Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bikini sleeve trend, to not think it deserves so much praise!

186 replies

marbleeffect · 27/03/2024 18:33

Huge trend here at the moment of several Mum friends / colleagues going to Egypt for the fashionable new trend of having a Bikini Sleeve operation. I have 4 friends and several more acquaintances that have had it done recently. Off to Egypt they go, return home, disappear for a few weeks then slowly reappear several stone slimmer. The 4 friends I know have lost 33 stone between them.
AIBU to think having this procedure done doesn't deserve as much adoring praise as it gets?
Lots of FB / Insta comments of "Well done!"
They are all in debt from having it done and now considering getting in more debt for follow up operations to rid them of the excess skin.
I'm probably very naive at the recovery process, I've no doubt it is difficult and painful but I worry about the example it is setting.
Thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
crew2022 · 29/03/2024 09:31

@LiterallyOnFire you misunderstood me.
I'm saying the NHS is broken and can't afford bariatric surgery which does keep people alive longer term, when they can't afford surgery for a 10 year old who will have her life cut short.
I agree bariatric surgery is important and personally think it should be prioritised before gender reassignment etc but the reality is, there's no money.
So if people can afford to go to Egypt then I doubt the risks are worse than in a poorly staffed under funded NHS hospital.

ALongHardWinter · 28/03/2024 18:52

Scarramoosh · 27/03/2024 19:09

I thought this was going to be about bikinis with sleeves attached! 😆

Same here! 😂😂😂

queenMab99 · 28/03/2024 18:52

People who do this, are probably desperate, not lazy. You may not want or need to do it yourself, however it is not supportive or kind, to be judgemental towards your friends.

BamberBoozlerGrewUp · 28/03/2024 18:50

The sleeve can "not work" quite easily. It restricts how much you can consume in one portion. But it isn't a great amount of time before you can eat again, so you could theoretically repeat that portion every hour. Foods which require little breaking down (crisps, chocolate, cake, soups, ice cream etc etc) can also be eaten more easily than those higher in protein.

The bypass will cause dumping pretty quickly when you consume too much of a fatty or sugary food. It makes you really quite unwell so you're unlikely to repeat the experience. The bypass also works by reducing the amount of calories absorbed through the digestive system, but that also means the amount of nutrients absorbed is reduced.

BamberBoozlerGrewUp · 28/03/2024 18:43

LiterallyOnFire · 28/03/2024 07:15

No I didn't think it was you. Still a ludicrous but of marketing. There is much to be gained than nice bikini photos. It's a public health issue.

I do sympathise with you if your socials are full of "Bikini sleeve - you go girl!!!" Very grating and trivialising.

It's nothing to do with marketing. Its called a bikini sleeve because the incisions are in the bikini area as opposed to the abdomen.

BamberBoozlerGrewUp · 28/03/2024 18:40

flutterby1 · 28/03/2024 06:34

Maybe I'm wrong but I feel that people that have this lose sight of the fact that it CAN be done naturally by metabolic physiological processes in the body. It feels like you opt for surgery then have no choice but to eat little portions afterwards, eat properly etc. the surgery has forced you into it whereas one could have done it the natural way if they exerted the willpower, saved the physical abuse of the body with the strain and dangers of surgery and saved thousands of pounds for both the surgery and the excess food people no doubt eat until the last minute before slimming down for the surgery .

You are wrong, as has been explained numerous times.

For most very obese people, especially those who have dieted over prolonged periods, it is not possible to lose and maintain a substantial amount of weight. The body has lost the hormone regulation to govern when it is satisfied and when it is hungry, and the metabolism doesn't work as it should due to the requisite hormones not functioning properly.

Shizzlestix · 28/03/2024 17:12

Beautiful3 · 28/03/2024 09:05

How does it stop you from being addicted to food? Genuine question. At some point is the sleeve removed? Hypnotherapy might be a better alternative to stop binge eating.

Because so much capacity is removed, you cannot really overeat. Saying that, there are multiple posters on the surgery group I use who have asked about a revision to a bypass, which also involves malabsorption and the ‘next step’ of a sleeve has not worked wonders. My neighbour says a friend had a sleeve and ‘it didn’t work’. Ime, you would need to eat entirely the wrong thing for it not to work.

I went to the canteen at work today, they do free meals on training days. I had a piece of melon and some grapes and was full (I should have prioritised protein). It is extremely uncomfortable to try to eat more once full. Being full might be a half a ramekin size in the early days.

Juliansfunkyshoes · 28/03/2024 12:31

Sorry, but hell no.

People hate fat that much they risk their lives not to be. Its sad.

