Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thread 27 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film?

790 replies

DisappointedReader · 25/06/2026 20:01

NO POSTS PLEASE UNTIL THREAD 26 IS FULL

Please see the OP of Thread 25 for all the links to The Observer's reporting and podcast series, our threads one to 24 and so on:
Thread 25 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film? | Mumsnet

New posters joining us in the genuine spirit of our civil discourse are always welcome. It would be helpful to get the background from some of Investigative Journalist Chloe Hadjimatheou's excellent exposé items before posting. Chloe's podcast series for The Observer 'The Walkers' covers most things:
The Walkers: The real Salt Path | The Observer
Another suggestion:
BBC Sounds - Secrets of the Salt Path - Available Episodes
To all - Please be extremely cautious when it comes to naming or implicating people and addresses not in the public eye or with no direct connection to the story, especially where details are unclear or still emerging. Remember, even Hollywood rabbits attract the odd flea: please do not engage with drive-by scolders who seem to have their own agenda and seek to derail. Avoid @'ing and quoting them as - from experience - this will only encourage them back to the threads. For nearly a year we have done amazingly well together for 26 very interesting, very serious and very silly, threads so far. I can't be here as much as I'd like so all help with keeping our discussion walking along in our usual reasonable and respectful fashion is very welcome.

We are still here after 26,000 posts and fast approaching our one year anniversary together on 6th July 2026, 12 months on from the start of our first thread in response to Our Chloe's somewhat stunning initial exposé. Little did we know what else would come out. Our longevity comes as both a total surprise and a pleasure (mostly!). We've seen charabancers come and go, come back again, delurk and join us for the first time. All are welcome. Threads have both filled up in a day and moved at a more stately pace. Thank you everyone for sharing your time, thoughts, opinions, experience, questions, sleuthing (there's that word!), kindness (there's that other word!) and great humour with me and with each other. As ever, as we embark on our 27th thread riding the community charabanc - this time all holding our brollies and fans aloft for much-needed shade and breeze - keep to the path, no saltiness, eat fudge and drink cider, (but not too much in the current heatwave).

NO POSTS PLEASE UNTIL THREAD 26 IS FULL:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5506717-thread-26-to-feel-disappointed-and-disgusted-and-vindicated-now-too-after-reading-this-in-the-observer-about-the-author-and-her-husband-from-the-salt-path-book-and-film?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
102
Anythingbutheadlands · 08/07/2026 11:36

I agree - if only there could be an open and honest acknowledgement of what has happened and their part in it. Not these tantalisingly vague hints.

HatStickBoots · 08/07/2026 09:12

I’m a compassionate person which is why I was so easily manipulated in the first place. I wish this family would stop using these tactics to control people. Some family therapy would be a good idea because it looks (from the above) as if Alice is just continuing the theme taught by her mother and father. If her parents won’t even acknowledge the problem here, at least she could? From what I have read about the subject I recognise so many of the traits of covert narcissism in Sally Walker. Alice is very talented in her own right but there’s no appeal at all in continuing to market fool’s gold.

HatStickBoots · 07/07/2026 16:42

Anythingbutheadlands · 07/07/2026 12:24

Sal’s daughter has posted on IG about experiencing some “wild trauma” last year and having had a “nervous breakdown” which she’s now recovering from. I am feeling curious and compassionate - intrigued really as to whether this is linked with the exposure of her parents…

Writing that on Instagram…. Is that yet more examples of emotional blackmail? She needs to look at the cause.
People don’t hate the Walkers or wish them harm, but there’s been no closure on this. I’d be much happier if Penguin relabelled these books, apologised and took some responsibility to make sure that future marketing for them does not lie. I know there’ll be no truth coming from the Walkers but I’d like to think that this teaches them something real about life, rather than hiding behind the false narrative they preach about in all three books and the way they’re continuing to behave on IG as though they really are those people and haven’t got a clue what all the fuss is about.

