Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

AIBU To not want to visit my MIL who is dying

412 replies

Aisleseat · 29/03/2024 21:40

As background, I’ve been married for 19 years and never had a close relationship with my MIL. She lives a few hours away and my DH would be pretty bad at visiting also. To make up for this he has spent the last number of years just buying her whatever she wants to appease her - and trust me, she’s always looking for something - from tvs to phones to hotel stays, he forks out. My kids would see her a couple of times a year.

Just before Christmas she was diagnosed with stage 4 cancer with a poor enough prognosis. My husband has now gone into a complete tailspin and since December is spending a few nights a week staying with them. He’s 54 btw. We work together in our own business so I’m picking up for him while he’s out.
The problem for me is that he seems to want us as a family to be ever present when she’s dying and I quite frankly just don’t want to do it. She was in hospital for mothers day and we went to visit her (because according to him its likely to be the last time she would see us together) with the children and she didn’t say one word to them. It was unbearably awkward and my poor kids didn’t know what to make of it.

So tonight, DH has arrived back from his overnight stay and has told me that we will all go to see her again on Sunday.
Ive just told him no, it’s uncomfortable for the children and for me. He can spend his entire week down with her for all I care but I just don’t want to see her.
If I hear again “this will probably be the last time she sees her grandchildren”
I’m trying not to be a heartless bitch here but it’s hard when he’s now stormed into the other room and is watching her on a monitor that he has set up in her house.

AIBU by refusing to go visit when quite frankly I feel nothing for the woman

OP posts:
Wait17 · 30/03/2024 06:31

Oh OP, should I join the bandwagon and call you you heartless for your aibu?
So many people PROJECTIng? It's her MIL not all the rest of you or your mother's or fathers. After your op seems nobody is reading the updates before jumping on.
However, support your OH otherwise there may be hell to pay once MIL's gone.
Op has a sick father whom she does not impose on her OH to visit.
Oh she was chatting away in the. hospital to DH It was the kids that she ignored. GRANDMA/MIL is not too sick to talk; just couldn't be bothered to didn't speak to the children so it was uncomfortable. Perhaps they could visit one last time for 10 minutes. Good luck!

MariaVT65 · 30/03/2024 06:27

Whereareallthemillionaires · 30/03/2024 03:32

Of course you’re being unreasonable, you’re being completely heartless to your dh and his mum.

You said visiting her in the hospital was awkward, well no shit Sherlock she’s dieing. And what exactly did your kids expect.

Why would a 9 year old know what to expect, in a situation where someone is dying, and it being a person he hardly sees and therefore doesn’t know very well? I wouldn’t know what to expect, and actually my default expectation was that if i was being asked to visit someone, they would talk to me.

SignoraVolpe · 30/03/2024 06:19

Dc should not be made to sit with their dying dgm for more than 30 minutes unless they want to.
Take the dc, pstay for 30 minutes and then leave your dh for as long as he wishes.
To me that’s a fair compromise. Hopefully you have 2 cars.

chocolategg · 30/03/2024 06:19

Whereareallthemillionaires · 30/03/2024 03:32

Of course you’re being unreasonable, you’re being completely heartless to your dh and his mum.

You said visiting her in the hospital was awkward, well no shit Sherlock she’s dieing. And what exactly did your kids expect.

Unfair the kids are kids and probably had no idea what to expect

Eyeroll2024 · 30/03/2024 06:18

You have no reason at all to feel the tiniest bit of guilt about not wanting to watch a woman you don't care about in her death throes. And your kids have already done their duty so definitely do not need to attend unless they want to.

But you do need to support your husband, as much as possible - assuming you have a marriage you want to keep. So perhaps the two of you could just go and you can be there for him.

WadiShab · 30/03/2024 06:15

THisbackwithavengeance · 29/03/2024 21:42

YABU.

It's his mum. You have made the situation all about you. You should be supporting your DH.

THIS

It's not about you. IMO support should be given to support DH, clearly just not objecting to DH spending time or stating with his mother is not enough.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 30/03/2024 06:08

Runnerinthenight · 30/03/2024 02:38

I think posters are overreacting.

I had known my MIL for many years when she was diagnosed as terminally ill, but she wasn't a great MIL and she was a shit grandmother. I did take the kids (with DH) to see her a couple of times after she was diagnosed but as the end approached, it was made clear that only DH and his sibling should be with her. Fine with me.

My eldest was 15 when she died, youngest 8, and tbh they really weren't upset. I blame that on DH because he didn't facilitate a closer relationship but I don't think she wanted it anyway. His sibling's child was the golden child and as soon as they came on the scene, she wasn't one bit interested in ours!

