Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to take out a £30k personal loan to revamp our odd garden?

117 replies

GardenDeLuxe · 28/03/2024 15:39

Would you??

We've had a rough quote from a gardener and this is the ballpark. We would have to finance it... at least a big chunk of it.

I've lived in my house for over 15 years and the garden has always been pretty rubbish. We have always struggled to know what to do with it. It has a strange plot shape so consists of multiple triangle shapes around the house. We are on a hill as well, so it's on lots of different levels so feels very disjointed.

We have 8 years left on our mortgage (£55k balance)... I think the current rate is currently similar to a personal loan. So, it seems a personal loan is a better way to go??? Seems 'frivolous' to take out a personal loan somehow - but then we would have a horrible garden forevermore otherwise??!

AIBU to just take out a loan as you only live once?!

OP posts:
CormorantStrikesBack · 28/03/2024 18:12

I’d spend 30k cash on a garden if I was so inclined. But no way would I get into 30k of debt for a garden. With interest how much would you actually pay back…..35k? 40k?

you say you can afford the repayments so why don’t you save for a bit and then get the work done? At least then you won’t pay interest.

Though I have to say I’d be learning what to do myself. I was quoted 4k for a patio years ago…..I ended up watching some YouTube videos, bought some slabs and did it myself.

Sothisiit · 28/03/2024 18:12

If you're not gardeners then why put so much into a space you'll have little interest maintaining.
I'd get a cheaper quote for a low maintenance design. 30k debt for a garden seems excessive.

Anguish · 28/03/2024 18:12

innerdesign · 28/03/2024 18:07

People lose their homes by taking on 30k of debt they can afford on top of a (very small) 55k mortgage..? Don't be ridiculous.

Some people on this thread are very debt-averse. I understand it in theory, but life is short. I'd rather have the benefit now and enjoy the garden for longer even if it costs a bit more in the long run. Everyone has different philosophies on that.

she asked her opinion, i gave it, personally think its catastrophic.

Fizzadora · 28/03/2024 18:08

The only thing I have against personal loans these days is that you don't get any leeway if you are able to pay it off early. You used to be able to get a settlement figure that knocked off the outstanding interest, a bit like HP. If you can get it at a relatively low rate then there's no problem.
I would definitely do it. I love my garden and spend hours in it. I would hate it if it made me unhappy.

innerdesign · 28/03/2024 18:07

Anguish · 28/03/2024 17:39

You're out of your mind, this is how people lose their homes. You have lived x years perfectly fine without a 30k garden. Learn to DIY?

People lose their homes by taking on 30k of debt they can afford on top of a (very small) 55k mortgage..? Don't be ridiculous.

Some people on this thread are very debt-averse. I understand it in theory, but life is short. I'd rather have the benefit now and enjoy the garden for longer even if it costs a bit more in the long run. Everyone has different philosophies on that.

Runnerduck34 · 28/03/2024 17:56

I love sitting in the garden so tbh if I could afford it I'd go for it.
Do what beings you joy.
Other people will spend that on a car or a kitchen without batting an eyelid.
And TBH I think 30k for landscape gardening would quickly be used up.
However if you are thinking if moving any time soon then I would spend less.

Stoufer · 28/03/2024 17:54

I think you should get your calculator out and work out how much you would have actually paid over the loan period… I imagine that the £30k garden will have cost you at least £50k - £60k when you add up all the interest payments. If it was me, I would focus all my efforts on paying down the mortgage early, as with high mortgage rates you will really benefit from reducing the capital part of the mortgage. I imagine that there would be lots of things that you could do in a simple way to improve how your garden looks and feels, that would not require a garden designer. Have you looked at books / magazines / online for inspiration? When you have paid your mortgage off then you can save and plan further (more substantial) work to your garden.

godmum56 · 28/03/2024 17:54

Can I suggest that if there are similar houses round you then look at what their gardens are like? look at houses for sale, what their gardens are like and what they sell for...do your am I getting value for money due diligence....also seriously consider if your house will be right for you in your 60's 70's if part of your argument is that you won't be moving...and I say this as a garden fanatic. deffo get more quotes and more opinions and ask to look at garden sthey have done...in real life is best but pics would help too...and if you can speak to previous clients even better.

GrimDamnFanjo · 28/03/2024 17:42

Perhaps what you need is to pay for the vision then either diy or find a green fingered handyman?

DiscoBeat · 28/03/2024 17:41

I would only do it if the expenditure didn't exceed the extra value on the house, but I wouldn't pay the high interest on a loan for it. - I'd save up instead, or do small amounts at a time.

TheNoodlesIncident · 28/03/2024 17:41

You need to get more quotes. Just one really isn't enough. Other garden designers may come up with other ideas that fit the spaces and aspects they present even better than the one you have. Plus consider how you will use the garden, not just now but in the future when you are older and maybe less able to get around a multi-level garden.

£30K seems like an awful lot, although the costs of materials has risen considerably. We had our rear garden landscaped in 2018, with lots of patio, paving, paths, pergolas and fences, plus a lot of turf, and involved five lads, a mini digger and at least two wagons for removal of spoil and took eight days (it should have been less but they discovered foundations under the lawn that we hadn't known about, so more work and costs to them than anticipated). It cost us £8K for that.

It's unlikely that we'd get that amount of work done for that amount again, but £30K still seems steep. Are you satisfied with the projected end result for the money? Does the design really work for you and you're convinced you'll want to be out in it as much as possible, kind of thing? Does £30K slapped on your mortgage seem worth it?

