Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you actually *can* be a bit...

110 replies

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 10:47

Autistic
OCD
ADHD

and a whole load of others?

I know people will often (angrily) declare that you can't be 'a bit' autistic, OCD etc, they're very serious diagnoses, you either are or you aren't etc etc.

However

The diagnostic criteria are made up of lists of indicators. You fulfil a certain number of these, you get the diagnosis.

So if the diagnosis is based on fulfilling, say, 25 of the criteria, and you fulfil 20, would it not be fair enough to say you are 'more' autistic that someone who fulfils 5?

Is it not the nature of all spectrums, that everyone must fall somewhere on them?**

OP posts:
gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:17

I find it interesting that people get so wound up about this issue.

If I had a very severely autistic child, non-verbal etc, then yes, I would be very annoyed by NT people saying they're 'a bit autistic'

However, I'd also be annoyed about people with 'an official diagnosis' but yet not particularly severely affected (e.g didn't even realise till they were 40) going on about their difficulties and generally claiming to be on the same bus, just because they had their 'official' diagnosis.

OP posts:
thatsnotacactus · 29/03/2024 11:15

Not for all the conditions mentioned above, but with ASD or ADHD, if diagnosis is made on say scoring 50 on a diagnostic test and you score 49, your lived experience is likely to be more similar to that of someone who scored 51 and got a diagnosis than it is people who scored 20 or below.

There are probably a lot of people who live in a sort of grey area where they don't feel like "normal" humans and don't fit in with various expectations but wouldn't necessarily meet criteria for a diagnosis.

CarrotCake01 · 29/03/2024 11:12

It irks me when people say they're a bit OCD or whatever when what they really mean is that they like things neat and tidy or like patterns and structure. It's definitely not the same thing and I think quite offensive to genuine sufferers.

However I do think there are spectrums with certain things. My ex and 2 of his siblings all have autism in varying degrees. He has mild autism, it effects him during his day to day life but you wouldn't necessarily know by meeting him that he's autistic. His little brother on the other hand has autism that is much more severe on the scale, to the point where a stranger would pick up on it almost immediately, and it effects his life in a much bigger way.
It's the same diagnosis, it's still autism, but there is a sliding scale of severity for sure.

That's different to random people who DON'T have the disorder saying they identify with the disorder because they have a couple of the traits. Sometimes people just have personalities and preferences and anxieties without it having to be linked to disorders.

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:12
  • Which is either officially assessed and diagnosed, or not.

Fuck, give me strength.*😂

Ok!

That 'official' assessment and diagnosis is still just a series of diagnostic criteria though. It's not a genetic test, with a binary 'you have it or you don't'.

OP posts:
MurderousCheekbones · 29/03/2024 11:11

Not sure what you mean @AgnesX but the autistic spectrum is the spectrum of people with autistic traits. It's not the spectrum of all humanity.

Brainded · 29/03/2024 11:10

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:02

That's the thing though, surely you actually can have a bit of a disorder?

To use the alcoholic example someone used

You can need three glasses of wine every night and get very anxious if you can't

You can also drink 2 bottles vodka a day and be completely incapable of looking after yourself

Probably both alcoholic, one probably a 'bit more alcoholic'

Which is shorthand for more 'more adversely affected by the condition'

But being an alcoholic isn’t just about the amount of alcohol you consume @gringlewalden it’s the behaviours and attitudes that go with it.

vanillawaffle · 29/03/2024 11:10

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:08

I think people are getting hung up on this one because of the grammatical issue

No, you can't 'be' a bit OCD, but you can be a bit obsessive compulsive (I.e have some of the traits)

You can't 'be' a bit ASD, but you can br a bit autistic (have some of the traits)

It's all the same point. Everyone seems to want to establish a very clear binary - you are or you ARE NOT, get off our turf! - when in reality it makes sense that there are people who hover around the boundary for diagnosis.

Oh right OK sorry I do read things quite literally.

RainbowZebraWarrior · 29/03/2024 11:10

Nice first post, or name change btw

Willmafrockfit · 29/03/2024 11:10

plenty of people now seem to want a number, a grade, for their diagnosis, where they are on the scale does this come from america?

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:08

vanillawaffle · 29/03/2024 10:52

You can't be "a bit obsessive compulsive disorder" that doesn't make sense

I think people are getting hung up on this one because of the grammatical issue

No, you can't 'be' a bit OCD, but you can be a bit obsessive compulsive (I.e have some of the traits)

You can't 'be' a bit ASD, but you can br a bit autistic (have some of the traits)

It's all the same point. Everyone seems to want to establish a very clear binary - you are or you ARE NOT, get off our turf! - when in reality it makes sense that there are people who hover around the boundary for diagnosis.

OP posts:
Willmafrockfit · 29/03/2024 11:08

well autism is a spectrum
previously it was severe autism, or rather non verbal autism

RainbowZebraWarrior · 29/03/2024 11:08

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:02

That's the thing though, surely you actually can have a bit of a disorder?

To use the alcoholic example someone used

You can need three glasses of wine every night and get very anxious if you can't

You can also drink 2 bottles vodka a day and be completely incapable of looking after yourself

Probably both alcoholic, one probably a 'bit more alcoholic'

Which is shorthand for more 'more adversely affected by the condition'

You are talking about severity, there.

Not 'a bit of a disorder'

Which is either officially assessed and diagnosed, or not.

Fuck, give me strength.

