Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Update to AIBU to refuse Aunt's fwb claim on her estate.

845 replies

Sleepneededprettyplease · 07/04/2026 17:52

Posting here because it is where I put the first thread.

A brief summery is that my Aunt died and her FWB is trying to say that he is entitled to part of her estate because she had asked me to allow him to stay in a house she had invested in for me. Anyway if you want the full story feel free to read what I put on the first thread.

Anyway the main thing is that he is now sueing in the courts. I need a bit of a hand hold please. My lawyers have suggested getting a barristers opinion so I am just waiting for that. I wouldn't even mind if it was possible to just go to mediation but he wants the house for the rest of his life and won't consider anything else.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5505433-aibu-to-refuse-aunts-fwb-claim-on-her-estate?utm_campaign=thread&utm_medium=share

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 17:50

WallaceinAnderland · 28/05/2026 17:41

The house however is not part of the estate so he cannot challenge the will for it as the will does not include it.

Yes, this is what we have all been telling you but you said that your lawyer told you he might have a claim on it when clearly he doesn't.

The aunt died and left nothing to him. She wasn't supporting him when she was alive. He is not a dependent, he has no claim on her estate.

Your house is nothing to do with any of that and you have a court order to evict him.

What actually is the court hearing in August about and why does it involve you?

I am sorry if I have phrased things badly at times. I am trying to respond to people but maybe I am not being 100% clear and accurate. All I can say is that this is way outside my area of expertise.

The lawyer doesn't say anything about a claim on the house. They said that if I evicted him he could possibly claim for living expenses until the case is settled.

They said it was better to leave him there than put a judges back up.

OP posts:
WallaceinAnderland · 28/05/2026 17:41

The house however is not part of the estate so he cannot challenge the will for it as the will does not include it.

Yes, this is what we have all been telling you but you said that your lawyer told you he might have a claim on it when clearly he doesn't.

The aunt died and left nothing to him. She wasn't supporting him when she was alive. He is not a dependent, he has no claim on her estate.

Your house is nothing to do with any of that and you have a court order to evict him.

What actually is the court hearing in August about and why does it involve you?

SheilaFentiman · 28/05/2026 17:29

The trouble with many of the posts on this thread (including some of my own, no doubt!) is that they assume the other party is a rational actor.

Of course mediation or a settlement would be a good idea, of course he should never have been advised to go to court etc etc... But ultimately he is going to do whatever the hell he is going to do, because the alternative (where he has to leave the house he has an unreasonable belief to be 'his' for life) is more unbearable to him than a 'sensible' approach.

And if he dies with legal debts, I doubt he sees that as his problem.

Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 17:23

humblesims · 28/05/2026 16:51

Exactly this. We had a different but similar scenario. The barrister was worth her weight in gold but at the end of the day the CF ended up with a big chunk of money. Two thirds of which went into the lawyers pockets, which though awful, was a kind of sick 'win' in my mind. If he has even a thread of a chance, you'd be best going to mediation (I think they will insist anyway, the lawyers) and offer a payoff of some kind.

I am willing to do mediation but he won't give up on the house. I offered money.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 17:22

WallaceinAnderland · 28/05/2026 16:54

No, you said originally that he wanted to stay in the house and that's what his claim was about but now you say that unofficially he wants to stay in the house.

If he's made no official claim on the house, then evict him.

It is complicated I may not being clear in my explanations but I will give it my best try.

He wants to stay in the house. He has said this officially through his lawyer and unofficially to me.

The house however is not part of the estate so he cannot challenge the will for it as the will does not include it.

Therefore he is saying that the estate should support him for the rest of his life.

At the moment he has not stated what this should look like. He has made no suggestion other than he keeps the house and the estate pays for him in some unspecified way.

Hopefully that clears things up.

I have been advised not to chuck him out as it is possible that the court will take exception to me changing things before the hearing and say that the estate has to pay his rent.

OP posts:
WallaceinAnderland · 28/05/2026 16:54

Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:44

I am sure I have said this a few times. My lawyers talked about an early strike out proposal but then the burden of proof changes. Hence we are just letting it grind through slowly as the most likely way of getting what I need in the end.