She knew nothing about our kids, their likes/dislikes, their interests. She only saw them a couple of times a year. When she bought them a present, it wasn't age appropriate or anything they might have liked.

I supported DH as best I could when she was dying, and gave him carte blanche to spend as much time as he wanted with her (she was an hour and a half away), even though he complained about me spending my mother's last week at her hospital bedside.

The kids and I all felt deeply uncomfortable at the funeral, like we were some afterthought, and not some of her closest relatives.

Most people feel uncomfortable at funerals but it's about the people who've lost a dear one supporting each other, not about making you feel comfortable.

GreatGateauxsby · 30/03/2024 06:07

losing your mother is different to your father for most people.... ask anyone who has lost both and 99 in 100 will agree.

She sounds awful so i get it but He sounds grief stricken and like he is coping badly.
I'd do it for my husband. And I'd make my children do it for their father.

One way to square the circle is...
yes you dont like her but you've barely had to see her for X years. Most people have to do 2-3 weeks a year. Even 4 or 5 visits now and you are "ahead"

Do it for your DH.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 30/03/2024 05:56

You are coming across as heartless.
Your DH's mother is dying, he's trying to make amends, it's never too late.

It's a teaching moment for your kids, they can't be forced to go but sounds like they're feeding off your negative energy.

What she's done in the past is not relevant, he wants to be there for her and needs your support.

Coming on here to talk her down in her dying days and criticise your DH's way of dealing with her impending death is selfish and uncalled for.

He needs his wife there for him.

You have your sister to help with your dad and probably prefer her to go with you to visit.

He prefers to go with his family.

If you can't support you DH in his time of need then yes, it is heartless.

Tornado70 · 30/03/2024 05:55

We were in a similar position a number of years ago when my FIL was nearing the end of his life. My kids and I saw him but he ignored one of them (he had always preferred my son to my daughter!) and both my kids struggled and said they didn’t want to go back. They found it so difficult seeing him so ill and they found the rather awful nursing home too difficult.
DH and I sat down with kids and discussed how we all felt. We all decided that I would focus on the kids and DH would focus completely on his parents. It worked out ok. DH went to stay with his mum and supported her. I stayed home with the kids. There was no pressure on him to input into home life.
I really feel for you OP. Very difficult time for you all.
I am fortunate though that my DH was 100% happy with what we all decided.

Autienotnaughtie · 30/03/2024 05:44

If your kids don't want to visit I wouldn't force them to.

I would have come at it from that angle but still try to support dh. It must be hard to think of losing his mum. And watching her go through that is brutal.

My mum had stage 4 cancer, she had various treatments to prolong her life but died after 4 years. I cared for her. Dh supported me by keeping on top of house, kids. Working.

He did visit but maybe every month with kids. Once she was in the hospice we did a last visit for them. I would not have wanted kids there near the end it was awful.

Noyesnoyes · 30/03/2024 04:45

Dentistlakes · 30/03/2024 04:35

People tend to remember how someone came through for them (or didn’t in your case) during the hard and difficult times. It doesn’t matter if you feel anything for your MIL or not. Your job is to support your DH. You are also setting an example for your children as to what a supportive partner looks like.

I don’t really know what else to say without being rude, so i’ll stop there.

This 100%

Dentistlakes · 30/03/2024 04:35

People tend to remember how someone came through for them (or didn’t in your case) during the hard and difficult times. It doesn’t matter if you feel anything for your MIL or not. Your job is to support your DH. You are also setting an example for your children as to what a supportive partner looks like.

I don’t really know what else to say without being rude, so i’ll stop there.

lemonmeringueno3 · 30/03/2024 03:52

I think your dc are old enough to learn compassion and duty. Demonstrate how one supports a family member during a difficult time, and how it is possible to set aside differences and forgive old disagreements and judgments at such times. I wouldn't expect them to sit there in silence for hours, but a brief visit is not too much to ask. If granny ignores them, just tell them that she is in intense physical pain and mental anguish, and that people are not always on their best behaviour at such times. Imagine that you are setting a blueprint for how you want your dc to treat you when your turn comes around.

Thomasina79 · 30/03/2024 03:49

If I were dying I would not want to be around people with people who obviously did not care for me and didn’t want to be there. Stay away and let the poor woman die in peace. Your husband is trying his best to support her, which is admirable. His is not about you.

