Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

AIBU To not want to visit my MIL who is dying

412 replies

Aisleseat · 29/03/2024 21:40

As background, I’ve been married for 19 years and never had a close relationship with my MIL. She lives a few hours away and my DH would be pretty bad at visiting also. To make up for this he has spent the last number of years just buying her whatever she wants to appease her - and trust me, she’s always looking for something - from tvs to phones to hotel stays, he forks out. My kids would see her a couple of times a year.

Just before Christmas she was diagnosed with stage 4 cancer with a poor enough prognosis. My husband has now gone into a complete tailspin and since December is spending a few nights a week staying with them. He’s 54 btw. We work together in our own business so I’m picking up for him while he’s out.
The problem for me is that he seems to want us as a family to be ever present when she’s dying and I quite frankly just don’t want to do it. She was in hospital for mothers day and we went to visit her (because according to him its likely to be the last time she would see us together) with the children and she didn’t say one word to them. It was unbearably awkward and my poor kids didn’t know what to make of it.

So tonight, DH has arrived back from his overnight stay and has told me that we will all go to see her again on Sunday.
Ive just told him no, it’s uncomfortable for the children and for me. He can spend his entire week down with her for all I care but I just don’t want to see her.
If I hear again “this will probably be the last time she sees her grandchildren”
I’m trying not to be a heartless bitch here but it’s hard when he’s now stormed into the other room and is watching her on a monitor that he has set up in her house.

AIBU by refusing to go visit when quite frankly I feel nothing for the woman

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LittleWeed2 · 31/03/2024 08:49

I don’t know as in life my dying DB was much keener to see his DB even than his DC -he’d never had a good relationship with them -possibly because our DF was a poor father.
All this rushing to the deathbed - I don’t agree really -I’d want to seethe ones I actually care about - not all the rest

Janiie · 31/03/2024 08:28

'I'm sure my DH would love to be married to one of the many responders who feel that I'm simply not doing enough for him while he races to make up for time that he never spent with his mother. If I were to drop dead in the morning I'd be confident that DH would have to think about where the kids even go to school or where their uniforms are. After all, that's my job.'

No one has said 'you aren't doing enough', your op was did you have to visit dying mil and must you take your kids who find the whole thing a bit boring. Yes, you do.

The rest of your post about school and school uniforms is bizarre. Clearly bit of a martyrdom complex going on. It may well be justified but it obviously needs addressing at some point.

Do you actually want to be with your dh?

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 30/03/2024 20:45

Well done OP for reflecting and taking constructive comments on board.

You're in a tough situation but it's not a competition.
Hopefully you can be there for each other on ways you both need according to your strengths.

A lot of posters come on here to be validated and won't take on any advice.
It's hard to Sew clearly when you're deep in the situation but glad you managed to get the good out of this post.

Ivymom · 30/03/2024 19:43

OP, you are in an impossibly difficult situation. I wish I could offer in person support and comforting. I’ve been in a similar situation to you, so I can understand how you may be feeling. I’m especially sorry that your DH is handling things so poorly and doesn’t seem to be able to offer you the same support he is demanding from you. I’m sorry you are facing poor treatment from his relatives and I hope that you and he can get couple’s counseling to work out how you can both support each other.

For decades, my in-laws have treated me abominably. They’ve insulted me, ignored me and tried to convince my DH to divorce me. Some even made up stories about me being abusive to DH and our children and then tried to convince my DH they were true. They’ve made no effort to get to know our children and when we would visit from thousands of miles away, wouldn’t make time for us. Because of this, and some personal stuff related to my DH’s upbringing, we have had a very limited relationship with them over the years.

A few years ago my FIL received a terminal diagnosis. While my DH felt terrible about the state of the relationship and missed time with him, unlike OP’s DH, he understood why and didn’t make it my problem. Like the OP, I maintained our business and ran our household while my DH flew to spend time with his dad. However, my DH understood why I continued to have boundaries with the in-laws for myself and our children.

