Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you actually *can* be a bit...

110 replies

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 10:47

Autistic
OCD
ADHD

and a whole load of others?

I know people will often (angrily) declare that you can't be 'a bit' autistic, OCD etc, they're very serious diagnoses, you either are or you aren't etc etc.

However

The diagnostic criteria are made up of lists of indicators. You fulfil a certain number of these, you get the diagnosis.

So if the diagnosis is based on fulfilling, say, 25 of the criteria, and you fulfil 20, would it not be fair enough to say you are 'more' autistic that someone who fulfils 5?

Is it not the nature of all spectrums, that everyone must fall somewhere on them?**

OP posts:
skoobydoo · 29/03/2024 12:07

It's not as simple as getting 50 autism points on a scale to earn your autism badge.

The DSM threshold for an autism diagnosis is to have 'persistent deficits' in at least three area of social communication, and at least two of 4 defined types of restrictive or repetitive behaviour. There's obviously a lot of subjectivity in assessment and diagnosis, but there's descriptions and guidance that allows clinicians to assess whether the whole picture is of a person whose brain appears to function in the neurodivergent pattern we (currently) call autism.

Nobody is arguing, OP, that people can't have autistic traits. But to call this being 'a bit autistic' is offensive because it ignores that the smorgasbord of difficulties that constitute ACTUALLY being autistic are very different from having some social anxiety / sensory sensitivities / rigid ways of doing things etc.

Spendonsend · 29/03/2024 12:03

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:34

I'm sure this is all true and valid.

No one's denying your life is hard.

But I'd dispute the fact that it's as hard as someone's whose autism means they can't live independently.

Which is my whole point. There are degrees.

Also, 'you don't know what you're talking about' is what people always say on these threads, but no one's said a single thing that actually contradicts my original point.

Its not your opening point at all.

Your opening point was that people who dont meet the threshold for diagnosis could describe themselves as a little bit autistic/asd/addhd

You are now arguing that those who have met the threshold might vary in severity or variety of traits. (With the minimum threshold of limiting and impairing everyday function) Which is whats meant by the specrtum.

The debate about severity of autism for those ON the spectrum is endless and full of misunderstandings between people desperate for support. Id rathger focus on support than watch desperate people compete.

SpeedyDrama · 29/03/2024 12:02

Similarly, there are autistic individuals who are brilliant scientists, travelling the world, and leaders in their disciplines, and there are autistic individuals who will never be toilet trained. There need to be words to describe this difference which will not cause the “either you have it or not” brigade to explode.

There are words to describe the difference - high needs, low support, global delays, additional learning disabilities. But autism in itself is just that. The ‘need’ to define autism as a scale from bad to ‘not that bad’ comes from a severe lack of understanding of what the disability is, how it can fluctuate in support needs over the years and people absolutely determined to see children and adults with adequate speech and academic abilities as ‘not that autistic’.

NotTerfNorCis · 29/03/2024 12:02

It's a bit like ... having a cold. You either have a cold, or you don't. If you have a bit of a cold, then you have a cold.

Cantara · 29/03/2024 12:00

You either meet the criteria or you don't, so as many have said, no, you can't be "a bit" whatever.
You having sensory issues doesn't make you a bit autistic, it means you have sensory issues. My sensory issues amongst a plethora of other traits make me autistic.
Yes there are varying levels of severity, but those with less "severe" OCD for example, aren't a bit OCD, they have OCD which is perhaps more easily controlled or doesn't take over their life as much.
Sad that this need to be explained, really. Not being able to stand your pictures not hanging straight makes you particular about it, not a tad OCD.

AceofPentacles · 29/03/2024 11:56

I have seen on here so many times that when someone is acting like an arsehole, a poster comes along and says 'are they autistic?'

OP, do you mean this sort of thing? That person is selfish, they must be a bit autistic?

That person spends hours in the shed disassembling machinery and ignoring their kids - they must be a bit autistic.

That's what your post sounds like to me. What would be the benefit of proclaiming yourself or someone else 'a bit autistic' anyway? Just say 'oh I like to walk the same way to work every day and only eat out of a specific bowl because that's my personal preference'. Therefore not minimising or offending others with actual lived experience.

SkyBloo · 29/03/2024 11:56

We can all have many traits in common with folk diagnosed with autism.

The key is, to warrant diagnosis the traits have to be severe enough as to cause impairment, and they have to cover a triad of areas.

LegoDeathTrap · 29/03/2024 11:53

You are not unreasonable, but you will get a flaming here.

My husband has OCD. It’s well controlled and typically it just means he checks the door locks carefully and repeatedly. This does not affect his life very much (though it does affect the longevity of our doors a bit). When he’s stressed and under pressure, it flares up so he’ll check the gas, stove, oven etc repeatedly, and sometimes leave the house, turn around and go check the same things again. That affect our lives a bit more. So I’d say he has mild OCD and would strongly object to anyone forbidding me to use that language. He clearly has OCD. It’s clearly not as bad as in someone who can’t leave the house because germs.

On the other had, some people when they say “I’m a little OCD” mean “I like my salad just so”, and this is likely what the posters are who say it’s a debilitating illness and you can’t be a little OCD mean this.

Similarly, there are autistic individuals who are brilliant scientists, travelling the world, and leaders in their disciplines, and there are autistic individuals who will never be toilet trained. There need to be words to describe this difference which will not cause the “either you have it or not” brigade to explode.

AntonFeckoff · 29/03/2024 11:51

This is how my OCD presents:

If I don't do X ritual, someone I love will die.

I do these rituals constantly throughout the day. It's worse when I'm stressed, or somebody is unwell. It's not 'uncomfortable', it's extremely distressing. I can get stuck in an infinite loop of not doing the ritual 'correctly' so I have to keep doing it over and over or someone will die. However, having suffered for over 20 years, I've become very good at hiding it when I'm around other people.

To say, oh, I'm a bit OCD because it would bother me if a book was upside down is quite irritating. An actual OCD version of this would be, for example, having to turn all the books upside down and then all of the books the right way up again otherwise something bad will happen. Do you not see the difference?

Smartish · 29/03/2024 11:46

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:34

I'm sure this is all true and valid.

No one's denying your life is hard.

But I'd dispute the fact that it's as hard as someone's whose autism means they can't live independently.

Which is my whole point. There are degrees.

Also, 'you don't know what you're talking about' is what people always say on these threads, but no one's said a single thing that actually contradicts my original point.

Different people will have different challenges. Surely that’s not an impossible concept??

WhatsitWiggle · 29/03/2024 11:44

CarrotCake01 · 29/03/2024 11:23

Being bothered by...

Having all the felt tip pens packed away in a coherent sliding colour scale but with the red and pale green swapped over.

Having all the books in a box set the right way up except one upside book.

Seeing a pattern of tiles in a wall or a floor but there's one odd one of a different colour in the pattern.

These are all examples I've seen before of people who are perfectly fine but they're a bit ocd because they're uncomfortable with the above.

That's not OCD though, that's liking order.

OCD is an impending feeling of doom if things are out of order, a fear that something bad is going to happen. The obsessive nature would be going to check the boxset multiple times a day to make sure the books are facing the right way, even when it was checked 5 minutes earlier and no-one has been close to the books.

I prefer order. My knickers are folded in a particular way, and lined up in the drawer in colour order. If my ex husband had put them away, I'd take them out and redo them. That's not "a bit OCD", it's me having a strong preference for a particular system. Nothing bad will happen if my underwear is just chucked randomly into a drawer. I won't think the world is ending, I won't have a panic attack. I just prefer things my way.

My daughter is autistic. We share many similar traits but I do not struggle in the same way she does. I don't call myself "a bit autistic", because I'm not.

Tlolljs · 29/03/2024 11:44

CarrotCake01 · 29/03/2024 11:23

Being bothered by...

Having all the felt tip pens packed away in a coherent sliding colour scale but with the red and pale green swapped over.

Having all the books in a box set the right way up except one upside book.

Seeing a pattern of tiles in a wall or a floor but there's one odd one of a different colour in the pattern.

These are all examples I've seen before of people who are perfectly fine but they're a bit ocd because they're uncomfortable with the above.

I’d be uncomfortable with those three things. I don’t have intrusive thoughts around these things though. It’s like having a stone in your shoe, an irritant.

SpeedyDrama · 29/03/2024 11:44

MinervaMcGonagallsCat · 29/03/2024 11:38

It's a spectrum but not everyone can be
on the spectrum

So you can be on the milder end of the spectrum

Oh dear another person talking about ‘the spectrum’ with a huge amount of ignorance. Just another day on MN I guess.

