Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I really so out of order here?

89 replies

JMSA · 30/03/2024 15:13

Today my 14 year old daughter asked if a school friend could come for a sleepover tonight. I said yes. Daughter was on the phone to her friend, saying that she was going to come to her home town (about 40 minutes away) to 'pick her up' on the bus, and that she'd be giving her friend the money for her fare here. I said that this wouldn't be happening, that the girl could make her own way to the city (my daughter could meet her there though, and head home together) and pay her own bus fare.
For reference, we're in Scotland, where every young person is entitled to a free bus pass. It's not my problem if the girl's mother hasn't applied for this.
The other point is that the girls attend a private school. I would be much more sympathetic if it was someone who genuinely couldn't afford the bus fare. Moreover, the girl gets the school coach every day, which costs thousands more per year. The bus fare here would be around £3.
I don't want my daughter to have the piss taken out of her. The girl has apparently spent the past 20 minutes convincing her mother that it is safe to come, and to give her the money for the fare. The girl has been here for a sleepover here before, and no invitation has been extended to my daughter. I've never even heard from the mother, let alone received a thanks for having her.
It's bonkers, is it not, to expect my 14 year old to foot the bill for her to come and stay here? Confused
I'm feeling awful now, as my daughter is furious and accusing me of judging this girl and her family.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 30/03/2024 17:37

It does sound odd and as if the mum is dysfunctional or controlling in some way but I would have let it go. It isn’t any huge cost to you and by blocking it you have come across as a bit punitive.

Barrenfieldoffucks · 30/03/2024 17:36

DD has often helped out a friend for whatever reason, I often slip it back to her and if necessary have a few words about keeping an eye on whether things are reciprocal and making sure the friendship stays fair. Not necessarily equal, circumstances considered, but fair.

You're wanting to encourage friendships, £3 is a small price at this stage.

potato57 · 30/03/2024 17:35

Is the friend Scottish? Because my parents are from a different culture and I wasn't allowed to have any money or go anywhere alone until I was 16. The reason I ask is because of the talk of it "being safe to come" which they/the parents may be nervous about if they're only familiar with certain areas.

Barrenfieldoffucks · 30/03/2024 17:32

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/03/2024 15:52

In your shoes, I would just give your DD the extra bus fare (or go and collect the friend yourself) and let things pan out.

At least that way, they'll be socialising at your house and you'll be able to keep an eye on them. Otherwise, you risk your DD not telling you things and potentially pushing you away.

I would do (and have done) this in the past.

GRex · 30/03/2024 17:29

Something is going on with the friend, and your house could become a safe place for her. I would want to gently know more to understand if it places DD at any risk, if the friend needs more support than a teen can provide, and if the friend is doing this a lot. Collecting a friend is just nice, ss long as the route is actually safe.

I'm the opposite camp about the £3 though. DS is much younger and I've actively encouraged him to spend pocket money on a little friend with £1 to feed goats, and 3 times now he's spent 50p to buy different friends a cake at the cake sale. He also buys us our gifts with his own money or paid for an extra item. I perceive it on the whole to be about money management skills; having a chat about being nice but you won't get anything back, so only give if you are happy to give it freely.

Mog65 · 30/03/2024 17:25

It's scotland. They have a young scot card. Travel anywhere free under 25. No need for bus fairs. Ynbu. Let you daughter travel but definitely not paying bus fairs. If her parents haven't got her card that's their problem.

KnackeredBack · 30/03/2024 17:24

Entirely reasonable, unless there's a backstory you don't know about. I had to put my foot down with my DDs friend and 'lifts' as the friend would constantly stay at our house, but the lifts there and back would somehow be our problem (didn't mind doing one way). It's an hour's round trip each time. I put my foot down and the parents got the message. They're still v good friends and I'm friends with the parents too now!

GabriellaMontez · 30/03/2024 17:24

Yanbu. I'd feel the same.

Irishmama100 · 30/03/2024 17:21

You are being perfectly reasonable! That’s why the rich are rich they just expect others to pay their way. She should be asking her own parents for the money.

Windysquall · 30/03/2024 17:20

I’m with you OP. Do you think the friend was scared of travelling by herself? Yet expects your DD to travel to her by herself? I’d have said no too.

Cakeandcardio · 30/03/2024 17:18

JMSA · 30/03/2024 15:32

And the cost of the fares is inconsequential. It's the principle.

Agreed. It's also very strange that pps would be so willing to let their child do something like this. Can just imagine the post if it was an adult asking their friend to foot the bus fare.

Mariannas · 30/03/2024 16:13

JMSA · 30/03/2024 15:31

Ok, so my feeling is that I've been unfair about the girls meeting at her hometown beforehand. That's my daughter's choice, which I should have respected.
However no one can persuade me otherwise about the bus fares. It's grabby and weird.

So why have you posted asking if you’re being unreasonable?

helpfulperson · 30/03/2024 16:05

All you've done is made sure your daughter won't tell you things in future.

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/03/2024 15:52

In your shoes, I would just give your DD the extra bus fare (or go and collect the friend yourself) and let things pan out.

At least that way, they'll be socialising at your house and you'll be able to keep an eye on them. Otherwise, you risk your DD not telling you things and potentially pushing you away.

JMSA · 30/03/2024 15:47

Suspected ADHD and she is never done with making mistakes at the moment. It's exhausting and challenging, especially as I'm on my own. I'm just trying to protect her Sad

OP posts:
fieldsofbutterflies · 30/03/2024 15:46

JMSA · 30/03/2024 15:43

I imagine its not the money its the principle and OP is worried about her DD being a doormat

Exactly. Thank you for your understanding. Daughter is going through a bit of a lonely phase where she's trying to find her 'tribe' (if that doesn't sound too wanky) and I want to support her friendships - hence the sleepover - but don't want her taken advantage of.

But at some point, you have to allow her to make her own mistakes. If you keep stepping in and protecting her, she'll never learn.

If the only thing at "risk" was a £3 bus fare, I would have just let her get on with it.

JMSA · 30/03/2024 15:43

I imagine its not the money its the principle and OP is worried about her DD being a doormat

Exactly. Thank you for your understanding. Daughter is going through a bit of a lonely phase where she's trying to find her 'tribe' (if that doesn't sound too wanky) and I want to support her friendships - hence the sleepover - but don't want her taken advantage of.

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 30/03/2024 15:42

What does your DD say is the reason she wants to pay her friend's bus fare, OP?

The answer to this is important here.

Spirallingdownwards · 30/03/2024 15:41

I wouldn't make the assumptions you had.

Perhaps she doesn't have access to her own money and your DD knows she can't ask you to collect her so she is doing so.

You don't know their financial background. Perhaps a parent has lost their job. Perhaps the girl is at school on a scholarship or bursary.

Trust your daughter's judgement and let the girl come. That way you can get to know her better and see how the land lies as to whether she is a chancer or someone in need of a good friend.

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/03/2024 15:40

I don't think it's your battle to fight. You've made your feelings clear but at 14 your DD can spend her money on whatever she likes (as long as it's legal, obviously).

BobbyBiscuits · 30/03/2024 15:37

If it was clear the family had severe financial problems I'd gladly pay the kids fare. But it sounds more like a ruse. Ie the kid wasn't given spending money, only bus fare. She wants to spend it on something else so...
Your daughter could be aware of this and trying to extract extra money off you?
Either way, can you send her mum or the kid herself the links to the free bus pass?

Hoppinggreen · 30/03/2024 15:36

SouthEastCoast · 30/03/2024 15:34

You are weirdly hung up about £3. Grabby?! That’s actually laughable

I imagine its not the money its the principle and OP is worried about her DD being a doormat

FictionalCharacter · 30/03/2024 15:36

JMSA · 30/03/2024 15:16

You don't think it's rather an odd precedent to set, with my daughter paying for her friend to come see her?

I'd normally say yes that is odd and not right, but I smell something unusual here. The mum doesn't want her teenager to travel by bus (doesn't get bus pass, pays more money for coach instead). The girl had to persuade her that going to your house is safe, yet she's been before.
I suspect this is a very overprotective and controlling mother who perhaps doesn't allow her daughter to have money, as a way of keeping her home.

SouthEastCoast · 30/03/2024 15:34

JMSA · 30/03/2024 15:31

Ok, so my feeling is that I've been unfair about the girls meeting at her hometown beforehand. That's my daughter's choice, which I should have respected.
However no one can persuade me otherwise about the bus fares. It's grabby and weird.

You are weirdly hung up about £3. Grabby?! That’s actually laughable

JMSA · 30/03/2024 15:32

And the cost of the fares is inconsequential. It's the principle.

OP posts: