Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thread 27 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film?

790 replies

DisappointedReader · 25/06/2026 20:01

NO POSTS PLEASE UNTIL THREAD 26 IS FULL

Please see the OP of Thread 25 for all the links to The Observer's reporting and podcast series, our threads one to 24 and so on:
Thread 25 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film? | Mumsnet

New posters joining us in the genuine spirit of our civil discourse are always welcome. It would be helpful to get the background from some of Investigative Journalist Chloe Hadjimatheou's excellent exposé items before posting. Chloe's podcast series for The Observer 'The Walkers' covers most things:
The Walkers: The real Salt Path | The Observer
Another suggestion:
BBC Sounds - Secrets of the Salt Path - Available Episodes
To all - Please be extremely cautious when it comes to naming or implicating people and addresses not in the public eye or with no direct connection to the story, especially where details are unclear or still emerging. Remember, even Hollywood rabbits attract the odd flea: please do not engage with drive-by scolders who seem to have their own agenda and seek to derail. Avoid @'ing and quoting them as - from experience - this will only encourage them back to the threads. For nearly a year we have done amazingly well together for 26 very interesting, very serious and very silly, threads so far. I can't be here as much as I'd like so all help with keeping our discussion walking along in our usual reasonable and respectful fashion is very welcome.

We are still here after 26,000 posts and fast approaching our one year anniversary together on 6th July 2026, 12 months on from the start of our first thread in response to Our Chloe's somewhat stunning initial exposé. Little did we know what else would come out. Our longevity comes as both a total surprise and a pleasure (mostly!). We've seen charabancers come and go, come back again, delurk and join us for the first time. All are welcome. Threads have both filled up in a day and moved at a more stately pace. Thank you everyone for sharing your time, thoughts, opinions, experience, questions, sleuthing (there's that word!), kindness (there's that other word!) and great humour with me and with each other. As ever, as we embark on our 27th thread riding the community charabanc - this time all holding our brollies and fans aloft for much-needed shade and breeze - keep to the path, no saltiness, eat fudge and drink cider, (but not too much in the current heatwave).

NO POSTS PLEASE UNTIL THREAD 26 IS FULL:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5506717-thread-26-to-feel-disappointed-and-disgusted-and-vindicated-now-too-after-reading-this-in-the-observer-about-the-author-and-her-husband-from-the-salt-path-book-and-film?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
102
Freshsocks · 29/06/2026 12:42

I totally agree @Vroomfondleswaistcoat, people bought TSP book in good faith, the readers are not the one's who should be feeling ashamed, Sally Walker should. I don't think Sally still gets it and she probably never will, people felt compassion for her and Moth because of the dreadful situation she portrayed to the readers, many things were overlooked because she was perceived as an ordinary woman writing a book, she was not judged in the same way that a professional writer would have been.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 29/06/2026 09:36

@HatStickBoots 'I would never ever have bought this book under normal circumstances. Never.'

I don't think any justification of the purchase is necessary. No one should ever feel ashamed of their reading material! In fact, I have been tempted on more than one occasion to read TSP (I've only read extracts up to now) and only the fact that I've only got limited reading time and many other books ahead of it in the queue has stopped me.

ETA; I would, of course, only read a charity shop purchase or borrowed copy, that woman is not getting a penny out of me.

HatStickBoots · 29/06/2026 09:30

Normallyinthepool · 29/06/2026 07:55

Agreed!

Her descriptions of being judged for looking a bit scruffy on walks never made any sense to me

Nor did so many of their supposed interactions with locals

Exactly. Those were the bits that didn’t make sense to me either, less so than Moth’s diagnosis in fact. I could believe in a story where a man and woman were so desperate, that they would embark upon a journey like that, however ill advised under those circumstances. It seemed like a natural reaction following the anger and disbelief of Moth’s diagnosis. The adrenaline fuelled fear that built up while packing up and emptying out their hard worked for home and hiding from the pounding on its door, could well lead to that sort of decision if not in your right mind. Ration and caution would cease to exist for two people who had bound themselves so tightly together that life seemed undesirable without the other (children don’t count). Believing it of them does not mean that I could relate to it, but also I have no idea how I would react in such a hypothetical situation. I’ve never met a couple like this, so perhaps its rarity in my life set me up for the Grift more?
I don’t think the book was ever aimed at that one group of people but more of a wider audience who had invested in Them, the couple. You’re right though @Vroomfondleswaistcoat . As long as the surroundings were described and documented in the book at all, the reality of the journey could ‘sit’ better in the readers’ minds….. and readers will always be forgiving of “first books” written by somebody whose husband (they are told) only has a few months or a year left to live. Every time I look back at this book now, I wince at the writing. I would never ever have bought this book under normal circumstances. Never.

Normallyinthepool · 29/06/2026 07:55

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 29/06/2026 07:14

I think part of it is what made her books 'books for people that don't read'. They are books for people who want to vicariously enjoy the countryside but have very little knowledge of it. Which is why they were convinced by a few mentions of plants and birds, that they were reading a deeply-knowledgeable book about the environment. If you don't know anything about the countryside, someone just mentioning a few birds and some greenery is enough to make you think the writer has experienced it all.

I suspect if OWH really does come out it will be her last ever book. There's only so many ways you can spin what is basically 'going for a walk and not describing it very well.'

Agreed!

Her descriptions of being judged for looking a bit scruffy on walks never made any sense to me

Nor did so many of their supposed interactions with locals

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 29/06/2026 07:14

YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree · 28/06/2026 23:26

Just catching up...great observations about her apparent superficial knowledge of plants and reference-book-like writing about them. I guess she hoped the juicy "pop" of a salted blackberry would be enough of a distraction. So much of her written "observations" about nearly everything are hackneyed.

Edited

I think part of it is what made her books 'books for people that don't read'. They are books for people who want to vicariously enjoy the countryside but have very little knowledge of it. Which is why they were convinced by a few mentions of plants and birds, that they were reading a deeply-knowledgeable book about the environment. If you don't know anything about the countryside, someone just mentioning a few birds and some greenery is enough to make you think the writer has experienced it all.

I suspect if OWH really does come out it will be her last ever book. There's only so many ways you can spin what is basically 'going for a walk and not describing it very well.'

YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree · 28/06/2026 23:26

Just catching up...great observations about her apparent superficial knowledge of plants and reference-book-like writing about them. I guess she hoped the juicy "pop" of a salted blackberry would be enough of a distraction. So much of her written "observations" about nearly everything are hackneyed.

HatStickBoots · 28/06/2026 21:30

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 28/06/2026 20:11

Probably conversations were mostly wondering whether to walk for one more day or to arrange for pick up and to be taken back to wherever they were staying at the time for a good meal, a shower and an avoidance of discussion about how much longer they'd be staying for...

I think they must have bickered a lot if they were sofa surfing, contributing nothing and then going on the series of walks. As they are such lazy and entitled people whose rustic alter egos don’t bear much resemblance to the reality, the novelty of ‘going for a walk’ probably wore thin despite all the musings in the book from Raynor as she recalls her youth swept up into Moth’s eco warrior world. I’m sure there would have been some snappy accusations about losing their house and having all their contents put into storage. In TSP I think they said they were having to lose it all but I doubt they did. I agree @UpfromSomerset on everything you say.

HatStickBoots · 28/06/2026 21:20

Holdinguphalfthesky · 28/06/2026 19:19

looking at the list of plants she wrote out for the Gigspanner tour made me think of Jackie Morris and Rob McFarlane’s The Lost Words. My daughter and I used to read a lot of Jackie Morris but the child had aged out of them by the time that one came out- I do wonder though whether Sal came across it.
This is from the book’s website (my bold):

“Each lost word is conjured back to importance through Robert’s powerful spells. They are called ‘spells’ rather than poems as they are designed to be spoken (or sung!) out loud in order to summon back these words and creatures into our hearts. Robert explains: "We’ve got more than 50% of species in decline. And names, good names, well used can help us see and they help us care. We find it hard to love what we cannot give a name to. And what we do not love we will not save.”
The book began as a response to the removal of everyday nature words - among them "acorn", "bluebell", "kingfisher" and "wren" - from a widely used children’s dictionary, because those words were not being used enough by children to merit inclusion. But The Lost Words then grew to become a much broader protest at the loss of the natural world around us, as well as a celebration of the creatures and plants with which we share our lives, in all their wonderful, characterful glory."

ETA I have been various cats on this series of threads, including alert, doubtful, and weary 🐈‍⬛

Edited

That’s so interesting! I’ve never heard of that. What a brilliant idea but how sad that it was necessary! I hope these books are in schools and referred to often. The words you’ve picked out are very surprising omissions because bluebells and acorns are surely in abundance. Wrens are more difficult to spot but so lovely when you do. Children are so naturally curious about the world they live in, so to not include the names of these things in a dictionary aimed at them seems absurd.

Edit: I thought you must be a regular! Also thank you for pointing out these similarities. As ever, Sal’s content and the presentation of it (overseen and driven by daughter) is all style over substance, like the Instagram rubbish.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 28/06/2026 20:11

HatStickBoots · 28/06/2026 18:52

I do wonder what their conversations as they walked and camped would have really been like. Clearly they weren’t Moth’s swan song or her histrionics as TSP would have us believe.

Probably conversations were mostly wondering whether to walk for one more day or to arrange for pick up and to be taken back to wherever they were staying at the time for a good meal, a shower and an avoidance of discussion about how much longer they'd be staying for...

Holdinguphalfthesky · 28/06/2026 19:19

looking at the list of plants she wrote out for the Gigspanner tour made me think of Jackie Morris and Rob McFarlane’s The Lost Words. My daughter and I used to read a lot of Jackie Morris but the child had aged out of them by the time that one came out- I do wonder though whether Sal came across it.
This is from the book’s website (my bold):

“Each lost word is conjured back to importance through Robert’s powerful spells. They are called ‘spells’ rather than poems as they are designed to be spoken (or sung!) out loud in order to summon back these words and creatures into our hearts. Robert explains: "We’ve got more than 50% of species in decline. And names, good names, well used can help us see and they help us care. We find it hard to love what we cannot give a name to. And what we do not love we will not save.”
The book began as a response to the removal of everyday nature words - among them "acorn", "bluebell", "kingfisher" and "wren" - from a widely used children’s dictionary, because those words were not being used enough by children to merit inclusion. But The Lost Words then grew to become a much broader protest at the loss of the natural world around us, as well as a celebration of the creatures and plants with which we share our lives, in all their wonderful, characterful glory."

ETA I have been various cats on this series of threads, including alert, doubtful, and weary 🐈‍⬛

UpfromSomerset · 28/06/2026 19:01

HatStickBoots · 28/06/2026 18:19

I believe that rhododendron chapter was lifted straight off the National trust’s signage and website everywhere they own and manage land in the county. Their work is controversial and opinion is quite divided about it. Raynor Winn appears to be putting forward her opinion rather than setting out the argument. What baffles me now, since we learned who they really are, is that Moth worked for the National Trust.

There are posts on this thread suggesting that great swathes of TSP and also TWS were "lifted" off the internet/guide books/Paddy Dillon's SWCP publication/etc./etc. I agree entirely.
SW after all had the previous experience, whilst working for Martin Hemmings, of "forging" invoices (remember the fictitious payment for work done on a vehicle engine replacement?)
I'm convinced that they were never entirely penniless, nor without their own transport. To give authenticity to the account of the 600 mile journey some visits to coastal locations were no doubt undertaken, plus some "wild camping". No way did they survive on fudge and pot noodles! Also I think that she deliberately researched and found an obscure, little known condition (described in the book as only able to be correctly diagnosed at post mortem! How convenient!) to "inflict" on Moth. Even the medical records released after CH's Observer article seemed suspect to me and proved nothing.
At this present moment in time it would be even easier to produce a story in the style of TSP without leaving home, by means of AI, as all the ingredients are there on the internet. No need to be a genuine nature writer nor an actual long distance walker, AI will do it for you. Simple.

BrandiedAromatics · 28/06/2026 19:00

HatStickBoots · 28/06/2026 18:52

I do wonder what their conversations as they walked and camped would have really been like. Clearly they weren’t Moth’s swan song or her histrionics as TSP would have us believe.

All we know are three things, as far as I remember:

Warren/Grant remembers them looking a bit lost and dishevelled?

Tadge remembers them lying down on benches with all their gear spread around.

Jo and David Parsons remember having a good chat with a couple who forgot to tell them they were homeless.

ETA: lying down on benches, not lying, I didn't want you to think they weren't telling the truth ...

HatStickBoots · 28/06/2026 18:52

I do wonder what their conversations as they walked and camped would have really been like. Clearly they weren’t Moth’s swan song or her histrionics as TSP would have us believe.

HatStickBoots · 28/06/2026 18:49

BrandiedAromatics · 28/06/2026 18:33

Yes, and I also remember her having a go at the NT in regard to what local's, along the SWCP, thought of their practices. How would she know? I discovered it was one of Sal's paraphrased sections of a paragraph in 500 Mile Walkies. From fact-based local knowledge I think it may be partly a reference, in Mark Wallington, to a ding dong between a local farmer and the NT about the use of the name Bedruthan Steps.

That’s correct yes - and I had never read that book before this year, had never seen it in bookshops or charity shops so had to get a copy from WOB. I was astonished at how much of the style and content had been lifted or copied with the assumption that nobody would know. Thankfully a lot of you did! Even though she credits and references Paddy Dillon throughout, she only touches upon Mark Wallington’s 500 miles at the beginning in particular and even though one of her favourite books (she tells us in TSP) she does not liken their “tramp” episode as being exactly like Mark’s experience, or any of the times when they are confronted by dogs being a nuisance as reminding her of Boogie and the humour of Boogie was a big part of 500 mile Walkies and I’m absolutely sure that the episodes with dogs in TSP was supposed to be humorous even if she managed to suck all that out because being a victim must trump everything else at all costs - except when you’re sitting on a sofa being interviewed in front of an audience.

BrandiedAromatics · 28/06/2026 18:33

HatStickBoots · 28/06/2026 18:19

I believe that rhododendron chapter was lifted straight off the National trust’s signage and website everywhere they own and manage land in the county. Their work is controversial and opinion is quite divided about it. Raynor Winn appears to be putting forward her opinion rather than setting out the argument. What baffles me now, since we learned who they really are, is that Moth worked for the National Trust.

Yes, and I also remember her having a go at the NT in regard to what local's, along the SWCP, thought of their practices. How would she know? I discovered it was one of Sal's paraphrased sections of a paragraph in 500 Mile Walkies. From fact-based local knowledge I think it may be partly a reference, in Mark Wallington, to a ding dong between a local farmer and the NT about the use of the name Bedruthan Steps.

HatStickBoots · 28/06/2026 18:19

ThompsonTwin · 28/06/2026 13:19

Sal does briefly talk about the unwelcome proliferation of rhododendrons after Porlock Weir ( where Moth is shown grand standng on the entry gate posts to a large country house) and a few comments about spending an afternoon looking for Autumn Lady's Tresses orchids on the Lizard peninsula, but apart from that, not much! I think we can discount the boomeranging peregrine falcon, the dog leashed tortoise nbear Pencarrow Point and Smotyn, from the discussion!

Edited

I believe that rhododendron chapter was lifted straight off the National trust’s signage and website everywhere they own and manage land in the county. Their work is controversial and opinion is quite divided about it. Raynor Winn appears to be putting forward her opinion rather than setting out the argument. What baffles me now, since we learned who they really are, is that Moth worked for the National Trust.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 28/06/2026 17:41

Not sure if this has been posted before, but it came up in my YouTube timeline (I think YouTube has got me bang to rights). Our Chloe talking to an American channel about TSP and what went on.

Hopefully all this negative publicity in the US will help bring the grift to the attention of the American audience who might just be getting all the publicity for the film.

BrandiedAromatics · 28/06/2026 17:23

So what I was after with this lockdown article is - it gives us more about how Alice sees her life pan out. "She finally wrote her way into being the main character in her own life story". Except that it doesn't. It is very clunky and confusing - with the two whiteboards.

Sal gives us this juxtaposition of her nature-filled days and Alice's 3 day imprisonment. The enlightenment comes in the form of the 3rd lockdown, "my daughter picked up the phone having decided how to change her life."

"Wildflowers are pushing through the ground in abundance and the endangered yellowhammers are calling to each other from the hazel bushes." So Alice has decided to do what Sal thinks is pukka.

So the moral of the story is " just occasionally you have to rip the whiteboard off the wall and make it happen." What the one that says: ‘Help me, I’m trapped.’

Et in Arcadia ego.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 28/06/2026 16:55

TheBookShelf · 28/06/2026 16:33

Thanks @BrandiedAromatics - really interesting about the birds, I don't know a lot about birds so hadn't picked up on that aspect. Overall I think SW sees the coastal and countryside landscape as a sort of flat theatre backdrop against which to describe her own supposed adventures, or to showcase her supposed achievements (finding more interesting birds than anyone else! looking for rare orchids at the Lizard! really long walks! ) , rather than something alive and fascinating in its own right.

This, but I would say she doesn't 'describe', she 'recounts'. A little like a child in a 'what I did on my holidays' essay. 'Today we saw a gorse bush, a nettle, some brambles, a robin, a wren, a seagull and it rained.'

BrandiedAromatics · 28/06/2026 16:41

reallyalurker · 27/06/2026 09:11

Not sure if this has been posted in an earlier thread, but here is an archive of the chicken shop piece:

web.archive.org/web/20250708144458/www.penguin.co.uk/discover/articles/raynor-winn-lockdown-hope

An extremely strange piece of writing. I'm surprised Penguin didn't ask her if she was ok. I mean, maybe they did, but they published it anyway.

Thanks to you as well @reallyalurker - I tried to find it in an archive to no avail. We have some good researchers on this thread! I hadn't re-read it all before sharing about the birds ... so was amused that this also refers to the dull birds followed by the more rare, colourful ones. Maybe I did remember subliminally ... as I say I did listen to Sal a lot (eyes glaze over) ....

TheBookShelf · 28/06/2026 16:33

Thanks @BrandiedAromatics - really interesting about the birds, I don't know a lot about birds so hadn't picked up on that aspect. Overall I think SW sees the coastal and countryside landscape as a sort of flat theatre backdrop against which to describe her own supposed adventures, or to showcase her supposed achievements (finding more interesting birds than anyone else! looking for rare orchids at the Lizard! really long walks! ) , rather than something alive and fascinating in its own right.

BrandiedAromatics · 28/06/2026 14:59

@TheBookShelf This was one of the things that made it ring hollow to me from the start - it reads as if written with a reference book to hand, slotting coastal plant names into a route.

Thanks for your whole piece - I am not surprised at this as I picked up a similar thing with the birds. I always own up - I haven't read any of the RW books but I have seen loads of extracts and heard lots of her interviews (for my sins, phew!) - she still has a E Midlands expectancy of what birds she will see, to me. So I have pointed out that you don't see that bird at that time of the year in Cornwall, for instance.

Where we did have some fun was over Haye Farm when the Walkers miraculous skills resulted in some amazing birds appearing in contrast to the former dull, plain, ones. It prompted me to share a song by The Carpenters, Close To You, dedicated to Moth:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=iNXtoTc6BYA&list=RDiNXtoTc6BYA&start_radio=1

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?list=RDiNXtoTc6BYA&start_radio=1&v=iNXtoTc6BYA

TheBookShelf · 28/06/2026 13:39

HatStickBoots · 28/06/2026 12:30

Mmmmmmmmm… I’m thinking hard but can’t really recall anything like that in TSP @TheBookShelf .. I agree with you and have that same longstanding interest about flora and fauna. I recently bought a little handmade book, handwritten and illustrated by a young art student at a local fair, all about foraging for edible plants, she calls them weeds. I knew most of them but some I didn’t and it is a lovely little book in its own right.
If you’d mentioned your observations about this lack back when it was first published, you might have had the response that there was too much else on her mind and inner turmoil to be able to really see anything outside of that. Its real selling hooks were the homelessness, Moth’s illness and their secular relationship with each other that transcends everybody else’s humdrum and grey existence. Picking up the book now and going through the pages, the things which leap out to me the most are her cartoonish observations of other people, the Wikipedia extracts about the places they pass through and their experiences with the weather and their bodies. There are also a lot of her feelings. We now know that their walks on the SWCP were a series of holidays and everything that helped towards its publication.. even the acknowledgments at the end and the ‘about the author ‘This is her first book’ is a bloody mockery. Yes, I agree with you that even if this story was real, there would be so much more of the observations you’ve suggested based on both of their backgrounds and interests and the fact that she makes such a big show of being a part of nature, just because. The book was written when she had time to reflect upon more than the circumstances of the walk itself. She wrote Moth’s character as being one that had accepted his fate (it’s easy when the reality was different?) and might have appreciated a little more of the nature content which was lacking, his interests supposedly being inclined that way and the book itself being a gift.

Edited

Thanks @HatStickBoots . SW does have the gift of making everything she describes seem flat and dull!

TheBookShelf · 28/06/2026 13:36

That's exactly it @Vroomfondleswaistcoat - thanks. SW tells rather than shows. She lists, but doesn't make us see, or feel.

ThompsonTwin · 28/06/2026 13:19

HatStickBoots · 28/06/2026 12:30

Mmmmmmmmm… I’m thinking hard but can’t really recall anything like that in TSP @TheBookShelf .. I agree with you and have that same longstanding interest about flora and fauna. I recently bought a little handmade book, handwritten and illustrated by a young art student at a local fair, all about foraging for edible plants, she calls them weeds. I knew most of them but some I didn’t and it is a lovely little book in its own right.
If you’d mentioned your observations about this lack back when it was first published, you might have had the response that there was too much else on her mind and inner turmoil to be able to really see anything outside of that. Its real selling hooks were the homelessness, Moth’s illness and their secular relationship with each other that transcends everybody else’s humdrum and grey existence. Picking up the book now and going through the pages, the things which leap out to me the most are her cartoonish observations of other people, the Wikipedia extracts about the places they pass through and their experiences with the weather and their bodies. There are also a lot of her feelings. We now know that their walks on the SWCP were a series of holidays and everything that helped towards its publication.. even the acknowledgments at the end and the ‘about the author ‘This is her first book’ is a bloody mockery. Yes, I agree with you that even if this story was real, there would be so much more of the observations you’ve suggested based on both of their backgrounds and interests and the fact that she makes such a big show of being a part of nature, just because. The book was written when she had time to reflect upon more than the circumstances of the walk itself. She wrote Moth’s character as being one that had accepted his fate (it’s easy when the reality was different?) and might have appreciated a little more of the nature content which was lacking, his interests supposedly being inclined that way and the book itself being a gift.

Edited

Sal does briefly talk about the unwelcome proliferation of rhododendrons after Porlock Weir ( where Moth is shown grand standng on the entry gate posts to a large country house) and a few comments about spending an afternoon looking for Autumn Lady's Tresses orchids on the Lizard peninsula, but apart from that, not much! I think we can discount the boomeranging peregrine falcon, the dog leashed tortoise nbear Pencarrow Point and Smotyn, from the discussion!

Thread 27 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film?