Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Update to AIBU to refuse Aunt's fwb claim on her estate.

845 replies

Sleepneededprettyplease · 07/04/2026 17:52

Posting here because it is where I put the first thread.

A brief summery is that my Aunt died and her FWB is trying to say that he is entitled to part of her estate because she had asked me to allow him to stay in a house she had invested in for me. Anyway if you want the full story feel free to read what I put on the first thread.

Anyway the main thing is that he is now sueing in the courts. I need a bit of a hand hold please. My lawyers have suggested getting a barristers opinion so I am just waiting for that. I wouldn't even mind if it was possible to just go to mediation but he wants the house for the rest of his life and won't consider anything else.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5505433-aibu-to-refuse-aunts-fwb-claim-on-her-estate?utm_campaign=thread&utm_medium=share

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 19:19

Llttledrummergirl · 25/08/2026 18:31

The judge has screwed you over,so why continue to play nicely?

Can you not now activate the original eviction notice and negotiate with him out of the house.

The risk of being hit by a lot of costs is why I play nice. It is not my preference.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 19:15

LovesLabradors · 25/08/2026 11:35

Wow - that's shocking. I think PP's are correct that the lower levels of the court concentrate on mediation, and don't necessarily apply the law. Maybe Judge was wary of making this man homeless.
But for him to lie in court and claim they were cohabiting makes all the difference - why weren't you able to bring more evidence at this stage, when they were allowed to change their argument? Seems unfair.
There is definitely a terrible lesson in all this. Never ever allow a cocklodger to get their knees under the kitchen table, as a favour. You and your Aunt were being kind and neither of you could have foreseen this.
Different I know, but many decades ago, DH and I allowed friends (a couple) to move in with us "for a couple of weeks" after they had been travelling. Of course they stayed far longer, and many months later we put the house on the market to relocate. We even moved out, leaving them there, and I began to fear they would never leave. I had visions of them still being there when the new buyers turned up with a removals van! Friends can turn into cheeky fuckers very quickly.

Yes. The sense of entitlement is amazing.

OP posts:
SheilaFentiman · 25/08/2026 18:46

CunningLinguist2 · 25/08/2026 18:38

This is mad! You own the house. Surely, it’s yours to sell. - with him as a sitting tenant? Let new owner charge him rent?

Who would buy it, though?

And if the argument is that FWB has an expectation of support from the estate, then the estate would just end up covering the rent.

CunningLinguist2 · 25/08/2026 18:38

This is mad! You own the house. Surely, it’s yours to sell. - with him as a sitting tenant? Let new owner charge him rent?

Llttledrummergirl · 25/08/2026 18:31

The judge has screwed you over,so why continue to play nicely?

Can you not now activate the original eviction notice and negotiate with him out of the house.

Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 18:24

SpikingDrinks · 25/08/2026 10:11

What's fwb

Friends with benefits. Or casual shag.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 18:23

NewBeginnings77 · 25/08/2026 16:54

Can you not buy and site a caravan on a nearby site, which would be a few thousand at most, and voila he's adequately housed by the estate?
Im sickened for you that he's got his way

It seems not. I wish I could.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 18:23

fashionqueen0123 · 25/08/2026 17:01

can you inform the providers that you own the house and no supply is needed? After all you aren’t living there.

Im also thinking - can you do things to just annoy him out of living there.
Move a family member in for a short holiday and get them to play really annoying music.

But definitely, he needs to be paying rent surely. Although I guess you’ve already tried to evict him. If he’s 86 though..: I’d be inclined to just wait it out. If you need the money from the house then get it up for sale. Get some contractors in to redecorate etc
That all takes ages.

Edited

I can't move people in with him there. At least I don't think I can.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 18:21

CoraPirbright · 25/08/2026 17:45

Is there any scope for renting YOUR house out to a bunch of rowdy students?!

I am so sorry OP. It’s not what we all wanted for you.

No. No students nearby.

Holidaymakers possibly but not with him there.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 18:20

diddl · 25/08/2026 17:31

I pay landlords and buildings insurances, gas safety certificate and ground rent.

How did that come about if he was supposedly just staying there as your Aunt wanted him to?

I was trying to protect myself. I thought if I set it up as a proper tenancy it would stop this situation.

I was wrong.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 18:19

Bulbsbulbsbulbs · 25/08/2026 10:29

Just as a warning- the house I live in was bought after a similar dispute. Lawyers fees were £340k. We bought the house for £360k.

The woman who won said she didn't care, she just didn't want a 'golddigger' getting her late sons house. But what a price to pay- she had to pay the gold-diggers costs despite winning.

This is why I will settle. I don't want that situation.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 18:18

PsychoHotSauce · 25/08/2026 10:09

It's not the law really, it's the system that scaffolds it. The principle of 'access to justice' is two-tier. Apparently if you have deep pockets and money to burn, you can run a case to a high enough court to have the law applied. At the lower levels though, there's a fixation on 'mediation' and settlement even for chancers. It becomes an expensive game of chicken or letting the brazen in society win.

ETA the case law supports OP on this, and judges really do respect the letter of the will so that is important evidence. It's difficult to win a claim like his. However there's a chasm and a LOT of cash between the law being on your side and actually enforcing it.

