Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you actually *can* be a bit...

110 replies

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 10:47

Autistic
OCD
ADHD

and a whole load of others?

I know people will often (angrily) declare that you can't be 'a bit' autistic, OCD etc, they're very serious diagnoses, you either are or you aren't etc etc.

However

The diagnostic criteria are made up of lists of indicators. You fulfil a certain number of these, you get the diagnosis.

So if the diagnosis is based on fulfilling, say, 25 of the criteria, and you fulfil 20, would it not be fair enough to say you are 'more' autistic that someone who fulfils 5?

Is it not the nature of all spectrums, that everyone must fall somewhere on them?**

OP posts:
EmotionalSupportAutie · 29/03/2024 11:38

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:34

I'm sure this is all true and valid.

No one's denying your life is hard.

But I'd dispute the fact that it's as hard as someone's whose autism means they can't live independently.

Which is my whole point. There are degrees.

Also, 'you don't know what you're talking about' is what people always say on these threads, but no one's said a single thing that actually contradicts my original point.

Asking again. Are you autistic? Speaking over someone's lived experience is so incredibly offensive just because they don't present like somebody else's autistic child. People like you and opinions like this are so ableist and why society can be so disabling.

ManchesterLu · 29/03/2024 11:36

A lot of people do use terms incorrectly (particularly when it comes to things like OCD) but on the whole, yes, most neurodiversity is on a spectrum that we're all on.

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:35

SpeedyDrama · 29/03/2024 11:34

People who say ‘you can be a little bit autistic’ have no idea what autism actually is. If someone was registered blind or deaf you wouldn’t have fuckwits going ‘ah but are you a little bit blind/deaf or you know… that kind of blind/deaf. Cos my mate John wears glasses/needs the subtitles on his telly and he doesn’t feel the need to have a ‘label’’…

Terrible example.

Of course you can be a little bit deaf. You probably wouldn't whinge about it to someone who was profoundly deaf but you can still be it.

OP posts:
AntonFeckoff · 29/03/2024 11:35

maudelovesharold · 29/03/2024 11:33

Genuine question - are there people who wouldn’t be bothered by the above examples? I know I would be. In my mind’s eye, I’m already reaching for the upside down book!

Exactly. If it wasn't normal to feel that way, humans wouldn't bother doing anything neatly or orderly. It's why the dewey decimal system exists, why we have things in alphabetical order etc.

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:34

Caluse · 29/03/2024 11:29

Also, the idea that there are different functioning levels with people being less or more autistic is a neurotypical creation.

Generally, what is meant by somebody being low functioning is they don't cause neurotypical people many issues, but that doesn't mean that we don't have issues. It just means that we are hiding them and masking and struggling at home and feeling suicidal inside but not telling anyone about that because nobody wants to listen.

You cannot tell how well somebody functions just by looking at them because you do not know their reality.

You might see me speaking at a conference and scoff at the idea that I have any issues but you aren't seeing me hiding away in a quiet room in the lunch break so I can try and recalibrate and you won't seeing me taking the next 2 days staying in the house quietly so I can recover and struggling to manage day to day activities.

I'm sure this is all true and valid.

No one's denying your life is hard.

But I'd dispute the fact that it's as hard as someone's whose autism means they can't live independently.

Which is my whole point. There are degrees.

Also, 'you don't know what you're talking about' is what people always say on these threads, but no one's said a single thing that actually contradicts my original point.

OP posts:
SpeedyDrama · 29/03/2024 11:34

People who say ‘you can be a little bit autistic’ have no idea what autism actually is. If someone was registered blind or deaf you wouldn’t have fuckwits going ‘ah but are you a little bit blind/deaf or you know… that kind of blind/deaf. Cos my mate John wears glasses/needs the subtitles on his telly and he doesn’t feel the need to have a ‘label’’…

INeedAnotherName · 29/03/2024 11:34

It irks me when people say they're a bit OCD or whatever when what they really mean is that they like things neat and tidy or like patterns and structure. It's definitely not the same thing and I think quite offensive to genuine sufferers.

Agreed it's not the same thing but I assume it's used as a form of shorthand that everyone universally understands. What do you think should be used as shorthand even if only for your examples?

I agree with you OP. If it was based on one or two traits then it would be obvious you are either in or out, but when there are multiple traits it's a lot harder to say you are, or you aren't.

maudelovesharold · 29/03/2024 11:33

CarrotCake01 · 29/03/2024 11:23

Being bothered by...

Having all the felt tip pens packed away in a coherent sliding colour scale but with the red and pale green swapped over.

Having all the books in a box set the right way up except one upside book.

Seeing a pattern of tiles in a wall or a floor but there's one odd one of a different colour in the pattern.

