Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

1 in 5 teachers hit by a pupil

267 replies

MrsMurphyIWish · 28/03/2024 06:07

AIBU to think it’s a low as that?

The worst encounter I have had is being pushed down the stairs when I was heavily pregnant with DS - luckily I grabbed the railing, however I was still expected to teach the boy. (He didn’t even get a detention). I teach in a different school now but swearing, general contempt (from some pupils), threats are still common. No physical violence though.

I put up with it as I’m in the money trap and waiting for mortgage to be paid off so I can escape but in’s worry if this doesn’t change we’ll have an endless cycle of ECTs who leave after a few years, continued missed recruitment targets, and behaviour will get even worse!

www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68674568 - * (post edited at OP's request to add link to BBC news site)

OP posts:
Greywhippet · 28/03/2024 07:32

The behaviours in most if not all schools day in day out would be a real shock to most people.

BCBird · 28/03/2024 07:32

At my school to support u would mean admitting there is an issue. It is usually verbal abuse at my school. I am sure things must happen that are swept under the carpet . There is supposed to be people on a rota walking around and an on call system, but it is ineffective The retention crisis is not helping either as generally when pupils know they have supply or another member of school staff instead of their usual teacher, the behaviour is a lot worse. We are starting the new term with one teacher down. Can't recruit. Going in in holidays to try to get some resources together for cover. It too much to face first day back

ArchesOfWisteria · 28/03/2024 07:31

Just to add it really is all levels of staff. As former SLT I spent all day being called to deal with incidents. I was expected to pull fights apart when no one else could, extract children from them who were getting harmed as the smaller child. If people had left a room due to violence, I had to go in and resolve it. I was always on gate duty/ in the playground so often first in the scene at flashpoints or just in the way. A child doesn’t have the hierarchical concept of adults, particularly a child with special needs. I could end up fire fighting and plugging holes. I’d also be the one keeping a child with me in an office etc until they were collected. Or the one in safeguarding situations the adults would be threatening to attack when children were safeguarded. Or the one local dealers followed to the station or threatened as the face of the school who reported them/ chased them off site.
I also was the face of staff frustration and got the verbal attacks. You’re kind of mean to solve the unsolvable problems or society or magic up sen placements for kids you have been directed to take.
Every level of staff, middays and catering, TAs, teachers and SLT is getting it.
I presume it’s 1 in 5 for hit, but far far higher for all kinds of contact. I wasn’t hit so many times, but shoved, had projectiles thrown at me etc more. The worst I had was actually being threatened with fire in a confined space.

OutOfTheHouse · 28/03/2024 07:29

Didimum · 28/03/2024 07:07

The existence of multiple royal family threads are always questioned too.

Parent bashing on mass is not ok. Some teachers don’t seem able to accept that strength of school leadership is often the problem.

Ahh I see. The behaviour of children who think it’s acceptable to hit school staff is the fault of school staff.

When I started teaching this simply didn’t happen in the numbers it does today. When it did happen it was a child with extreme additional needs.

Countless times a parent has been informed that their child has hit staff who have blamed the staff member.

I’m sorry this is annoying you. Sorry you don’t want to hear it. But school staff are leaving in droves, don’t act surprised when your child has no teacher.

MrsMurphyIWish · 28/03/2024 07:29

MushMonster · 28/03/2024 06:51

Can you please link the article? It is not showing.
I must confess I was not aware this could possibly be that bad.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68674568

Sorry!

Stock image of secondary school children next to lockers

Pupil behaviour 'getting worse' at schools in England, say teachers

A survey reveals nearly one in five teachers in England has been hit by a pupil this year.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-68674568

OP posts:
ZipZapZoom · 28/03/2024 07:28

Didimum · 28/03/2024 07:23

To anyone working in one of these environments – how does the school leadership assist you? What is their policy on behaviour?

Honestly in most schools SLT either support in removing the child and then the child often gets a lovely treat and some restorative conversation before returning to class or they tell you to log it on CPoMs and discuss with the parent again.