Anythingbutheadlands · 07/07/2026 12:24

Sal’s daughter has posted on IG about experiencing some “wild trauma” last year and having had a “nervous breakdown” which she’s now recovering from. I am feeling curious and compassionate - intrigued really as to whether this is linked with the exposure of her parents…

Oeufs · 07/07/2026 10:29

BrandiedAromatics · 07/07/2026 10:20

If someone on this thread had given the extract below, as if from the works of Raynor Winn, I would have just accepted it. So many comments say RW is a good writer but it is like this:

.. sometimes we’d sit outside in silence, letting the wind and birdsong fill the gaps that words couldn’t reach. We were changed, both of us. Scarred, yes, but also sharpened, more awake to the fragility of things – the land, the sky, the small mercies we’d once taken for granted. As the autumn light faded over the hills, ====== stood beside me on the field we’d once fought so hard for, her hand in mine. The grass shimmered gold and a red kite wheeled lazily overhead.
“Maybe now,” she said, her voice soft but sure, “the land can heal.”

Edited

Yes, exactly. It’s hitting precisely the same beats there. And yes, godawful writing. I think it’s perfectly possible that the ghostwriter’s brief may have been ‘The Salt Path but with psycho neighbours’.

(Renovating dilapidated Welsh farmhouse, financial shenanigans involving a stupid decision to trust someone, paeans to nature, nice middle+aged couple subjected to appalling reversal of fortune through no fault of their own etc etc).

So the ghost writer may have been told to match the Raynor Winn style to see if it might cross over into bestseller status.

BrandiedAromatics · 07/07/2026 10:20

If someone on this thread had given the extract below, as if from the works of Raynor Winn, I would have just accepted it. So many comments say RW is a good writer but it is like this:

.. sometimes we’d sit outside in silence, letting the wind and birdsong fill the gaps that words couldn’t reach. We were changed, both of us. Scarred, yes, but also sharpened, more awake to the fragility of things – the land, the sky, the small mercies we’d once taken for granted. As the autumn light faded over the hills, ====== stood beside me on the field we’d once fought so hard for, her hand in mine. The grass shimmered gold and a red kite wheeled lazily overhead.
“Maybe now,” she said, her voice soft but sure, “the land can heal.”

Oeufs · 07/07/2026 09:57

Peladon · 07/07/2026 09:02

Read like TSP to me. Maybe the same ghost writer?

I just think all those books are written to much the same style, whether ghostwritten or not. Rather like a longer-form version of those Take A Break ‘true life’ stories where they’re written very tightly to the same beats in the same language with the same kind of pull-quotes — ‘My whole world came crashing down’, ‘He was the perfect man’, ‘A chilling realisation struck me’ etc etc.

BrandiedAromatics · 07/07/2026 09:36

Peladon · 07/07/2026 09:02

Read like TSP to me. Maybe the same ghost writer?

I did look to see if it is Penguin but it is Harper. The extract, in The Guardian, is so long that I don't know why you would buy the book. This book is definitely marketed for the True Crime section - but it starts off like a 1980s Timotei shampoo advert.
Interesting for the conversation @ThompsonTwin started about authenticity in writing/AI. Other than that I'll give this a miss.

Peladon · 07/07/2026 09:02

Read like TSP to me. Maybe the same ghost writer?

Catdaddy1978 · 06/07/2026 21:58

DisappointedReader · 25/06/2026 20:01

NO POSTS PLEASE UNTIL THREAD 26 IS FULL

Please see the OP of Thread 25 for all the links to The Observer's reporting and podcast series, our threads one to 24 and so on:
Thread 25 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film? | Mumsnet

New posters joining us in the genuine spirit of our civil discourse are always welcome. It would be helpful to get the background from some of Investigative Journalist Chloe Hadjimatheou's excellent exposé items before posting. Chloe's podcast series for The Observer 'The Walkers' covers most things:
The Walkers: The real Salt Path | The Observer
Another suggestion:
BBC Sounds - Secrets of the Salt Path - Available Episodes
To all - Please be extremely cautious when it comes to naming or implicating people and addresses not in the public eye or with no direct connection to the story, especially where details are unclear or still emerging. Remember, even Hollywood rabbits attract the odd flea: please do not engage with drive-by scolders who seem to have their own agenda and seek to derail. Avoid @'ing and quoting them as - from experience - this will only encourage them back to the threads. For nearly a year we have done amazingly well together for 26 very interesting, very serious and very silly, threads so far. I can't be here as much as I'd like so all help with keeping our discussion walking along in our usual reasonable and respectful fashion is very welcome.