NY152 · 30/03/2024 03:41

Absolutely encourage your husband to do what he needs to do. But you’re right not to force this on your kids!

Whereareallthemillionaires · 30/03/2024 03:32

Of course you’re being unreasonable, you’re being completely heartless to your dh and his mum.

You said visiting her in the hospital was awkward, well no shit Sherlock she’s dieing. And what exactly did your kids expect.

ForestBather · 30/03/2024 03:02

The main difficulty is that your DH hasn't nurtured his or the children's relationship with his mother, now she is dying they are suddenly supposed to gather around like they have some sort of close relationship with her. It no doubt feels very fake.

In any case though, your DH is going to have to live with what he did or didn't do when his mother has gone, and you need to support him. I'd talk to the children about how at times like this we need to be there to support their father. It's for him, not for MIL.

How long is MIL expected to live for? If a few weeks, I could put up with a lot more visiting than if it was a few months or longer. I'd let him visit whenever and work out what is reasonable expectations for the children and yourself. Focus on being a wife, not your being the DIL.

Spencer0220 · 30/03/2024 03:00

If we can all see the distaste for her, so can your husband.

Grief, and the prospect of grief, does weird things to us all.

I certainly wouldn't demand the children go. As a child I was very relieved to have been spared seeing death.

That said, it's important you step up for your husband in whatever way he needs you. This isn't about you, or her. It's about him.

As much as I won't be in the same room as my mil, I know if she was dying and my husband asked, I'd be there in a flash.

If you can't support him, you need to evaluate why.

HDready · 30/03/2024 02:52

Aisleseat · 29/03/2024 22:33

Most certainly won’t be the case. I wouldn’t take a cent from her - I won’t need to worry though, we’ll probably end up having to pay off her bills when she’s gone

You’ll be thrilled to hear that this is not how probate works. Why don’t you use some of the time you save not visiting your dying mother in law to do some research?

Toothbrushh · 30/03/2024 02:50

You do exactly what he asks you to

or this will haunt every row for the rest of your marriage.

Runnerinthenight · 30/03/2024 02:38

I think posters are overreacting.

I had known my MIL for many years when she was diagnosed as terminally ill, but she wasn't a great MIL and she was a shit grandmother. I did take the kids (with DH) to see her a couple of times after she was diagnosed but as the end approached, it was made clear that only DH and his sibling should be with her. Fine with me.

My eldest was 15 when she died, youngest 8, and tbh they really weren't upset. I blame that on DH because he didn't facilitate a closer relationship but I don't think she wanted it anyway. His sibling's child was the golden child and as soon as they came on the scene, she wasn't one bit interested in ours!

She knew nothing about our kids, their likes/dislikes, their interests. She only saw them a couple of times a year. When she bought them a present, it wasn't age appropriate or anything they might have liked.

I supported DH as best I could when she was dying, and gave him carte blanche to spend as much time as he wanted with her (she was an hour and a half away), even though he complained about me spending my mother's last week at her hospital bedside.

The kids and I all felt deeply uncomfortable at the funeral, like we were some afterthought, and not some of her closest relatives.

Onthebrink87 · 30/03/2024 02:34

I can understand not wanting the kids to go, especially with the youngest being 9 and the eldest expressing discomfort with it and neither being given the opportunity to develope any sort of relationship with her previously - so I say fair enough to that. But all the pp saying it's about supporting your DH are right.

I disagree with the whole 'you can support him in other way's' sentiment, because if the support you offer doesn't feel like support to your husband, I'd argue it isn't support at all. I also feel like people suggesting that, might say differently If a woman was posting about needing support from her husband through a difficult period and his argument was, I'm supporting you in a way I can/want to.

MariaVT65 · 30/03/2024 02:29

lecreseut · 30/03/2024 02:10

Your husband will find emotional support in the arms of someone else.

Have compassion for someone who is dying. Your MIL is not some criminal. At the end of the day, she gave birth to your husband, and he didn't turn out too badly since you chose to marry him.

Age 9 and 16 is old enough to visit a dying family member. The kids need closure as well.

I wouldn’t assume the kids need closure for someone they saw twice a year tbh.

MariaVT65 · 30/03/2024 02:27

I don’t think a 9 year old should be forced to visit someone who is dying, who he doesn’t have a close relationship with and who didn’t want to speak to him when he last visited.

I’m with you op but is there a compromise where your 16 year old can sit somewhere outside or somewhere else with your 9 year old while you visit so at least they don’t have to visit?

What did your DH say when you raised that MIL didn’t speak to the kids?

Swipe left for the next trending thread