Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being given raw broad beans to eat....

85 replies

Ilivetosleep · 05/04/2024 22:13

I've had an experience today that I am genuinely perplexed by and I want to see if people think I have been unreasonable. Its quite long and I'm tired. But I will shorten the story as much as I can. We have travelled abroad for a major family holiday (think big 50th). All the inlaws including us. We stayed one night at MIL & FIL house as our flight came in really late. MIL kindly cooked the kids a meal they requested which was very carb heavy. All their meals are like this TBH. But as we were going to air bnb later I just agreed to eat this. I have a gastric ulcer meaning I have to really restrict my diet. Anyway went off to the air bnb but it hadn't been cleaned and we complained. They agreed to sort the flat and we returned to MIL house. Again she had cooked a very carb heavy meal.

Next day DH wanted to stay and have lunch there before we go back to the air bnb. Again they cooked a very carb heavy meal. I really don't want to be rude as I know they have let us stay with them. But by this point I've got serious gastric reflux and feel awful. I said to Dh maybe we can buy some cooked chicken and I can have this with salad and he agrees but he goes to 2 markets and finds none.

So again we sit down to eat. I have said nothing about not eating the food. I decided to just shut up and eat a little and not be impolite. MIlL starts to dish up the food. Then DH goes oh she can't eat that. MIL gets all flustered and asks me why didnt tell her I was on a diet and she could have cooked some beans and salad. She offers to cut me up carrot sticks.... so I say. Its fine there's no need to fuss. I will eat what I have. Then my FIL goes into the fridge and picks up a bag of raw unpeeled and unprepared Broad beans and puts these in front of me. I was so shocked. I got really embarrassed and said that I am OK. And thanked her for the meal and left the table.

Afterwards
Dh had a massive go at me that I am always disrespecting his family and I was so rude to his parents.

quick add..... its really hard telling FIL/MIL that I don't want to /can't eat their food as their entire days is focused ocooking g for the family. Today they had a major argument over it proper shouting and screaming at each other. They also do not know about my ulcer as I am waiting for a operation and if they know they would talk about it all the time. And I don't want them to do this ad I was hospitalised and the kids were very scared. They would speak about this information of the kids.
.

OP posts:
Beatrixpotts · 05/04/2024 23:11

Unless I've missed something, there seems to be so many dilemmas that wouldn't occur if people (and families) were just honest with each other! How many times I've had to say thanks, I'd love it but If I eat it I'll be shitting for days.

AlwaysFreezing · 05/04/2024 23:09

Shitty behaviour from fil. Meant to be saying you were insulting them somehow.

Even shutter behaviour from dh afterwards.

But, thsy didn't know, they tried, but got it wrong. But then they forgot their manners.

Nobody eats a bag of raw unwashed broad beans unless they have a special thing for it (I have a pal that eats bags of garden peas. She's weird. She knows it).

Cbalk it up to shit happens. Hope your stomach is OK!

Justleaveitblankthen · 05/04/2024 23:04

I'm intrigued. Are all these "carb heavy" meals various pasta dishes? 🍝

betterangels · 05/04/2024 23:00

The chicken example didn't do you any favours. It's not remotely similar. The beans are eaten raw.

Your DH should not have stirred though at first.

Sgtmajormummy · 05/04/2024 22:58

“Primo maggio, fave e formaggio”
It’s a well known delicacy when Italian people go on their May Day picnic.
Big velvety pods that yield about 4 beans each, a tiny amount of salt to dip them in and a hearty chunk of mature cheese.
Your PIL probably thought they were giving you a treat, almost a month ahead of time.
They’re perfectly edible, just like fresh peas from the pod.
But if you’re struggling with digestive problems you know what you can and can’t eat.
Just tell them. And DH should shut up about disrespect.
(although a strong liqueur is often the cure-all!)

Branster · 05/04/2024 22:47

I think if you made it clear you have a medical issue, they'd have gone above and beyond to make sure you are well catered for accordingly. And it would have been no bother to them whatsoever. All they want is to feed their guests/ family the best way they know how.
They didn't gave a clue what the situation was and they did the best they knew how. Beans was the only available healthy' stuff at the ready and, possibly, FIL is not the cook but wanted to offer you something as near to what he thought you could gave as possible

Renamed · 05/04/2024 22:46

Um, are you in Italy? At this time of year raw broad beans are eaten, and this might have been seen as a natural pure kind of food, if you are having to watch what you eat - maybe this is just misunderstanding, because they don’t know what you need?

SudExpress · 05/04/2024 22:45

NerdWhoEatsMedlar · 05/04/2024 22:33

Know I am being a prat, but where the feck are broad beans in season this early in the year?

Italy.
And eating them raw is mainly how they're consumed.
At this time of year it's totally normal at the end of a meal for a huge pile of broad beans in their pods to be plonked in the middle of the table and everyone digs in. Especially when they're still small so sweet and tender.
Presume that other southern med countries do the same.

kalokagathos · 05/04/2024 22:43

Allowballow · 05/04/2024 22:38

I come from a Mediterranean country and eating raw broad beans is very common. Typically you get a pile of unprepared pods and you work your way through them (ie peeling them then eating them etc etc similar to what you might do with fresh peas) whilst having a chat etc. So it might be very normal for them.

