Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want to kill my gf

244 replies

theBOD · 16/06/2008 22:28

she was meant to be home after work so we could go out for dinner but apparently got rail roaded into dinner (yeah right) with her boss and couldn't say no.
i really feel like putting my fist through her face as soon as she walks through the door pissed out of her mind to make sure she never does it again.

OP posts:
VictorianSqualor · 17/06/2008 11:48

Twelvelegs, why must he be bored?
What on earth has a job got to do with anything?
Would you say the same to a woman who could be a SAHM? I doubt it, more double standards.

He has raised a valid thread and a valid point, if I was a man on a predominately female site and kept reading the way some of the threads are towards men I'd be rather pissed off.

If I was a woman on a predominately male site and posted on here that men were misogynistic on said site I'd bet there would be tons of posters trotting over there to give them what for, because it's not right for any sex to be so dismissive of the opposite gender.

Twelvelegs · 17/06/2008 11:43

theBOD, have you got a job? If not why don't you get one, you're obviously bored. The difference in the tone of your OP and the other two is enormous. There's is obviously funny and are not supposed to represent an actual RL situation where someone would strangle her husband with a towel.

Ryobi · 17/06/2008 11:38

i agree with vs

cestlavie · 17/06/2008 11:35

From some of the posts on here, some people clearly do seem to think that any recognition that DV occurs against men as well as women dimishes the seriousness of DV against women. It doesn't. On the other hand, trying to ignore DV against men or pretend it doesn't go on very much diminishes the seriousness of DV against men.

wannaBe · 17/06/2008 11:28

the op was badly constructed but...

  1. At least the op had the balls to put his usual mn name to it rather than hiding behind a namechange. I'm not so sure how many people would if they wanted to make a similar point. and
  1. Domestic violence against men exists. Just because it isn't as prevalent as violence against women doesn't make it any less real for the men who experience it. In fact some of the responses on this thread, ie "when two men are killed by their partners we'll start to take it seriously" just sho that on the whole violence against men is not seen as a serious matter in the same way as violence against women.

Is it any wonder more men don't report DV when this is the response they are faced with?

It is not acceptable to take the piss out of doing anything physically harmful to anyone, ever.

The op was badly worded, but the point is a valid one.

belgo · 17/06/2008 11:11

I agree VS.

VictorianSqualor · 17/06/2008 11:10

Yes, theBOD was rather, shall we say, insensitive with his OP, but I think it was a point well made, hence this rather large thread on domestic abuse against men.

Surely aggression/violence used against anyone should not be condoned, partner or not, same gender, different gender, male on female, female on male, it's all wrong, and tbh there is a lot of 'joking' about women doing stuff to their husbands on here, I've probably said things myself, but we should really be more careful because each time one of posts a 'joke' about doing something to our partner we could be normalising it for a real violent abuser that is harming their partner.

WilyWombat · 17/06/2008 11:09

As I see it if you want to be pedantic the OP was badly constructed but it HAS started an interesting discussion.

WilyWombat · 17/06/2008 11:08

I have a friend with a husband I would regard as abusive, she maintains he doesnt hit her (he shouts and smashes things) I wouldnt put up with his behaviour, she just thinks she isnt "assertive enough" and should and says "I stand up for myself more"...I just want to tell her hes a complete wanker. I did try to steer her towards the councellors at school as her son has been mirroring Dads behaviour and has come to their attention but she just will not do anything.

Servalan · 17/06/2008 11:07

Oh - now I skim down the thread I see what you were doing OP...

Whilst I agree that violence against anyone is no laughing matter, I'm not sure that the original post was the best way to highlight this - it will have distressed a lot of people.

AitchTwoCiao · 17/06/2008 11:05

yes, Hedgewitch, but what is the def of DV in this survey? it's not in the repeat crimes tables, so far as i saw.

AitchTwoCiao · 17/06/2008 11:04

oh, the OP likes to teach us all a lesson, Servalan... we're just silly women. thank god he's here.

PS great name.

TheHedgeWitch · 17/06/2008 11:02

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Servalan · 17/06/2008 10:58

Haven't read the whole thread, but nasty, nasty op.

Whilst I can see how the poster might be disappointed with the situation, I find the aggression and violence in the OP very upsetting and difficult to stomach tbh.

How on earth the poster thought these things were acceptable to say is beyond me

TheHedgeWitch · 17/06/2008 10:55

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

AitchTwoCiao · 17/06/2008 10:53

yep, i#ve looked at that table, hedgewitch, and i do think that tbh without knowing what questions were asked it's not that compelling tbh. that's unfortunate, because clearly it does need to be looked at.

as i said before the power differential between men and women in terms of financial and physical clout and responsibility for continuing childcare will make a huge difference in how DV will escalate and how vulnerable the other partner will feel. no alla violenza and all that, though.

TheHedgeWitch · 17/06/2008 10:49

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

cestlavie · 17/06/2008 10:45

Spice: I have no idea where that 40% comes from. I was just looking at that survey.

'nearly 80% of DV' - hmmm, selective phraseology. How about almost 1 in 4 DV incidents are against men? Both are equally true, but it depends how you care to phrase it which is why I chose to simply report.

As an aside, on the original post I thought it was crass, stupid and badly phrased. I know what theBOD was trying to do but there are far better ways to open up a discussion on the differences in ways in which men and women are treated on MN and in real life.

TheHedgeWitch · 17/06/2008 10:45

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

AitchTwoCiao · 17/06/2008 10:44

no willy, that's the good thing about this data, it's not culled from reported crimes. however it does then suffer from the two gender's definition of DV. i don't know about men, but the stats i've read from WA suppport that it takes a Long Time for women to admit that they are being beaten in the first place.

spicemonster · 17/06/2008 10:42

While I don't dispute that there are many men who are victims of DV, where does the '40% of men are victims of DV' come from cestlavie?

And while I don't think it's a laughing matter anymore than DV against women is, the fact is that according to that document nearly 80% of DV is committed against women by men.

FWIW I wasn't enamoured with that slapping thread either.

AitchTwoCiao · 17/06/2008 10:42

i'd like to know what that means, though. Did it mean that the woman slapped him once and so that's what he told the survey, or does it mean that it's a pattern of behaviour and sustained abuse. because the male pattern of DV by and large is escalation. certainly no mention of it in the repeat crimes section, which is odd.

WilyWombat · 17/06/2008 10:42

The amount of men who ARE victims is going to be considerably higher than the amount who admit to being victims.

TheHedgeWitch · 17/06/2008 10:40

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

cestlavie · 17/06/2008 10:39

Having scanned the report it would seem that in 2006/07:

  • 93,000 men (23% of total victims) were the victim of domestic violence vs. 312,000 (77% of total victims) - p.69.
  • 2.0% of all men aged 16-75 were the victim of domestic violence or one or more occasions vs. 4.8% of all women - p.67

This would seem to support THW's assertion that whilst women are clearly more likely to be the victim of domestic violence a sizeable proportion of men are also the victim.

Spicemonster: your figures are accurate but distorted by the fact that (a) men are much more likely to be the victims of violence per se and (b) much more likely to be the victims of stranger violence and violence from acquaintances. The percentage amount for men for domestic violence is therefore a lot lower and in any event is not the right metric.

Swipe left for the next trending thread