Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want to kill my gf

244 replies

theBOD · 16/06/2008 22:28

she was meant to be home after work so we could go out for dinner but apparently got rail roaded into dinner (yeah right) with her boss and couldn't say no.
i really feel like putting my fist through her face as soon as she walks through the door pissed out of her mind to make sure she never does it again.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GoodOldDays · 11/11/2022 17:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

silvercrown · 18/06/2008 18:33

The thing is when we say we want to strangle our husbands - we don't actually DO it!! I can see why you might think it's double standards but despite the fact that abuse does go on between both sexes - it does happen more to women and a man's fist can do serious damage (I'm sure you can work that out for yourself even if you've never hit a woman). Some men do find it an acceptable way to treat someone they claim to love. Please be reasonable.

Twelvelegs · 17/06/2008 17:48

I'm with Aitch, LB and Dittany too!
Whilst at Relate (who I believe know about DV) they frowned upon all DV but were more concerned about my dh being agressive than me... him 6'2" very broad, and me teeny tiny.

TheFallenMadonna · 17/06/2008 17:43

The thread I'm thinking of wasn't like this one in reverse. And there was reciprocal violence

This OP was part of a wider set of issues for theBOD I think. It's not just a reaction to a couple of other threads. I suspect an agenda.

LittleBella · 17/06/2008 17:38

wannabe you are misquoting me. I did not say that I would take DV against men seriously when two of them a week are killed by their partners. I thought I'd made it very clear that I take DV against men seriously, I'm simply not prepared to accept this revisionist bollocks that it is as big a problem as the enormous levels of DV against women.

Something struck me about that wanting to strangle your DH with a towel, who was it who pointed out that it would be too big and bulky for the job. I think that's the slapstick element of humour isn't it - choosing an inappropriate implement with which to carry out cartoon violence as opposed to the real type. "Should I slap my GF across the face with a wet fish thirty two times?" would elicit a different response because of the incongruity of the implement and the absurdly specific number of slaps and therefore the clarity that no real violence is intended. It's all about the tone and language.

dittany · 17/06/2008 16:25

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

AitchTwoCiao · 17/06/2008 16:16

find the thread, then. i just don't think that all this is a terrific double standard. did the OP read like theBOD's one? did she want to put her fist through his face? i doubt it. yes, i'd be very interested to see exactly what went on on one MN thread of thousands, but i don't think that a sample of one is particularly conclusive.
but then, i also think that if you're a lone man fiddling about on a laptop in a car while parked outside a playpark and someone comes and asks you what you're doing, then you might just as easily say 'i'm playing solitaire while i'm waiting to play five a side in the football pitch over there, why do you ask?' as say 'none of your business, fuck off'. and i already know that i'm in the minority on that one.

cestlavie · 17/06/2008 16:08

Aitch: that absolutely wasn't my point. My point was that (a) there were even a minority of posters expressing that view and (b) the minority of posters expressing that view were certainly not shouted down in the way that your statement presumed. If, on the other hand, a guy had posted saying he hit his wife you can bet whatever you like that anyone wondering whether she had done anything to deserve it would have been torn apart.

dittany · 17/06/2008 15:57

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

AitchTwoCiao · 17/06/2008 15:54

oh hang on, i didn't realise that MN was defined by its moronic minority... of course there will be a few idiots. like, for example, the OP of this thread, who presumably doesn't represent the MO of all the male posters on here.

TheFallenMadonna · 17/06/2008 15:20

Actually, I'm with cestlavie on that. I remember a thread too..

cestlavie · 17/06/2008 15:18

"let's be completely honest here, had a woman posted exactly what the OP did, she would have been taken to task. she really would, and there's no amount of bleating about inverse sexism that will change that".

Actually Aitch, I disagree. Yes, the majority of posters would absolutely would have taken her to task but there would have been a minority who whilst not necessarily condoning what she did would certainly have asked questions along the lines of "Surely he must have done something to deserve this?". I remember one thread in particular which I'll try to dig out.

AitchTwoCiao · 17/06/2008 14:37

i haven't ever heard anyone say that, tbh. not the sort of circles i run in, obv.

JS bobbit was a bit more than a prat, as i recall... wasn't she forced to have an abortion by him, and i think he had affairs and she accused him of DV and rape. that's not a prat, that's an abuser. wasn't she found not fit for trial or something, because of what came out about him during the preliminary stuff?

i'm not lauding her as a feminist heroine, by the way, and i do think that had he not played along and had his name not been bobbit there would have been less levity surrounding the case. it's a bit more complicated than you're making out, imo.

minorityrules · 17/06/2008 14:33

So if a woman had her breast cut off after playing away, there would be jokes? Why is it acceptable to joke about a man being mutilated (I already said the bloke was a prat but that shouldn't come into it)

And I have heard many jokey comments coming from women about this one case and how they would do a bobbit, not meant and funny but not if a man said the same thing...ever

Scuff · 17/06/2008 14:29

... and JW Bobbit joked about the situation himself, whilst also taking up a career in porn in order to showcase the main protagonist in the saga, iirc.

AitchTwoCiao · 17/06/2008 14:25

most of those jokes were made by male comedians, of course...

minorityrules · 17/06/2008 14:17

Was thinking about these double standards in bed last night

One of the things that came to my mind - John Bobbit

That man suffered a terrible mutilation at the hands of his partner and became the brunt of many a joke and a laughing stock (yes I know he was an arsehole/prat but did he deserve what he got and the aftermath)

If a woman had been mutilated in that way, there would be no joking about it - ever

I hate these double standards, even just joking about it

VeniVidiVickiQV · 17/06/2008 13:28

Eek!

edam · 17/06/2008 13:23

Well said, Aitch.

Scuff · 17/06/2008 13:21

"let's be completely honest here, had a woman posted exactly what the OP did, she would have been taken to task. she really would, and there's no amount of bleating about inverse sexism that will change that".

Absolutely, Aitch.

If there is any sexism on this thread, it is coming from those assuming that MN posters (ie mostly women) don't take violence against men by women as seriously as violence against women by men.

MsDemeanor · 17/06/2008 13:19

Exactly Aitch.
Nobody has ever condoned a woman hitting a man, even if he also hits her.

AitchTwoCiao · 17/06/2008 13:13

oh it completely diminishes the point he was trying to make...

his post reeked of threat, violence and intimidation. the others, from what i understand not having seen them, were fairly juvenile banter.

let's be completely honest here, had a woman posted exactly what the OP did, she would have been taken to task. she really would, and there's no amount of bleating about inverse sexism that will change that.

i've seen women posting for help on here to deal with their propensity towards violence, no-one's ever said 'oh it doesn't matter love, you're just a woman'. quite the opposite, there's an equally hard line taken against both imo and ime.

MsDemeanor · 17/06/2008 13:12

Except (yawn) they aren't threatening their partners. They are turning their usually entirely justifiable frustration into humour for a predominantly female audience. And we completely understand it as such.
When a woman DOES talk about hurting her partner, either physically (almost always in a mutually aggressive relationship) or even by being over controlling she is ALWAYS pulled up on it in no uncertain terms. Because we can immediately see the difference between a woman sharing her frustration with other women, and a woman making genuine threats. It's not even very difficult.
The OP in this thread reads like a genuine threat to extreme violence to a woman. The other threads most definitely did NOT.

TheHedgeWitch · 17/06/2008 13:08

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Twelvelegs · 17/06/2008 13:07

Minster, I like your turn of phrase!!