Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thread 27 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film?

790 replies

DisappointedReader · 25/06/2026 20:01

NO POSTS PLEASE UNTIL THREAD 26 IS FULL

Please see the OP of Thread 25 for all the links to The Observer's reporting and podcast series, our threads one to 24 and so on:
Thread 25 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film? | Mumsnet

New posters joining us in the genuine spirit of our civil discourse are always welcome. It would be helpful to get the background from some of Investigative Journalist Chloe Hadjimatheou's excellent exposé items before posting. Chloe's podcast series for The Observer 'The Walkers' covers most things:
The Walkers: The real Salt Path | The Observer
Another suggestion:
BBC Sounds - Secrets of the Salt Path - Available Episodes
To all - Please be extremely cautious when it comes to naming or implicating people and addresses not in the public eye or with no direct connection to the story, especially where details are unclear or still emerging. Remember, even Hollywood rabbits attract the odd flea: please do not engage with drive-by scolders who seem to have their own agenda and seek to derail. Avoid @'ing and quoting them as - from experience - this will only encourage them back to the threads. For nearly a year we have done amazingly well together for 26 very interesting, very serious and very silly, threads so far. I can't be here as much as I'd like so all help with keeping our discussion walking along in our usual reasonable and respectful fashion is very welcome.

We are still here after 26,000 posts and fast approaching our one year anniversary together on 6th July 2026, 12 months on from the start of our first thread in response to Our Chloe's somewhat stunning initial exposé. Little did we know what else would come out. Our longevity comes as both a total surprise and a pleasure (mostly!). We've seen charabancers come and go, come back again, delurk and join us for the first time. All are welcome. Threads have both filled up in a day and moved at a more stately pace. Thank you everyone for sharing your time, thoughts, opinions, experience, questions, sleuthing (there's that word!), kindness (there's that other word!) and great humour with me and with each other. As ever, as we embark on our 27th thread riding the community charabanc - this time all holding our brollies and fans aloft for much-needed shade and breeze - keep to the path, no saltiness, eat fudge and drink cider, (but not too much in the current heatwave).

NO POSTS PLEASE UNTIL THREAD 26 IS FULL:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5506717-thread-26-to-feel-disappointed-and-disgusted-and-vindicated-now-too-after-reading-this-in-the-observer-about-the-author-and-her-husband-from-the-salt-path-book-and-film?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
102
Freshsocks · 19/07/2026 12:46

I think you could be right @ShinyBlueTractor, there is no mention of the film being based on a true story. Maybe they hope to release the film as a stand alone project, separated from the books, but if that is the case, I wonder how they will deal with questions that will inevitably be asked about TSP?

ShinyBlueTractor · 19/07/2026 09:51

BrandiedAromatics · 13/07/2026 23:48

The US and Canada release isn't until 28 August. The lady in the green tracksuit is one of those who says: “Working with Marianne on her first feature was a rare opportunity to translate an intimate, deeply felt story to the screen,” said producers Elizabeth Karlsen and Stephen Woolley.

Gillian Anderson, Jason Isaacs Drama 'The Salt Path' Gets U.S. Release

I've been following along with interest but probably missed a few posts along the way, so apologies as this has no doubt already been asked and answered - is it significant that the blurb for the US film release never at any point says it's true? I'm seeing "drama" and "story" in this article but not "real" - is this a low key rebrand at work?

HatStickBoots · 16/07/2026 18:25

YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree · 16/07/2026 13:49

One interpretation of what the leaping miracle photo conjured in my mind [Not Generative-AI - just old fashioned photo editing.]

🤣 Love it. Being bucked off! 🤣 These pictures deserve to be published in the new annotated version of TSP!

MrKippling · 16/07/2026 16:59

I wonder if the TW star jump photo is actually a photo of TW on his knees on the ground with his arms raised upwards, and it has been photo-shopped with him doing this 'bionic' star jump. Looking at the lightened photo, even with a setting sun, surely there would be some shadow on the ground? (I could be wrong)

I forgot to add with my post on the critic's praise of SW's trilogy. If OWN does get published will PRH send advanced copies out for review in order to have the critics praise/comments splashed across the covers and in the book as well. What right minded critic, who probably now be well aware of TSP scandal, OC's expose via The Observer, and the shady, criminal reputations of SW and TW, would be able to take the book at face value and say how honest, unflinching, moving etc. when there is the strong likelihood it will be a bogus book of lies, with sneering, patronising comments about all individuals that SW encounters, and how everyone is inferior to the love shared between SW and TW.

I remember a few years ago there was that it was revealed that publishers were failing to be honest with critics comments used as reviews on book covers, were a review could be damning with faint praise, the damning comments were excluded to just leave praise! I also remember that some authors became cover quoters for hire, from my recollection - step forward the late Terry Pratchett, one such Pratchett cover comment I remember from the 90s was on William Kotzwinkel's The Bear Went Over The Mountain, uk paperback edition "Very funny" commented Pratchett "and probably very true" (I read the book and for me it was no to both) Pratchett later acknowledged he did not read all the books that he provided comment on! Btw - to any Pratchett fans I am not knocking Pratchett, I have read many of his books and enjoyed them, but he did become ubiquitous appearing on the covers of other authors works.

Peladon · 16/07/2026 15:25

On my phone the photo isn't very clear. Is it definitely someone leaping high in the air, not kneeling on a grassy knoll with his hands thrown in the air? Apologies if that is a very silly question.

YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree · 16/07/2026 13:49

One interpretation of what the leaping miracle photo conjured in my mind [Not Generative-AI - just old fashioned photo editing.]

Thread 27 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film?
YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree · 16/07/2026 13:25

ThompsonTwin · 16/07/2026 07:23

Could you take such a photo with the sort of camera phone they took with them on LL?

I reckon so. What is unusual, however, is the lack of blur in Tim's jump. To achieve zero blur in low light for this jump, it would require very accurate timing to capture Tim at the very moment he is neither rising nor falling. If I were to guess, Sal likely used a burst mode on her phone/camera to take a series of shots very quickly. It could be a still from a video but i think the quality of the light enhanced image would be far worse.

NowSober · 16/07/2026 09:45

Mauvish1 · 15/07/2026 17:42

I've just tried jumping like TW** and getting your legs and arms up isn't difficult, but to get that high off the ground you'd need to be spring-heeled Jack.

The photo may be faked, but I'm inclined to think that maybe the photographer was very low on the ground to give the illusion of height. I don't think it's a mock up of a kneeling photo because his feet look to be slightly lower than his knees. I'm sure, if the jump happened in that spot, that the photo must have been manipulated; it looks as though any glare or errant rays from the sun (as shown in the photo without TW) have been removed. You'd also need to shoot dozens of photos (which would be exhausting for the jumper), or shoot as a reel and pick out that one frame, as the chances of getting it right first time would be very low.

Now given that Sal only has a simple brick phone and is completely unversed in more sophisticated technology, who could have done that, I wonder.

** For the benefit of veracity, I don't have CBD!

I was a professional photographer for five years & looking at that photo with an experienced eye I immediately thought that it had been taken with the photographer low down looking up. It's probably just a lucky shot although it could have been a still extracted from a video

ThompsonTwin · 16/07/2026 07:23

YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree · 15/07/2026 23:07

You wouldn't. You can only get flare if the Sun hits the lens, so if he obscured it as a leaping Moth eclipse there would be no flare. Flare can't bend round objects, it is an artefact of direct sunlight coming in at an angle inside a lens.

Edited

Could you take such a photo with the sort of camera phone they took with them on LL?

YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree · 15/07/2026 23:07

Mauvish1 · 15/07/2026 19:49

But you'd still get flare around our spring heeled friend, unless the sun had gone below the horizon by then.

You wouldn't. You can only get flare if the Sun hits the lens, so if he obscured it as a leaping Moth eclipse there would be no flare. Flare can't bend round objects, it is an artefact of direct sunlight coming in at an angle inside a lens.

Anythingbutheadlands · 15/07/2026 22:51

There are a few more negative comments on the latest Insta post. I’m glad people are managing to post but frustrated that my comments were being blocked. Maybe because I made a new profile but had no posts or followers so appeared like a bot? Shame as I enjoyed making up names. Doubtful Shed, TickTack, Shara Banks …

Meanwhile, planning to see The Odyssey film which begins with the quote:
“Tell me about a complicated man.
Muse, tell me how he wandered and was lost” I was then horribly transported back to the start of TSP. Only SalRay could steal an epic quote from Homer and apply it to mars-bar-eating-Tim.

Oeufs · 15/07/2026 21:28

Mauvish1 · 15/07/2026 19:49

But you'd still get flare around our spring heeled friend, unless the sun had gone below the horizon by then.

Perhaps Moth is so majestically large he causes eclipses?

He certainly looks much the same size as Genial Man-Mountain Dave from Up North when they're photographed side-by-side, despite all SW's protestations of him looking all shrunken and fragile in comparison.

Mauvish1 · 15/07/2026 19:49

But you'd still get flare around our spring heeled friend, unless the sun had gone below the horizon by then.

YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree · 15/07/2026 19:46

Mauvish1 · 15/07/2026 17:42

I've just tried jumping like TW** and getting your legs and arms up isn't difficult, but to get that high off the ground you'd need to be spring-heeled Jack.

The photo may be faked, but I'm inclined to think that maybe the photographer was very low on the ground to give the illusion of height. I don't think it's a mock up of a kneeling photo because his feet look to be slightly lower than his knees. I'm sure, if the jump happened in that spot, that the photo must have been manipulated; it looks as though any glare or errant rays from the sun (as shown in the photo without TW) have been removed. You'd also need to shoot dozens of photos (which would be exhausting for the jumper), or shoot as a reel and pick out that one frame, as the chances of getting it right first time would be very low.

Now given that Sal only has a simple brick phone and is completely unversed in more sophisticated technology, who could have done that, I wonder.

** For the benefit of veracity, I don't have CBD!

I think the sun is obscured behind Jumping Jack Moth.

HatStickBoots · 15/07/2026 19:32

😂🤣 Moth and the tortoise!

HatStickBoots · 15/07/2026 19:28

Thank you @YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree 😀 It really is a pity that we can’t have a neurologists’ convention and show them the miraculous proof here that perilous walking on a diet of noodles and fudge not only cures CBD but frightens the hell out of it. I think Moth may be the new Chuck Norris.

ThompsonTwin · 15/07/2026 19:23

Moth out for a walk in Polruan, with Lettuce!

Thread 27 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film?
ThompsonTwin · 15/07/2026 19:16

MrKippling · 15/07/2026 17:14

These AI pictures are fantastic, well done to the people who created them. When I look at the cat herding picture I can hear either the theme music to Bonanza or the film The High Country 😀

The photo of TW's star jump really is an insult to those that do have CBD, I feel sorry for any person with CBD being told by a relative "look what TW can do, you try, you do it, you'll be better for it!" The Walker clan are utterly shameless in their deception.

Out of idle curiosity I have pulled out SW's trilogy (not to re-read, I hasten to add) But to read the quotes and promotional reviews on the covers. I was wondering if any of the reviewers post OC's Observer article and podcast feel that their reviews that were given in good faith at the time of publication are still valid after the expose?

On TSP:

A beautiful, thoughtful, lyrical story of homelessness, human strength and endurance - The Guardian

The most inspirational book of the year. Conveys the human capacity for endurance and the regenerative power of nature - The Times

A tale of triumph; of hope over despair of love over everything - The Sunday Times

etc.

On TWS:

Extraordinary - The Observer [it certainly was, it was completely bogus!]

Notions of home are poignantly explored ... her evocations of weather, landscape, the sea and her love for her partner, Moth ... are wonderful - The Guardian

TWS confirms Raynor as a a natural and extremely talented writer ... so moving it made me cry - Sophie Rayworth

etc

My hardback copy of LL does not have any critic or review comments.

Now post OC's articles, do these glowing reviews have any validity now that tawdry criminality of SW and TW is now revealed. And now the real truth is known and in the public domain (not SW's version of the truth) would the reviewers really want to have their praise permanently linked to a bogus memoir? Could the reviewers either request or insist that their comments or reviews be removed as they were given in good faith of the book being an honest memoir? And by the comments remaining it could be considered a form of misrepresentation or misleading to the book buying public.

I wonder if Moth would ever be invited to appear on the panel of 'Would I lie to You?' with David Mitchell.... (For some reason ChatGPT has mixed up 'Would I lie to You' with 'Who do you think you are' !!!!

Thread 27 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film?
HatStickBoots · 15/07/2026 18:42

MrKippling · 15/07/2026 17:14

These AI pictures are fantastic, well done to the people who created them. When I look at the cat herding picture I can hear either the theme music to Bonanza or the film The High Country 😀

The photo of TW's star jump really is an insult to those that do have CBD, I feel sorry for any person with CBD being told by a relative "look what TW can do, you try, you do it, you'll be better for it!" The Walker clan are utterly shameless in their deception.

Out of idle curiosity I have pulled out SW's trilogy (not to re-read, I hasten to add) But to read the quotes and promotional reviews on the covers. I was wondering if any of the reviewers post OC's Observer article and podcast feel that their reviews that were given in good faith at the time of publication are still valid after the expose?

On TSP:

A beautiful, thoughtful, lyrical story of homelessness, human strength and endurance - The Guardian

The most inspirational book of the year. Conveys the human capacity for endurance and the regenerative power of nature - The Times

A tale of triumph; of hope over despair of love over everything - The Sunday Times

etc.

On TWS:

Extraordinary - The Observer [it certainly was, it was completely bogus!]

Notions of home are poignantly explored ... her evocations of weather, landscape, the sea and her love for her partner, Moth ... are wonderful - The Guardian

TWS confirms Raynor as a a natural and extremely talented writer ... so moving it made me cry - Sophie Rayworth

etc

My hardback copy of LL does not have any critic or review comments.

Now post OC's articles, do these glowing reviews have any validity now that tawdry criminality of SW and TW is now revealed. And now the real truth is known and in the public domain (not SW's version of the truth) would the reviewers really want to have their praise permanently linked to a bogus memoir? Could the reviewers either request or insist that their comments or reviews be removed as they were given in good faith of the book being an honest memoir? And by the comments remaining it could be considered a form of misrepresentation or misleading to the book buying public.

Yes, I’ve said exactly the same thing about those reviews! I also think of the books that Raynor Winn has been asked to provide a little tagline or foreword for 😬
I definitely think those reviews contributed to its success because they are reputable sources. So many people conned!

HatStickBoots · 15/07/2026 18:37

ThompsonTwin · 15/07/2026 15:06

Only fair that Ray should make an appearance - no prizes for guessing where this shot comes from!

That is my favourite yet! 🤩 Fantastic! Does the Ai manipulate her facial expression too or was the original photo of her like that? I’ve never used chat gpt to know these things. Very, very poignant moment when Ray looks the future and sees herself as half of a pasty.
👏👏👏

Oeufs · 15/07/2026 18:34

Mauvish1 · 15/07/2026 17:42

I've just tried jumping like TW** and getting your legs and arms up isn't difficult, but to get that high off the ground you'd need to be spring-heeled Jack.

The photo may be faked, but I'm inclined to think that maybe the photographer was very low on the ground to give the illusion of height. I don't think it's a mock up of a kneeling photo because his feet look to be slightly lower than his knees. I'm sure, if the jump happened in that spot, that the photo must have been manipulated; it looks as though any glare or errant rays from the sun (as shown in the photo without TW) have been removed. You'd also need to shoot dozens of photos (which would be exhausting for the jumper), or shoot as a reel and pick out that one frame, as the chances of getting it right first time would be very low.

Now given that Sal only has a simple brick phone and is completely unversed in more sophisticated technology, who could have done that, I wonder.

** For the benefit of veracity, I don't have CBD!

Oh, TW probably trained at the Bolshoi in one of his many other lives, when not playing football, herding llamas with cats, and being an ecowarrior called Moth who heroically manacled himself to threatened trees or lurked with Swampy in tunnels under future motorways. Maybe he was a promising young member of the corps de ballet when the siren call of SW's woodcreature charms drew him back to a Staffordshire college cafeteria and that fatal Mars bar.

Mauvish1 · 15/07/2026 17:42

I've just tried jumping like TW** and getting your legs and arms up isn't difficult, but to get that high off the ground you'd need to be spring-heeled Jack.

The photo may be faked, but I'm inclined to think that maybe the photographer was very low on the ground to give the illusion of height. I don't think it's a mock up of a kneeling photo because his feet look to be slightly lower than his knees. I'm sure, if the jump happened in that spot, that the photo must have been manipulated; it looks as though any glare or errant rays from the sun (as shown in the photo without TW) have been removed. You'd also need to shoot dozens of photos (which would be exhausting for the jumper), or shoot as a reel and pick out that one frame, as the chances of getting it right first time would be very low.

Now given that Sal only has a simple brick phone and is completely unversed in more sophisticated technology, who could have done that, I wonder.

** For the benefit of veracity, I don't have CBD!

MrKippling · 15/07/2026 17:14

These AI pictures are fantastic, well done to the people who created them. When I look at the cat herding picture I can hear either the theme music to Bonanza or the film The High Country 😀

The photo of TW's star jump really is an insult to those that do have CBD, I feel sorry for any person with CBD being told by a relative "look what TW can do, you try, you do it, you'll be better for it!" The Walker clan are utterly shameless in their deception.

Out of idle curiosity I have pulled out SW's trilogy (not to re-read, I hasten to add) But to read the quotes and promotional reviews on the covers. I was wondering if any of the reviewers post OC's Observer article and podcast feel that their reviews that were given in good faith at the time of publication are still valid after the expose?

On TSP:

A beautiful, thoughtful, lyrical story of homelessness, human strength and endurance - The Guardian

The most inspirational book of the year. Conveys the human capacity for endurance and the regenerative power of nature - The Times

A tale of triumph; of hope over despair of love over everything - The Sunday Times

etc.

On TWS:

Extraordinary - The Observer [it certainly was, it was completely bogus!]

Notions of home are poignantly explored ... her evocations of weather, landscape, the sea and her love for her partner, Moth ... are wonderful - The Guardian

TWS confirms Raynor as a a natural and extremely talented writer ... so moving it made me cry - Sophie Rayworth

etc

My hardback copy of LL does not have any critic or review comments.

Now post OC's articles, do these glowing reviews have any validity now that tawdry criminality of SW and TW is now revealed. And now the real truth is known and in the public domain (not SW's version of the truth) would the reviewers really want to have their praise permanently linked to a bogus memoir? Could the reviewers either request or insist that their comments or reviews be removed as they were given in good faith of the book being an honest memoir? And by the comments remaining it could be considered a form of misrepresentation or misleading to the book buying public.

YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree · 15/07/2026 16:30

@HatStickBoots I enhanced the lighting to see it more clearly. I think it is real, which only goes to show how Tim really wasn't ill.

Thread 27 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film?
Swipe left for the next trending thread