RainbowZebraWarrior · 29/03/2024 11:44

MinervaMcGonagallsCat · 29/03/2024 11:38

It's a spectrum but not everyone can be
on the spectrum

So you can be on the milder end of the spectrum

Appreciate what you are trying to say.

There aren't any 'ends' though as it's not linear.

This is more like what the Autism 'spectrum' looks like. With different people scoring at varying degrees on each particular aspect of difficulty.

To think you actually *can* be a bit...
SpeedyDrama · 29/03/2024 11:42

ManchesterLu · 29/03/2024 11:36

A lot of people do use terms incorrectly (particularly when it comes to things like OCD) but on the whole, yes, most neurodiversity is on a spectrum that we're all on.

That every neurodivergent person is on. If you’re not ND then the autism spectrum doesn’t apply to you. Because it’s not a line from ‘very bad autism < perfectly typical and functional human’, that’s not what ‘the spectrum’ is.

OkPedro · 29/03/2024 11:42

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:02

That's the thing though, surely you actually can have a bit of a disorder?

To use the alcoholic example someone used

You can need three glasses of wine every night and get very anxious if you can't

You can also drink 2 bottles vodka a day and be completely incapable of looking after yourself

Probably both alcoholic, one probably a 'bit more alcoholic'

Which is shorthand for more 'more adversely affected by the condition'

No definitely not. You are either an alcoholic or you're not.. as another poster said, being an alcoholic isn't about how much or how often you drink. It's the effect your drinking has on your mind and body. Someone who can't not drink. Is obsessed with having a drink can't function until they've had that drink is an alcoholic. I'm a recovering alcoholic

AssignedNorthern · 29/03/2024 11:40

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:17

I find it interesting that people get so wound up about this issue.

If I had a very severely autistic child, non-verbal etc, then yes, I would be very annoyed by NT people saying they're 'a bit autistic'

However, I'd also be annoyed about people with 'an official diagnosis' but yet not particularly severely affected (e.g didn't even realise till they were 40) going on about their difficulties and generally claiming to be on the same bus, just because they had their 'official' diagnosis.

Ah I see you're just an arsehole. Sorry I wasted my time with you and your shitty thread. Have the day you deserve.

AssignedNorthern · 29/03/2024 11:38

Spendonsend · 29/03/2024 11:07

No, i dont think you can be a little bit autistic because the spectrum in autism doesnt mean gradient of mild to severe.

It means there are a variety in the type of symptoms. But the symptoms have to be across the 'triad' of impairments and have to limit and impair daily function.

This!

But some people struggle when things aren't about them so they try to relate to a condition like ASD by saying I'm a little bit like this too or we're all on the spectrum. We're not and if your little bit of whatever you think ASD is isn't impacting your life in anyway then you're really not being helpful you are actually just minimising.

SpeedyDrama · 29/03/2024 11:38

gringlewalden · 29/03/2024 11:35

Terrible example.

Of course you can be a little bit deaf. You probably wouldn't whinge about it to someone who was profoundly deaf but you can still be it.

I said registered blind/deaf, not a bit hard of hearing.

But fine, what about Downs Syndrome? Would you say someone with the mosaic variant had a lesser Downs syndrome than other variants? Again, do you actually know what autism is?

MinervaMcGonagallsCat · 29/03/2024 11:38

It's a spectrum but not everyone can be
on the spectrum

So you can be on the milder end of the spectrum

OkPedro · 29/03/2024 11:38

MurderousCheekbones · 29/03/2024 11:11

Not sure what you mean @AgnesX but the autistic spectrum is the spectrum of people with autistic traits. It's not the spectrum of all humanity.

Yes absolutely this.. people seem to think that the spectrum is a human spectrum. My sister drives me mad saying "Ah sure we're all on the spectrum" No we are not! Only those with ASD/ADHD are on the spectrum

Newtonianmechanics · 29/03/2024 11:38

I think high need and low need are much more intrinsic ways of describing people.

BandyMcBandface · 29/03/2024 11:38

But I'd dispute the fact that it's as hard as someone's whose autism means they can't live independently.

I am playing devil’s advocate here slightly, but…

from the perspective of the autistic person themselves (rather than the parent / carer), if someone can’t live independently but is having all their needs taken care of and they don’t have to worry about that, is that actually harder FOR THEM than someone who allegedly can, but actually doesn’t cope with everything they need to do?

Swipe left for the next trending thread