Still cant get over the story of the woman whose tit went septic and black and her nipple fell off, among other complications from a weight loss surgery abroad. The Doctor literally wiggled her fat in his hand in front of her face while she was on the table.

whynotwhatknot · 28/03/2024 11:07

Shizzlestix · 28/03/2024 07:06

The NHS may not do bloods/B12 injections, although my GP is delighted I’ve pretty much resolved my medical issues and was extremely keen to organise follow ups. If there’s an issue beyond the initial residual gas pain which can last a few days-mine was minimal and disappeared after some simple walking/swinging arms/hot water bottle-then of course you can access the NHS if you’re unwell. The group I linked has recommended surgeons in the UK and abroad. Research is key.

im gladyoure well just thinking worse case scenario

MattDamon · 28/03/2024 10:56

MorrisZapp · 27/03/2024 19:19

I don't believe anyone who is a size 16 got a gastric sleeve, sorry.

'Size 16' is a meaningless term anyway these days thanks to vanity sizing.

LiterallyOnFire · 28/03/2024 10:28

Lanawashington · 28/03/2024 08:45

@marbleeffect I think it's more the fact that the poster has been slating fat people, saying how awful they look and then it turns out their son was overweight. When it was him it's justified and he has his multiple reasons why he was overweight, but when it's someone else they are just fat and lazy...

Youngsters are really the only group who have any statistical chance of losing it and keeping it off, anyway. Even then it's not a big proportion of people who'll manage it, and we don't know that PP's son will keep it off long term.

soupfiend · 28/03/2024 10:20

LiterallyOnFire · 28/03/2024 08:45

I don't think @Candleab sounds defensive. She sounds irritated by the moralising and condescension.

@Candleab will be familiar with the science if she's had the procedure (it's part of the education and counselling that candidates are given) and once you're aware of the medical research underlying the inesity medicine discipline, then listening to all this moralistic twaddle is like eavesdropping on a bunch of medieval witch-hunters conducting a trial. Or flat earthers, or victorians insisting suicide is a sin, or something.

It's all just so much uneducated wittering, and really not helpful to the public health message. One wonders whether some of these posters go though life telling anorexics to pull themselves together and just eat.

This, this!!!

Society hates fat people

Society hates fat people that lose weight the 'wrong' way.

soupfiend · 28/03/2024 10:18

Beautiful3 · 28/03/2024 09:05

How does it stop you from being addicted to food? Genuine question. At some point is the sleeve removed? Hypnotherapy might be a better alternative to stop binge eating.

Most people who are overweight/obese are not 'addicted to food', we as a culture and country just eat too much of the wrong things, its a simple as that. We are not physically nor psychologically different to the vast majority of humans around the world

A sleeve is misnamed, gastric sleeve surgery removes around 80% of your stomach so you dont have the big bulge at the bottom of your stomach where food sits, it turns it into a sleeve shape.

Its not reversible but there is a new sleeve surgery which is, which essentially just sews up your stomach so that its in the same shape as a sleeve, smaller, and enables weight loss in the same way. I dont know how effective that one is.

Giggorata · 28/03/2024 09:16

I have a friend who underwent this surgery some years ago and you wouldn't recognise her. She went blonde and took up all sorts of sports and so on. It transformed her life and outlook.
She was morbidly obese and very unhappy before.

Sean Murphy, the Snooker player, had this procedure, after lifelong struggles with weight. He is quite open about it and I think (hope) is happier and doing well.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/snooker/63373974

Shaun Murphy

Shaun Murphy: Ex-world champion opens up on reasons for 'life-changing' stomach surgery

Shaun Murphy says reaching "the bottom of my mental health" convinced him to brave "life-changing" stomach surgery.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/snooker/63373974

LiterallyOnFire · 28/03/2024 09:13

BTW, you can't "remove the sleeve" or reverse the operation. Gastric sleeve surgery means cutting away more stomach than you leave behind and stapling the cut edge so it becomes a "sleeve" rather than stomach shaped. It's a serious surgery.

LiterallyOnFire · 28/03/2024 09:11

Beautiful3 · 28/03/2024 09:05

How does it stop you from being addicted to food? Genuine question. At some point is the sleeve removed? Hypnotherapy might be a better alternative to stop binge eating.

m.youtube.com/watch?v=VwSz7SuHs9w&pp=ygUeQmFyaWF0cmljIHN1cmdlcnkgZGljdW1lYW50YXJ5

It's a really good film. Not hard going but very informative.

Beautiful3 · 28/03/2024 09:05

How does it stop you from being addicted to food? Genuine question. At some point is the sleeve removed? Hypnotherapy might be a better alternative to stop binge eating.

LiterallyOnFire · 28/03/2024 08:45

marbleeffect · 28/03/2024 08:25

@Candleab But you asked @theeyeofdoe a question about whether her son had any conditions, she answered you and now you don't like the answer?

Your surgery has worked for you, her Sons exercise and eating less has worked for him.
It's obvious you're fiercely defensive about your chosen weight loss surgery but not very respectful of others chosen methods.

I don't think @Candleab sounds defensive. She sounds irritated by the moralising and condescension.

@Candleab will be familiar with the science if she's had the procedure (it's part of the education and counselling that candidates are given) and once you're aware of the medical research underlying the inesity medicine discipline, then listening to all this moralistic twaddle is like eavesdropping on a bunch of medieval witch-hunters conducting a trial. Or flat earthers, or victorians insisting suicide is a sin, or something.

It's all just so much uneducated wittering, and really not helpful to the public health message. One wonders whether some of these posters go though life telling anorexics to pull themselves together and just eat.

Lanawashington · 28/03/2024 08:45

@marbleeffect I think it's more the fact that the poster has been slating fat people, saying how awful they look and then it turns out their son was overweight. When it was him it's justified and he has his multiple reasons why he was overweight, but when it's someone else they are just fat and lazy...

HarrietPierce · 28/03/2024 08:35

RE Dr. Tamer

"British trained (or has become an expert by furthering his studies in British hospitals). Very well thought of in the weightloss surgery circles, no deaths, known for no leaks (something that is very dangerous post wl surgery) Regular on the lecture circuit in the UK."

It seems that Medstudent12 can't get her head around the fact that some Egyptian surgeons are excellent.

marbleeffect · 28/03/2024 08:25

@Candleab But you asked @theeyeofdoe a question about whether her son had any conditions, she answered you and now you don't like the answer?

Your surgery has worked for you, her Sons exercise and eating less has worked for him.
It's obvious you're fiercely defensive about your chosen weight loss surgery but not very respectful of others chosen methods.

OP posts:
Shizzlestix · 28/03/2024 08:06

Candleab · 28/03/2024 08:00

But they do?

I've had NHS aftercare for 3 years now without any issue at all?

Edited

Some GPS are refusing follow up procedures given the recently published guidelines. As you can read from my posts, I am fortunate to have a great GP who has helped enormously but the new guidelines state that the GP does not have to do follow up bloods/B12. This is extremely common according to the group I linked, with reference to private surgery or for those who've gone abroad.

Candleab · 28/03/2024 08:00

Shizzlestix · 28/03/2024 07:06

The NHS may not do bloods/B12 injections, although my GP is delighted I’ve pretty much resolved my medical issues and was extremely keen to organise follow ups. If there’s an issue beyond the initial residual gas pain which can last a few days-mine was minimal and disappeared after some simple walking/swinging arms/hot water bottle-then of course you can access the NHS if you’re unwell. The group I linked has recommended surgeons in the UK and abroad. Research is key.

But they do?

I've had NHS aftercare for 3 years now without any issue at all?

Candleab · 28/03/2024 07:59

theeyeofdoe · 27/03/2024 22:10

multiple reasons. He was a bit sad at school, liked eating, I’m a good cook (healthy one -we only noticed he was late night eating at a later date as he’s tall). We didn’t make a massive deal out of it and he lost the weight when he was ready.

Does he have a SEN -, he has an ECHP
is that enough for you?

Oh so you can make excuses got your own kid but everyone else is just fat and lazy.

Give over.

Coming on here acting like it's awful to be fat then dropping you have a fat kid.

Shizzlestix · 28/03/2024 07:25

I booked another renowned surgeon abroad, Dr Tuna in Turkey, following extensive research. I then cancelled because I’m not good flying and would have been travelling solo. I then took out a policy with Vitality, the only health insurance that offers weightloss surgery in the UK. It was £2600 for a bypass (slightly more now).

I wasn’t prepared to wait for years on the NHS (up to 4 years, no guarantee of patients ever getting to Tier 4 which is surgery). I was sent to a very local private hospital and have had lots of follow ups from the surgeon who I believe is Sri Lankan-just saying that because people seem to be doubting the expertise/care of foreign surgeons on here-and operates at a major city hospital also.

Since my surgery last year, I’ve lost 8 stones. I had previously lost similar through diet and extreme exercise and it all went back on following multiple medical issues/an incident which limited my mobility. I was in hospital for multiple problems some months before the surgery. I could not have done it again through exercise.

I believe it is a life saving/life extending operation. I was a size 26 last July, now a 16, so still a way to go, it’s now a question of self control/new habits, massively supported by physically being unable to overeat.