Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that the term "Bastard Children" is not and never will an acceptable way to talk

160 replies

ALMazing · 19/06/2008 11:08

about a child born out of wedlock.

Just wondering as another poster on Mumsnet seems to think that it is.

And I don t give a fark if I am telling tales. As a "bastard child" of the seventies it hit me hard that someone would still use that term especially on Mumsnet.

OP posts:
ALMazing · 19/06/2008 13:21

Do you know I just sat and typed a lengthy response to all this and then deleted it because you are right whisywhisp time to walk away.

NJM you were wrong to use that term and you are now trying to dodge the issue. Keep going I couldn't give two hoots about it now. Please feel free to get this thread deleted if you feel so strongly about it.

OP posts:
mrsruffallo · 19/06/2008 13:21

Oh, this is crap
NJM's remark was an off the cuff expression loaded with humour.
I don't think it was meant as a genuine insult to children of unwed parents or muslims.

notjustmom · 19/06/2008 13:21

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Rhubarb · 19/06/2008 13:12

(Re-reading Shakespeare for today's Mumsnet: King John
Enter Robert Faulconbridge and Philip, his brother....Patronagely challenged Philip I know not why, except to get the land. But once he slander'd me with .....

Not got the same ring to it, somehow...

notjustmom · 19/06/2008 13:12

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

whispywhisp · 19/06/2008 13:11

ALMazing....give it a rest now...please?

You've made your point. You didn't like what NJM put on the BB thread. I think you've made that perfectly clear.

Time to put this one to bed now surely please?

notjustmom · 19/06/2008 13:10

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ALMazing · 19/06/2008 13:10

I don t know that at all VS. Alex has a child born when she was underage and out of wedlock. Who on earth else is NJM talking about?

OP posts:
VictorianSqualor · 19/06/2008 13:07

That's rubbish.
Alexandra (bb housemate for those of you who don't know) kicked off at Mohammed (another housemate) claiming he was a bad musli8m because he was dressing up in girls clothes and drinking.
NJM said that the Quoran did not advocate underage sex and bastard children'

How is that in any context other than religious?
Are you claiming she has made an assumption on Alexandra's child without even meeting/seeing her and is trying to insult her?
Because you know as well as I, that is not the case.

ALMazing · 19/06/2008 13:00

IMO NJM was not using it in a religious context but was referring to one of the Big Brother House Members daughters.

I am sorry if you are upset NJM but tbh if I had not linked to your original post someone else would have. I was not the only one who noticed and was offended by it. I did not feel that the Big Brother thread was the place to discuss this and was also asked to pass over it by another poster.

I don t think anyone who has not experienced it knows what it is like to be abused for the circumstances of your birth and that is all I thought about when I read that term on the thread. A 7 year old little girl being referred to in that way is wrong. I feel very strongly about this for various personal reasons. I am not just waiting to be offended by Mumsnet.

VS I did post on the initial Big Brother thread first with a post for NJM and then posted here later in the morning.

I still think it is an extremely offensive term and it was not used in a general context the op was referring to someone specific and that makes it unacceptable imo.

OP posts:
WilyWombat · 19/06/2008 12:45
Grin
VictorianSqualor · 19/06/2008 12:33

and then post in AIBU to get the most answers

Rhubarb · 19/06/2008 12:33

What was that Willy?

notjustmom · 19/06/2008 12:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

WilyWombat · 19/06/2008 12:28

LOL - I have also just had to re-check my mumsnet name as people keep responding to me as "Willy" this is about the 4th or 5th time.

VictorianSqualor · 19/06/2008 12:28

Gosh I really hate these threads.
IF you feel something deserves a new thread, which the use of the word bastard as a description of a child may well warrant then at least have the decency to start the new thread and link it where the original post was made, especially if you want to talk about rights and wrongs.

IMO what NJM said was perfectly justified, she was talking about religion, which would use words such as 'bastard children' it was not meant to be an insult.

Personally I think "Just wondering as another poster on Mumsnet seems to think that it is." is low without giving 'another poster on mumsnet' a chance to put her point across.

Teuch · 19/06/2008 12:28

well, it did take me some time to traw through...

No, I wasn't reading the press release link!!...

WilyWombat · 19/06/2008 12:27

"Perhaps its time for bastards and their parents everywhere (there are enough of us) to reclaim it"

Nice theory and one that the rap world tried with the word "n*gger" unfortunately it still didnt work because it can still be perceived as an insult.

notjustmom · 19/06/2008 12:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PuppyMonkey · 19/06/2008 12:25

I agree, whether offence was meant or not, whether in context/or not it is a nasty and objectionable word now/today/at this moment. Especially to those of us who (quite proudly, I might add so ner ner) have kids born "out of wedlock."

...Just like some other words that are now deemed nasty and objectionable so are not used in polite conversation, whether in context or not etc etc. Like some of the racist terms, for example.

So I think the op is not being unreasonable!

Teuch · 19/06/2008 12:24

I am a bastard, sometimes a cheeky bastard and sometimes just a lucky bastard.

I was a clever bastard and searched the term 'bastard child' before the link was even posted.

Most threads like this are triggered by other threads and you will find that lots of us will do a quick search.

I did notice on the BB thread that someone else actually stated that they didn't want it discussed there so I understand the new thread.

Rhubarb · 19/06/2008 12:20

So I contributed a post on Mumsnet and used the Shakespearean term "bastard child" in context because I was referring to Shakespeare in the post, that would be wrong would it?

I think if you are going to slag off someone's post you need to quote their post in it's entireity, and that particular post was being quoted within a Bibical context in which they did refer to "bastard children".

Just out of interest, if you did have to read Shakespeare, would you replace many of the terms there for more pc ones?

notjustmom · 19/06/2008 12:15

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

herbietea · 19/06/2008 12:15

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

didoreth · 19/06/2008 12:13

link to etymological dictionary - seems to have been around a long time before was adopted as term of abuse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread