Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Keeping sons money

85 replies

Piggybankme · 30/03/2024 08:10

I am a mother to a DS with disabilities. He's turned 18 and gets pip. I've been giving him an allowance from his pip money and saving the rest for him in an account of mine that I don't use. It's accrued a nice amount for his future but here is where I wonder if IABU.
I wanted to open him an ISA in his own name but I know he's probably going to need to claim UC in the near future and it would disqualify him as its over 16k
That PIP money is given because of the difficulty he has in life. I've saved it up for him so that he will have a bit of a buffer because he is more likely to need it than someone who can easily get work etc.
I don't like having his money in my name but I don't see another option. AIBU for keeping this money but earmarked for him. Obviously it would be complicated if I die as my other DC would technically be entitled to half. Arrggh my mind is all over the place. I just want to do everything possible to help my DS. Please be kind. He is entitled to the PIP and could have spent it all every month. Perhaps that's my mistake.

OP posts:
Winter2020 · 30/03/2024 10:46

This comment isn't intended to be a criticism of you - I know you have done your best. This comment is intended to be purely about the future and where you go from here. It is meant kindly.

You are creating a financial mess for yourself and your son. His PIP is money for his needs which you are his appointee for (I assume). You are spending some of your own money on his needs so then saying we'll it's not simply his money ....

You need to separate the two things. Imagine you were told today that in 12 months your son's finances and your behaviour as appointee are being audited. What would you do differently?

Whether that money hits an account in your name or your son's (which I think you would need power of attorney from the court of protection to manage so is perhaps not feasible at this time) it needs to be kept separate and managed appropriately.

You need to be confident that if the authorities ask you "can you show me how you, as your son's appointee, have managed his pip. You can reply "Yes - here is the account his pip goes into. Here is what he has spent it on (records/book/budgeting app).

Under your current system if a day service/ social worker/anonymous tip off accuses you of financial exploitation and you are asked to demonstrate how your son's PIP is being used what are you going yo be able to show them to demonstrate that your son is not being exploited?

You must also remember that you are managing the money on behalf of your son - and he should be included/his wishes paramount in any decisions. You say he might work so he has a good degree of capacity. You should help him manage his money- not take over. So if he wishes to buy a holiday or a computer and you would prefer him to save his money you need to discuss it and try to help him see the consequences of his decision but an adult has the right to make a bad or risky decision.

newyear2024 · 30/03/2024 10:45

I'm surprised you could afford to use your own money to pay for his needs, while saving his dla if you don't work yourself due to his needs, you definitely should have been claiming carers of you haven't been able to work OP

Blueblell · 30/03/2024 10:27

you could be charging him rent now so it would be legitimate to be putting some of this money into your account. Also anything he has needed in the past. I would get proper advice though if you are worried about keeping him money secure for the future and he is not able to manage his own money.

Unfortunately you hear of cases of people scrimping and saving up their benefits, only to then fall foul of the savings rule. So I would keep that in mind

colouredball · 30/03/2024 09:31

midgetastic · 30/03/2024 09:16

I guess op wants to ensure his life is easier when she isn't around and will need a lot more support

But instead the rules insist you spend now rather than save for when you know you will need it - well if we had good care for disabled people it wouldn't be a problem but we don't . So they could spend it now easily , keep getting the credit , and then when the mother dies and the child needs someone to live in with them they will get someone once a day to wash their face . It would end up costing the state as much or more over the child's life but the state dictates how you spend

It's your savings OP - you could only save that PIP because of your work and actions - save it somehow and write the will accordingly

You seem to have completely erased fathers.

Also, in this circumstance OP is hopeful her DS will be employed, the need for a live in carer is probably unrealistic.

Coolgarden · 30/03/2024 09:18

You should claim carers allowance in your name
It is also a gateway to other help & benefits.

He should claim universal credit in his own name, even if he doesn't receive the money. Because the National Insurance "stamps" go towards state pension & other benefits

midgetastic · 30/03/2024 09:16

I guess op wants to ensure his life is easier when she isn't around and will need a lot more support

But instead the rules insist you spend now rather than save for when you know you will need it - well if we had good care for disabled people it wouldn't be a problem but we don't . So they could spend it now easily , keep getting the credit , and then when the mother dies and the child needs someone to live in with them they will get someone once a day to wash their face . It would end up costing the state as much or more over the child's life but the state dictates how you spend

It's your savings OP - you could only save that PIP because of your work and actions - save it somehow and write the will accordingly

gamerchick · 30/03/2024 09:04

Pip is for the extra costs that go alongside a disability. I admire you saving it, but it's there to make his life easier.

There isn't anything noble about refusing to claim carers. You're missing out on extra money that also go towards making life easier. How are you coping working part time and not claiming top up benefits?

Piggybankme · 30/03/2024 08:59

Thank you to everyone who's offered advice. I'm sorry I haven't replied to everyone but I've read and digested all your comments.

I'll probably keep the money safe and use it towards his future needs of which there are bound to be many.

Just to add also. I've not been able to work full time due to his needs and I have never claimed any carers allowances etc. I'm his carer because I'm his mum so I didn't feel right being paid for it. With hindsight I probably should have claimed that.

OP posts:
Piggybankme · 30/03/2024 08:49

Livelovebehappy · 30/03/2024 08:45

Agree. If he was never going to be able to work due to his disability, then fair enough. But op has said he will be getting a job. Therefore, he should seek employment.

We don't know how easily he will find work yet. It's all hyperthetical at the moment. If he can manage, then he will work. The pip should top up what's likely to be a low wage and the savings will be there to help him. He may never need to claim UC anyway.

OP posts:
Livelovebehappy · 30/03/2024 08:45

colouredball · 30/03/2024 08:24

Honestly? No you shouldn't be squirrelling away his money so he can claim further benefits. The disability factor really isn't too relevant here, having someone hold on to a load of savings in their name so you can claim UC is fraud. It is an unfortunate situation, but the reality is people should not be claiming benefits if they have huge amounts of savings.

Edited

Agree. If he was never going to be able to work due to his disability, then fair enough. But op has said he will be getting a job. Therefore, he should seek employment.

Gingerbee · 30/03/2024 08:44

I don't know your sons disability.
Please contact one of the disability organisations such as Mencap, Scope Autistic Society or whatever is best related to his disability.
They will be able to best advice you on trusts, wills, law etc.
I know several local organisations often have lawyers come and give talks with regard to savings, wills and planning for the future.

Piggybankme · 30/03/2024 08:44

colouredball · 30/03/2024 08:39

When I was saving this for him I had no idea about the rules of UC. We've been subsidising his financial needs as his parents. It's not quite as black and white as perhaps you're seeing it. I do value all advice and opinion though so thank you.

I hadn't consider that at all, I wouldn't put the money in his name I would just keep it and use as and when you see fit. That could be for anything he needs, or even wants.

Yes I think I'll keep it aside like I have done already and use it for his needs as and when. He may never need to claim UC just depends how the dice falls in his working life. We're not there yet with apply for work as he's in education still.

OP posts:
colouredball · 30/03/2024 08:44

@izimbra

If he's 18 he's entitled to claim UC under 'limited capability for work or work related activity' if he's not in work or education.

It's not that simple. You have to be assessed to be in the LCWRA group. OP has already expressed that work will be a factor in the future so he may not actually be considered unfit for work.

Notadoormat4 · 30/03/2024 08:41

So really the money has been spent but you've also saved alongside it?

Keep the money in your name because there have been costs previous to him turning 18.

izimbra · 30/03/2024 08:41

If he's 18 he's entitled to claim UC under 'limited capability for work or work related activity' if he's not in work or education.

Except his 6K in savings means he's not.

If he had £5999 in savings he'd be entitled to roughly £600 a month in UC. Plus his PIP. PIP isn't means tested.

Piggybankme · 30/03/2024 08:40

Menomeno · 30/03/2024 08:38

Also be aware that he’d have to declare anything over £6K savings to UC, and his benefits would be reduced accordingly.

Thank you. He may not need to claim so it's hyperthetical anyway at this point but I'll consider that before I give him any money.

OP posts:
colouredball · 30/03/2024 08:39

When I was saving this for him I had no idea about the rules of UC. We've been subsidising his financial needs as his parents. It's not quite as black and white as perhaps you're seeing it. I do value all advice and opinion though so thank you.

I hadn't consider that at all, I wouldn't put the money in his name I would just keep it and use as and when you see fit. That could be for anything he needs, or even wants.

Menomeno · 30/03/2024 08:38

Also be aware that he’d have to declare anything over £6K savings to UC, and his benefits would be reduced accordingly.

determinedtomakethiswork · 30/03/2024 08:37

These are your savings because you spent your own money on your son. I would put it into something like premium bonds or a separate account and I would explain to my other children why that was his money. I think you need to write a will if you want to keep that separate as well.

Piggybankme · 30/03/2024 08:37

colouredball · 30/03/2024 08:24

Honestly? No you shouldn't be squirrelling away his money so he can claim further benefits. The disability factor really isn't too relevant here, having someone hold on to a load of savings in their name so you can claim UC is fraud. It is an unfortunate situation, but the reality is people should not be claiming benefits if they have huge amounts of savings.

Edited

When I was saving this for him I had no idea about the rules of UC. We've been subsidising his financial needs as his parents. It's not quite as black and white as perhaps you're seeing it. I do value all advice and opinion though so thank you.

OP posts:
newyear2024 · 30/03/2024 08:34

Just be really careful OP, there was an elderly man in my area arrested and charged for claiming benefits while having over 30k in savings. The last thing you want is to get your son in trouble for claiming while having large savings. (16k is alot of money for someone to have while claiming benefits)

colouredball · 30/03/2024 08:34

The amount I've saved at this point could easily get gobbled up if he's unable to get work for a period of time

Work? Why are you managing the money for him if he is likely to able to work? Let him start doing it. He is never going to learn this skill of you don't allow him the chance. Start by having his money paid into his account and take X amount from him leaving him the rest. See what happens. If he spends it all, he spends it all, you can't control his money because you don't like what he does with it any more than you can for any adult DC

I misunderstood your OP as him never being able to work due to his disabilities when you mentioned the UC - sorry.

Quitelikeacatslife · 30/03/2024 08:31

Presumably you've been subsidising his living expenses yourself , you could have been using all his pip so it's not strictly his money. That could have gone into the family pot and it could be the extra to your salary that's been saved. So I can't see it as fraud or his really . However as you choose to call it his, it's good to have it earmarked for the future, for if you aren't around etc or if he needs something. Talk to the family and maybe put it in trust

Octavia64 · 30/03/2024 08:30

Ok, in which case maybe you can think of it as the PIP has been spent on the care costs and that this money is a fund you have saved which you will use if and when he needs help.

I wouldn't be setting up a trust for the amount of money you are talking about it's not worth it.

Piggybankme · 30/03/2024 08:28

Yes we've supported him ourselves

OP posts: