Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think many politicians who claim to be Christians and who say this is a Christian country really aren't Christians and would criticise the teachings of Jesus

236 replies

cakeorwine · 29/03/2024 08:36

Lee Anderson saying this is a Christian country and complaining about some councils celebrating Ramada with lights.

"But let’s turn our attention back to traditional values for a second. The last time I checked Britain is a Christian country, it is enshrined in our law. So why is it that one of the most important religious festivals in the country is not proudly celebrated in the nation’s capital? Just like Labour, the Tories also refuse to stand up for Christian values it seems. Their candidate for the Westminster constituency said the lights were to be “welcomed” before paying trivial lip service to the promotion of other religions and their holy days. Under successive Tory governments British culture, identity, and values have ebbed away, and the rate at which they are doing so seems to be rapidly increasing.
Let me be clear, this isn’t an attack on Islam or any other religion. I firmly and absolutely respect the rights of individuals to celebrate their faith, but who in the establishment is standing up for the Christian values that made our country so great and revered across the globe? Can you honestly believe that if the shoe were on the other foot, a Muslim country would decorate its capital city with Easter decorations during Ramadan?"

'UK is Christian – it's time to demand our country back' | Express Comment | Comment | Express.co.uk

Farage saying that he has stopped going to church because of what someone said

"Mr Farage said: "I won't go to my local church, I won't go. I am christened and confirmed in the Church of England, all my family on both sides have been Church of England.
"I used to believe in it, I used to attend, not every Sunday but regularly during the year, I will not go. It is hopeless, they've given up, they've surrendered."
Nigel Farage reveals why he has stopped going to church: 'It is hopeless!' | Politics | News | Express.co.uk

I firmly believe that these two, as well as other politicians who claim to be Christian and to believe in Christian values would be the first to have Jesus locked up for his views. They would not understand the story of the Good Samaritan.

I say this as someone who is not a Christian but who can see what Jesus was trying to say about helping others and particular values.

Nigel Farage says he has stopped going to church: 'It is hopeless!'

The former Ukip leader blasted the Church of England and said he no longer attends services.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/1881644/nigel-farage-church-archdeacon-anti-whiteness

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
11
Zyq · 02/04/2024 09:33

cakeorwine · 29/03/2024 08:43

When a person who claims to be Christian displays none of the values that Jesus taught, I think it can be concluded that they aren't Christian. Or weren't listening to the Christian message. Or maybe they just don't get it?

Absolutely. Some of the most ostentatiously Christian politicians fit right into this mould. Jacob Rees Mogg for one.

Laikalaika · 30/03/2024 20:27

cakeorwine · 30/03/2024 10:21

It's about following the rules of the Old Testament.
Do you believe that you have to follow the rules of the Old Testament to be a Christian?

Because there are a lot of rules in there.

As exemplified in the videos.

Unless only some of the rules need to be followed?
And if so, which ones?

You asked if Christians believe we have to continue to keep the Mosaic law under the New Covenant of salvation by grace. Here's a summary of the different opinions :

Westminster covenantalism
The mosaic covenant and the law is a covennant of grace. The new covenant is a continuation and expansion of this covenant, fulfilling it entirely. The law we now have written on our hearts by the holy spirit now is essentially the same law as they had back then.

1689 federalism
Similar view, but emphasises that the new covenant is different in substance to all previous covenants. The new covenant can be applied retrospectivly to believers before Jesus who trusted God, and was how people were saved then. The law is however still applied to believers, especially the 10 commandments.

Progressive covenantalism
The new covenant is the final fulfillment of all previous covenants, but previous covenants had tensions and conditionality that the new covenant resolves through the work of Jesus. Law especially 10 commandments should still shape the lives of believers.

New covenant theology
Similar to before, but emphasises new covenant as new, and that therefore the law does not govern Christians now, we now live under new covenant laws and the teaching of Jesus.

Dispensationalism
The mosaic covenant is a covennant of works and separate from all other biblical covenants in this way. This makes it temporary and not longer to be applied to the Christian.

BandyMcBandface · 30/03/2024 19:44

SerendipityJane · 30/03/2024 09:37

Lots of men, and women,

Hang on - there are women in the bible ?