I’m a former hospice nurse. I told my DH that I was willing for myself and our children to travel so I could be his dad’s carer, but I had some strict boundaries surrounding that. First and foremost, I would be doing it for my DH and not any of the in-laws and as such, I wouldn’t answer to or put up with anything from any of them. We would have to rent an AirBnB as the children and I wouldn’t share a home with the in-laws. Our children would also not be expected to interact with any of the in-laws without us present (this is already a boundary around visits and wouldn’t be lifted just because FIL was dying). Our children would also not be expected to entertain or cheer up any of the in-laws.

My DH understood that by managing the business and home, I was supporting him. My boundaries around my children and myself visiting or helping the in-laws directly was a result of the in-laws’ behavior and treatment of me and our children over the years. He also understood that a sick, dying or grieving jerk is still a jerk. He doesn’t resent me for my boundaries, but he hates that they were necessary. Any regrets he has are his to manage. We made the decision that he travel alone for visits and ultimately he went to FIL’s funeral alone. It was what was best for our nuclear family, as hard as it was for my DH.

LiveLaughCryalot · 30/03/2024 18:29

RiderofRohan · 30/03/2024 17:19

I've never said the OP needs no support. You seem unable to stop making things up, from this to the OP's father actively dying. You clearly read a sentence and turn it into a whole tale in your head.

Actually, I thought you were comparing the life expectancies of both illnesses to say that's why the OP didn't need support. That's why I pointed out my experience. The 'official' life expectancy of an illness means so little because every person is different.
Again, I assumed you were saying the OP didn't need any support because of this. Apologies.

Fargo79 · 30/03/2024 18:26

CliantheLang · 30/03/2024 17:52

I think OP is unreasonable too, and should be going to support her DH.

While 'DH' does absolutely nothing to support the OP.
And it's said patriarchy doesn't exist...

ODFOD. I'm not doing the work of the patriarchy 🙄 If only you knew what an idiotic accusation that was. I didn't actually make any comment on DH's behaviour, so you've leapt to a conclusion there. I didn't see OP's dripfeed update about her husband being unsupportive and not taking responsibility for his children, which obviously makes him a shit partner. However it also doesn't change my opinion that a married person should be supporting their spouse when they are going through extremely hard times, like bereavement. Refusing to support a grieving spouse is also shit. Not as shit as opting permanently out of being a present husband/father, but still shit.

CliantheLang · 30/03/2024 17:52

I think OP is unreasonable too, and should be going to support her DH.

While 'DH' does absolutely nothing to support the OP.
And it's said patriarchy doesn't exist...

Fargo79 · 30/03/2024 17:38

JMSA · 30/03/2024 17:31

YABU. If it's awkward between her and your children, then it's probably because you have done nothing to foster a relationship over the years.
And I can't imagine being this cold towards a dying woman.

I think OP is unreasonable too, and should be going to support her DH. However, why on earth is it her job to "foster" a relationship between her MIL and her children? That's 100% down to MIL and DH. Absolutely nothing to do with OP at all and not her responsibility. I would also stake my house on the fact that you wouldn't consider it DH's job to create a bond between OP's mum and the children.

JMSA · 30/03/2024 17:31

YABU. If it's awkward between her and your children, then it's probably because you have done nothing to foster a relationship over the years.
And I can't imagine being this cold towards a dying woman.

Saintmariesleuth · 30/03/2024 17:28

I'm sorry that you're in such a difficult and stressful situation OP.

I hope you can drop as much 'unnecessary' stuff from your plate to take the burden off you a bit right now. Is there anyone else in the business that you trust to step up and take on some tasks that you or DH normally oversee in the business?

Do you have a friend that might be willing to watch your kids whilst you visit MIL? I'd certainly do this for a friend in your situation

You have been very generous in the way you have spoken to your DH. I think after this upcoming visit you need to speak to him again to devise a plan on how you can support each other and a fair way of dividing the load. I think you are going to have to spell out to him (you shouldn't have to, but your DH is very wrapped up in his problems right now and is unlikely to realise this on his own) 'my father is dying too, and I can no longer handle all this alone- we need to figure out something else at this point but I cannot continue as we are. Do you have any suggestions?/ my suggestion is that we.....

RiderofRohan · 30/03/2024 17:19

LiveLaughCryalot · 30/03/2024 14:20

Again and for the final time because I know you won't answer. Why, with everything the OP has on her plate, do you think the OP needs LESS support than her husband?
It's your assumptions that are irrelevant, I have known, and nursed people through end stage liver failure that have lived a matter of weeks and months. I supported my best friend through stage 4 bowel cancer who passed away 8 awful months after diagnosis. You say yourself we have no idea and are just making assumptions. So why are you so determined that the OP needs no support?

Edited

I've never said the OP needs no support. You seem unable to stop making things up, from this to the OP's father actively dying. You clearly read a sentence and turn it into a whole tale in your head.

M1Holly · 30/03/2024 17:17

M1Holly · 30/03/2024 17:12

Yes. He should. This applies equally to him. I don't know whether his mother's death is more imminent or her illness more serious but everything else being equal (more personal guilt about being a crap child doesn't count) they should absolutely both be supporting each other and not one dumping on another.

The OP's question was about whether she's justified in not going to see her MIL when her husband asks purely because she doesn't care about her, essentially, and that's my opinion on that. She said she doesn't mind her DH going off to stay with MIL so assume there are some variables at play there that leads her to feel it's fair enough she's holding the fort, but if not and she's feeling resentful about running business and children, that's something to address with him, absolutely.

I don't think a tit-for-tat "you're not doing this so I won't do that" (however tempting and justified) ever leads where one hopes it will in the context of a marriage.

And I've just seen her latest updates. It sounds like she very much does need to also tell her DH what she needs from him to support her while her father is unwell and make veg clear all the things she's doing herself. If he reacts poorly to that and continues to be ungrateful after being made aware (ideally he wouldn't need to be told I appreciate) then there are bigger problems and she should continue ending the marriage. But just declining to support her DH without that conversation is a pretty surefire way to ultimately end the marriage by default.

M1Holly · 30/03/2024 17:12

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/03/2024 08:16

Shouldn’t he equally be expected to suck things up and support her?

Instead, he seems to have a free pass to disappear for days on end while OP holds down the fort at home and deals with her own dying parent.

And yet everyone is slamming the OP for being unsupportive. Fuck me - a woman’s place really is in the wrong.

Yes. He should. This applies equally to him. I don't know whether his mother's death is more imminent or her illness more serious but everything else being equal (more personal guilt about being a crap child doesn't count) they should absolutely both be supporting each other and not one dumping on another.

The OP's question was about whether she's justified in not going to see her MIL when her husband asks purely because she doesn't care about her, essentially, and that's my opinion on that. She said she doesn't mind her DH going off to stay with MIL so assume there are some variables at play there that leads her to feel it's fair enough she's holding the fort, but if not and she's feeling resentful about running business and children, that's something to address with him, absolutely.

I don't think a tit-for-tat "you're not doing this so I won't do that" (however tempting and justified) ever leads where one hopes it will in the context of a marriage.

BeckyAMumsnet · 30/03/2024 15:18

Hello, everyone. Please be sure to read the OP's later posts for further context. Do remember that there are real people behind the posts and consider if your comment is likely to cause further upset to an already difficult situation. Our Talk guidelines are here if you need a reminder. Peace and love.

Mumsnet's Talk Guidelines | Mumsnet

A guide to using Mumsnet's discussion boards (Talk), including netiquette, rules of use and how to stay on the right side of the moderating team!

https://www.mumsnet.com/i/netiquette

neverbeenskiing · 30/03/2024 15:15

Those telling OP she needs to "support her DH" must be reading a completely different thread to me. For over 3 months now OP has been doing the vast majority of parenting and running the business they share while her DH has been staying over at his Mum's several nights a week. Even on the nights he's home, he's not really present because he's watching his DM on a monitor but OP accepts that. That is support.

