Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guy did a 180 after date, does shyness put them off?

64 replies

Solonelyifeelsolonely · 28/03/2024 12:29

Of course he's entitled to not want another date, I'm just wondering if it's something I did that I can learn from for future dates. Obviously I can't know for sure but just want to give an idea.

I'd known him for around 2 months prior to the date through friends/events etc. and I'd say we met around 7 times in various settings and always got on well.

It sounds arrogant it I really thought sometimes that he fancied me, ,2 of our friends picked up on it too. I just felt that sort of chemistry.

Then he asked for my number and we were texting lots. I asked for the drink.

It was my first date in years and I admit I was quite nervous, but I tried to remember he was already an acquaintance.

I was shy, but still the conversation flowed really well. It felt natural, wasn't strained at all or forced.
He paid for my drink, I offered to get him one but he wouldn't.
The thing I thought was a little strange was that he didn't flirt at all, whilst it was nice I just didn't get a flirty vibe at all, even though it was a great chat.
I complimented him once but didn't wanna go overboard.
Anyway when I texted to thank him his tone immediately changed , and that was it.

Does it sound like I put him off by being a bit nervous? As I say he already knew me, knows what I look like and so on. I admit I was a little blindsided. Maybe he wanted someone more 'out there'? Even though he was giving me the same.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bobbotgegrinch · 28/03/2024 15:18

Solonelyifeelsolonely · 28/03/2024 12:34

I agree. When I told my 2 friends they were surprised too as they'd been convinced.
I don't know what I could've done to create the spark .
Agreed that people want it immediately. It does sound like I'm ruminating but I haven't got much dating experience and I'd like it to go better with someone next time.

You can't create a spark. Either two people have chemistry or they don't. There's no point in trying to analyse what went wrong, you just weren't right for him. You will be for someone else.

Pinkbonbon · 28/03/2024 15:17

My guess would be he was only looking for a fling and has cottoned on you aren't. Perhaps he messes women about and doesn't want to risk his social circle doing that to someone they know.

Livelifelaughter · 28/03/2024 15:11

Just wish to clarify, this was a coffee? Not a drink. When I have met someone in real life at a party, work etc because we are already familiar we have had a proper dinner date. When I have met men as friends it's coffee. In OLD the first date is often coffee because you are meeting for the first time. I think he had a coffee with you rather than considered it a date

Roryhon · 28/03/2024 14:45

You don’t sound particularly shy, you asked him on the date, conversation flowed and you asked him about going somewhere else.

Sometimes the chemistry just isn’t there, even if you wish it were. I once went on a date with a guy I’d been talking to online who was absolutely lovely, but there really was no chemistry. Some other lucky girl would have got a lovely husband with him, he just wasn’t for me..

Also it sounds as though he’s very picky about what he wants or isn’t bothered about finding someone- just by him not having had a serious girlfriend. It might be his issues, and nothing to do with you or what you did.

Solonelyifeelsolonely · 28/03/2024 14:35

You're right, I was just really convinced it was my nerves/shyness. Thanks!

OP posts:
waterrat · 28/03/2024 14:25

100 per cent what above poster said - you are thinking 'how could I have acted differently' - this is the unhelpful way to think of it

You and he didn't have what it takes between you - just keep being yourself !

5128gap · 28/03/2024 14:24

To be brutally honest, he didn't sound very keen in the first place. He didn't ask you out and didn't try to move beyond friendliness on your date. I'd say it's one of those where he though 'she's obviously into me so I might as well meet her' but when you met it didn't inspire any more enthusiasm in him. This isn't about you doing something wrong, it's just about not being what he's looking for. I'm sure you've felt this way about people yourself who liked you in the past? Its disappointing but that's life.Try not to fall into the trap of thinking there's a way to be that will keep a man interested. You have to be true to you, and they have to take it or leave it.

waterrat · 28/03/2024 14:23

The best lesson I learnt in life - and it took a while but then suddenly hit me - is that there is literally no point wasting a single second wondering why someone doesn't want to see you /isn't interested in you.

The guy went on a date with you and decided he didn't want to go further. There is literally no point giving it a single second thought. You have no idea the complexities of his mind or what drives chemical / phsyical attraction

There are many people in the world I click with intellectually - have flirted with but don't actually want to date

You will move through life so much faster when you take this on board - you can just move on to looking for the guy who really is right.

OneTC · 28/03/2024 14:15

Have you only previously seen him at the hobby?

MillieIou · 28/03/2024 14:10

Solonelyifeelsolonely · 28/03/2024 14:04

If he'd been interested he'd have suggested an alternative or another time, plus continued the convo. Prior to this drink he was writing me long paragraphs, I could just see the sudden change.

But you could say the same. You messaged him knowing he wasn't free and he said thanks for the thought. But then neither of you have continued since. How long ago was it?

greiday · 28/03/2024 14:04

maybe more people do like it than dislike it, but surely people don't date based on that

I would use it as a filtering criteria. This is probably not accurate about you at all but I'd be thinking "oh she's going to a fussy one" when it comes to food, and enjoying food together is a big part relationships for me. I also don't gel with men who don't like football, not that I love football but I just don't like the vibe of men I've met who hate it.

When you're dating you can be as picky with your mundane preferences as you like but highly unlikely to articulate them to the other person.

Solonelyifeelsolonely · 28/03/2024 14:04

MillieIou · 28/03/2024 13:40

I basically tested the waters by saying, shame you aren't free on Saturday as I'm going to X thing, would've been cool.He just put 'thanks for the thought, and basically a polite text but hasn't continued the convo so neither have I.

So he hasn't actually shut it down? How long ago was this? It could just be that you are both bad communicators and are waiting for one another to text again?

If he'd been interested he'd have suggested an alternative or another time, plus continued the convo. Prior to this drink he was writing me long paragraphs, I could just see the sudden change.

OP posts:
MillieIou · 28/03/2024 13:40

I basically tested the waters by saying, shame you aren't free on Saturday as I'm going to X thing, would've been cool.He just put 'thanks for the thought, and basically a polite text but hasn't continued the convo so neither have I.

So he hasn't actually shut it down? How long ago was this? It could just be that you are both bad communicators and are waiting for one another to text again?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/03/2024 13:39

I don't think shyness puts a man off a woman if he finds her attractive, thinks she finds him attractive, and he wants to have sex with her. Tbh I think the same applies to stupidity, obnoxiousness and probably satan worship.

I would guess that he liked you, found you at least somewhat attractive, but maybe was on the fence and since you have friends in common didn't want to either be edged into a more serious relationship than he wanted, or look like the bad guy if he kept it casual and wanted nothing more.

Solonelyifeelsolonely · 28/03/2024 13:29

CRbear · 28/03/2024 13:22

It’s possible he was never interested and agreed to the drink in a friends way and realised you want more so had shut it down?

i wouldn’t overthink it!

It could be that since there was zero flirting etc from him at the drink! Don't get why he asked for my number, surely that gives the wrong idea.

OP posts:
CRbear · 28/03/2024 13:22

It’s possible he was never interested and agreed to the drink in a friends way and realised you want more so had shut it down?

i wouldn’t overthink it!

CRbear · 28/03/2024 13:22

It’s possible he was never interested and agreed to the drink in a friends way and realised you want more so had shut it down?

i wouldn’t overthink it!

Solonelyifeelsolonely · 28/03/2024 13:19

He kinda shakes a bit around me which I don't know why, looks a bit like a deer in headlights sometimes, probably I've made him feel weird or something.

OP posts:
Solonelyifeelsolonely · 28/03/2024 13:18

AlohaOptima · 28/03/2024 13:14

Being single for 8 years at that age would be a red flag for me, are you sure he isn't Aromantic/Asexual?

Otherwise could you moving have put him off? Are you moving far and it would be a big effort to see each other?

I don't think he is, but I have no way of knowing.
I'm only moving 20 minutes away so wouldn't have been an issue, but yeah he didn't really go into the single thing. All I know is that he's only ever had short -term relationships when he was much younger, not that that matters.

OP posts:
AlohaOptima · 28/03/2024 13:14

Being single for 8 years at that age would be a red flag for me, are you sure he isn't Aromantic/Asexual?

Otherwise could you moving have put him off? Are you moving far and it would be a big effort to see each other?

ChampagneLassie · 28/03/2024 13:10

Honestly I dated loads, literally hundreds of men and I had some dates which I genuinely imagined might be the start of something serious and then got politely declined. There is no point trying to work it out. It might be nothing to do with you at all, you have no idea what is going on in rest of his life. When men did tell me (as I did sometimes ask I was variously told:
I seemed a bit too fit and they worried they wouldn’t keep up,
they didn’t think I’d want to move and thought it would be too long distance
they thought I seemed quite serious and they’re more laid back
it wasn’t me but they realised they weren’t in the right head space
i I reminded them of an ex
i reminded them of a boss they’d hated!
im amazing but they just want to have fun and I deserved a proper relationship
they worried they’d hurt me and I seemed too nice
who knows if any of this is true but I realised I couldn’t really do much about any of it!

Solonelyifeelsolonely · 28/03/2024 13:08

PossumintheHouse · 28/03/2024 13:06

I was also going to suggest that he perhaps didn't see it as a date and, when he realised you viewed it that way, tried to set up some boundaries. But it seems odd that he asked for your number... Unless the number-asking was linked to a hobby or work or something like that rather than part of a flirt.

Apparently the number was just so we could chat more .. maybe he is just the type to have really close kinda friendships with women, which is not a bad thing.

OP posts:
PossumintheHouse · 28/03/2024 13:06

I was also going to suggest that he perhaps didn't see it as a date and, when he realised you viewed it that way, tried to set up some boundaries. But it seems odd that he asked for your number... Unless the number-asking was linked to a hobby or work or something like that rather than part of a flirt.

samestyle · 28/03/2024 13:04

Doesn't sound like your shyness, conversation flowed, you gave a compliment, followed up with a text. Only thing is you asked for the date, so perhaps that wasn't his intention, odd why he asked for your number though.
Who knows maybe there is someone else and he doesn't want to commit any further.

Solonelyifeelsolonely · 28/03/2024 13:04

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 28/03/2024 13:02

I think he knew it was a date. Most men know this.

I hate to say it, but maybe he had another date lined up who he was more keen on, but didn't want to let you down, so had the date with you but therefore wasn't flirting or initiate anything as he didn't want to be accused of that with you.

Honestly I don't think he did, though I could be wrong. He's never had a serious girlfriend apparently, 31 now and single since 23 he said. And very much a homebody type who's very square of his own admittance. But I could be wrong.

OP posts: