Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unmarried mothers with partner, how do you do finances?

61 replies

Theyellowoneplease · 30/03/2024 07:14

I've got a lot going on at the moment and I'm stewing about things, I don't know if I'm just being unreasonable or if I have a valid point!

Together with DP for 9 years, we have two DC 6 and 5. I was made redundant between babies, had a large redundancy package equivalent to two years wages which meant I could afford to stay at home for 2 years. Once that money ran out I picked up jobs in hospitality to fit around DPs work to avoid childcare costs. I was struggling financially after COVID passed so found a very flexible job in education where I could write my own diary essentially, meaning I worked PT during preschool hours and did drop offs/pick ups and just (cheekily) WFH when it was the holidays (term time pre-school).

I hated the job but stuck it for 2 years until my youngest started school and we could access wrap around care (not offered at pre-school). I also worked Fri night, sat night and all day Sunday in a pub kitchen as I wasn't bringing in enough money to cover my 50% of the bills.

I left my jobs in November after my DF's terminal cancer diagnosis after realising life is too short to work a job I don't enjoy. I've struggled to find something (a couple didn't work out) but now been in this job about 6 weeks and I like it! However it's low paid so I'm going to have to top up my income with an evening job.

AIBU to be mad that we don't pool our money as a couple? I've always paid 50% of the shared bills AND until November time been the main parent for drop offs/pick ups, holidays etc. DP is being primed for a 2-band promotion with the NHS so he'll be on even better money which I feel really bitter about! He's also moaning about his holiday allowance being 'taken up' for school holidays.

OP posts:
SunshinDay · 30/03/2024 08:32

@Givemepickles excellent post.

I could not live with this dviying up stuff..

Op your dh has had a wondeful time and as you have carried this load he doesn't understand what it all entails.

You could suggest you will find the engineering job but that he would need to turn it down this promotions? So someone can be present for the dc as to what they are used too.

I can't believe he is happy for you to get a second job?

Bjorkdidit · 30/03/2024 08:32

His argument is that I need a higher paying job in the industry I trained in (engineering) but i just feel so burnt out I'm enjoying having a low stress job I can walk away from at the end of the day

So if you did this, would he step up and do his half of childcare and no doubt all the mental load of running the household along with cooking, cleaning, laundry etc?

He's currently not appreciating the value of him being able to go to work without having to think about who's going to care for his DC, take them to school/nursery, etc etc. That's huge.

He has two choices. You work full time and continue to split bills 50/50. But you also split 50/50 all childcare including pick ups, drop offs, sick days, appointments etc etc. Same for laundry, cooking, cleaning, money management, gardening, DIY etc etc.

Or you continue as you are but all joint household costs (mortgage, bills, childcare, food, DCs clothes, extra pension contributions to prevent you falling behind where he is) are paid from joint income and the remainder is split 50/50.

Ofcourseshecan · 30/03/2024 08:24

Myopicglass · 30/03/2024 07:32

No doubt he’s another man who watches his partner run ragged while he makes an arse dent in the sofa (an exceptionally deep one due to the weight of the coins in his pockets).

Yup. Wonderful how ‘principled’ these men are, refusing to support the outdated institution of marriage blah blah blah … Oh and just coincidentally it lets them have their cake and eat it, and have half their partner’s too!

Sayingitstraight · 30/03/2024 08:22

What a shitshow! Why are you accepting this, raise the bar !

GabriellaMontez · 30/03/2024 08:19

Can you go back to work, full time and improve your income? If so I suggest you do this. Let him know he'll have to step up to half of pickups/holidays/sick days etc

Plus half the cost of childcare.

He sounds disgusting, to stand by and watch you work yourself into the ground... and continue to do 50% financial contributions. Whilst doing 0% child/family jobs.

How much have yoi discussed the situation with him?

Tisfortired · 30/03/2024 08:15

I’m 33, been with DP 15 years and have two kids 10 and 1.5. When we moved in together 10 years ago we opened a joint account for all bills, and sent 50/50 to it every month, it helped that we have always earnt about the same. Anything leftover was our own to do as we pleased with.

I have never been bothered about getting married, DP mentioned it a few times over the years but I didn’t see the point, or what difference it would make.

Long story short, we are actually getting married this June finally. I think a combination of getting older, having the second baby and me quitting work after mat leave to care for the baby FT it just made sense. I am surprised at the sense of security it’s given me.

ClaudiaWinklepanda · 30/03/2024 08:06

I’m not married. We each put the same amount into a joint account to pay for bills (inc childcare when DD was younger). I’m the higher earner so I tend to cover additional stuff like doing up the house.

We are both self employed and work full time.

CagneyAndLazy · 30/03/2024 08:02

User11223344 · 30/03/2024 07:33

This is straight up misogyny, with him ring-fencing his leisure time, not contributing to childcare (drop offs etc) and not counting your contribution as work. It’s madness.

This is a tight-fisted, uncaring arsehole issue.

It's not a misogyny issue.

Catopia · 30/03/2024 08:00

We have a joint account for household expenses. This covers mortgage (which we hold as tenants in common in unequal shares), bills, maintenance on the property, household items, food, a small "fun budget" for a meal out or takeaway a month and a holiday fund. We contribute unevenly because I pay more of the mortgage as I am currently the higher earner. This means I do effectively substitute his lifestyle a little, but it also evens out the amount of personal disposable income we each have for our respective cars, fun with friends, clothes, etc. Sometimes one of us will treat the other to dinner out, and sometimes I'll pay for a weekend away or similar because I want to get away and would prefer him to come with me! We review contributions a couple of times a year in line with changing bills/household needs/income. This will be reviewed if/when have children and have mat leave/possibly reduce hours and we intend to plan for child expenses etc from about 6 months out to ensure we are covering the "big ticket items" and also can pay into a trust fund for them, and also to reduce the hit of mat leave reduced income.

Theyellowoneplease · 30/03/2024 08:00

GabriellaMontez · 30/03/2024 07:47

Do you want to marry him?

What's your rent / mortgage situation?

It all sounds dreadful. You're treated like a low paid slave.

At this point in time. No I don't think I do. We're going to a good friends wedding today and I have lots of emotions coming to the surface.

Mortgage approx £1k a month. Run down house needs a lot doing. Also making me quite miserable tbh! I don't feel like I'll ever have the money to contribute to improvements.

OP posts:
Givemepickles · 30/03/2024 08:00

Regardless of whether you're married or not, the problem is neither of you seems to see yourselves as a team just as two individuals. You're more like flat sharers than a couple. A team, and this includes the children, does what's best for the team. It doesn't let one team member sink, it adjusts to accommodate and assist. A team recognises the other members' contributions. It sees success as team success not individual. So for example, in a marriage where they are a team, your DH's promotion would mean you could take your foot off the gas a bit as more money is coming in from him. You could recover from running yourself ragged for so long and he could pick up more bills and allow you a less stressful job with better hours. This in turn benefits the whole household as you, the mother, are less stressed, less tired and more available for the children and him.

Have you ever had this together? Do you feel you are a team?

Theyellowoneplease · 30/03/2024 07:57

DramaticBananas · 30/03/2024 07:46

Does he know how much money you do bring home? If he does and he stills insists on 50-50, that's cruel and a measure of who he is.

Regardless, I'd look to yourself and your own needs now, after 6 years of so much giving. You need to be earning and to build up those savings again. Find a full time job, that you can enjoy, if not love (love is a big ask!).

The kids will adapt fine to an after school club. For the school holidays, book up grandparents if possible and weekly holiday clubs for the weeks you can't cover. Maybe save a weeks leave just for you, in term time? DP might do the same? Go away with a friend, or by yourself to recharge. Look after your self, health and your own finances.

Fortunately kids are loving the wrap around care so that's a relief!

We have relied on my parents for help until my father's diagnosis we have to be very careful. The Easter holiday for example, they were going to help out but my daughters friend has chicken pox so can't risk my Dad being near her (he's never had chicken pox and is on chemo). DP asked his Mum (who doesn't work) but essentially she doesn't want to (gym, plans with friends).

OP posts:
cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 30/03/2024 07:55

This is financial abuse.

He's not doing 50% of childcare/wifework/ chores/life admin etc so obey shouldn't be 50/50 either.

Theyellowoneplease · 30/03/2024 07:52

Causewerethespecialtwo · 30/03/2024 07:43

How much do you both earn per month? If there is a big difference in your earnings then yes you do need to sit down with him and have a chat to see if you can adjust the % you each pay of the family outgoings. If you are scraping by and taking on extra work just to pay your half of the bills, whilst he has plenty of spending money and savings each month, then it’s clearly not ok.

If he isn’t willing to talk about it and adjust the amounts you each pay fairly, then you know you have a big problem.

This month for example my take home pay is £1515 and his was £2500 with a bit of overtime, but his will soon go up with the good promotion. I've been doing overtime at my job but this will dry up in 2 weeks hence having to find evening work for a few hours a week. I think that will bring me to about £1650/1700 take home pay.

We each pay £1200 in to a joint account.

His argument is that I need a higher paying job in the industry I trained in (engineering) but i just feel so burnt out I'm enjoying having a low stress job I can walk away from at the end of the day.

OP posts:
chocolategg · 30/03/2024 07:50

Are you better off leaving him and him paying you child maintenance?

GabriellaMontez · 30/03/2024 07:47

Do you want to marry him?

What's your rent / mortgage situation?

It all sounds dreadful. You're treated like a low paid slave.

DramaticBananas · 30/03/2024 07:46

Does he know how much money you do bring home? If he does and he stills insists on 50-50, that's cruel and a measure of who he is.

Regardless, I'd look to yourself and your own needs now, after 6 years of so much giving. You need to be earning and to build up those savings again. Find a full time job, that you can enjoy, if not love (love is a big ask!).

The kids will adapt fine to an after school club. For the school holidays, book up grandparents if possible and weekly holiday clubs for the weeks you can't cover. Maybe save a weeks leave just for you, in term time? DP might do the same? Go away with a friend, or by yourself to recharge. Look after your self, health and your own finances.

Happycow · 30/03/2024 07:44

As youre not married, I would take the starting point as that you both 'have the right' to work full time. childcare costs to facilitate that are a joint responsibility, and all bills / hoisehold expenses split 50-50.

Then make adjustments as a couple for that. So if his full time job pays £50k and yours £25k, he pays more towards the household pot.

If you (jointly) agree that you work less than full time, then you need to jointly agree what would be a fair split of bills contribution (given you earn less) and childcare (given you allow the hoisehold to spend less on this).

Sounds quite cold, but he shouldnt assume you do all the childcare AND housework AND lose all leisure time (doing shifts at the pub or wherever). Sit down with him, talk it through and see that (at the start point at least) he would be doing a hell of lot more than he does, and have less freedom on his work schedule!

Causewerethespecialtwo · 30/03/2024 07:43

How much do you both earn per month? If there is a big difference in your earnings then yes you do need to sit down with him and have a chat to see if you can adjust the % you each pay of the family outgoings. If you are scraping by and taking on extra work just to pay your half of the bills, whilst he has plenty of spending money and savings each month, then it’s clearly not ok.

If he isn’t willing to talk about it and adjust the amounts you each pay fairly, then you know you have a big problem.

MFF2010 · 30/03/2024 07:43

Hobbitfeet32 · 30/03/2024 07:34

Genuinely don’t understand why people think that having a child together is less of a commitment than getting married.

It's usually a bigger commitment for a woman but not so much for men who seem to walk away from their kids and responsibilities with alarming regularity. Marriage helps protect women financially when this happens. To not insist on this security before having children is mind boggling 🤷‍♀️

Freshair87 · 30/03/2024 07:41

I'm in the same position relationship wise as you, we don't have a joint account as my partner is terrible with money but we pay the bills proportionally to what each other earn as he earns a lot more which seems fair, he still has plenty to himself after this

MFF2010 · 30/03/2024 07:40

You say you have a 50/50 arrangement but it doesn't sound like you do. He should be picking up half the childcare costs, that means paying you if you're staying at home to look after them instead of paying a nursery 🤷‍♀️ he doesn't get to work FT and you work PT to save nursery costs and take the entire hit. You were foolish for not marrying and joining finances tbh. You either do it now or you're better off leaving and claiming CSA or having 50/50 care freeing you up to work 💐

buntymcfun · 30/03/2024 07:36

I’m not married. We’ve been together 15 years and have three children. We’ve always taken the approach that any income is both of ours. Even if I’m not working, I’ve still been keeping the house and looking after the kids which is a full time job in itself. We have a joint account and I manage all the money.

Hobbitfeet32 · 30/03/2024 07:34

Genuinely don’t understand why people think that having a child together is less of a commitment than getting married.

bryceQ · 30/03/2024 07:34

We've never been 50% each we both just pay what we can into joint and all big things come from there. When I've had to have time off because of our child my partner (now husband but we were together 12 years before we married) paid for everything. Since we've married nothing has changed financially. There's never been a 50/50 expectation.