Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to switch DD to packed lunch in juniors after FSM ends?

80 replies

bumburlinga · 27/03/2024 18:37

At our school most parents switch to packed lunches after FSM ends at end of Y2. I guess because of cost which is £2.10 a day. They’re good quality and she likes them. I LOVE the convenience and hate having to make a packed lunch (like now for Easter holiday club) and think this is worth my money.

DH isn’t here during the week and can’t see past the money aspect. He wants us (me) to start doing a pack up. This will soon turn into three lunchboxes I’m sure because I have 2 others at the school including one in the school nursery (I pay lunch because it’s not free until Reception) and I’m sure they won’t put up with biggest having a lunch box and their not having one just for the FOMO factor.

So AIBU paying for lunch after FSM ends when it would be cheaper to make?

OP posts:
NewName24 · 27/03/2024 20:53

Of course YANBU.
From your circumstances, you would only be saving about 50p a day, not £2.10 per day.
By the time you factor in your time, it makes much more sense to have school meals.
My dc had school dinners right through from Nursery to Year 13. We were lucky in that all their schools did nice meals.
It also meant that when we had a quick turn around after school (from when I got them from OoS Care to when they had to be a cubs or swimming or whatever) I had no problem giving them a sandwich or something on toast for tea, as they'd had a cooked meal and pudding at lunch time.
I'd 100% make the same decision again.

EVHead · 27/03/2024 20:50

“Hot” lunch LOL. They’re never anything but tepid/cold.

Youdontevengohere · 27/03/2024 20:46

idontlikealdi · 27/03/2024 20:28

School dinners are not 'substantial' here. The yR get the same portion as the Y6, and they're tiny. They're also £3.40 / day.

We are not allowed to send pastry, chocolate, cakes, nuts (understandable)). PITA

Ours are tiny portions too, and really poor quality. My 2 eldest children are brilliant with food and will eat most things, but they often can’t even identify the meal. I’ve heard ‘some sort of hard, chewy meat’ as a descriptor a few times! I wish they were decent, it would be so much easier.

idontlikealdi · 27/03/2024 20:28

School dinners are not 'substantial' here. The yR get the same portion as the Y6, and they're tiny. They're also £3.40 / day.

We are not allowed to send pastry, chocolate, cakes, nuts (understandable)). PITA

bumburlinga · 27/03/2024 20:15

vanillawaffle · 27/03/2024 19:39

Do they not let you use cling film?

Edited

No that’s me wanting to reduce single use plastic

OP posts:
Vitriolinsanity · 27/03/2024 20:09

My job involves oversight of the kitchen. We cook in house and our food is amazing. We take note of the School Council, and if the water suggests the kids don't like something we tweak it until they do. We consider ways to make things appeal to kids eyes and palettes.

Best thing is I get to QC and I eat with the kids to watch their reactions.

Favourite is Mac and cheese which we've recently added smashed tortilla chips too. Chatting to a caterer recently I'm also flirting with adding a dash of bbq sauce to the upper years.

One thing I'll say. The school dinner tables are comparatively easy to clean after a sitting. You might think your packed lunch goes down a storm if you get an empty box back, but the food that's chucked on the floor suggests strongly your kids think their contents were not as yummy as you'd thought.

nutbrownhare15 · 27/03/2024 19:58

Tell him that's absolutely fine as long as he makes them. I can't be bothered to make mine packed lunches either and won't even tell them it's an option. It probably does cost us money but the reduction in morning hassle is priceless to me.

lotsofpeoplenametheirswords · 27/03/2024 19:49

I agreed to packed lunches after the FSM came to an end. Do not make the same mistake! It was a ball ache. I don't have them, DH doesn't have them and I hate making them. I was thrilled to bits when he started comp in September and I didn't have to bother anymore.

Another one that doesn't get the hot meal thing!

vanillawaffle · 27/03/2024 19:39

bumburlinga · 27/03/2024 19:35

Glad I’m not the only one who hates making them. I think it’s the washing of the little tubs that gets me. Can’t bring myself to use disposable plastic bags for everything but that would speed things up maybe.

I’ll gently suggest DH could maybe make the saving elsewhere if he thinks it’s that tenner a week that will make the difference…(it’s not).

Typical lunchbox from this week at Easter holiday club costed at Sainsbury’s £1.57. Yes could be cheaper at Aldi or unbranded but Sainsbury’s is where I shop.

Frube 25p
Sandwich thin 23p
Ham 28p
1/6 cucumber 15p
1/4 pepper 15p
Banana 16p
Babybel 18p
Rocky bar 17p

Do they not let you use cling film?

Youdontevengohere · 27/03/2024 19:38

I absolutely hate making packed lunches and would happily pay for my kids to have school dinners, but the quality is poor at our school so I don’t.

bumburlinga · 27/03/2024 19:35

Glad I’m not the only one who hates making them. I think it’s the washing of the little tubs that gets me. Can’t bring myself to use disposable plastic bags for everything but that would speed things up maybe.

I’ll gently suggest DH could maybe make the saving elsewhere if he thinks it’s that tenner a week that will make the difference…(it’s not).

Typical lunchbox from this week at Easter holiday club costed at Sainsbury’s £1.57. Yes could be cheaper at Aldi or unbranded but Sainsbury’s is where I shop.

Frube 25p
Sandwich thin 23p
Ham 28p
1/6 cucumber 15p
1/4 pepper 15p
Banana 16p
Babybel 18p
Rocky bar 17p

OP posts:
Candleabra · 27/03/2024 19:34

daffodilandtulip · 27/03/2024 18:59

Making packed lunches everyday makes me want to pull my own eyes out.

Agreed. I’ve just posted on the “jobs you hate” thread and packed lunches is up there.

waterrat · 27/03/2024 19:31

Never wld i ever agree to packed lunches. Total hassle and having to think of yet more meals

vanillawaffle · 27/03/2024 19:29

What does your child want?

craigth162 · 27/03/2024 19:25

I HATE making packed lunches
£2.10 is a bargain to not have to.

Ioverslept · 27/03/2024 19:25

We pay 2.50 for the lunches and I don't even look at the menu any more, I think it is more varied than what they would get in a packed lunch plus it gets them used to eating different things and just what's there (one of mine actually eats better at school than at home it seems). We both work and it's one less thing to do plus I like them having a cooked meal, especially if we don't have to cook it! It's a small school and the chef is one of the mums and we know they are getting a decent meal. They have the occasional packed lunch as a treat (they love it) at the end of a half term or if one needs it for a trip or something then they might as well all get it, but it is very rare.

GlitterBall91 · 27/03/2024 19:25

My child is coeliac so I make her lunch boxes because of the risk of cross contamination.. if she wasn’t then she would DEFINITELY still be having school meals!! Making lunch boxes does my head in!!!!

FlyingPandas · 27/03/2024 19:25

DH isn’t here during the week

He wants us (me) to start doing a pack up.

If he's not here during the week then he doesn't get to choose. If he was home and willing to make up a packed lunch every day then fine. He's not, so tough.

(Though I guarantee that if you put him on daily packed lunch duties he would last possibly three days before putting DC on school lunches).

Amazing what dads announce they would like to happen whilst blithe in the knowledge that they will have none of the logistical faff!

A1ia · 27/03/2024 19:25

I don't like the faff of making packed lunches, but they are the only way to ensure my son actually has a decent lunch... I send him with a sandwich (bread from a 400g loaf as that's what we have at home or a muffin) or tuna pasta, at least one type of fruit (often chopped grapes, blueberries, a banana, an apple etc), a portion of veg (cucumber, carrot sticks etc), a savoury snack (such as a couple of crackers, a small packet of crisps or a mini pepperoni as he enjoys those) and a 'pudding' (which can be two biscuits, a pot of jelly, a homemade flapjack etc). My son is allergic to dairy and tomatoes so we have to be mindful.

At school, he often has a small muffin with tuna on and an apple. That's it for the school lunch... On a "good" day, he has a thin slice of chicken, two mini roast potatoes (like the frozen ones you can buy) and some broccoli...

I was really shocked when I did lunch duty and realised that even the Year 6s are being given portions like that. I suspect it is linked to cost cutting and the fact the dinners are provided by an external company, as - years ago - they used to be great when we had "in house" kitchen staff, who provided appropriately sized meals.

If the meals at your child's school are decent though, and they come home fed and happy, I'd definitely opt to keep them on school dinners.

whatsappdoc · 27/03/2024 19:24

So dh isn't there during the week? Well Sundays will be him making and freezing a week's worth of lunches!

caringcarer · 27/03/2024 19:23

trippily · 27/03/2024 18:51

A proper school meal is almost always going to be healthier than a packed lunch. All those sugary yogurts/juice boxes/fruit winders etc etc.

My son took a chicken and salad wrap and an apple, and either carrot sticks, cucumber sticks or a banana and water in his water bottle. Not everyone sends their kids off with sugary rubbish.

happyasharry · 27/03/2024 19:23

Did nobody read that OP where she says her husband isn't there in the week??

Causewerethespecialtwo · 27/03/2024 19:18

If husband doesn’t like the expense of school dinners then suggest to him that he can do a weekly food shop every Sunday - to buy everything for a week of lunchboxes. Then every evening he can make the lunchboxes and leave them in the fridge for the next morning.

If he isn’t willing to do that, then they will be having school dinners.

Overtheatlantic · 27/03/2024 19:18

ScottishScouser · 27/03/2024 18:43

Why a hot meal? Why does one meal a day have to be hot?

I do not understand why this is always trotted out.

I don’t get this either!

StedeBonnet · 27/03/2024 19:15

Mine had jacket potato and beans literally every day. At least with packed lunch I can vary it slightly!

Swipe left for the next trending thread