No, you said originally that he wanted to stay in the house and that's what his claim was about but now you say that unofficially he wants to stay in the house.

If he's made no official claim on the house, then evict him.

humblesims · 28/05/2026 16:51

TheignT · 07/04/2026 20:01

Yes I knew someone in a similar dispute. The solicitors ended up with all the money.

Exactly this. We had a different but similar scenario. The barrister was worth her weight in gold but at the end of the day the CF ended up with a big chunk of money. Two thirds of which went into the lawyers pockets, which though awful, was a kind of sick 'win' in my mind. If he has even a thread of a chance, you'd be best going to mediation (I think they will insist anyway, the lawyers) and offer a payoff of some kind.

Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:44

WallaceinAnderland · 28/05/2026 16:33

Officially he is after the money from the main house.

Oh, I didn't realise that, I don't think you've mentioned that before.

In that case, I really can't understand why your solicitors are making such a meal of it.

I actually would be inclined to evict him and leave it for him to sue your aunt's estate if that is what he wants to do.

I think you've had poor legal advice, this is much simpler than you first described with him claiming that he has a right to live in your house.

I am sure I have said this a few times. My lawyers talked about an early strike out proposal but then the burden of proof changes. Hence we are just letting it grind through slowly as the most likely way of getting what I need in the end.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:42

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 28/05/2026 15:50

This is what I suspect. He's hoping to drag it out (and therefore live rent free) until he dies. Or that the court will feel so sorry for the 'poor old man' that they find in his favour in the expectation that he will be gone in a few months. He could go on for another ten years or more!

Yes. I do think he is trying to stall and make things just take forever. Unfortunately that is all to easy with the legal system.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:41

Tabarnak · 28/05/2026 15:06

What benefits did your aunt retain once she gave you the house? Was it just using it as a holiday home?
There seems to be an important fact that YOU allowed him to live there and she had to ask your permission, rather than your aunt offering it to him as 'her share' of whatever benefits she was retaining.

It isn't 'a house your aunt bought in your name' - she bought you or gave you a house.
It isn't 'technically' your house - it's your house.

The whys and wherefores as to how it was bought are irrelevant.

It's a truly horrible situation OP, and a shocking reminder as to just how badly people behave once someone has died.

Not just nasty freeloading grifters like him, but family men, the men who will inherit everything in a mirror will 'but can be trusted to pass everything on to the kids'. Oh no he can't. I could tell you some absolute horror stories of lovely husbands, great Dads, who let a deceased wife's assets slide into a new woman's grasp and then on to her own kids. They don't mean to be like this...but it happens, Again and again. People need to be so watertight in the way things are set up.

Good luck with all this OP, so disheartening.

Yes she used it as a holiday home.

He acknowledged me as his landlord in writing which I have put in my evidence.

The mirror wills thing has made me think a bit. I mean hopefully never happen but I am aware of cases when one partner died and the other was intestate so it went to her family not his children.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:36

diddl · 28/05/2026 14:54

It's probably been asked & answered but where was he living before this?

Did he need somewhere to live or just saw an opportunity to pay no rent for a while?

He was in a relationship that broke down. Lived with his partner who bought him out of the house after a while.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:35

Northermcharn · 28/05/2026 14:25

Ok. Just remember the lawyers are making money from everybody. They are not altruistic.

Trust me I am very aware. However they do at least try to get me some as well.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:34

SheilaFentiman · 28/05/2026 16:24

@Manxexile not necessarily - a friend of mine had to defend a nonsense case from a prior business partner, said business partner having charmed a solicitor into advising her and writing various letters on her behalf. More because he felt sorry for her than because he felt she had a good case and therefore expected to get paid.

He is an expert at selling the sob story so this is possibly the situation. I expect to many people he knows I am being painted as some vengeful, greedy woman ignoring her aunts clear wishes.

OP posts:
WallaceinAnderland · 28/05/2026 16:33

Officially he is after the money from the main house.

Oh, I didn't realise that, I don't think you've mentioned that before.

In that case, I really can't understand why your solicitors are making such a meal of it.

I actually would be inclined to evict him and leave it for him to sue your aunt's estate if that is what he wants to do.

I think you've had poor legal advice, this is much simpler than you first described with him claiming that he has a right to live in your house.

Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:32

Manxexile · 28/05/2026 16:20

You said earlier that he had some kind of "deferred fee" arrangement.

I'm not sure what you mean - is it some kind of "no win, no fee" or conditional fee agreement?

What would surprise me is that "no win, no fee" solicitors or those offering a conditional fee agreement will usually only do so if they are virtually certain of winning. Because if they don't win they won't get paid for the work they've done.

I don't understand it. In his financial statement it said something about the rest of the money he has he potentially owes to his solicitor. I have queried it.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:30

OVienna · 28/05/2026 13:53

OP
If the court date gets moved again, would you consider enforcing?

I am just a bit concerned at the timings of proceedings and the significant delays there are currently.

Might be better in this case just to get him out, especially if the date is moved very far into the future.

I wonder what your lawyers would say to that?

Edited

I wanted to enforce this time but they were very strong that I shouldn't. Hopefully it doesn't get any longer. At this rate though I have no chance of getting it on the market before the market dips quieter over winter.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:28

BunnyLake · 28/05/2026 13:44

That will probably make his case weaker. This guy had to show proof of his rent (before everything was electronic). He had a rent book the landlady signed off each month. Good luck though, it must be stressful for you as he doesn’t want a settlement.

Sorry I may have missed it but has the house completed probate.

Edited

The house he is in didn't go through probate as it was already in my name. My Aunt's main house has completed probate and is being sold.

Officially he is after the money from the main house. Unofficially he wants the house I own.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:26

FrizzyFrizbee · 28/05/2026 13:35

@Sleepneededprettyplease
You never know what you might find out about him , maybe nothing, maybe not but worth checking? Point is, where has he got his money from, and is he, would he tell the court the truth about his situation, or he be caught out lying? He seems to be a real schemer, and not especially honest either
www.gov.uk/government/publications/proprieters-names-search-of-the-index-pn1

Will happily check but as I say I know a fair amount about him. His family had money previously and without being too outing I know he and his siblings got a LOT of money from the family home. Think in the millions for each child.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:24

FrizzyFrizbee · 28/05/2026 13:29

Does he have form for doing things like this? Who initiated the contact, him or your Aunt? Did he plot it? Can any of this be checked? How did he rock up in Aunt’s life after all these years? Has he been swindling others out of inheritance? Where has he got his money from to take you to court? Can the judge be asked to lift the veil on HIS finances, and whether he actually owns or has owned and sold other properties and who they belonged to versus who was on the original will? Can you do further digging yourself about this man? Is a solicitor allowed to ask for search on the Land Registry with regard to property he has been linked with previously? Did your Aunt know anyone else who may know more about this man, his other ‘old flames’?

They met at a reunion thing.

No form on this. I think that he has done more in the getting good deals in divorce line previously. His ex-wives all seem to be more financially stable and earn more than him.

He has disclosed several years of bank statements from which you can see him spending his share of the money he got from his previous house (his ex bought him out). We are talking about 80k from memory.

Aunts friends from uni all know him. I know who his exes are including the affair partners and illegitimate children. None of his exes are dead so pretty sure he hasn't tried this before.

OP posts:
SheilaFentiman · 28/05/2026 16:24

@Manxexile not necessarily - a friend of mine had to defend a nonsense case from a prior business partner, said business partner having charmed a solicitor into advising her and writing various letters on her behalf. More because he felt sorry for her than because he felt she had a good case and therefore expected to get paid.

WallaceinAnderland · 28/05/2026 16:21

Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:17

I had come to the conclusion that my best chance was to just follow legal advice and let it grind through. If they seem willing to negotiate then great but he cannot have the house.

Don't give him any cash either. You already offered that and he declined.

What he has done instead is cause an expensive legal battle and I don't think a judge would deem it reasonable for him to now want a financial settlement.

In effect, that would just be you paying his legal costs.

Manxexile · 28/05/2026 16:20

Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 08:54

I don't know how he has found this solicitor. I half think it might be a friend of a friend thing. I also don't know how he is paying. It is one of the aspects that worries me

You said earlier that he had some kind of "deferred fee" arrangement.

I'm not sure what you mean - is it some kind of "no win, no fee" or conditional fee agreement?

What would surprise me is that "no win, no fee" solicitors or those offering a conditional fee agreement will usually only do so if they are virtually certain of winning. Because if they don't win they won't get paid for the work they've done.

Sleepneededprettyplease · 28/05/2026 16:17

NoctuaAthene · 28/05/2026 13:04

Just popping on to say this is absolutely correct. The people who think that no solicitor would ever encourage or assist someone to pursue an obviously futile claim are sadly naive and mistaken. Yes there are ethical codes meaning they can't actively mislead the court or lie to their client but there's a very big margin between that and writing some letters or submitting a claim that may not be strictly arguable or have a very low chance of success. And the same goes for the happy assumption that if OP is clearly on the right side of the law (according to MN verdict anyway) she can simply either take the law into her own hands and assert her rights by booting the man out of the house, sending him a bill for rent and/or that the court will swiftly and efficiently strike out the misconceived or vexatious claim without OP having to shell out for her own solicitors and legal advice - I wouldn't want to live in the world where the former is true i.e. people are allowed to act first and legally prove they were correct later, if the latter was true it would be great but that would require a well resourced and efficient modern lower tier court and tribunal system which tax payers seemingly are in no way prepared to fund...

I work in the HR/employment law field and it's incredibly common to receive letters and/or ET1 claims from solicitors for things that are totally and obviously misplaced/misconceived (e.g. unfair dismissal claims when the person doesn't have the requisite service), badly drafted (often obviously with the dubious assistance of ChatGPT), lacking particulars or vital information - just rubbish that isn't worth the paper really. But that doesn't absolve the employer of the requirement to respond and answer the case all the way through the various tiers of the court if necessary, all of which costs time, money and stress, no matter how clear cut the victory at the end is (and before you ask no it usually isn't possible to recover costs from the losing party no matter how badly they ran their case).

The solicitors that engage in this kind of thing tend to fall into two camps, one is the 'shark' firms who will happily charge a client a couple of hundred quid to send any old rambling toilet paper of a threatening letter to their (former) employer without bothering to advise them properly as to their actual prospects, sometimes this will spook the employer into coughing up a bit of cash, sometimes not but they still get paid by their client either way. Or, in some ways more dangerous, the 'a little knowledge is a dangerous thing' brigade, the friend of a friend or second cousin who took a law degree a decade ago or who practices in a totally different area of the law, who will aid and abet the aggrieved complainant all the way through a lengthy and ultimately futile process with bad advice and poor quality submissions - dangerous because while the sharks can usually be put off by either a robust and aggressive rebuttal or shelling out a modest sum to make them go away, the passionately misinformed party usually wants (perceived) justice to be done and won't settle for less than what they believe to be their full due, however unlikely that is to be delivered by the law... I wouldn't be surprised if the OP's chap and his solicitor are one of these and there's really nothing to be done but pay up for some good legal advice and then wait for the sloooowww machinery of the law to turn and do it's thing...

I had come to the conclusion that my best chance was to just follow legal advice and let it grind through. If they seem willing to negotiate then great but he cannot have the house.

OP posts:
Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 28/05/2026 16:09

Liberancho · 28/05/2026 12:51

A low life grifter who is still at it at 86. Let's hope his end is nigh.

His lack of shame is astounding and I imagine this influences his levels of delusion too.

Terrible for you in the meantime though OP. Reading this, as well as your previous thread, has made me very angry.

He could well live into his 90s.

SheilaFentiman · 28/05/2026 16:00

It might cast a new light on the solicitor support as well: "oh go on, honey, pleeease can you help Great Uncle Fred not get thrown out of his house, I know you think it's a crap case but it's worth a try..."