These are all examples I've seen before of people who are perfectly fine but they're a bit ocd because they're uncomfortable with the above.

Genuine question - are there people who wouldn’t be bothered by the above examples? I know I would be. In my mind’s eye, I’m already reaching for the upside down book!

AntonFeckoff · 29/03/2024 11:30

CarrotCake01 · 29/03/2024 11:23

Being bothered by...

Having all the felt tip pens packed away in a coherent sliding colour scale but with the red and pale green swapped over.

Having all the books in a box set the right way up except one upside book.

Seeing a pattern of tiles in a wall or a floor but there's one odd one of a different colour in the pattern.

These are all examples I've seen before of people who are perfectly fine but they're a bit ocd because they're uncomfortable with the above.

But OCD isn't about 'being bothered by' or 'uncomfortable'.

It's distress, often severe, that continues until a ritual is carried out.

What you're describing is perfectionism, or liking things a particular way.

EmotionalSupportAutie · 29/03/2024 11:30

@gringlewalden are you ND or autistic?
I am an autistic adult with relatively low support needs in my day to day life. I am one of those people who 'angrily' declares we are not all a little bit autistic much like we aren't all a little bit pregnant. It is exhausting to have my lived experience and voice talked over by NT people who may have some traits but realistically have actually no idea how disabling being autistic can be.

Rudolftheorange · 29/03/2024 11:29

I’m reserving judgement about this. I have an autistic child and there is evidence emerging that their brains do function differently. If that is the case it may genuinely be a binary thing. On the other hand personality traits which result in a diagnosis are obviously a matter of degree. You could have qualities short of the threshold and have similarities.
So for now, I’m waiting to see what neuroscience teaches us.

LunaNorth · 29/03/2024 11:29

I work with autistic teenagers, and some are fond of saying ‘I have a touch of the ‘tism.’

I find it refreshing that they are totally okay with it and don’t get hung up on semantics.

I have OCD, the much-debated ‘pure’ kind that manifests as intrusive thoughts. Sometimes debilitating, sometimes more under control. I don’t classify myself as as badly affected as people I know of who can barely function, but I still have it and it’s horrible and exhausting.

Willmafrockfit · 29/03/2024 11:29

you still have arthritis

Caluse · 29/03/2024 11:29

Also, the idea that there are different functioning levels with people being less or more autistic is a neurotypical creation.

Generally, what is meant by somebody being low functioning is they don't cause neurotypical people many issues, but that doesn't mean that we don't have issues. It just means that we are hiding them and masking and struggling at home and feeling suicidal inside but not telling anyone about that because nobody wants to listen.

You cannot tell how well somebody functions just by looking at them because you do not know their reality.

You might see me speaking at a conference and scoff at the idea that I have any issues but you aren't seeing me hiding away in a quiet room in the lunch break so I can try and recalibrate and you won't seeing me taking the next 2 days staying in the house quietly so I can recover and struggling to manage day to day activities.

EnterFunnyNameHere · 29/03/2024 11:28

maudelovesharold · 29/03/2024 11:19

Yes and you can say I'm a bit arthritic if your hands feel stiff or a bit ocd if you like a tidy rooms or a bit cystic fibrosis if u have a chesty cough

But surely you can (for example) be a bit arthritic? Arthritis can make your joints a bit swollen and painful but manageable, or it can mean that you can hardly move.

Edited to add quote.

Edited

What you're describing is the difference between having mild arthritis and more severe arthritis though - not having a bit of a sore wrist for some unrelated reason and saying "oh I'm a bit arthritic".

Caluse · 29/03/2024 11:26

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:17

I find it interesting that people get so wound up about this issue.

If I had a very severely autistic child, non-verbal etc, then yes, I would be very annoyed by NT people saying they're 'a bit autistic'

However, I'd also be annoyed about people with 'an official diagnosis' but yet not particularly severely affected (e.g didn't even realise till they were 40) going on about their difficulties and generally claiming to be on the same bus, just because they had their 'official' diagnosis.

This post shows how little you know what you're talking about. I am one of those people who was diagnosed late in life and from the outside you would probably say you don't think I'm autistic at all, but my life has been really really difficult because of being autistic and particularly because of being undiagnosed, and it has been absolutely life changing to be diagnosed in my 40s and to understand myself and to be able to ask for the accommodation that I need in order to help me function better in a neurotypical society.

Your whole thread feels very goady because you really don't know what you're talking about and you're making that clearer and clearer with every comment you make. You would be better off going away and learning from neurodivergent people what it is like to be us rather than making assertions that everybody can be a bit autistic when they really can't, and aren't, and have no idea what it's like to live our lives.

IncompleteSenten · 29/03/2024 11:24

You either have a condition or you don't.
If you don't then you don't.

If you do then you may have more or fewer challenges or be affected in different ways.

almostspring2024 · 29/03/2024 11:23

IME the people I hear who describe themselves as 'a bit' OCD are solely anal personalities. I've worked with people with true OCD and it was so, so disabling
The people who describe themselves as 'a bit' ADHD often have something similar to a personality disorder ? EUPD
Having had children who were neuro typical and now having a GS who lives with Autism ( high functioning) I am adamant there is such a huge difference in the way they are that there could be no 'a bit' Autistic.
Some years ago EUPD was discussed here much more, now it's so many posters declaring they have ASD or ADHD without a diagnosis

EnterFunnyNameHere · 29/03/2024 11:23

But having some of traits of OCD isn't the same thing as having enough traits to have a formal diagnosis. And having a diagnosis isn't about semantics, it's about getting support. So how does someone with some OCD traits benefit from saying they're "a little bit OCD"? They don't, maybe it makes them feel special to label themselves? How does them saying it damage people with diagnosed OCD? Well it massively downplays the significance of how OCD can totally fuck up your life, make it look like the support OCD sufferers seek isn't really warranted etc. So it's harmful basically.

We all have cells in our body that are constantly mutating but I don't have "a little bit cancer". When I had a chesty cough I didn't have "a little bit cystic fibrosis". In both cases I share some minor traits but they don't adversely affect my life or outcomes to a significant degree. So I'd be pretty stupid to compare my relatively trivial ailments to people with a formal diagnosis, wouldn't I?

It's like the medical equipment of "all lives matter". Yes, all lives do matter but let's focus on the consistently and significantly fucked over groups first, eh? Yeah maybe you do share some traits with someone with an autism diagnosis, but maybe rather than try and claim part of that label for yourself to no real benefit for anyone, leave it for the people who need it to try and get the support they need to live.

InterIgnis · 29/03/2024 11:23

You can, and most people do, exhibit traits of multiple disorders. That’s a huge reason as to why personality disorders for example are so hard to diagnose - because all the symptoms are traits found in entirely normal personalities. What differentiates between normal and abnormal is the severity of the traits, which ones occur together, and the interplay between them.

It goes without saying that having a specific trait is very different from having a disorder, but ‘a bit…’ is just shorthand for having the trait.

CarrotCake01 · 29/03/2024 11:23

AntonFeckoff · 29/03/2024 11:19

Can someone give an example of what 'a bit OCD' looks like in practice please?

Being bothered by...

Having all the felt tip pens packed away in a coherent sliding colour scale but with the red and pale green swapped over.

Having all the books in a box set the right way up except one upside book.

Seeing a pattern of tiles in a wall or a floor but there's one odd one of a different colour in the pattern.

These are all examples I've seen before of people who are perfectly fine but they're a bit ocd because they're uncomfortable with the above.

AntonFeckoff · 29/03/2024 11:19

Can someone give an example of what 'a bit OCD' looks like in practice please?

maudelovesharold · 29/03/2024 11:19

Yes and you can say I'm a bit arthritic if your hands feel stiff or a bit ocd if you like a tidy rooms or a bit cystic fibrosis if u have a chesty cough

But surely you can (for example) be a bit arthritic? Arthritis can make your joints a bit swollen and painful but manageable, or it can mean that you can hardly move.

Edited to add quote.

NerdyIsMyMiddleName · 29/03/2024 11:18

It's a dick move because it simplifies the significance of suffering people go through. It normalises it which implies people with those conditions should get on with it because people without those conditions manage

^^ yes, this! Having parented two kids, both with ASD and ADHD plus a load of other co-morbids who were diagnosed at the start of primary school, I can safely say a lot of people who are 'a little autistic' just have no idea how bad it can get.

Yes, I understand they're trying to empathise sometimes, but it's like someone having a bad day trying to empathise with someone with long term clinical depression. Just don't.

veryawkwardohno · 29/03/2024 11:17

No you can't because to be autistic by definition is to meet all the diagnostic criteria. That's what autism is, so you either meet the criteria or you don't.
all people are different, all people have difficulties and quirks and some people will have some in common with autistic people but that doesn't make them a bit autistic it just makes them a human person.
Being a bit ocd doesn't even make sense. You can have I suppose mild or severe ocd but again you either have it or you don't. I do and sometimes it's severe and other times not but it's always ocd.
usually people who say they have a "bit" of adhd/autism/ocd only mean the quirky stuff, it doesnt ever seem to have any significant negative impact on their life and they are talking shit to make themselves feel special

Swipe left for the next trending thread