Anguish · 28/03/2024 17:40

Minfilia · 28/03/2024 17:39

I wouldn’t. Assuming that you’re in the uk, you’ll get about 3 days when you’ll actually be able to enjoy it 😂

definitely not worth getting into 30k of debt for!

This. Do the math.

Anguish · 28/03/2024 17:39

You're out of your mind, this is how people lose their homes. You have lived x years perfectly fine without a 30k garden. Learn to DIY?

Minfilia · 28/03/2024 17:39

I wouldn’t. Assuming that you’re in the uk, you’ll get about 3 days when you’ll actually be able to enjoy it 😂

definitely not worth getting into 30k of debt for!

innerdesign · 28/03/2024 17:38

I'd do it if it's important to you and you can afford it. We paid 9k just to have the garden of a new build levelled, turfed and paved so if there's a lot of work involved I can see where the figure comes from. Don't put it off, things only get more expensive. One thing, you say you 'think' your current mortgage rate is the same as a personal loan. When you're talking about finances you need to be sure you're borrowing in the most sensible way

Isobel201 · 28/03/2024 17:35

Maybe it would be slightly cheaper to find another house with a better garden? You can swap mortgages.

ABwithAnItch · 28/03/2024 17:29

I don’t think you are being frivolous. We are literally finishing up a 50K revamp of our garden in next few weeks. Before people start tutting, I have lived in 5 houses over past 25 years and every one had garbage gardens. We own our current home and tried to improve it on our own but it was just not in our wheel house. We’ve had it completely redone, with a patio and awning, lovely plants and a huge pond. I’m so excited. I say go for it.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 28/03/2024 17:24

You need to be realistic about the maintenance. Even if it's mostly landscaping it will still need to be maintained

This. Also, definitely get more than one quote.

Hellogoodbyehello4321 · 28/03/2024 17:17

In which case it does seem a lot on a 300k house. Perhaps if you could save up for a year or two first to limit the amount you'd need to borrow? Or is there a way that they could do some but not all of the design?

That being said, If you plan to live in that house for another 20 years and believe you will get enjoyment out of it, then you may decide its worth it. It may mean you need to be prepared to work an extra couple of years as obviously it's 30k you can't overpay your mortgage with, but if you're prepared to do that than I think that's ok.

I do think it's a lot to spend in proportion to your house value so I think it comes purely down to whether the £xxx repayment is worth the enjoyment it will bring.

Singleandproud · 28/03/2024 17:08

I think you also need to get the price for ongoing gardener visits regularly once it's done if you aren't keen gardeners, 5 years after it's done it could look like a weedy mess if you aren't interested in it's up keep.

GardenDeLuxe · 28/03/2024 17:01

MissPeachyKeen · 28/03/2024 16:57

Yanbu to pay for a proper designer to come, assess the space and come up with a good design but I'd be more comfort with taking that and doing it yourself, or doing it over 3 years so breaking down the cost.

I would baulk at a £30k loan.

This is definitely the more sensible plan, although we are not ones for DIY, it has to be said.

OP posts:
GardenDeLuxe · 28/03/2024 16:59

Hellogoodbyehello4321 · 28/03/2024 16:55

Tbh while I wouldn't normally think spending 30k on a garden is a good idea, you have a small mortgage and a good few years of working still a head of you so assuming you aren't planning on stopping work imminently and are on half decent salaries, it seems like you would easily be able to afford it especially since you are planning on staying in that house.

If it makes you happy then I'd say go for it. I caveat that by saying a) as long as you have decent pensions on track and b) it isn't a disproportionate amount compared to the value of your house.

It's about 10% about the house value. I don't like the idea of taking on the debt, but perhaps it's worth it, is what I'm thinking?!

I think we are OK on the pensions front.

OP posts:
MissPeachyKeen · 28/03/2024 16:57

Yanbu to pay for a proper designer to come, assess the space and come up with a good design but I'd be more comfort with taking that and doing it yourself, or doing it over 3 years so breaking down the cost.

I would baulk at a £30k loan.

GardenDeLuxe · 28/03/2024 16:56

babytakemehome · 28/03/2024 16:44

I mean, if you can afford it, and can pay it back, YANBU, do whatever you want.
But IMO dead space no matter how pretty it is won't increase the value of the house. Not only do people want one big space it also sounds like a pain having to maintain little bits everywhere.
It sounds like you can joint up the triangles into one big space? If so, that would be a worthwhile investment.
I live on a hill too and a couple of houses have multilevel gardens. People are put off by them. Stairs/gates etc don't matter really. Do you have a picture of the ideal vision?
Can you level it to make is smoother..?

Edited

We're not planning to move... but, yes, I get your point of dead space being dead space. Potentially, we would reconfigure the spaces making the large-ish front garden smaller and the side larger.

There would be quite a lot of levelling. However, we couldn't have it all on one level as the road is higher. So, if we have a new entrance and enlarge the side space, it definitely would need steps (which I wasn't sure on, to be perfectly honest).

OP posts:
Hellogoodbyehello4321 · 28/03/2024 16:55

Tbh while I wouldn't normally think spending 30k on a garden is a good idea, you have a small mortgage and a good few years of working still a head of you so assuming you aren't planning on stopping work imminently and are on half decent salaries, it seems like you would easily be able to afford it especially since you are planning on staying in that house.

If it makes you happy then I'd say go for it. I caveat that by saying a) as long as you have decent pensions on track and b) it isn't a disproportionate amount compared to the value of your house.