Someone had to serve the men 🤷

cakeorwine · 30/03/2024 16:47

Mysticlines · 30/03/2024 11:04

There is no Old and New Testament God if you are a Christian. It is the same God as there is only one God.

Again, this is a basic Christian belief.

Look, you knock yourself out criticising people for not holding values that you demonstrate yourself not enacting, if you want to.

You knock yourself out criticising people for not enacting a faith. you yourself don't believe and have a stunning lack of knowledge of, if you want to.

I'm off out now.

If you had read what I said carefully, you would have read that I said that the God in the Old Testament seems very different to God in the New Testament. As if they had had anger management lessons.

In the Old Testament ,God is busy destroying towns, flooding the Earth etc.
In the New Testament, he sent his only son to die on the cross. Because he loves us so much.

Bit of a difference - considering some people believe they are the same God.

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 30/03/2024 13:41

cakeorwine · 30/03/2024 10:15

Old Testament God killed a lot of people.

I think that's clear in the Old Testament.

New Testament God didn't kill that many. Correct me if I am wrong

"Two men say they're Jesus
One of them must be wrong ..."

Bicyclethief · 30/03/2024 13:36

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/03/2024 11:09

Bicyclethief · Yesterday 15:27
Whenwillitgetwarm · Yesterday 15:04

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/mar/29/sir-jeffrey-donaldson-resigns-as-democratic-unionist-party-leader

Mega ‘Christian’
**
And.....? What is the point you are trying to make? Who said religious people don't do bad things? If he has done something bad no Christian will support him.

Don't know about that. Catholic priests who have transgressed in the most appalling ways have been supported by their institution for decades. All “Christians” far as I know.

But I guess if they seek and are granted absolution, that’s all hunky dorey.

The church cover up was appalling for sure but no Christian I know condoned any of it. What the priests did was Dispicable.

Absolution doesn't work like that. The person must acknowledge wrong, do penance and not do it again. Only God can know whether he forgives them cause only he knows if you are really sorry. Some sins are cardinal, unforgivable and these would fall under that.

And even so, the priests should have still being imprisoned for their crimes.

KeinLiebeslied54321 · 30/03/2024 11:11

Mysticlines · 30/03/2024 11:04

There is no Old and New Testament God if you are a Christian. It is the same God as there is only one God.

Again, this is a basic Christian belief.

Look, you knock yourself out criticising people for not holding values that you demonstrate yourself not enacting, if you want to.

You knock yourself out criticising people for not enacting a faith. you yourself don't believe and have a stunning lack of knowledge of, if you want to.

I'm off out now.

Xtians and some other faiths might 'think' there is only one god, most us know there were many god and goddess figures.

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/03/2024 11:09

Bicyclethief · Yesterday 15:27
Whenwillitgetwarm · Yesterday 15:04

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/mar/29/sir-jeffrey-donaldson-resigns-as-democratic-unionist-party-leader

Mega ‘Christian’
**
And.....? What is the point you are trying to make? Who said religious people don't do bad things? If he has done something bad no Christian will support him.

Don't know about that. Catholic priests who have transgressed in the most appalling ways have been supported by their institution for decades. All “Christians” far as I know.

But I guess if they seek and are granted absolution, that’s all hunky dorey.

Sir Jeffrey Donaldson resigns as DUP leader after sexual offence charges

Donaldson has stepped down after being charged over ‘allegations of a historical nature’, party says

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/mar/29/sir-jeffrey-donaldson-resigns-as-democratic-unionist-party-leader

Mysticlines · 30/03/2024 11:04

cakeorwine · 30/03/2024 10:15

Old Testament God killed a lot of people.

I think that's clear in the Old Testament.

New Testament God didn't kill that many. Correct me if I am wrong

There is no Old and New Testament God if you are a Christian. It is the same God as there is only one God.

Again, this is a basic Christian belief.

Look, you knock yourself out criticising people for not holding values that you demonstrate yourself not enacting, if you want to.

You knock yourself out criticising people for not enacting a faith. you yourself don't believe and have a stunning lack of knowledge of, if you want to.

I'm off out now.

Delawear · 30/03/2024 10:50

The New Testament is version 2.0 - an update to the laws and teachings of the Old Testament.

