Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be cross that a mother took her healthy child to see a child with chicken pox because she wanted her child to get it which she did and now my daughter and few other in the class have got it from her DD

93 replies

schmoopoo · 02/05/2008 12:37

AAARGH

OP posts:
1dilemma · 03/05/2008 01:08

YANBU

I disagree with the majority on here quite her business if she wants to expose her child to illnesses if she willingly did then she should have kept her away from others/school.
HOw does she know who has a new baby/who is pregnant and never had it/who is immunosuppressed/or just going away on holiday.

I've always thought chicken pox parties were being confused with rubella parties, there was a very real reason why people wanted their (usually) daughters to get rubella as a child pre vaccination, however chicken pox was very common, therefore most got it as a child and it was a lot less infectious once the spots were out anyway.

Wonder if I'm right.....?

WendyWeber · 03/05/2008 00:53

I encouraged a friend whose daughter had CP to visit us just before Christmas in the hope that DS2 (then aged 3) would catch it.

When he went back to nursery school in January there was no sign of it, but that same afternoon I was summoned to collect him because he had suddenly got very poorly

CP then went round and round (in ever-decreasing circles) over the next few weeks until everyone had had it. I did feel bad but on the other hand it got it out of the way for them all - and all their sibs too, probably.

scottishmummy · 03/05/2008 00:26

indeed folk had chickenpox parties

edam · 03/05/2008 00:25

YABU. Your dd and her classmates could have caught it from anyone, at any tme. You are actually very lucky that they have been exposed at a young age, for all the reasons mentioned - MUCH worse to be left without immunity and catch it as an adult, especially for girls wrt pregnancy.

(ohtobe, I remember thinking german measles were FAB - felt no worse than a cold but got two weeks off school. Result!)

ohtobe20again · 03/05/2008 00:17

I vaguely remember being sent over to my friends house to catch German Measles when I was younger (pre-vacc times I think).

Twoddle · 03/05/2008 00:14

YABU, I'm afraid. As others have said, this is definitely something best caught young. When DS had it (on his third birthday), some other little kids did avoid us, but for understandable reasons: about to go on holiday, newborn in the household, etc. However, I couldn't believe that the mother of one of DS's bigger friends (age 10 at the time, and hadn't had chickenpox) kept him away from his usual weekly playdate with us. I appreciate that she's a single mum, and that if her DS becomes ill, she has to take time off work - but it would be so worth him getting it sooner rather than later.

scottishmummy · 02/05/2008 19:07

some people do advocate deliberate exposure.kind of get it over with. i can see both POV.hope wee one ok

DorisIsAPinkDragon · 02/05/2008 14:29

I see where you're coming from and likewise would not intenionally infect my dd's however

at least she has it now before the holidays

seriously i hope she feels better soon

NYC6723 · 02/05/2008 14:23

OMG.. i could never purposefully infect my child with chicken pox! Yikes

Soprana · 02/05/2008 14:23

YABU. It's best to get it as young as poss. When you're older it can be much nastier - I know, I had it in my teens, AND the scars are worse and tend not to fade.

Besides, your dd could have caught it from somewhere else and you'd be none the wiser. Get it over with I say.

Soprana · 02/05/2008 14:23

YABU. It's best to get it as young as poss. When you're older it can be much nastier - I know, I had it in my teens, AND the scars are worse and tend not to fade.

Besides, your dd could have caught it from somewhere else and you'd be none the wiser. Get it over with I say.

Miggsie · 02/05/2008 14:13

Chicken pox can be grim and although several chidren have had it at nursery DD still had not caught it so I thought sod it, and got her immunisised. I was 1 when I had it and don't remember it, neighbour had shingles and was in agony and my friend told me her daughter got it in her mouth and all up her fanjo at 14 and the itching was awful and you can't get chamomile liquid up there!
Oh yuk, that's why I wimped out and got DD the injection before she goes to school.

rowingboat · 02/05/2008 14:08

YANBU - I do see the point of exposing a child to chicken pox at an early age, however I think she should offer some kind of warning to other parents so that they can make a decision, about whether they wish to be exposed via their children. Chicken pox can damage a foetus in a pregnant woman and can leave adult men infertile, for those reasons adults should be made aware if there is an option to do so.
Obviously if just 'happens' that children get chicken pox then it is impossible to control, but if it is done knowingly with a real risk then it is only fair to inform others at risk.

sparklesandnowinefor6months · 02/05/2008 14:06

Sorry to hear that it has affected you being able to see your friend, and i hope that you manage to get there without your DC

However, although i know the is a small possibility it can lead to other illnesses in children i believe that its easier to get it out of the way as a child (infact i went to see my friend yesterday even though her DD had chickenpox as i thought DS3 might get it - the trip was already arranged i just didn't pull out!)