Edited

Same in Eastern Europe, I.e. Poland- we'd eat it like that- very healthy . You also would have expected to be more assertive/ say what the issue is or the strategy of eating very little/ eating just a few mouthfuls would have been read as rude.

Allowballow · 05/04/2024 22:43

I think he just wanted to give you something that is not that carb heavy and have you what they had in.

Ilivetosleep · 05/04/2024 22:42

Maybe he doesn't like me. I don't know. He's never given the suggestion he dislikes me. Buy it could be this.

OP posts:
Ilivetosleep · 05/04/2024 22:41

Allowballow · 05/04/2024 22:38

I come from a Mediterranean country and eating raw broad beans is very common. Typically you get a pile of unprepared pods and you work your way through them (ie peeling them then eating them etc etc similar to what you might do with fresh peas) whilst having a chat etc. So it might be very normal for them.

Edited

Yes. I know this. I am also from the same county as DH and when we grew up we did this. However not in the middle of having dinner.

OP posts:
Ilivetosleep · 05/04/2024 22:40

I think being assertive about my food needs would have been far more worse.

It caused a huge argument with DH. Whereby I said how would he like someone putting raw chicken in front of him at a table of he couldn't eat what they prepared. Dh said he didn't give you raw chicken.

They always have extended family for lunch/dinner most days and the cooking is the focus of the day for them. It is delicious what they cook. I wish I could have eaten it.

OP posts:
Allowballow · 05/04/2024 22:40

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/04/2024 22:38

Because he doesn't seem to like you very much.

Or because it is a normal thing for him (as it was for me growing up and anyone I know).

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/04/2024 22:38

Ilivetosleep · 05/04/2024 22:35

Clearly people on MN have misinterpreted what I am asking for an AIBU.

I didn't expect anyone to cater to my food needs. I have not posted that anywhere.

I know what they are like and how they take huge offence to anyone not eating the food they prepare. So knowing this I didn't say anything and planned to just have a few mouth fulls and loads of salad. I get on well with them and never had any disagreements.

It was DH who really caused this issue as he told MIL she has cut me too big piece of the food. When I didn't ask him to say anything.

My AIBU is why would my FIL give me a bag of raw unwashed and unprepared Broad beans when he thought I was on a diet.

Because he doesn't seem to like you very much.

Allowballow · 05/04/2024 22:38

I come from a Mediterranean country and eating raw broad beans is very common. Typically you get a pile of unprepared pods and you work your way through them (ie peeling them then eating them etc etc similar to what you might do with fresh peas) whilst having a chat etc. So it might be very normal for them.

crackofdoom · 05/04/2024 22:37

Actually that's true, it was DH sticking his oar in that made everything so much worse.

I get that it's uncomfortable, I used to find myself in similar situations when I lived in Italy/ Greece, and so did English friends. (I learnt, eventually, and for a while when I came back to England I would frighten people with my loudness and vehemence until I readapted 😆) They would have been expecting you to be far more assertive about what you wanted.

Ilivetosleep · 05/04/2024 22:35

Clearly people on MN have misinterpreted what I am asking for an AIBU.

I didn't expect anyone to cater to my food needs. I have not posted that anywhere.

I know what they are like and how they take huge offence to anyone not eating the food they prepare. So knowing this I didn't say anything and planned to just have a few mouth fulls and loads of salad. I get on well with them and never had any disagreements.

It was DH who really caused this issue as he told MIL she has cut me too big piece of the food. When I didn't ask him to say anything.

My AIBU is why would my FIL give me a bag of raw unwashed and unprepared Broad beans when he thought I was on a diet.

OP posts:
JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 05/04/2024 22:34

You don't have to tell them about the ulcer, just "the doctor has put me on a special diet so please don't cook for me I'll get something at the shop"

titchy · 05/04/2024 22:33

Well your FIL was rather passive-aggressive yes, but your DH was an arsehole. Out of nowhere saying you couldn't eat something when you'd already said you'll grin and bear it, then blaming you for his parents feeling uncomfortable. He caused this.

NerdWhoEatsMedlar · 05/04/2024 22:33

Know I am being a prat, but where the feck are broad beans in season this early in the year?

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/04/2024 22:30

Well, if you don’t know then to know about your health problems and if you tell them you are happy to eat anything them what exactly to you expect them to do to accommodate you?

PrincessTeaSet · 05/04/2024 22:29

crackofdoom · 05/04/2024 22:25

Just read your update. You shouldn't have said you'd eat what they served and then refused what they served!!

Equally, your DH should have mentioned the ulcer to them.

The OP didn't refuse to eat what they had served.. why is reading comprehension so bad on MN??

betterangels · 05/04/2024 22:28

She offered to do something else. You declined. FIL probably overreacted. All this could have been avoided if you'd taken food or told them what you can eat. Seems your MIL would have made you something. DH needs to chill.

LaMarschallin · 05/04/2024 22:28

Ilivetosleep

No. Why?

Because when someone posts "Think X" I always assume it's something a bit like X, but not actually X itself.
Still. Probably not relevant anyway to the broad beans under discussion.