There is not full agreement on how the bible should be interpreted as a manual for living life. This is unsurprising, as people approach it from different cultural backgrounds and the original writing was not in English. Translations, even if done skilfully, can lose some of the subtle meanings or create unintended changes.

But some peoples’ Christianity is not well grounded in the bible. I once held an unpleasant church man to account who was bullying a homeless man. He did not even recognise the famous quote I cited as being from the bible! Christians are called to defend the weak and hold one another to account, absolutely.

bozzabollix · 30/03/2024 10:43

Yep you’re correct.

If I were God I’d bring down lightning and have the couple of bastards, then send them downwards.

Mysticlines · 30/03/2024 10:40

cakeorwine · 30/03/2024 10:31

I find your posts to show an unedifying combination of arrogance and ignorance OP

Because Farage and Anderson are hypocrites who would be the first to call for Jesus to be locked up?

Making stuff up and then condemning people for the stuff you have made up about them is never a good way to argue.

You are really not very ' let he who is without sin cast the first stone' are you?

Mysticlines · 30/03/2024 10:36

cakeorwine · 30/03/2024 10:21

It's about following the rules of the Old Testament.
Do you believe that you have to follow the rules of the Old Testament to be a Christian?

Because there are a lot of rules in there.

As exemplified in the videos.

Unless only some of the rules need to be followed?
And if so, which ones?

Look, the Old Testament is part of the Bible, do you deny that? Being part of the bible, it still has authority for Christians and lectures and sermons are still given around its books and the values and theology within it. Its taught at theological colleges that train ministers.

There are a lot of rules in the OT, , different Christians churches follow different rules in the OT. You can look this up for yourself if you are interested.

As I said, there are passages in the NT relieving Christians of following some rules. You can look those up too, if you like.

Popular tv shows are just that. There are not source materials to evidence your understanding of Christianity.

Bicyclethief · 30/03/2024 10:32

Mysticlines
You are definitely trolling.

It's about following the rules of the Old Testament.
Do you believe that you have to follow the rules of the Old Testament to be a Christian?

Because there are a lot of rules in there.

As exemplified in the videos.

Unless only some of the rules need to be followed?
And if so, which ones?

Because Jesus came with a new covenant. He came to save the people of God who had strayed. He told us what was important to save our souls. Keep the commandments, no need for sacrifes ( he is the eternal sacrificial lamb) to love your neighbour etc. show us the way. He reset the rules.

cakeorwine · 30/03/2024 10:31

I find your posts to show an unedifying combination of arrogance and ignorance OP

Because Farage and Anderson are hypocrites who would be the first to call for Jesus to be locked up?

OP posts:
Mysticlines · 30/03/2024 10:29

Look, the simple fact is that people interpret the bible, or whatever their holy book is, or indeed any book at all, according to their own existing values and beliefs. People with socially conservative beliefs are conservative christians, people with liberal beliefs become liberal christians, people have used the bible both to defend and oppose slavery and both have had biblical justifications for doing so, feminists find feminisim in the bible (bit of a stretch) and even those believing in the modern trans beliefs are starting to argue for biblical support for this ( even more of a stretch).

So attacking the people for not being Christian enough does not show a good understanding of how these things work. The bible's a long book. Opinions are divided over its interpretation. I refer you to the sheer number of different churches that exist, and sheer volume and diversity of theological interpretation.

I do find it hard to hear a non- Christian berate Christians for not christening right ( and I'm not even a Christian myself), especially when you have such a poor understanding of what Christianity and its core beliefs actually are.

I do find it hard to hear someone being so judgemental about others for not following non-judgemental teachings.

I find your posts to show an unedifying combination of arrogance and ignorance OP.

cakeorwine · 30/03/2024 10:23

The Prom is about a gay teenager who is not allowed to go to the Prom because she is gay and the religious folk don't like it.

It exposes the hypocrisy of people who cherry pick the Bible.

OP posts:
KeinLiebeslied54321 · 30/03/2024 10:21

Bicyclethief · 30/03/2024 10:18

Serenpidityjane

It is, that is core to Christianity. God loves you, Jesus came to save you but it's only through him and his teachings.

That's your Christianity. (Which has no qualms about immediately calling people who don't believe it "sinners". Talk about othering).

There will be other Christians who have a different view.

*It's not my version of Christianity, as far as I know I didn't write a gospel according to bicyclebrief.

It's what Jesus says himself. I'm not saying anyone is sinful, I'm saying Jesus tells us what is sinful. I'm just pointing out what these sinful things are according to his teachings.

How many times does he say that heaven comes only through him?

I'm not sure why people get so upset if they're not Christian and the don't believe in the definition of what is sinful according to a faith.

If this is not what the core message of Christianity is what is it according to you?*

It's actually what people report a figure called Jesus to have said/done.

cakeorwine · 30/03/2024 10:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It's about following the rules of the Old Testament.
Do you believe that you have to follow the rules of the Old Testament to be a Christian?

Because there are a lot of rules in there.

As exemplified in the videos.

Unless only some of the rules need to be followed?
And if so, which ones?

OP posts:
Mysticlines · 30/03/2024 10:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Bicyclethief · 30/03/2024 10:18

Serenpidityjane

It is, that is core to Christianity. God loves you, Jesus came to save you but it's only through him and his teachings.

That's your Christianity. (Which has no qualms about immediately calling people who don't believe it "sinners". Talk about othering).

There will be other Christians who have a different view.

*It's not my version of Christianity, as far as I know I didn't write a gospel according to bicyclebrief.

It's what Jesus says himself. I'm not saying anyone is sinful, I'm saying Jesus tells us what is sinful. I'm just pointing out what these sinful things are according to his teachings.

How many times does he say that heaven comes only through him?

I'm not sure why people get so upset if they're not Christian and the don't believe in the definition of what is sinful according to a faith.

If this is not what the core message of Christianity is what is it according to you?*

cakeorwine · 30/03/2024 10:17

Mysticlines · 30/03/2024 10:16

Of course OT teachings are part of the Christian faith!!!

You are surely trolling now!!

The OT is part of the Christian Bible!!!! How do you not know this????!!!!

You are quoting a popular tv series to claim it’s not??!!!!! Dear God!!!!

There are some passages in the NT saying that certain Jewish laws no longer apply. But the OT is still and valued part of the Christian Bible and faith and you will hear it taught in Churches up and down the UK, and world.

I have another one for you:

"Love Thy Neighbor" Full Performance feat. Andrew Rannells | The Prom | Netflix

Andrew Rannells and the cast of THE PROM perform the showstopper "Love Thy Neighbor."Subscribe: https://bit.ly/36dnr0kFind Netflix Film Club on:➡️INSTAGRAM: ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mODJjkFp_hg

OP posts:
Mysticlines · 30/03/2024 10:16

cakeorwine · 30/03/2024 10:10

I have no doubt that the featuring of a Messiah is in the Old Testament.

But the words and teachings and values of Jesus are in the New Testament.

And I would hope that is where Christians get their values from - from the teachings of Jesus. In the New Testament.

Unless you believe that the Old Testament values and laws are also part of the values of Christianity?

Of course OT teachings are part of the Christian faith!!!

You are surely trolling now!!

The OT is part of the Christian Bible!!!! How do you not know this????!!!!

You are quoting a popular tv series to claim it’s not??!!!!! Dear God!!!!

There are some passages in the NT saying that certain Jewish laws no longer apply. But the OT is still and valued part of the Christian Bible and faith and you will hear it taught in Churches up and down the UK, and world.

cakeorwine · 30/03/2024 10:15

Mysticlines · 30/03/2024 10:11

I know this is a common comment, but I personally see it as reflecting a deep cultural, unconscious anti-semitism.

For someone who claims to value being non-judgmental and acceptance and tolerance, you might want to reflect on how it comes across to Jewish people to hear people from Christian traditions speak about some of their Holy Books and God in this way, especially as the comparison is clearly meant to show the superiority of the Christian God and texts to Jewish ones.

Old Testament God killed a lot of people.

I think that's clear in the Old Testament.

New Testament God didn't kill that many. Correct me if I am wrong

OP posts:
KeinLiebeslied54321 · 30/03/2024 10:13

Mysticlines · 30/03/2024 10:12

No idea why you felt the need to say this. Where do I make a spiritual truth claim?

I'm don't think I did suggest that, merely adding a comment to an ongoing thread.