Spendonsend · 29/03/2024 11:07

No, i dont think you can be a little bit autistic because the spectrum in autism doesnt mean gradient of mild to severe.

It means there are a variety in the type of symptoms. But the symptoms have to be across the 'triad' of impairments and have to limit and impair daily function.

KalaMush · 29/03/2024 11:04

People misunderstand the word "spectrum" in autism to think that it is a spectrum from "less autistic" to "more autistic". It's actually a spectrum of the areas in which you are affected (sensory, motor skills, language etc).

SpongeBob2022 · 29/03/2024 11:04

Am only really commenting on OCD.

The phrase 'I'm a bit OCD" doesn't really make 'proper' sense. I think the spirit in which it's used can be true though. I have traits of OCD now and definitely did as a teenager, compared with people who I know who don't have these at all. I dont feel that strongly about it but personally I wouldn't use the term as I think it trivialises how completely debilitating it can be for some people.

OkPedro · 29/03/2024 11:03

Malibu12 · 29/03/2024 10:58

YABU

OCD for example...yes most people have obsessions and compulsions and intrusive thoughts, but what makes these things a disorder (the D bit of OCD) is when these things become completely debilitating.
So whilst you may have obsessions and compulsions, you most certainly don't have OCD or 'a bit of OCD'.

Do most people have obsessions, compulsions and intrusive thoughts??
I have ptsd from childhood trauma so I do have obsessions and intrusive thoughts. I find it hard to believe "most" people have these things though

CloverOrwell · 29/03/2024 11:03

I think you can have some of the traits that are part of autism, OCD, ADHD etc. but having those traits doesn’t make you ‘a little bit autistic’. It means you have some traits.

I have autism and OCD and for autism, the spectrum isn’t a linear one, and I do not believe that everyone falls on to it. My parents have some similar traits to me. It doesn’t make them autistic, though, because they don’t meet the criteria for diagnosis.

Similarly, I have some traits often associated with an eating disorder, but I don’t have an eating disorder.

It annoys me much more when people say they are ‘a bit OCD’, possibly because it’s very common to say this. Lives are taken over and destroyed by OCD and the associated compulsions, intrusive thoughts, etc. You don’t have it if your only symptom is liking lines on your carpet and the kitchen to be spotless all the time. This means you are a tidy, clean person! It’s insulting to compare this to the trauma of OCD.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 29/03/2024 11:03

Me and my best friend were told we were eccentric in our 20s. She actually had a drink problem and was either schizophrenic or bipolar. But both didn’t come out for a few years.

TyneTeas · 29/03/2024 11:02

The spectrum doesn't mean a spectrum of everyone from neuro typical to neuro diverse, it is a spectrum of autism, neuro diversity, so you are only part of the spectrum if you are ND

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:02

PandaCwtch · 29/03/2024 10:58

Although autism and AD(H)D are often described as being on a spectrum, OCD definitely isn't. It's obsessive compulsive disorder. The subject of people's obsessive thoughts or compulsive behaviours will vary, but it is classed as an illness. The diagnosis is based on the fact that the uncontrollable compulsion (the behaviour - such as cleaning, counting things etc.) takes a significant proportion of time, and that doing it is resulting from obsessive thoughts. You either have the disorder or not. You can't be OCD, you have OCD. And you can't have a bit of a disorder.

That's the thing though, surely you actually can have a bit of a disorder?

To use the alcoholic example someone used

You can need three glasses of wine every night and get very anxious if you can't

You can also drink 2 bottles vodka a day and be completely incapable of looking after yourself

Probably both alcoholic, one probably a 'bit more alcoholic'

Which is shorthand for more 'more adversely affected by the condition'

OP posts:
AgnesX · 29/03/2024 11:01

MurderousCheekbones · 29/03/2024 10:49

Well it's a spectrum but no, not everyone is on it.

So people are just rude or bloody minded, difficult or awkward as that's what people are as a species?

Discuss....

PullUpTheDrawbridge · 29/03/2024 11:00

It's not linear, it's more like a wheel. You can recognise traits but unless most of your spokes are affected so the whole wheel works differently in you'll still be driving relatively easily.

vanillawaffle · 29/03/2024 11:00

You could have "well managed OCD" but no you can't be "a bit ocd"

Leonarda89 · 29/03/2024 11:00

I think it's a very complex issue. On one hand you can have traits but not meet full criteria, and there is an issue where people who fall just outside the criteria but still have some difficulties then can't access supports (i would say this is more a problem with the medical model and diagnosis based support system) but on the other hand to meet criteria you have to have impairment, and I think it's difficult for people who are impaired when people who aren't either talk about it as if they are in the same position, or fill up waiting lists for assessment/treatment just because they feel they are a bit "quirky" and want to know out of interest. I think the OCD one is particularly difficult as people really don't understand it, people who are just very clean/like cleaning think that is OCD but it's not at all, OCD is one of the most distressing and impairing disorders there is and is often not related to cleanliness at all.

PandaCwtch · 29/03/2024 10:58

Although autism and AD(H)D are often described as being on a spectrum, OCD definitely isn't. It's obsessive compulsive disorder. The subject of people's obsessive thoughts or compulsive behaviours will vary, but it is classed as an illness. The diagnosis is based on the fact that the uncontrollable compulsion (the behaviour - such as cleaning, counting things etc.) takes a significant proportion of time, and that doing it is resulting from obsessive thoughts. You either have the disorder or not. You can't be OCD, you have OCD. And you can't have a bit of a disorder.

Swipe left for the next trending thread