We are still here after 26,000 posts and fast approaching our one year anniversary together on 6th July 2026, 12 months on from the start of our first thread in response to Our Chloe's somewhat stunning initial exposé. Little did we know what else would come out. Our longevity comes as both a total surprise and a pleasure (mostly!). We've seen charabancers come and go, come back again, delurk and join us for the first time. All are welcome. Threads have both filled up in a day and moved at a more stately pace. Thank you everyone for sharing your time, thoughts, opinions, experience, questions, sleuthing (there's that word!), kindness (there's that other word!) and great humour with me and with each other. As ever, as we embark on our 27th thread riding the community charabanc - this time all holding our brollies and fans aloft for much-needed shade and breeze - keep to the path, no saltiness, eat fudge and drink cider, (but not too much in the current heatwave).

NO POSTS PLEASE UNTIL THREAD 26 IS FULL:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5506717-thread-26-to-feel-disappointed-and-disgusted-and-vindicated-now-too-after-reading-this-in-the-observer-about-the-author-and-her-husband-from-the-salt-path-book-and-film?

I'll be honest and say that when I was reading it, I didn't know it was supposed to be non-fiction, the opening few chapters did seem rather far-fetched. It also rambled on quite a lot and I got a little bored in the middle, so I didn't finish it. I do love Cornwall and Devon and some of the descriptions were good but yeah, not a book I'd return to finish.

HatStickBoots · 06/07/2026 21:41

Ahhhhhh good old memory loss! I’d forgotten that excuse could be used, thank you @Peladon and @BrandiedAromatics im going to read these now.

Peladon · 06/07/2026 21:24

Regarding interviews, I just re-read this interview at Polruan.

"Moth" wasn't there (out for a walk) - but he came back while the journalist was still in the flat.

Journalist observed that "Moth" looked better than expected, given his illness.

"Moth" indicated that he was losing his memory so couldn't answer any questions.

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2018/dec/06/home-is-a-state-of-mind-you-dont-need-walls

‘Nature was my safe place’: Raynor Winn on homelessness and setting off on a 630-mile walk

Without a home, and facing terminal illness, Winn and her husband decided to walk the South West Coast Path. She talks about the experience – and her Costa-nominated memoir, The Salt Path

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2018/dec/06/home-is-a-state-of-mind-you-dont-need-walls

BrandiedAromatics · 06/07/2026 20:05

So to follow up my post above: I couldn't share the original link earlier as it is behind a paywall in The Times (and I have tried to archive it twice and failed).

Here it is, at last: What the Salt Path author Raynor Winn told me about honesty

BrandiedAromatics · 06/07/2026 19:30

@Oeufs @Vroomfondleswaistcoat @HatStickBoots I'm laughing at the posts above about the journalist who was diverted from meeting Tim. I couldn't share the original link earlier as it is behind a paywall in The Times (and I have tried to archive it twice and failed).

My memory is that it just says that Sal picked her up herself from the station and drove them to the Duchy Nursery but I haven't reread the original.

On the subject of authenticity, that we were discussing last night - this is an example for me from the extract shared by @Oeufs from Grazia : where music and loud chatter abounded beneath the blooms. When I read that I thought oh that journalist has definitely been to that café - it is an amazing space, a converted barn with huge beams exposed high above. But, the acoustics are deafening with conversations bouncing off the walls, and the chairs scraping are a nightmare ....

Whereas, when I have seen extracts of TSP, I often thought oh the ferry you want does not go from there, or you paraphrased that from 500MW, or the dolphins would get stranded if they swam with you and you never seem to swim.

Oeufs · 06/07/2026 19:06

gets a modelling contract for Finisterre😀😀

Oeufs · 06/07/2026 19:04

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/07/2026 14:06

@Oeufs That, I think, is the lady I am thinking of. I don't know which interview I read, I seem to remember her being picked up and driven by Sal in a rattly old car and being stonewalled whenever she asked where Tim was.

That sounds like the original interview. I think someone must have cut and pasted it on here many threads ago, as I've never had a Times sub.

SW does stonewalling very well, as we know, when she's confronted with stealing from family, or live on stage at a literary festival when a friendly interviewer presses her on what Moth's real name is -- she relies on an interviewer in a literary context generally not wanting to make a woman they perceive as a stoical survivor of traumas uncomfortable, or push her for painful details of the eviction or TW's decline.

And that journalist, looking back on an 'unsatisfactory' interview, puts her finger exactly on what we've often said here, SW's refusal to deviate from a script, and her insistence on retelling the same anecdotes over and over. The Mars bar, the moment of illumination under the stairs etc etc.

It's also of course significant that the journalist finds 'kind' explanations for her stonewalling and repetitive script, and the shift of the interview away from their home, plus the absence of Moth. She thinks they all come from a protective impulse towards TW's privacy.

HatStickBoots · 06/07/2026 18:58

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/07/2026 14:06

@Oeufs That, I think, is the lady I am thinking of. I don't know which interview I read, I seem to remember her being picked up and driven by Sal in a rattly old car and being stonewalled whenever she asked where Tim was.

Yes. Hindsight is such a wonderful thing! The rattly old car was probably a prop as well. Of course Tim didn’t want to be present and I’d love to have overheard their conversations regarding these interviews! 😀 Tim, when it dawned on him that he’d actually have to be a dying Moth! It’s like a Greek tragedy or something. Healthy, handsome guy, life and soul of the party has been shackled by his loving wife’s presentation of him in her bestselling book and has to hide away lest he breaks out of character or gets a modelling contract for Finisterre. Awkward questions about CBD and whether or not doctors have asked to monitor or study him for progress. After a while even “twinkling” is going to wear thin.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/07/2026 14:06

@Oeufs That, I think, is the lady I am thinking of. I don't know which interview I read, I seem to remember her being picked up and driven by Sal in a rattly old car and being stonewalled whenever she asked where Tim was.

HatStickBoots · 06/07/2026 12:16

BrandiedAromatics · 06/07/2026 09:02

Thanks to @DisappointedReader for starting a thread on 06/07/2025, with the interesting article below. Thanks to Our Chloe for her determination - what a charabanc journey:

The real Salt Path: how a blockbuster book and film were ...

I went to the Duchy Nursery a few months ago and got a few bottles of Haye Farm cider, this is where Sal picked up a journalist from the train and took her to the café rather than home and Tim. It is still the 2023 vintage so I don't know if they will continue to make it? I will be toasting you all tonight with the one in the fridge, I do recommend it.

Haye Farm Cider

Thank you @BrandiedAromatics for the reminder! 🍻❤️

HatStickBoots · 06/07/2026 11:25

@YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree yes, absolutely, I just picked out the St Ives scene because it related to Beowulf. I agree with you, I think I might have shared my disappointments about the film when I first joined the charabanc. Yes, it looked and felt hammy in the screen and was totally the fault of Sally Walker’s deceitful writing which made it that way. Awkward silences, scenes which you don’t know are supposed to be funny or tragic probably because there was no tragedy so she was trying to be entertaining whilst still firmly a victim. Mark Wallington’s humour was stolen and put through a misery wash. All the preaching throughout the book and film about Cornwall’s past and present were another exploitative tactic because I haven’t seen any evidence that she gives a damn about any of that, but I’m happy to be proved wrong. @Oeufs oh yes… I’d forgotten that.. the half eaten pasty… Even if the reader is allowed to have a little laugh at one thing or another in her writing (rarely) you are instantly reminded that this is a sob story and don’t you dare forget it! That quote you’ve shared.. ugh… and the reality was no such thing!! She writes about emotions that she thinks she is supposed be feeling, as though she planted herself in Raynor’s shoes and thought about it that way. Her writing grabs the reader and wrings every drop of sympathy from them and also bludgeons anything left over, to death.

edit: thank you for sharing the above article.

Oeufs · 06/07/2026 10:14

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/07/2026 10:03

Phew, thank you. That is precisely what I thought I read - and we can't both be wrong, can we?

(Please tell me we can't).

Well, we could be in a Christopher Nolan film with a shared hallucination, I suppose... Grin

Googling 'Raynor Winn interview Duchy Nurseries' seems to suggest it was published in the Times, but this is the same journalist reflecting on it in Grazia after the Observer story.

https://graziadaily.co.uk/life/in-the-news/i-interviewed-salt-path-author/

I too have been forced to reconsider Winn’s words anew. Two Julys ago I boarded a train for the small Cornish town of Lostwithiel, ahead of the release of her third book. It was a hot Friday afternoon when we met, Winn collecting me from the station and driving me up to the Duchy of Cornwall Nursery, where music and loud chatter abounded beneath the blooms.

The woman whose emotional turmoil had poured across her pages was far more reserved in person: the rawness I had expected from someone who had battled so much unbelievable misfortune was absent. As we spoke, I struggled to learn more about her life than had already been recounted in her books; Winn repeating some of the anecdotes I’d read. On leaving, I couldn’t help feeling our encounter had been somehow unsatisfying: that everything beyond what she had already written was somehow off-limits.

Moth’s illness was on my mind then, too. I had looked forward to meeting the man who had so spectacularly defied the odds of his disease (those with CBD typically live for six to eight years in a progressively deteriorating state; he had by then been diagnosed a decade earlier, and in each of the books undertook months-long walks that would test even the fittest among us).

But ahead of the interview, the location shifted from their home to a solo meeting with Winn elsewhere. The photoshoot also got postponed. Given the lows of his condition – the agony, bowel problems, memory slips and despair – and the apparent healing powers of their walks, I had mulled whether living out in the open had triggered a decline they were unwilling to share.

‘I Interviewed The Salt Path Author – I’ve Been Forced To Reconsider What She Told Me’

As the truth about Raynor Winn’s heartwarming story is called into question, Charlotte Lytton reflects on the time she spent with her.

https://graziadaily.co.uk/life/in-the-news/i-interviewed-salt-path-author/

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/07/2026 10:03

Oeufs · 06/07/2026 10:00

No, I'm pretty sure I read that too. I think the implication was that TW was too ill to be talked to, and that SW was stoically not talking about it and protecting him from intrusive media exposure.

I think I remember another one where the journalist had also expected a face to face meeting with SW, but it ended up being on Skype/Teams because of Covid or TW being ill or something.

Phew, thank you. That is precisely what I thought I read - and we can't both be wrong, can we?

(Please tell me we can't).

Oeufs · 06/07/2026 10:00

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 06/07/2026 09:54

I'm sure I remember reading a piece that the journalist wrote, where she was expecting to go to Sal and Tim's home and talk to both of them but was unexpectedly taken to a cafe instead where she only had Sal to talk to. IIRC the tone of the piece was fairly neutral but the journalist did wonder if she hadn't been allowed to talk to Tim for some reason...

Am I making this up or did I read it? There is so much out there now that I'm not always certain if I am using firsthand or secondhand sources any more!

No, I'm pretty sure I read that too. I think the implication was that TW was too ill to be talked to, and that SW was stoically not talking about it and protecting him from intrusive media exposure.

I think I remember another one where the journalist had also expected a face to face meeting with SW, but it ended up being on Skype/Teams because of Covid or TW being ill or something.

Oeufs · 06/07/2026 09:57

YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree · 06/07/2026 09:28

So much of the film made me uneasy...because it was even more obvious that the interactions she wrote about were unrealistic and contrived. The salted blackberries man, the girl from the cafe, Grant, the man/family looking at them in disgust upon Moth saying they were homeless, and so on. Even the ridiculous tent flooding scene. Nothing about it was convincing. Even if it were presented as fiction it would have remained terrible writing.

The bit where they're having a cream tea near the start and tell the family at the next table they're homeless always struck me as hilarious. I mean, those people were just sitting down for some food with their small children on holiday. It doesn't make them snobbish or in any way unpleasant to not be particularly enthused by a gabby stranger at a neighbouring table who is clearly about to launch into the story of his life at the slightest provocation any more than it would be to be less than thrilled by someone who started showing you their weird rash in a cafe!

Swipe left for the next trending thread