OP hasn't threatened to withdraw any of the above support, she hasn't even said she begrudges it. She isn't demanding her DH cut back on his overnight visits to be around more for the kids or to do his share with the business. She's actually said if he wants to spend even more time with his Mum she'll facilitate it! She has visited her MIL in hospital and taken the DC along, although they and she found it uncomfortable, because that's what her DH wanted. The only thing she doesn't want to do is to keep dragging the DC back to the hospital so they can be physically present to watch her MIL die. The children don't want this either, which is understandable, because they have no relationship with MIL and that's not on OP. She is not responsible for assuaging her DH's guilt or regrets about not spending enough time with his DM over the years, and the DC certainly aren’t.

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/03/2024 15:08

Janiie · 30/03/2024 14:59

Well yes but this current sad situation seems the last straw rather than the cause of all the angst.

I suspect you're right. If her DH's behaviour now is any indication of what he's normally like, then I reckon the resentment has been bubbling for a while now.

It sounds awful.

chocolategg · 30/03/2024 15:05

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/03/2024 14:52

The part about her father was a nice drip feed 8 posts in. It often happens when the OP finds the responses aren't what they wanted.

And? So what. It's her life. It's not a drip feed. I think everyone should assume people have other stuff going on in their own lives.

Janiie · 30/03/2024 14:59

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/03/2024 14:22

From her updates, I'm not surprised she's bitter and resentful lol.

Well yes but this current sad situation seems the last straw rather than the cause of all the angst.

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/03/2024 14:58

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/03/2024 14:52

The part about her father was a nice drip feed 8 posts in. It often happens when the OP finds the responses aren't what they wanted.

It was clear from the opening post that there were underlying issues going on, but as usual, everyone was quick to stick the boot in and kick someone who was quite clearly struggling with their marriage and relationship with their MIL.

The fact that you're accusing OP of lying about her own dying father says way more about you than any of OP's posts say about her.

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/03/2024 14:52

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/03/2024 14:41

Really?

Even though she's been left at home to run their joint business and care for their joint children with absolutely no help or support from him while he rushes off to appease his guilt?

The part about her father was a nice drip feed 8 posts in. It often happens when the OP finds the responses aren't what they wanted.

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/03/2024 14:41

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/03/2024 14:38

Which makes the attitude even more confusing to me.

Really?

Even though she's been left at home to run their joint business and care for their joint children with absolutely no help or support from him while he rushes off to appease his guilt?

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/03/2024 14:38

fieldsofbutterflies · 30/03/2024 14:27

OP's dad is dying too.

Which makes the attitude even more confusing to me.

Willyoujustbequiet · 30/03/2024 14:36

LookItsMeAgain · 30/03/2024 14:26

Did you miss the post by the OP where she stated clearly and in plain language this:
"my own dad has end stage liver failure so I do understand what it’s like to face the potential loss of a parent. He calls my kids on the phone as he doesn’t want them to see him looking so unwell and in the poor man’s defence he does his best to sound upbeat.

I also don’t expect my DH to visit him nor would I ask him to. My sister and I visit (he’s in hospital) most evenings for an hour or so."

Do you still believe her attitude to be shocking???

Yes. I wouldn’t have said it otherwise.

LookItsMeAgain · 30/03/2024 14:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

The OP's father is dying too.

Which grandparent or parent takes priority here???
"Are you normal?" Who the actual fuck asks a question like that??
The OP is tending to her dying father, looking after the children, keeping the household and managing to keep a business going. That's not normal. That's superhuman!

Have some empathy for a situation that you should hope you never find yourself in!

SerafinasGoose · 30/03/2024 14:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Be careful about wishing such gratuitous ill on others. Or you could, of course, have chosen to direct this same spiteful invective toward the OP's husband's attitude toward her and her dying father.

No? How surprising. The question is, why not?

The answer, unfortunately, is fairly transparent.