Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Update to AIBU to refuse Aunt's fwb claim on her estate.

845 replies

Sleepneededprettyplease · 07/04/2026 17:52

Posting here because it is where I put the first thread.

A brief summery is that my Aunt died and her FWB is trying to say that he is entitled to part of her estate because she had asked me to allow him to stay in a house she had invested in for me. Anyway if you want the full story feel free to read what I put on the first thread.

Anyway the main thing is that he is now sueing in the courts. I need a bit of a hand hold please. My lawyers have suggested getting a barristers opinion so I am just waiting for that. I wouldn't even mind if it was possible to just go to mediation but he wants the house for the rest of his life and won't consider anything else.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5505433-aibu-to-refuse-aunts-fwb-claim-on-her-estate?utm_campaign=thread&utm_medium=share

OP posts:
Bigcat25 · 09/04/2026 13:39

Wow, op what an absolute asshole. If he's into gender norms he should be paying his own way and not mooching off two women.

Sleepneededprettyplease · 09/04/2026 13:35

Woodfiresareamazing · 09/04/2026 13:28

Why doesn't he feel you are a "proper woman"? That's bizarre.

And just another excuse for not moving out.

Oh he feels that women shouldn't work in the area I do. Blaims the infertility on my job and thinks women should be at home with babies. Which is hilarious as my Aunt was way more radical in her feminism and outlook.

He had to shut up if she was around. Most of this has been said after her death.

I am not worried about the opinion of an anacronistic dinosaur like him.

OP posts:
Woodfiresareamazing · 09/04/2026 13:28

Sleepneededprettyplease · 09/04/2026 07:04

Thank you for this summary. I think thos is the truth. He may still feel he can force me to give in. He always has been dismissive of me as he feels I am not a 'proper woman'. I do however think there is a certlevwl of revenge in his actions. I just don't know where we will end up.

On one side his case has no standing but he is blind ro that realty.

On the other I will act within reason to lessen my costs but I will not agree to him staying. I am trying to keep a lid on solicitors fees etc and not have them do unnecessary bits but I do have to respond to legal letters and court documents. It all adds up.

Why doesn't he feel you are a "proper woman"? That's bizarre.

And just another excuse for not moving out.

Sleepneededprettyplease · 09/04/2026 11:47

Daleksatemyshed · 09/04/2026 11:30

Let's face it Op, a lifetime of no rent has got to save him huge amounts of money, far more than the estate could give him. Do you have a court date or is he just dragging this out as long as possible?

Dragging it out atm

OP posts:
Daleksatemyshed · 09/04/2026 11:30

Let's face it Op, a lifetime of no rent has got to save him huge amounts of money, far more than the estate could give him. Do you have a court date or is he just dragging this out as long as possible?

Sleepneededprettyplease · 09/04/2026 10:53

fashionqueen0123 · 09/04/2026 10:45

I have a feeling if the executor was another person he wouldn’t be doing this though

Also possibly true.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 09/04/2026 10:52

browneyes77 · 09/04/2026 10:01

I am not a legal expert by any means

But.

He is trying to claim he was financially dependent on your Aunt.

However, he agreed to pay rent on a property that you own, meaning he wasn’t financially dependent on her for housing. He was simply a tenant and you are his landlord.

He also paid the bills there. So he wasn’t financially dependent on your aunt for those.

And she wasn’t his carer.

They didn’t live in the property together and were not spouses/married.

So on the surface, he wasn’t financially dependent on her for anything. Which from my understanding is the basic legal definition of a dependent. Someone (usually a relative or spouse) who relies on someone else for financial support and care.

He just moved into a property as a tenant. Didn’t pay the rent, but paid the bills. And now he is being evicted by the landlord (you) as the house is going up for sale.

I don’t see how he can think that, legally, he has a case!

Seems more to me he’s just trying to drag things out so he can live there longer.

Edited

This is probably true.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 09/04/2026 10:51

AluckyEllie · 09/04/2026 08:53

When you get the bailiffs in to get him out (and definitely do this- it will not be a new story to them) change all the locks immediately. Could you get a clearance firm in the same day to remove all his stuff that is left in the house? As long as he’s had clear warning before the day I think you can do this? Completely clear the house- I guess you’ll want to want to wait to get it decorated for sale etc until the court process is done.

Yes. It is a little tricky as it I don't want to have to go there more than necessary. So many good memories that are now swamped by stress. I will get this organised though.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 09/04/2026 10:49

suggestionsplease1 · 09/04/2026 08:23

You said earlier on the thread that he's terrible with money OP...he's not a gambler is he? Because if he's got a gambler's mindset he might think he's got a chance taking this all the way when most regular people would recognise that they're on a hiding to nothing and give up sooner perhaps?

Which may be a little more reassuring to you in terms of unlikelihood of success ie. He's maybe happy to pursue a 1 in 500 likelihood when most people wouldn't.

I still think it's a bit concerning about the deferred fees situation but he's got a gambler's mindset I could see how he might go all-in on a longshot.

Not a gambler I don't think. Just grew up with certain expectations of lifestyle that he still expects to maintain whilst no longer having the means.

OP posts:
fashionqueen0123 · 09/04/2026 10:45

LovesLabradors · 08/04/2026 23:49

She's the Executor @fashionqueen0123

I have a feeling if the executor was another person he wouldn’t be doing this though

browneyes77 · 09/04/2026 10:01

Sleepneededprettyplease · 08/04/2026 07:01

Yes but he is sueing her estate saying that he was a dependent and therefore needs to stay in the house.

I am not a legal expert by any means

But.

He is trying to claim he was financially dependent on your Aunt.

However, he agreed to pay rent on a property that you own, meaning he wasn’t financially dependent on her for housing. He was simply a tenant and you are his landlord.

He also paid the bills there. So he wasn’t financially dependent on your aunt for those.

And she wasn’t his carer.

They didn’t live in the property together and were not spouses/married.

So on the surface, he wasn’t financially dependent on her for anything. Which from my understanding is the basic legal definition of a dependent. Someone (usually a relative or spouse) who relies on someone else for financial support and care.

He just moved into a property as a tenant. Didn’t pay the rent, but paid the bills. And now he is being evicted by the landlord (you) as the house is going up for sale.

I don’t see how he can think that, legally, he has a case!

Seems more to me he’s just trying to drag things out so he can live there longer.

Lennonjingles · 09/04/2026 09:16

I’ve read both your posts and it’s really unbelievable what this man is doing, can only assume he thinks he has nothing to loose by going down this legal route just to have somewhere to live. I’m glad you’ve stopped taking calls from him. I hope you’ve got bailiffs arranged for when his time is up. Then let him take it to Court, it’s going to cost him a small fortune suing an Estate, especially when he wasn’t even mentioned in the Will of your Aunt.

AluckyEllie · 09/04/2026 08:53

When you get the bailiffs in to get him out (and definitely do this- it will not be a new story to them) change all the locks immediately. Could you get a clearance firm in the same day to remove all his stuff that is left in the house? As long as he’s had clear warning before the day I think you can do this? Completely clear the house- I guess you’ll want to want to wait to get it decorated for sale etc until the court process is done.

suggestionsplease1 · 09/04/2026 08:23

You said earlier on the thread that he's terrible with money OP...he's not a gambler is he? Because if he's got a gambler's mindset he might think he's got a chance taking this all the way when most regular people would recognise that they're on a hiding to nothing and give up sooner perhaps?

Which may be a little more reassuring to you in terms of unlikelihood of success ie. He's maybe happy to pursue a 1 in 500 likelihood when most people wouldn't.

I still think it's a bit concerning about the deferred fees situation but he's got a gambler's mindset I could see how he might go all-in on a longshot.

Sleepneededprettyplease · 09/04/2026 07:04

PyongyangKipperbang · 09/04/2026 01:57

He had made it clear that he doesnt want money, the OP has floated this. He wants to keep the house, free and clear. If he doesnt get that then his intention is to make the OP use all of her inheritance (including the house) in legal costs as revenge.

He is on to a loser there as no lawyer would take a "No win, no fee" that far, but clearly he lacks that level of critical thinking.

Thank you for this summary. I think thos is the truth. He may still feel he can force me to give in. He always has been dismissive of me as he feels I am not a 'proper woman'. I do however think there is a certlevwl of revenge in his actions. I just don't know where we will end up.

On one side his case has no standing but he is blind ro that realty.

On the other I will act within reason to lessen my costs but I will not agree to him staying. I am trying to keep a lid on solicitors fees etc and not have them do unnecessary bits but I do have to respond to legal letters and court documents. It all adds up.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 09/04/2026 06:58

MyTrivia · 09/04/2026 04:19

I meant to say. My uncle had ‘assumed’ that he would be gifted the entire house after his wife passed away.

What a nightmare. Yes another entitled so and so trying to use the law to claim what they shouldn't have.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 09/04/2026 06:56

WallaceinAnderland · 08/04/2026 23:53

The argument is:

'does asking me to let him stay count as giving financial support because it was housing without really paying'

The answer is clearly no.

