Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to let my Autistic dd spend the majority of the Easter break at home not socialising?

159 replies

Sfuandtired · 27/03/2024 21:08

My 12 year old DD is autistic and currently on her 2 weeks Easter holiday, I’d mentally planned a few days out over the break, dd has agreed to two but other than that has asked to spend the majority of this time at home relaxing and “ avoiding people “
She’s happy in herself, communicative with the family but doesn’t really want to do much other than play on her iPad on roblox or watch Tiktoks
she also FaceTimes a close friend daily. AIBU to go with what she’s asking? It seems almost irresponsible crap parenting to let her sit around not doing much, but not sure if I’m getting swept along with the social media ideal of having to go on lots of days out etc? But then maybe what she’s asking is what she needs to do? In order to recharge/relax? Thanks

OP posts:
Crowgirl · 27/03/2024 23:17

serin · 27/03/2024 23:07

Why is mixing butter, sugar, flour and eggs together seen as such a wholesome activity?

Is that a real question or rhetorical?

I haven't suggested cooking but I know others have.

If it's real I imagine:

It's traditional and often harks back to a farmhouse kitchen type idyl and people's own fond memories with their mums.

Entry level creativity with tasty tangible results.
Low waste as you eat the product, so you don't end up with a shelf of clay work / wall of crap paintings/ bits of paper or wood everywhere etc.

Nice smells but definitely either big hit or total miss in other sensory ways. One of my kids loves the feel of scrunching flour and butter, the other wouldn't be able to stand having it anywhere near their skin.

AnyDayAnyWay · 27/03/2024 23:16

mollyfolk · 27/03/2024 23:14

It just the act of creating something - there is a sense of accomplishment at the end and it is a lightly active thing to do . It’s just one of many activities that someone can do alone at home and might find relaxing. I think finding ways to relax off screens will benefit everyone. Doing the same thing all the time isn’t good for us.

You can be creative on screens as well, though.

I personally always hated baking. Too much potential for mess and the ingredients had weird textures.

mollyfolk · 27/03/2024 23:14

serin · 27/03/2024 23:07

Why is mixing butter, sugar, flour and eggs together seen as such a wholesome activity?

It just the act of creating something - there is a sense of accomplishment at the end and it is a lightly active thing to do . It’s just one of many activities that someone can do alone at home and might find relaxing. I think finding ways to relax off screens will benefit everyone. Doing the same thing all the time isn’t good for us.

serin · 27/03/2024 23:07

Why is mixing butter, sugar, flour and eggs together seen as such a wholesome activity?

mollyfolk · 27/03/2024 23:02

I think it is great that she recognises that she needs this time to decompress, if peopling is difficult for her then forced socialisation will do nothing for her. I appreciate that, I need time away from people myself.

ideally I’d encourage her to find other ways to decompress rather than using a screen all the time. Too much time immobile on a screen isn’t great for mental health. Time in nature, exercise, pottering around cooking, baking, drawing or writing are all healthy ways to decompress. But it’s easier said than done, I know. You don’t want to make her feel like she’s on a schedule.

bloodyeffinnora · 27/03/2024 23:02

NaiceUser · 27/03/2024 22:53

@bloodyeffinnora There's no need to resort to name calling

there's no need to be so nasty or sanctimonious either

Crowgirl · 27/03/2024 22:59

NaiceUser · 27/03/2024 22:42

Why do so many people think that being Autistic means that no other aspects of health & wellbeing matter at all?

I manage to find a balance with my Autistic DC. Very rarely is there overstimulation as a result. There is plenty of laughter, fresh air & exercise however. Much better than throwing the Nintendo switch/iPad across the room because a game was lost.

This totally.

Also there a plenty of child led things to do that aren't screens but also aren't demands.

But then I'm not going to let my kids spend their childhood inside on screens all the time. They get plenty of that don't get me wrong, the will get days of factored in decompression but they will also have to go out a face the sunshine. They can sit and read a book on the swing seat. Go for a walk, go for a skate or bowling or soemthjng else heavy with satisfying sensory feedback. One of them often ends up sorting buttons, beads and similar if you take away all the screens. When people say don't just give them iPad all the time where not saying take them to Disney and have play dates everyday - force them into sensory overload - but there 100% are options. Have the decompression period and continue to have them throughout the holidays but the country is full of tweens and teens who just want to sit around on devices.

There are so many ways to regulate with asd. Screen time shouldn't be the only one and no child should be allowed to have weeks of it.
You may think you're doing them a favour but it's robbing them of opportunities to find other ways and other experiences.

www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1353829218305756

Createausername1970 · 27/03/2024 22:59

Interesting responses. I was a child in the 60s/70s. Being left to my own devices, spending the school holidays mooching about, reading etc., was the norm. If we were lucky, there might be one big outing in the summer holidays, but neither me or any of my friends were being taken out on a regular basis.

I have often wondered whether there is genuinely greater degree of ND now (and if so, why?), or is just that our way of life now means that kids could "cope" back then, but now the everyday expectations are just too much?

WaitingForMojo · 27/03/2024 22:58

Irisginger · 27/03/2024 22:55

Are your children younger? Teens can say what they need which needs to be respected.

I was wondering whether your children are young, too. When mine were young, we had a lovely wholesome time of reading and den building and play dough.

When they got to tween/teen age, it all hit the fan.

Irisginger · 27/03/2024 22:55

NaiceUser · 27/03/2024 22:51

@PostItInABook That's exactly what's being said. I think you need to read the thread again from the beginning

Are your children younger? Teens can say what they need which needs to be respected.

WaitingForMojo · 27/03/2024 22:55

NaiceUser · 27/03/2024 22:42

Why do so many people think that being Autistic means that no other aspects of health & wellbeing matter at all?

I manage to find a balance with my Autistic DC. Very rarely is there overstimulation as a result. There is plenty of laughter, fresh air & exercise however. Much better than throwing the Nintendo switch/iPad across the room because a game was lost.

That’s really fab that you and your dc have found that balance. I am autistic and have several autistic dc, and I think it’s what we’d all like to achieve. I found that when mine hit the teenage years it all got much harder.

I also think this is great when you are at a starting point of healthy equilibrium. It sounds like the OP’s dc isn’t there, after a term of school, and is verging on shutdown / burnout.

For my family, it’s definitely the case that if they are in school, there’s nothing left outside of that. One of my dc has been out of school a few months and only just getting to the point of joining outdoor activities / doing anything social again, it’s taken that long to recover from burnout.

i didn’t get this right for myself until I was diagnosed at 38… all my life, I thought my mental health was poor. It wasn’t. It was pure sensory overload. Now that I regulate it, I can do the outdoor stuff and socialise in my own way. Rather than losing the plot all the time, pushing through then crashing, in an endless cycle. But I do have to let myself shut down and decompress very regularly. I don’t do it for long periods any more, because I can do it regularly. A child in school can’t do that and will need to shut down for longer in order to cope, in many cases.

my experience is that when I back off, the children do show an interest in baking, fresh air, story writing, etc, when they’re ready, but pushing those things when they’re already overloaded leads to meltdown and burnout, and in that state, the good wholesome things aren’t good for them or what they need.

I hope that makes sense. I certainly don’t think all autistic people should play Roblox in a darkened room for the rest of their lives. What I do think is that for autistic people, learning to regulate and allow our brains to recover and recalibrate is extremely important and that pre wanting our children from doing that by imposing well meaning healthy and productive activity when they’re already overloaded isn’t good for anyone.

PostItInABook · 27/03/2024 22:55

No thanks. I read it fine the first time. Nobody has said other aspects of health & wellbeing doesn’t matter at all, but thanks for the patronising response. You carry on being the font of all knowledge, perfect parent to your kids and the rest of us autistic plebs can carry on using our own coping methods as we see fit. 👍

NaiceUser · 27/03/2024 22:53

@bloodyeffinnora There's no need to resort to name calling

muffledvoicesinyourhead · 27/03/2024 22:52

If you wouldn't begrudge an adult spending their free time relaxing, why should a child or teen 'need' a full calendar if they'd rather not? Yes, it's good to get some exercise and fresh air, and little things together as a family (or with her friends) would be fine, but that's plenty!

I treasure having time to enjoy my hobbies or just sit around streaming some entertainment. I'd really resent being 'forced' to go somewhere. It's such a relief, as an adult, to be free of the pressure to conform with someone else's idea of what I should be doing on my own time!

NaiceUser · 27/03/2024 22:51

@PostItInABook That's exactly what's being said. I think you need to read the thread again from the beginning

PostItInABook · 27/03/2024 22:49

NaiceUser · 27/03/2024 22:42

Why do so many people think that being Autistic means that no other aspects of health & wellbeing matter at all?

I manage to find a balance with my Autistic DC. Very rarely is there overstimulation as a result. There is plenty of laughter, fresh air & exercise however. Much better than throwing the Nintendo switch/iPad across the room because a game was lost.

I don’t think anyone is saying that. What they are saying is parents should allow their autistic kids the time and space to decompress properly in the way that works for them and stop trying to apply NT approaches to them. And also, what helps ‘well-being’ can be very different to the NT norm.

bloodyeffinnora · 27/03/2024 22:49

PassingStranger · 27/03/2024 21:39

How absolutely boring and strange. No exercise, no sunshine, no sport?

what a nasty little person you are

Librarybooker · 27/03/2024 22:49

So even if not ND, 12 is an important age when DCs let you know how they want to spend their time. It’s beyond the needing to go to a holiday club so you can work age. It’s the time when my NT DC told me no more tennis, cricket coaching. It’s the holidays, if your DC wants to chill, that is totally fine be they NT or NC.

Socialising in the hols is fine but not compulsory. FaceTime is socialising actually.

teacheroffsick · 27/03/2024 22:49

I'd say definitely go with what she's wanting to do in order to relax and recharge. Maybe get some walks in too.

Howmanysleepsnow · 27/03/2024 22:49

Everyone needs different things.
Personally, I need to be outside part of each day.
DD16 could spend all day in bed 6 days out of 7, but needs lots of social contact by FaceTime or text to be happy: for her, leaving the house is a bonus.
DS18 needs neither fresh air nor company (though he’ll talk my ear off). Exercise is important to him though, at the gym or at home with weights.
DS10 is a homebody and needs 4 days in pyjamas at the start of each school holiday to decompress. Gaming and TV play a big part, and it’s only after this he reengages and starts wanting to play out/ walk the dog/ go places.
DS12 likes to have plans. That can mean baking, football, ice skating, climbing, cinema… but he needs to know he’s something to do!
It can be tricky to balance everyone’s needs, but it’s so important that everyone gets what they want from their downtime. Good for your DD knowing what she needs and having confidence to ask for it!
fwiw, my 12yo is very tired atm and likely to rest much more than usual this Easter. He’s been taking himself to bed increasingly early and clearly needs a rest.

NaiceUser · 27/03/2024 22:48

@456pickupsticks 👏🏻 Completely agree. I do allow my DC down time. Like I said, I find a balance that suits well. I do agree though, boundaries are definitely still needed. Additional boundaries in some aspects. It just may need to be implemented in a different, more ND-considerate way.

ASimpleLampoon · 27/03/2024 22:46

Sounds ideal to me.

I have one autistic child with high support needs and a very sociable NT child. Both used to be cranky if I tried to outings activities every day in the hols. I soon learned dialling it down is best.

Maddy70 · 27/03/2024 22:46

She needs to relax. Whats wrong with resting and watching tv at home. Its a holiday..a recharge

Zanatdy · 27/03/2024 22:44

I’d 100% let her. My DD wants to do nothing but revise over Easter, who am I to step in her way!

Llamadramallama · 27/03/2024 22:43

Boundaries - my parents are wonderful, loving parents and they are only now (I’m late 30s) realising that their boundaries for their 4 children were inappropriate for me. I was a very well behaved child who got the top grades in the school in my GCSEs. But telling me I “had to” do things that if you had no experience of neurodiversity would be very normal - speak to every extended family member at an event, want to go out and see family or friends on a weeknight or in the holidays, not read all day and ask to have my book at the dining table - were not right in parenting a ND child. But it was self regulating and I internalised all of the “you must not do X” as “why are you so lazy and antisocial.” Your child coming to you and saying I need this, is a huge step for them

Swipe left for the next trending thread