When DS1 got chickenpox i hadn't had it and caught it off him at 24, it got onto my chest/lungs, i had difficulty breathing because of this and was hospitalised for a week or so. It was one of the most awful experiances i've ever had, wondering what would happen if it developed further internally, would i have a stroke etc - having gone through this i would rather my DC had it in childhood than went through what i did

flack · 02/05/2008 14:00

What does your friend want, NBG? Does he want everyone to be vaccinated in the hope that wild chickenpox will disappear?

Iamthedoctor · 02/05/2008 14:00

I also took DD to her cousins house, when said cousin had CP.

Would do it again.

nettiehay · 02/05/2008 13:56

My parents were always exposing us to chicken pox, but we never caught it when we were young. My younger brother finally got it when he was about 14, but even then my DbigB and I didn't get it... does that mean that if my PFB gets it I will???

BalloonSlayer · 02/05/2008 13:51

Just read the bit about the poor little boy who contracted leukemia. My friend's son certainly lost his entire immune system when he was ill - sounds like a similar thing. Luckily for him he is fine now.

scottishmummy · 02/05/2008 13:48

but chances are she would have caught chickenpox anyway,better to catch it young as it is less severe (as compared to being pg adult)

BalloonSlayer · 02/05/2008 13:47

I have some sympathy with the OP.

My friend's son (18m) nearly died from chicken pox. And I do mean nearly died, I am not exaggerating.

When my kids had it a friend asked me to come round so they could give it to hers. I refused. There was no way I was going to knowingly pass on a disease to anyone, having seen what my friend's son went through.

SlouchingTigerBittenDragon · 02/05/2008 13:46

Scmoopoo, very sorry to hear about your friend and the problem it causes for going to visit. However, at least you know that the virus is in the area and can act accordingly. Even if that mother hadn't gone & got her child infected, it would be very likely that your kids would have been exposed by now anyway and you might have taken them up to vist your friend no knowing they were contagious.

Rosylily · 02/05/2008 13:43

That's usefull to know.
We are a plastered with spots household at the moment. Managed to spread it to my friends children before I knew. Probably infected dd's class too.
So I hope all the parents are gratefull for their present.

prettybird · 02/05/2008 13:29

Found this:

"When can children return to school?

This has been a controversial issue for sure, but ought not to be. The latest word from the Canadian Pediatric Society, which restates it's 1994 recommendation (Can J Infect Dis 10;193-196, May/June 1999) is that children with mild varicella should be allowed to return to day care or school as soon as they feel well enough to participate normally in all activities, regardless of the state of the rash. Mild chicken pox is defined as having a low fever for a short period of time and fewer than 30 spots. Many of these children are 'well' by the second or third day of the illness and can participate in regular activities. The decision to return to school therefore should be based on individual facts and circumstances. As you indicated, many schools and day care centres still have strict exclusion policies that that keep children with varicella at home for 5 days after the rash appears (and some schools keep them home even longer, until the vesicles are completely dried). The reasoning behind the CPS position statement is that varicella is contagious from two days before the rash appears and is believed to be most infectious from 12 - 24 hours before the rash is recognized. Since the goal of exclusion is to protect other children from developing varicella, by the time the rash has appeared it is already too late to prevent the spread. "

Saggarmakersbottomknocker · 02/05/2008 13:26

Chickenpox kills significantly more adults than children though so purposely avoiding it in childhood is not necessarily a good thing.

SheikYerbouti · 02/05/2008 13:24

Scmoopoo - have you had chicken pox? If you have, you will be perfectly safe to visit your friend alone. It's a highly probable that your friend will have had it too. I think it's quite usual to reach adulthood without catching it

Actually, your little one won't be contagious by then anyway. They stop being contagious after the last crop of spots crust over, which took about 4 or 5 days when mine had it.

Sorry to hear about your friend