Idhavelikedtoknow · 28/03/2024 07:24

I’d agree with that @Elendel

I would also imagine that small children lashing out isn’t seen as a serious problem, so isn’t treated as such.

ZipZapZoom · 28/03/2024 07:24

Recently I have been thinking how I would hate my child to be in a class like mine.

I think many staff would admit the same to be honest. Taking into account all of the classes in all of the schools I've taught this year this is not a isolated thought. There's been many times I've found myself looking at the majority feeling that same guilt knowing they deserve better but it's impossible to give it them.

GoodnightAdeline · 28/03/2024 07:24

Didimum · 28/03/2024 07:23

To anyone working in one of these environments – how does the school leadership assist you? What is their policy on behaviour?

What should the parents be doing at home to support you, bar not fighting the school and moaning to them at every opportunity? Is this a product of poor parenting or something else?

Didimum · 28/03/2024 07:23

To anyone working in one of these environments – how does the school leadership assist you? What is their policy on behaviour?

HelloCiao · 28/03/2024 07:20

Recently I have been thinking how I would hate my child to be in a class like mine. My TA and I have been hit several times but I actually feel really sorry for the other children in the class; it is unpleasant for them to witness violent behaviour and they are not getting the support they need with their education because I am spending all my time deescalating situations/managing the behaviour of a minority.

Dextersenergy · 28/03/2024 07:15

I work in primary schools as a consultant. The level of violence and abuse in some schools is shocking. It's not just TA's - it can happen to anyone. When a child is disruptive the senior staff often have to get involved. I know of headteachers who have been bitten, scratched, bitten and hit with objects, a caretaker who had a child spit in her face.
Sadly a lot of this is related to the attitude of parents. You can't sweep it all aside by suggesting that these children must have special needs. The things they say, the language they use, it comes from home. So many parents unsupportive of the schools, it's no wonder so many are leaving the profession. I've seen headteachers break under the strain of dealing with these behaviours and the families.

NotQuiteNorma · 28/03/2024 07:15

It wasn't that long ago it was the other way around. Most pupils were hit by a teacher and when you told your parents they'd smack you too for misbehaving at school.

weefella · 28/03/2024 07:15

I'm in EYFS and being hit or kicked is something that happens on at least an hourly basis. Being spat at or bitten is probably more of a weekly thing. Having chairs thrown and tables tipped over is something that happens a couple of times a week.

The needs of these children just can't be met in a mainstream school with underfunding and minimal staffing. And even when it's been agreed that a child needs specialist provision, there is currently a waiting period of around 3 years in my area for a place to become available at a suitable school.

People would be seriously shocked if they could see what was happening for themselves.

Elendel · 28/03/2024 07:13

I wonder whether it is worse in primary schools, in a way, because the children are with the same adult all the time and therefore see them as their safe space? That could especially be the case if they have an unstable home life, which many of these children will have, and so they're lashing out with the only safe adult in their lives.

I've been working in secondary schools, many very rough ones, for close to 20 years. Verbal assault is commonplace, so is being pushed out of the way if a kid is determined to go somewhere and you're in their way. I've been threatened a few times, too, and been told (when pregnant) that the kid hopes my baby dies. All upsetting, of course. But I have never had a hand laid on me, and objects thrown my way were generally light (an exercise book, a tie). And while I'm competent, I'm certainly not Mrs Popular.

Any child assaulting a member of staff, even accidentally (a colleague once broke up a fight and was punched by one of the kids by accident), is always followed up with a severe sanction, usually exclusion for at least a day. Even in the shit schools where other behaviour incidents are tolerated way beyond what they should be.

But that's because it's very uncommon, and I wonder whether the child often doesn't have the time to build that relationship with an adult if they see them, maybe 4 times a week for an hour rather than all day, every day.

We know that most kids are worse at home than at school, because it's their safe space and thei intrinsically know they'll still be loved and accepted even if they have a meltdown.

It doesn't make it acceptable. Not in the slightest. But the issue does seem to be far worse in primary schools than in secondaries.

Groovee · 28/03/2024 07:09

In the last 3 years in nursery, at least 2 staff get hurt daily. My legs have horrific sore bruises this week from being kicked then laughed at by a 4 year old. The violence is coming from younger and younger children.

BCBird · 28/03/2024 07:08

Most kids I have taught are decent. Laziness however is endemic now as is talking and not valuing education- pupils and many parents. The level.of additional needs pupils is soaring, whilst provision to help is dwindling. Powder keg. I agree re calling police. Parents should be told all children and staff deserve to be in a safe environment and that any attacks will be reported.

Idhavelikedtoknow · 28/03/2024 07:07

I have known hitting incidents but very rare and usually result in a permanent exclusion. Not always.

Verbal abuse was nasty at one point.

ZipZapZoom · 28/03/2024 07:07

I don't think they'd do it for TAs I don't know many in primary who haven't been bitten, kicked, hit or worse the figures would be astronomically high.

I'm genuinely surprised it's as low as 1/5 for teachers. I'm a supply and have been hit deliberately by a child on 4 separate occasions since September!

Didimum · 28/03/2024 07:07

SeulementUneFois · 28/03/2024 07:01

Yes I think we should have many threads on this.
It's a horrific social phenomenon.
If the Royal family can have multiple threads so can this.

Why don't teachers call the police, at least when it's teenagers? That would be a sharp shock for the schools / dept of education to have to do something.
(And yes that's a rhetorical question - not victim blaming - I understand that teachers have been completely cowed and emotionally blackmailed, and if they dared call the police on being assaulted it would be all about the poor kiddies and the teacher would be tarred and feathered....Why don't unions stand up to that?)

The existence of multiple royal family threads are always questioned too.

Parent bashing on mass is not ok. Some teachers don’t seem able to accept that strength of school leadership is often the problem.

Whinge · 28/03/2024 07:05

BCBird · 28/03/2024 07:02

Whinge it's true. The bad behaviour is usually verbal.

Edited

I could understand if you had said it was a rare occurrence, but to have never encountered a single staff member who has been hit in over 30 years is unbelievable.

Notmyuser · 28/03/2024 07:03

I’ve been badly hit once, also when pregnant - someone threw a chair at me because I asked them to move seat for talking. No damage done but I was really shaken, and nothing was really done about it.

Being hit by things like pencils, jotters, etc is probably a twice yearly occurrence. Almost always accidental ( as in, it was intentionally thrown but I’m not the intended target) but rarely when covering a class or teaching kids I’ve not built a relationship with yet it’ll be intentional. Normally it’s dealt with and the kids gets a temporary exclusion from my class until we have a meeting and they do a detention, or they will get fully suspended.

BCBird · 28/03/2024 07:02

Whinge it's true. The bad behaviour is usually verbal.

SeulementUneFois · 28/03/2024 07:01

Didimum · 28/03/2024 06:51

Do we need another thread on this? There was a huge one only a week ago, and it descended into bashing working parents.

For every school with significant behaviour problems, you will get another which has very few.

Yes I think we should have many threads on this.
It's a horrific social phenomenon.
If the Royal family can have multiple threads so can this.

Why don't teachers call the police, at least when it's teenagers? That would be a sharp shock for the schools / dept of education to have to do something.
(And yes that's a rhetorical question - not victim blaming - I understand that teachers have been completely cowed and emotionally blackmailed, and if they dared call the police on being assaulted it would be all about the poor kiddies and the teacher would be tarred and feathered....Why don't unions stand up to that?)

BCBird · 28/03/2024 07:01

Rarely have a TA so was not aware how bad it is for u. I would push for the same as a TA. I have one TA who i spoke out for as i.was unhappy with injustice. Was thinking about being a TA nxt year when I.leave teaching.. Might have to reconsider