Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that the term "Bastard Children" is not and never will an acceptable way to talk

160 replies

ALMazing · 19/06/2008 11:08

about a child born out of wedlock.

Just wondering as another poster on Mumsnet seems to think that it is.

And I don t give a fark if I am telling tales. As a "bastard child" of the seventies it hit me hard that someone would still use that term especially on Mumsnet.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GoodOldDays · 11/11/2022 17:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

bb99 · 20/06/2008 19:53

IMO context is everything.

Bastard became a 'bad' word because in days of yore it was considered 'bad' to be born outside of wedlock and very poor form for the mother (tsk, tsk, naughty harlotty unchristian woman...).

So it is now a 'bad' word, or a 'swear' word, that can be used to insult someone.

BUT being a 'bastard' isn't such an unacceptable thing to be these days, especially among the younger generations. My DD, from the 'wrong side of the sheets' as some people describe it, or 'my unexpected blessing' as I like to describe her, doesn't have a problem being illegitimate.

She does have a massive problem that a word, which is considered to be so offensive (eg a 'swear word') could be used to describe her because of the circumstances of her birth. It's not the actual word she finds hard, but that the word has now become a bad word, eg people tend to use it to describe an unpleasant person, or someone who has been completely unreasonable (utter bastard). She doesn't mind being considered illegitimate, it is a fact. She HATES thinking that she could be thought of as an unpleasant person (sort of how the word is used today).

Context is everything - I don't think it's acceptable to use as a term of reference because it has insulting overtones, rather like me not expecting people to refer to my lady bits as a cunt lady bit, even though it is technically that, as that term has insulting connotations.

NotDoingTheHousework · 20/06/2008 19:16

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

yoursurroundedbyarmedbastards · 19/06/2008 22:53

Horrible horrible term. Many moons ago when I was still in the land of the working my then manager described my DSD as a bastard child. I very nearly decked him one. He really couldn't see the problem with it even though the all the staff had a go at him he still claimed he was right. Needless to say I handed my notice in shortly after.

cory · 19/06/2008 14:58

sleepycat on Thu 19-Jun-08 11:28:05
"I think historically a bastard child meant the Father was completely unknown."

Not necessarily. William the Bastard's father was the Duke of Normandy. Seems an odd term for someone to use who wasn't born in the 11th century though

CaptainUnderpants · 19/06/2008 14:31

Therss a connecion here somewhere -Alex on BB just went on and on about things and never let go just like some posters here .

The context it was used was OK.

How can BB cause such issues amongst MN !

TheFallenMadonna · 19/06/2008 14:24

You see, that's why this is so difficult. We disagree. One of us is always going to be more offended...

Perhaps quotes ('bastard') would have made it better - more obvious that it was reference.

Anyway. Looks like the principals have moved on.

TheHedgeWitch · 19/06/2008 14:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Nocca · 19/06/2008 14:17

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TheFallenMadonna · 19/06/2008 14:13

Noooo. Illegitimate is horrible.

TheHedgeWitch · 19/06/2008 14:11

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

SaintGeorge · 19/06/2008 14:06

This still going?

Sheesh, I've been to work, done some shopping and queued for 20 minutes behind some slow bastards OAPs in the Post Office.

Thought this one would have been put to bed by now.

(please note, use of the word bastard above was intended as a deliberate insult and no way implies I have knowledge of the parentage of said OAPs)

whispywhisp · 19/06/2008 13:59

ALMazing...please do us ALL a favour and leave this be. NJM was not directing her comments about bastard children at YOU personally, was she? Why you have taken all this personally is beyond me. I quite often read stuff on MN that I don't like or disagree with but I would never start a thread targetting that poster and nor would I drag this on and on, which you've got to agree you have done. I do what I have suggested to you and that is walk away. NJM has apologised. Is that not enough?

mrsruffallo · 19/06/2008 13:59

Maybe she meant horrible by 'bastard'?

NotDoingTheHousework · 19/06/2008 13:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Rhubarb · 19/06/2008 13:55
Rhubarb · 19/06/2008 13:55

ALM, boy I'd hate to be someone who offends you, because an apology would never do would it? You'd have to grind them to the ground and then spit on them for good measure!

njm apologised on the original thread and on this one. You quoted her out of context but obviously that's fine in your book. You started a new thread instead of sticking to the original one, but that's ok too isn't it? If anything, I think it's you who should apologise to njm. She's come across on this thread as being very reasonable and considered and polite, whereas you are just being offensive for the sake of it now.

WilyWombat · 19/06/2008 13:55

"whatever" LOL njm you forgot "speak to the hand"

AL I was impressed I thought the meant you had accepted the apology and moved on...obviously I was wrong.

notjustmom · 19/06/2008 13:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TheFallenMadonna · 19/06/2008 13:45

Do you know, I almost prefer 'bastard' to 'illegitimate'.

VictorianSqualor · 19/06/2008 13:45

ALMazing.
Whether or not your parents were married I think you're being a bit of a bastard.

Oliveoil · 19/06/2008 13:45

I am not narky Rhubarb, you bitter veg (fruit?) as I am currently in sunny mcr and the land of the living

ALMazing · 19/06/2008 13:44

Oh poor old you njm. Just stop will you. You farkin said it with regards to a contestant on BB who has clearly had underage sex and now has a child while unmarried. Why did you not just use the term out of wedlock or illegitimate? Neither ideal but certainly better than "bastard children". You blardly said it and just keep going on and on about how you didnt mean it this way or that way. I am not crazy or spiteful. I would NEVER use that term to describe anyone or in reference to anything. If you honestly believe that you have done nothing wrong then just leave it there instead of whinging on and on.

OP posts:
VictorianSqualor · 19/06/2008 13:43

MRSR, NJM actually apologised on the previous thread!
Not that the OP would just accept that and move on, on no.
We need a public tar and feather session.

whispywhisp · 19/06/2008 13:43

Is that it? Are we done with this thread now? Glad to see ALMazing you took my advice to walk away. Best option I think. Enough has been said.

Let's talk about something else!...The weather? Nice and sunny here!