who worked with them on those books and the film and that by not cancelling them, Penguin are promoting the idea that an author’s crimes, fraud, hypocrisy and lies don’t matter. At the time of the wild camping trip along the SWCP, Moth didn’t have CBD and hadn’t just been diagnosed with it, we know this as a fact. This is not inspirational stuff. People might as well be inspired by a cartoon as a fictional account of a miracle cure for an incurable disease.
Reading the actors’ comments recently, filled me with despair. Sitting on a perch and having to be protective of their work because of the unfortunate reality that’s swilling all around and threatening to engulf their careers, seems a little cowardly to me. Their careers have never been at stake here. Both had been moved by the couple’s story and seemed to have invested into them on a personal level, admiring and applauding them. On the other hand, I’ve been thinking that as actors immerse themselves into worlds of make believe, that it’s easy for them to forget what happens on the other side of the curtains and it’s not relevant to them. Reading lines from a page and dressing up to portray the person on the page is what they were paid to do and in that respect, they got it right. Of course “RW” was ‘guarded’ and noticeably different to the person on the page and that’s because she was! But Gillian has never touched upon that aspect since. Actors/Hollywood stars undoubtedly move on very quickly and their lives must be so full that a year later they have both properly detached themselves from the people in hiding. I imagine that if they had publicly commented last summer, their emotions would have been less easy to control. The film had been eagerly anticipated and released just a short while before the news exploded! If I were to watch the film again now I would feel a range of emotions that would spoil the experience. I suppose the film will be written off as a bad loss but the Raynor Winn persona still plods on, pretending to be real. Another book waits in the wings to tell another story of loss and loneliness from a soon-to-be widow’s perspective… while back in the real world her words have no meaning and in yet another vein altogether the IG account seems to celebrate being solo and alone!

Since I wrote this (in draft) the thread has moved along! So many interesting posts from all of you. I am also intrigued by the removal of Moth.

Oeufs · 06/10/2026 10:24

Well, that's what I mean, really, @BrandiedAromatics -- she's no longer dropping those little mentions, or implying there's anything sad or novel about the fact that she's walking alone. TW is no longer even an offstage presence. It's like he never existed.

That she was walking the Coast to Coast Path solo, without TW, was very much the tagline for OWH, and she said several times in interviews in the run up to the TSP premiere that we would have to wait to read OWH to discover why he wasn't with her.

(I mean, if the whole thing wasn't a scam, and he was actually a dying man who was suddenly deteriorating, it would explain his absence from a challenging walk in January in poor weather. It would not, however, explain why his purportedly devoted wife decided to leave him dying at home and took off arbitrarily for a challenging walk in January in unusually poor weather, because 'I needed a walk to put in a book' looks a bit calculating in the supposed circumstances...)

But if we accept that the Instagram account is a lowstakes way of keeping the 'Raynor Winn' brand ticking over until her next book offering, the total absence of any mention of TW is a significant deviation from the brand. I notice that very few of the comments, since she reopened comments, mention him either.

Poor, tragic Moth. One minute you're a national treasure, heroically running up beaches in your underpants while confounding medical science as you drag one leg around the SWCP and are fanboyed by Jason Isaacs, the next you're forgotten. Grin

BrandiedAromatics · 06/10/2026 10:01

@Oeufs Because you’d think that a beloved, dying spouse would merit the occasional mention, even if not photographed, or that there would be the occasional ‘we’ attached to some banality about sunsets.

RW has always tantalised us with the promise of Moth. That tension has seen them through all of these books. Think of the interviews: she always seemed to offer a "he's fine, a lot better than he has been for months, actually". It always seemed to follow that pattern.

It reminds me of studying the Canaanite religion - Moth is the god who overcomes the Sea and Death, the dying and rising sun god, the posing up a storm god.

The main body of TSP is bookended by this superhuman. The beginning

Moth ran up the beach in the moonlight in a ripped pair of underpants that he’d been wearing for five days straight, holding a fully erected tent above his head. It was a miracle.

The end

Moth would begin a degree without any real hope of surviving to the end of it. I would look for a job and start writing.

And so it goes .....

Oeufs · 06/10/2026 09:41

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/10/2026 09:14

But the books will already be printed. The cover has been advertised, and I suspect they've got a warehouse full of them ready to go. This, I think, might be part of the problem, that Sal had already written her heart-tugging lone walk while pondering the loss of Moth. It was edited, first run printed and ready to go. Then Moth was bouncing around on stages and being pally with Jason Isaacs and obviously not dying; the whole scandal broke and the release had to be delayed. There was a lot of talk of Sal having to stop writing it because she was so traumatised by all the lies being told, which was why they said release was delayed, but in reality it was all ready to go, and they held it back just to let the fuss die down.

Absolutely to all that. One wonders if there was a behind-the-scenes fight between SW/her agent and PRH over whether OWH should be released as planned, or only delayed a few weeks or months, and/or whether OWH could be released as was/ needed a self-exonerating introduction, but could otherwise go out as it stood, or required a total rewrite, and whether, if so, it could still be released under the OWH title.

It seems to me that, in delaying it so long, they’ve put paid to the possibility of the ‘original’ OWH being released at all, surely? Even if there are tens of thousands of printed copies in a warehouse somewhere, and an author who steadfastly maintains every word she’s written is true and Chloe H was conducting a smear campaign….

I wonder at what point you pulp existing print copies of something that can never be released? I confess it came to mind when there was that recent story about copies of Charles Spencer’s Diana book being stolen from a lorry.

I remain very interested in the total deletion of TW from Instagram. Not just no photos, but once she resumed writing captions, where she uses pronouns, it’s always, pointedly, ‘I’. ‘Back where I feel most at home.’ ‘A few characters I met along the way’. ‘Just me and my rucksack’.

Is it related to his deletion from OWH, or purely to sidestep questions of his continued good health? To imply he’s now far too unwell to walk? Or could they have actually split?

Because you’d think that a beloved, dying spouse would merit the occasional mention, even if not photographed, or that there would be the occasional ‘we’ attached to some banality about sunsets.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/10/2026 09:14

AlwaysRightISwear · 06/10/2026 08:34

They would still have printing and distribution costs. And whatever publicity they think would not be counterproductive.

But the books will already be printed. The cover has been advertised, and I suspect they've got a warehouse full of them ready to go. This, I think, might be part of the problem, that Sal had already written her heart-tugging lone walk while pondering the loss of Moth. It was edited, first run printed and ready to go. Then Moth was bouncing around on stages and being pally with Jason Isaacs and obviously not dying; the whole scandal broke and the release had to be delayed. There was a lot of talk of Sal having to stop writing it because she was so traumatised by all the lies being told, which was why they said release was delayed, but in reality it was all ready to go, and they held it back just to let the fuss die down.

AlwaysRightISwear · 06/10/2026 08:34

They would still have printing and distribution costs. And whatever publicity they think would not be counterproductive.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/10/2026 08:29

@BrandiedAromatics If you order the book from Penguin you will get the thick paper, normal paperback option. The books in The Works are a different printing, they are produced more cheaply which is why The Works can sell them more cheaply. They aren't remaindered copies of unsuccessful books, they are books that sell successfully from their publisher and The Works (who supply garden centres and other similar outlets) buy the rights to publish their own version.

@PullTheBricksDown Exactly, and this is why I think threads like this are so important. Otherwise, PRH will just wait for the fuss to die down and nobody to be bothered any more and bring out OWH, hoping that everyone will just shrug and let it go. They've paid for that book already, as part of her contract. As you say, Sal's made her money, she can sit back and live on it forever. Although it can't be cheap to rent an entire estate and her earnings must be dropping now she's not doing constant publicity.