Judges look at intentions.

Giving 'financial support' is not the same as intending to support someone for the rest of their life. Therefore your Aunt asking if he could stay in your house does not make him her legal dependent with a claim on her estate.

Definitions in laws have meanings. Either he is legally dependent or he isn't.

You cannot just say that because someone helped you out once that makes you a legal dependent entitled to claim on their estate.

I can't understand why your solicitors have not already assured you that he has no claim.

He is not going to take this court because he knows he will lose. He doesn't want to go to court, he just wants you to let him live in your house. Once you have evicted him I'm pretty sure he'll just go away.

Definitely continue to ignore his calls. Mute or block him. If there is any actual action from him his solicitors will write to you. Just try to forget about him now, this will soon be over.

This is what I thought but he has filed in court. My solicitors are confused too because they don't think he has a claim but he is suing in court.

OP posts:
MyTrivia · 09/04/2026 04:19

I meant to say. My uncle had ‘assumed’ that he would be gifted the entire house after his wife passed away.

K2054 · 09/04/2026 04:12

PyongyangKipperbang · 09/04/2026 01:57

He had made it clear that he doesnt want money, the OP has floated this. He wants to keep the house, free and clear. If he doesnt get that then his intention is to make the OP use all of her inheritance (including the house) in legal costs as revenge.

He is on to a loser there as no lawyer would take a "No win, no fee" that far, but clearly he lacks that level of critical thinking.

Oh I hadn't seen that bit, what a truly horrible man. I sincerely hope he ends up having to pay her legal costs when he loses.

MyTrivia · 09/04/2026 04:04

He sounds like my psychopath uncle who spent many, many years living in his disabled wife’s mother’s huge house in an expensive area of London. Never having to pay rent or anything else for 50 years. When his wife died before her mother did, upon his mother in law’s death, he had the audacity to try to claim 25% of her estate by chasing his in-laws through the courts, which his wife would have received, had she lived.

The entitlement of these people is something to behold.

jigglybits · 09/04/2026 03:55

Sleepneededprettyplease · 08/04/2026 19:38

He is probably harassing me but my solicitors have refused contact from him so he has to go through his solicitor and therefore doesn't much. It costs him. He isn't able to run up my costs with them.

As for the harassing me. It isn't daily or anything so I'm not sure what the threshold is. He probably contacts me a few times a week.

Edited

That is harassment and you can go to the Police about it.

PyongyangKipperbang · 09/04/2026 01:57

K2054 · 09/04/2026 00:27

I agree with this. I think he thinks at the very least you'll pay him off. From what you've said before it doesn't sound like he has a case. So awful you have to go through this though. Good luck OP.

He had made it clear that he doesnt want money, the OP has floated this. He wants to keep the house, free and clear. If he doesnt get that then his intention is to make the OP use all of her inheritance (including the house) in legal costs as revenge.

He is on to a loser there as no lawyer would take a "No win, no fee" that far, but clearly he lacks that level of critical thinking.

K2054 · 09/04/2026 00:27

SummerFate · 07/04/2026 20:03

Exactly. He still thinks you’ll offer him something to get rid of him - and for someone in his situation, I can see why it seems like an appealing strategy. A lot of people would give in and offer a settlement.

Please don’t. Tell him you’ll see him in court. He has no case - do NOT blink first.

I agree with this. I think he thinks at the very least you'll pay him off. From what you've said before it doesn't sound like he has a case. So awful you have to go through this though. Good luck OP.

WallaceinAnderland · 08/04/2026 23:53

The argument is:

'does asking me to let him stay count as giving financial support because it was housing without really paying'

The answer is clearly no.

Judges look at intentions.

Giving 'financial support' is not the same as intending to support someone for the rest of their life. Therefore your Aunt asking if he could stay in your house does not make him her legal dependent with a claim on her estate.

Definitions in laws have meanings. Either he is legally dependent or he isn't.

You cannot just say that because someone helped you out once that makes you a legal dependent entitled to claim on their estate.

I can't understand why your solicitors have not already assured you that he has no claim.

He is not going to take this court because he knows he will lose. He doesn't want to go to court, he just wants you to let him live in your house. Once you have evicted him I'm pretty sure he'll just go away.

Definitely continue to ignore his calls. Mute or block him. If there is any actual action from him his solicitors will write to you. Just try to forget about him now, this will soon be over.

LovesLabradors · 08/04/2026 23:49

She's the Executor @fashionqueen0123

Swipe left for the next trending thread