Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask to stop your children ‘play’ screaming?

392 replies

JediKnightingale · 27/03/2024 16:03

I live in a cul de sac where we have around six families with small children (weirdly, all girls - not relevant I know) that range from ages 2 - 7. They all walk to school together with parents and at home time they congregate in the middle of the close. Mums chatting and the entire gaggle of tiny noise machines run around screaming for absolutely no reason for about 30/45 mins depending on the weather. During the holidays or at weekends they can be out there for hours at a time.

I and quite a few others work from home in our road - my home office is in the front part of my house and I literally cannot take or make phone calls due to the racket. Normal play noise is absolutely fine but WHY do parents put up with this stupid screaming? When my 3 were small I would never have allowed it but it doesn’t seem to even register with these parents.

Do you let your children play scream and if so would you be put out if you were asked (nicely) if they could play WITHOUT THE SCREAMS?

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 28/03/2024 10:33

CagneyAndLazy · Yesterday 16:05
**
Get your flame suit on, OP!”

Why? There is no reason why children have to scream when they’re playing. Ours didn’t, was never an issue 🤷‍♀️

Needmorelego · 28/03/2024 10:31

@DodoTired then you are lucky.
I live next to a primary school and a play area.
It is a regular noise.
Thankfully the school staff tell them to stop.
When it's the play area and parents are in charge - they don't tell them to stop.
It is seriously like the sound of someone being murdered on a loop for sometimes hours.

user1471554720 · 28/03/2024 10:31

When I was young, if we behaved in a boisterous way when playing, or heaven forbid, screaming, we would be told that playing in groups 'overexcites' us, and playdates, visitors to our house with dcs would be stopped for months.

It was not framed as a punishment. It was framed as 'it is bad to get overexcited' and 'we are not mature enough to play properly'.

I hate seeing others screaming and getting away with it. God forbid, if any of them got hurted I would ignore, as they are screaming anyway!!

DodoTired · 28/03/2024 10:28

Needmorelego · 28/03/2024 10:22

All this "they're just playing blah blah" nonsense - do people really not get what is meant by "screaming"?
You know when at 3 am when you are woken by a blood curdling scream that you can't decide is the local foxes mating or a woman being murdered - it's that sound.
For (often) hours on end. That is NOT playing or kids being kids.
It's anti social shit.
Please note I do not include children who have SEN and can't help it - but all other children need to shut up and stop doing that noise.

Ive never heard blood curling screaming from children and don’t see any difference between “normal shouting” which is apparently ok and “screaming”
which is apparently not. What is this imaginary screaming?

Excited101 · 28/03/2024 10:28

Kids should be able to let off steam outside, running, calling out, laughing, the odd shriek. Screaming shouldn’t be allowed- it’s an extra level that isn’t ever necessary. I was never allowed to do it, and none of the children I’ve ever looked after have been allowed to, either. They need to be encouraged to think about the people in their houses and gardens nearby, and if it’s a nice noise for them to have to listen to- the more they can be encouraged to think about others, the nicer the world could be.

DodoTired · 28/03/2024 10:25

Pepsiisbetterthancoke · 28/03/2024 10:18

Where has anyone said absolute quiet?

People do put up with chatting, playing, general sounds but screaming that is being talked about here is something very different.

If you think they are the same then you are obviously like the parents that are being discussed here

The OP complains about 30 minutes. It is ridiculous.

Needmorelego · 28/03/2024 10:22

All this "they're just playing blah blah" nonsense - do people really not get what is meant by "screaming"?
You know when at 3 am when you are woken by a blood curdling scream that you can't decide is the local foxes mating or a woman being murdered - it's that sound.
For (often) hours on end. That is NOT playing or kids being kids.
It's anti social shit.
Please note I do not include children who have SEN and can't help it - but all other children need to shut up and stop doing that noise.

rainbowtinsel · 28/03/2024 10:21

Oh God I can’t stand it…..my DF, DC’s Grandad did a lot of childcare for me before DC went to school and whilst he was so soft on comparison to how he was with me and my siblings…..the one thing which he drew a hard solid line on from day dot was play screaming! Thus DC does not do it!

It seems to continue into the teenage years as well used to live

Pepsiisbetterthancoke · 28/03/2024 10:18

DodoTired · 28/03/2024 10:06

We are talking here about 30 MINUTES only. Surely it goes both ways. If people want their needs to be taken into account they need to be taking not only their needs into account too. Kids do need to run around, shout and let off steam a little (especially after school, for 30 mins for Christ sake)
it is unreasonable to demand constant quiet 24/7
live and let live

Where has anyone said absolute quiet?

People do put up with chatting, playing, general sounds but screaming that is being talked about here is something very different.

If you think they are the same then you are obviously like the parents that are being discussed here

BriceNobeslovesMurielHeslop · 28/03/2024 10:17

OP states that it’s AT LEAST 30-45 minutes daily, with it going on for hours some days depending on the weather or time of year.
Nobody is complaining about normal play noises or chatting, it’s about whether screaming is necessary during play and whether it is anti-social or not.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 28/03/2024 10:15

DodoTired · 28/03/2024 09:17

There is (should be) noone in residential area except parents, kids and some curmudgeons pensioners who should get a grip (because life certainly doesn’t revolve around them even if Tory party makes them believe otherwise)

Where are the childless people supposed to live?

brunettemic · 28/03/2024 10:12

Honestly, there’s all this whining in society about how kids sit indoors on screens and now there’s whining about them playing outdoors. It’s a small proportion of your day and I don’t buy for a second you can’t make calls with the noise unless your house doesn’t have windows with glass in them.

DodoTired · 28/03/2024 10:06

Pepsiisbetterthancoke · 28/03/2024 09:58

I may be British but I am certainly not middle class or have a stiff upper lip

But yes I do judge bad parenting and that does include not being aware that there are other people trying to live their life, whether that’s working, sleeping because they have been on a night shift or just want to watch the tv

We are talking here about 30 MINUTES only. Surely it goes both ways. If people want their needs to be taken into account they need to be taking not only their needs into account too. Kids do need to run around, shout and let off steam a little (especially after school, for 30 mins for Christ sake)
it is unreasonable to demand constant quiet 24/7
live and let live

Pepsiisbetterthancoke · 28/03/2024 09:58

DodoTired · 28/03/2024 09:46

It makes people look like a bad parent only to a certain category of BRITISH people. Many other cultures are less stuffy and dont have “children should be seen and not heard” culture. Are they all wrong and the only way is a British middle class way? Britain isn’t known for producing happy people, it is known for producing reserved “stiff upper lip” people which actually isn’t psychologically healthy.

I may be British but I am certainly not middle class or have a stiff upper lip

But yes I do judge bad parenting and that does include not being aware that there are other people trying to live their life, whether that’s working, sleeping because they have been on a night shift or just want to watch the tv

BriceNobeslovesMurielHeslop · 28/03/2024 09:58

DodoTired · 28/03/2024 09:46

It makes people look like a bad parent only to a certain category of BRITISH people. Many other cultures are less stuffy and dont have “children should be seen and not heard” culture. Are they all wrong and the only way is a British middle class way? Britain isn’t known for producing happy people, it is known for producing reserved “stiff upper lip” people which actually isn’t psychologically healthy.

There’s always a poster that is determined that “other” children frolic and scream unabashed while their parents look on beaming, while all British children live a life akin to a Dickensian orphan.

Which countries are these? Who says they are healthier? What’s the measure of healthy anyway?

OnceinaMinion · 28/03/2024 09:50

What a load of bollocks. Most people like hearing children playing normally.
Just being able to scream blue murder and make as much noise as they like is not normal. Children are part of the community and therefore have to act that way too.
It’s like parents who left their children run amok in restaurants because ‘they’re enjoying themselves’ and spoiling it for everyone.

DodoTired · 28/03/2024 09:46

Pepsiisbetterthancoke · 28/03/2024 09:29

It really is spot the twatty folks that are failing at parenting on this thread

Interesting that folks are thinking that someone who commented on people being unsociable is the one that’s getting the blame (don’t wfh, but things like headphones and soundproofing that you don’t need)

The world doesn’t revolve around your screaming kids and just makes you look like a bad parent. And before you say it this doesn’t include those with medical needs but not all screamers are doing that uncontrollably

It makes people look like a bad parent only to a certain category of BRITISH people. Many other cultures are less stuffy and dont have “children should be seen and not heard” culture. Are they all wrong and the only way is a British middle class way? Britain isn’t known for producing happy people, it is known for producing reserved “stiff upper lip” people which actually isn’t psychologically healthy.

BriceNobeslovesMurielHeslop · 28/03/2024 09:35

DodoTired · 28/03/2024 09:17

There is (should be) noone in residential area except parents, kids and some curmudgeons pensioners who should get a grip (because life certainly doesn’t revolve around them even if Tory party makes them believe otherwise)

Er, what? I’m neither a parent, kid or a curmudgeonly pensioner- where do I go?
I used to work night shift. You’re right that normal life can’t stop but screaming outside my house for half an hour every afternoon?
Also, people are “curmudgeonly” because they don’t love the sound of screaming? Do you hear yourself?

Pepsiisbetterthancoke · 28/03/2024 09:29

It really is spot the twatty folks that are failing at parenting on this thread

Interesting that folks are thinking that someone who commented on people being unsociable is the one that’s getting the blame (don’t wfh, but things like headphones and soundproofing that you don’t need)

The world doesn’t revolve around your screaming kids and just makes you look like a bad parent. And before you say it this doesn’t include those with medical needs but not all screamers are doing that uncontrollably

Caravaggiouch · 28/03/2024 09:28

Meowandthen · 28/03/2024 08:02

You're one of those selfish parents, aren't you? Think the workd revolves around your screaming brats.

I only have one brat and she doesn’t scream, so unlucky.

DodoTired · 28/03/2024 09:17

Naunet · 28/03/2024 09:08

It’s a residential area FFS, it doesn’t matter if she’s working or not, NO ONE wants to listen to kids screaming. Is there no consideration for other people left? So many selfish, entitled, lazy parents around.

There is (should be) noone in residential area except parents, kids and some curmudgeons pensioners who should get a grip (because life certainly doesn’t revolve around them even if Tory party makes them believe otherwise)

Naunet · 28/03/2024 09:08

DodoTired · 28/03/2024 09:05

I mean, the OP also thinks the world revolves around her. She can work in the office in an area without screaming children, but she chooses to work from home - no doubt for her convenience, but why is it everyone else’s problem? Just because adults now want to WFH for their own benefit it doesn’t mean that the world should start revolving around them to minimise all domestic noise

It’s a residential area FFS, it doesn’t matter if she’s working or not, NO ONE wants to listen to kids screaming. Is there no consideration for other people left? So many selfish, entitled, lazy parents around.

Malarandras · 28/03/2024 09:06

Noise cancelling headphones?

DodoTired · 28/03/2024 09:05

Meowandthen · 28/03/2024 08:02

You're one of those selfish parents, aren't you? Think the workd revolves around your screaming brats.

I mean, the OP also thinks the world revolves around her. She can work in the office in an area without screaming children, but she chooses to work from home - no doubt for her convenience, but why is it everyone else’s problem? Just because adults now want to WFH for their own benefit it doesn’t mean that the world should start revolving around them to minimise all domestic noise

Meowandthen · 28/03/2024 08:02

Caravaggiouch · 27/03/2024 20:27

If she doesn’t have an office then I’d recommend headphones. Mine were £8. Hth.

You're one of those selfish parents, aren't you? Think the workd revolves around your screaming brats.

Swipe left for the next trending thread