Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to let my Autistic dd spend the majority of the Easter break at home not socialising?

159 replies

Sfuandtired · 27/03/2024 21:08

My 12 year old DD is autistic and currently on her 2 weeks Easter holiday, I’d mentally planned a few days out over the break, dd has agreed to two but other than that has asked to spend the majority of this time at home relaxing and “ avoiding people “
She’s happy in herself, communicative with the family but doesn’t really want to do much other than play on her iPad on roblox or watch Tiktoks
she also FaceTimes a close friend daily. AIBU to go with what she’s asking? It seems almost irresponsible crap parenting to let her sit around not doing much, but not sure if I’m getting swept along with the social media ideal of having to go on lots of days out etc? But then maybe what she’s asking is what she needs to do? In order to recharge/relax? Thanks

OP posts:
WaitingForMojo · 27/03/2024 22:43

NaiceUser · 27/03/2024 22:36

I respectfully disagree with this. It may be the case for you but not all autistic people. My Autistic DC thrive on socialisation

I agree that autistic vary in how much they need social interaction. I think most autistic people find it draining, even if they need it. Interesting if your dc don’t have a low social battery, I mean genuinely interesting and I love hearing about different autistic people’s experiences.

NaiceUser · 27/03/2024 22:42

Why do so many people think that being Autistic means that no other aspects of health & wellbeing matter at all?

I manage to find a balance with my Autistic DC. Very rarely is there overstimulation as a result. There is plenty of laughter, fresh air & exercise however. Much better than throwing the Nintendo switch/iPad across the room because a game was lost.

WeirdIsPartOfTheJob · 27/03/2024 22:41

456pickupsticks · 27/03/2024 22:22

Its literally parenting to 'impose demands' on your children!! Particularly when they're for their own good such as getting outside, exercising, having to have a drink etc.

Why are there suddenly so many people who seem to feel that imposing limits on children with diagnoses is this terrible thing?!

Autistic children, like all children, need boundaries, including around screen time - giving choices on other things to do, without demanding, is a good way to achieve this. It's a parents job to provide these boundaries - they may be slightly different from other children (eg you might allow more ipad time than for other children, or you might allow more time in bed etc), but they do need to be provided. 12 Year olds are not in a position where they should be making all of their own decisions.

OP's DD seems to recognise that she needs a balance herself - having agreed to a couple of days out. I'd suggest some screen time limits would be useful and have suggested other activities.

You need to google PDA profile as you clearly do not understand the way “demand” is being used in this context.

For my ASD partner, when they are tired and over stimulated, something like saying “I watched x film lately, I’d highly recommend it” is a demand that can cause an involuntary shut down or melt down.

So can eating food, even if hungry (and prepared by some else and literally handed to them).

You are applying neurotypical standards to a totally different situation. It’s like saying “well it’s only 100 yards from the car park to the entrance, everyone can walk” without realising some people cannot walk 100 yards.

Lifeofasd1 · 27/03/2024 22:39

I am autistic as are my three children.
Please leave her spend the easter hols
as she wishes. In her room, away from people.
She needs this to recharge, she doesn't just want it, she needs it.
People are only beginning to realise that socialising around people is not always a must.
iPads are completely fine too, let her be herself, it will not damage her like skills by letting her be.

currentstateofthings · 27/03/2024 22:39

Yeah let her do what she needs to do like you said Op. fact is the holidays are for recharging and her way of recharging is without external people, noises, places. She sounds like a smart cookie

serin · 27/03/2024 22:37

ItBeDarkTonight · 27/03/2024 21:19

Sorry but I disagree with the above posts. At home relaxing is ok but only scrolling tiktoks and playing Roblox wouldn't be ok to me. That's not helpful or healthy for anyone. There needs to be a balance. Does she meet the exercise guidelines? Does she do any chores? Has she got homework? Relaxing at home could be baking, reading, doing art, learning a language, knitting, gardening etc. That can all be balanced with screen time too but it's not ok for that to be all she does. She can avoid days out but she needs to be doing something

She really doesn't "have to be doing something" and everyone's idea of a meaningful activity is different.

Do you have much experience of autism? My DD has PDA and somehow managed to get through school and 2 degrees but only by having no demands at all placed on her outside of education. She's a talented software engineer now, living independently. I dread to think where she would be if we had "forced her" into socialising or completing activities that were meaningless for her.

ManchesterLu · 27/03/2024 22:37

It can be exhausting to be in school 5 days a week when you have autism, she may spend a lot of her time trying to mask, and I see nothing wrong with allowing her to chill out and spend some time on her own, being who she wants to be. She has agreed to do a couple of things with you, which is great.

LiveLaughCryalot · 27/03/2024 22:37

My DD is NT but she also likes to spend the shorter holidays decompressing. She works really hard at school, it doesn't come naturally to her so she needs to rest her brain as she says. I've encouraged her to meet friends at least once at the local park/woodland, they can spend all day there no matter the weather. If left up to her though she wouldn't be bothered. She does like doing stuff around the house, she's sorted her bedroom out and will cook tea a few nights, i bought loads of baking stuff last week in preparation! Again though, she is NT so easier to encourage. I wouldn't worry OP. School itself is full on these days, they need the rest.

NaiceUser · 27/03/2024 22:36

ntmdino · 27/03/2024 21:21

Absolutely not unreasonable. Autistic people don't need socialisation, it doesn't make us any better at it - all it does is reinforce the idea that we have to mask to be accepted.

The one thing she needs is a rest from that. Far from being irresponsible parenting, it's the only responsible thing to do. If only more parents would do the same when their child is telling them in no uncertain terms what they need.

Rest easy, and don't let the social media peer pressure get to you. You've not only done the right thing by asking her what she wants, you'll be doing even better by following through with it.

Also: you should be proud that she has both the confidence and the self-awareness to be able to tell you that she needs that time on her own. Too many autistic teenagers would just go along with it because they think they're broken if they don't; you've done a good job there.

I respectfully disagree with this. It may be the case for you but not all autistic people. My Autistic DC thrive on socialisation

TheSnowyOwl · 27/03/2024 22:36

456pickupsticks · 27/03/2024 22:22

Its literally parenting to 'impose demands' on your children!! Particularly when they're for their own good such as getting outside, exercising, having to have a drink etc.

Why are there suddenly so many people who seem to feel that imposing limits on children with diagnoses is this terrible thing?!

Autistic children, like all children, need boundaries, including around screen time - giving choices on other things to do, without demanding, is a good way to achieve this. It's a parents job to provide these boundaries - they may be slightly different from other children (eg you might allow more ipad time than for other children, or you might allow more time in bed etc), but they do need to be provided. 12 Year olds are not in a position where they should be making all of their own decisions.

OP's DD seems to recognise that she needs a balance herself - having agreed to a couple of days out. I'd suggest some screen time limits would be useful and have suggested other activities.

You have no idea. I sincerely hope you don’t have an autistic child. Your beliefs are just cruel.

Irisginger · 27/03/2024 22:36

AnyDayAnyWay · 27/03/2024 22:32

Baking, board and card games, nature walks, sorting out the garden, painting, knitting, sewing, drawing etc are all great substitutes for ipad time, but don't involve loads of people.

Why are these seen as more worthy than screen time? Particularly board / card games - a game is a game, however it’s played!

Forcing ND people to engage in activity in their downtime is the problem. ND people have their own needs, to regulate, and to follow special interests. Why do NT people feel they must interfere with this?

NaiceUser · 27/03/2024 22:34

Why are you allowing a 12yr old on TikTok??????

WeirdIsPartOfTheJob · 27/03/2024 22:33

456pickupsticks · 27/03/2024 22:07

Not suggesting all these things need to be done every day, but a limit on screen time with these suggestions of alternatives (alongside stuff like reading that she probably already does).

None of these are particularly over stimulating activities.

You are wrong.

AnyDayAnyWay · 27/03/2024 22:32

Baking, board and card games, nature walks, sorting out the garden, painting, knitting, sewing, drawing etc are all great substitutes for ipad time, but don't involve loads of people.

Why are these seen as more worthy than screen time? Particularly board / card games - a game is a game, however it’s played!

WaitingForMojo · 27/03/2024 22:32

456pickupsticks · 27/03/2024 22:22

Its literally parenting to 'impose demands' on your children!! Particularly when they're for their own good such as getting outside, exercising, having to have a drink etc.

Why are there suddenly so many people who seem to feel that imposing limits on children with diagnoses is this terrible thing?!

Autistic children, like all children, need boundaries, including around screen time - giving choices on other things to do, without demanding, is a good way to achieve this. It's a parents job to provide these boundaries - they may be slightly different from other children (eg you might allow more ipad time than for other children, or you might allow more time in bed etc), but they do need to be provided. 12 Year olds are not in a position where they should be making all of their own decisions.

OP's DD seems to recognise that she needs a balance herself - having agreed to a couple of days out. I'd suggest some screen time limits would be useful and have suggested other activities.

Forgive me if I’m wrong, but it sounds from your post as though you have no direct experience here.

BeaRF75 · 27/03/2024 22:32

Sounds great. I'm not autistic, but I used to spend the vast majority of my school holidays on my own in my bedroom reading books and listening to records (it was the 70s/early 80s). In my view, that's what the holidays are for - we are forced to be with other kids at school, so it's natural to crave time alone. I'm still the same now, and it's such a treat to have a few days solo where I don't speak to a single other person.

PostItInABook · 27/03/2024 22:30

@Llamadramallama

Same. When I was working full time frontline shifts I did 5 on, 4 off. The first 2 days off were basically spent in bed and on the sofa, curtains closed, to recover from masking 10 plus hours a day in a sometimes extremely stressful job.

mrsfollowill · 27/03/2024 22:29

My DS has autism- he's in his early 20's and still lives at home. As he has got older we have all learned more coping strategies. If she needs downtime and has said as much then she needs it- no ifs or buts.
My son holds down a full time job and has progressed so well in the last 5 years thanks to 2 years at a specialised college after A levels. He did an internship at his current employer and they offered him a full time paid job after his first three days. There is hope for kids with autism but you need to listen to them and not try and jolly them along with activities that are not for them!
He loves travel, history and good food so we spend time on city breaks abroad off season (not crowded) these days. He is also quite sociable and has friends from school who still look out for him when they go out for a drink in town.
I think my point is listen to your kid if they are willing to open up to you and follow their lead!

Llamadramallama · 27/03/2024 22:28

I’m a newly diagnosed autistic teacher and I do not know how I’d get through the next half day without a promise (to myself) of some decompression time over this weekend. Generally at the end of a half term I have what my husband calls “end of term fever” where I move from bed to sofa and back for a few days. I don’t engage, I do nice things for me (I will spend several hours on games - for those who dismiss them as unhelpful, they are nice routined environments where if you do ABC then XYZ will happen - very very soothing), I will lie down a lot and if you had no experience of neurodiversity you’d say I was being lazy. But I’ve masked my natural state for 6 weeks, 9 hours a day, not counting my social masking. And I am so exhausted by it. Making sure I make appropriate eye contact, say appropriate things, be bright and cheery. I love my job and I’m very good at it. But autistic children - especially females - have the same masking and please just let them be.

I have many family activities planned from Sunday onwards and I’ll be fine but the decompression is so necessary to allow me to function.

Irisginger · 27/03/2024 22:24

456pickupsticks · 27/03/2024 22:22

Its literally parenting to 'impose demands' on your children!! Particularly when they're for their own good such as getting outside, exercising, having to have a drink etc.

Why are there suddenly so many people who seem to feel that imposing limits on children with diagnoses is this terrible thing?!

Autistic children, like all children, need boundaries, including around screen time - giving choices on other things to do, without demanding, is a good way to achieve this. It's a parents job to provide these boundaries - they may be slightly different from other children (eg you might allow more ipad time than for other children, or you might allow more time in bed etc), but they do need to be provided. 12 Year olds are not in a position where they should be making all of their own decisions.

OP's DD seems to recognise that she needs a balance herself - having agreed to a couple of days out. I'd suggest some screen time limits would be useful and have suggested other activities.

Have you got an autistic child?

PostItInABook · 27/03/2024 22:23

Ugh, nature walks. Insects, dogs, people, noises, smells, temperature, lighting.

Ugh, baking. Recipe instructions, horrible textures of ingredients, smells, etc.

Ugh, ‘sorting out the garden’ - this is demand to do a chore you think needs doing. See also nature walk…..insects, smells, textures bleurgh.

Ugh, outside everyday. Just. No.

These things are fine if the autistic person is in a place to do them and is interested in them. But if they are needing to recharge these things are unhelpful. Recharging for autistic people means dimmed lighting, quiet, soothing regulatory activities, sensory seeking preferences, low demands.

If you’re neurotypical and/or don’t have an autistic kid you aren’t going to get it.

456pickupsticks · 27/03/2024 22:22

Its literally parenting to 'impose demands' on your children!! Particularly when they're for their own good such as getting outside, exercising, having to have a drink etc.

Why are there suddenly so many people who seem to feel that imposing limits on children with diagnoses is this terrible thing?!

Autistic children, like all children, need boundaries, including around screen time - giving choices on other things to do, without demanding, is a good way to achieve this. It's a parents job to provide these boundaries - they may be slightly different from other children (eg you might allow more ipad time than for other children, or you might allow more time in bed etc), but they do need to be provided. 12 Year olds are not in a position where they should be making all of their own decisions.

OP's DD seems to recognise that she needs a balance herself - having agreed to a couple of days out. I'd suggest some screen time limits would be useful and have suggested other activities.

Crowgirl · 27/03/2024 22:21

No frigging way. I have autistic kids one of whom would love to do that all the time.
I was allowed to behave like that at that age too.
It was not healthy and does not lead to positive outcomes. It made getting back into normal outside life a million times harder and more stressful. Don't get me wrong a lazy PN weekend or so is grand but the whole two weeks? Just no

I work with autistic kids in an outdoor setting and we manage to help the regulate just fine. A bit of screen time/ gaming time is fine but and we all do we what need to do to get thought the day as parents but tbh there's plenty of other ways to promote regulation that aren't gaming and doom scrolling. Look into sensory circuits, hammocks/ swings, certain kinds of massages.

Circadian rhythms, exercise and time in nature are all also very good for regulating and general wellbeing. Also time with animals. You don't have to do a big thing or lots of things, also leave recovery periods in between stuff, but if it were my child I would not (and do not) let them hermit out for the entire holiday.

Knickersinatwist36 · 27/03/2024 22:21

Our daughter (14) stays in her dark room whenever she isn't in school. It took ages to get used to but just believing her need really helped her.

When she was younger (before diagnosis) we were very smug about limited screen time etc. when we went to her paediatrician she said, kindly, that the screen was probably helping her regulate as it was removing everything immediate and giving her brain a break from all the coping she had to do. It was much better.

Now, she will not go on holiday because she doesn't like unfamiliar smells or food that is different. She is hugely has huge sensory sensitivity and the world is just overwhelming for her. She sometimes bakes, or wants to go on a long drive to take photographs and she enjoys sketching, but all of these are done on her schedule and we all just fit in.

She is working as hard as she can at school and is now getting As.

You sound like a normal parent wanting the best for your child, let go of your anxiety and you will both feel much better. Good luck.

NotAgainWilson · 27/03/2024 22:21

Honestly, most 12 years old would prefer to stay at home doing their own thing rather than being dragged from one thing to another by their parents.

Swipe left for the next trending thread