Edited

This.

I might well be able to win but it would cost me more than the win is worth.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 18:17

fashionqueen0123 · 25/08/2026 09:40

So what happens if you said ok you can live there but rent is will need to be paid?

How old is he?

or… you make him move out. He finds a rental. If he ‘might’ have a claim
then presumably he also may not? So he may not be able to get any money. And you wouldn’t be able to pay him until the house is sold? So confusing. I don’t know how this is allowed to happen. He’s a squatter!

What evidence did he have?!

What happens is that we have to agree a settlement. The better outcome here as far as I am concerned is I pay him some money and he goes away. Otherwise we may end up with him living there at a cheap rent. I don't like that because I think it has ongoing headaches written all over it.

He is in his 80's.

His evidence was statements from his friends. Also we put on the IHT form that my Aunt retained benefit from the house because it was her holiday home. He argued that it meant that she supported him and therefore he was dependent. That gives him a claim to her estate it seems.

OP posts:
CoraPirbright · 25/08/2026 17:45

Is there any scope for renting YOUR house out to a bunch of rowdy students?!

I am so sorry OP. It’s not what we all wanted for you.

diddl · 25/08/2026 17:31

I pay landlords and buildings insurances, gas safety certificate and ground rent.

How did that come about if he was supposedly just staying there as your Aunt wanted him to?

fashionqueen0123 · 25/08/2026 17:01

Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 16:33

He is paying the utilities. Not rent though. I pay landlords and buildings insurances, gas safety certificate and ground rent.

Edited

can you inform the providers that you own the house and no supply is needed? After all you aren’t living there.

Im also thinking - can you do things to just annoy him out of living there.
Move a family member in for a short holiday and get them to play really annoying music.

But definitely, he needs to be paying rent surely. Although I guess you’ve already tried to evict him. If he’s 86 though..: I’d be inclined to just wait it out. If you need the money from the house then get it up for sale. Get some contractors in to redecorate etc
That all takes ages.

NewBeginnings77 · 25/08/2026 16:54

Can you not buy and site a caravan on a nearby site, which would be a few thousand at most, and voila he's adequately housed by the estate?
Im sickened for you that he's got his way

Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 16:45

PinkEasterbunny · 25/08/2026 10:01

I have nothing to suggest just to say it all seems desperately unfair and I am so sorry

Same here, the law is ridiculous sometimes and what's the point of a will if you can end up in situations like this

I don't know. It makes me question things tbh.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 16:36

OVienna · 25/08/2026 10:57

I am so sorry. This reallly sucks. Anyone out there able to procure a rent a poltergeist to BOO him out?!

If you know anyone send over their details 😁

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 16:35

WhistPie · 25/08/2026 10:55

I'd move in with him & make his life hell! Or even better, move a certain male relative in and no attempt would have to be made to make his life hell, it would just happen.

Edited

Tempting but I live hundreds of miles away and can't work remotely.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 16:34

SickandTiredofEverything · 25/08/2026 10:51

What an awful position to be in OP, I am so sorry. Personally, rather than see him have it, I’d spend every penny of the inheritance on challenging him in court if necessary. Then there is nothing for him to use to pay his housing as his claim is against the estate, not you.

I want need some of that money for IVF and to pay off my mortgage. I won't cut my nose off to spite my face.

OP posts:
Sleepneededprettyplease · 25/08/2026 16:33

fashionqueen0123 · 25/08/2026 11:10

That's actually quite a good idea!

Also - as he's not paying rent or anything official, and the house is yours, can you cut off the electric/gas supply? Who is paying the bill - like for water and all of the utlities?

Edited

He is paying the utilities. Not rent though. I pay landlords and buildings insurances, gas safety certificate and ground rent.

OP posts:
pinkdelight · 25/08/2026 16:19

diddl · 25/08/2026 16:13

So if he is allowed to live in it-what is he responsible for?

Bills? Upkeep?

Is there any sort of contract that if broken means he can be turfed out?

This is what I can't fathom. There is no status that involves just getting to live in a house that's not yours on paper in any way and that you're not paying for in any way and no one alive wants you there not least the real owner. It's like he's in some magic twilight zone where he gets everything for nothing and the judge has perpetuated that. Surely he should win some MN award for top cocklodger of the century, transcending death, the law, common sense and all logic!

diddl · 25/08/2026 16:13

So if he is allowed to live in it-what is he responsible for?

Bills? Upkeep?

Is there any sort of contract that if broken means he can be turfed out?

FullLondonEye · 25/08/2026 15:39

OK, I may be oversimplifying here but can you not charge him full market rent, paid by the estate, as the law is suggesting? Because that money (from the estate) effectively remains in your hands, to use as you wish - such as split with your sister as intended with money from the estate. Essentially he wins by being able to stay in the house but the money from the estate remains with you rather than being used to pay him off or to pay lawyers and on the basis that he's 86 it might (hopefully) not be too long. Meanwhile you can conduct an inappropriate hate campaign to make his life there hell.

It's not the result you wanted but ultimately the estate money goes to you rather than him and it doesn't all go on lawyers.