Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable to dread visits of my husbands sister

139 replies

JaneMumofTwins · 27/03/2024 15:53

About twice a year we see my husbands sister and her husband. What happens is I get left with her and my husband finds 'manly' things to do with her husband. This would be OK if I found her company remotely agreeable but I don't. She is a stream of consciousness talker and a major hypochondriac. She talks over me continually and if she wasn't my husbands sister I would have no problem in just telling her to STFU, but I am hamstrung by family duty. I find her company so difficult I stop sleeping properly when she is in the house. I am sure she means well but I have endured 3 hours of her tedious boiler story and now she has underfloor heating issues I have completely lost the will to live. I have told husband that if he leaves me alone to deal with her again I will divorce him but I know that it will just repeat itself. How do I get her to shut up without killing her? Am I being unreasonable feeling this way?

OP posts:
Renamed · 27/03/2024 22:46

what if… she DREADS coming to stay, but was taught that a guest must always continue conversation so as not to burden the host? Half an hour in and she is listening in horror to the sound of her own voice gabbling about the boiler, but as you (to her relief) do seem to be interested, she moves on to under floor heating as a related topic.. all the time wishing that she too could have gone clay pigeon shooting or whatever it is… Could you not drag her out to something you are interested in? Preferably something noisy. Or insist that you all four spend a day playing bridge, I believe it is absolutely obligatory to hate each other whilst doing so.

easylikeasundaymorn · 27/03/2024 22:33

Just either do the 'manly' things with your husband or book in lots of plans yourself - work, days out with friends etc. and leave them to it. His family, his invite = his responsibility to entertain them.
I doubt you invite your relatives to stay for up to a week and then leave your DH to look after them.

Seperateaccount · 27/03/2024 22:29

Repeat everything she says back at her, word for word. If she trys to interrupt, keep talking.

Walkingwashingmachine · 27/03/2024 22:27

And Austen is full of people that talk too much and say little of consequence and she takes a very dim view of those sorts!

Walkingwashingmachine · 27/03/2024 22:23

izimbra · 27/03/2024 21:53

"Not sure where ypu have been for the last 300 years but we don't have to live like it's the 18th century any more. Things have moved on. We don't need men to "chasten" young women for speaking their mind, and it is possible to do so politely but firmly. We can even vote and own property now."

You want to frame Emma being told she's been a mean spirited cow, when she HAS been a mean spirited cow, as a feminist issue?

And yup - obviously we're all now entitled to sneer at socially awkward family members we rarely see, and to feel personally victimised by have to be bored by them for a few hours. Up the sisterhood! Hmm

Emma was a mean spirited cow but the point was that Miss Bates was her social inferior. If she was Emma's equal, Emma would be able to find her chat very annoying and say what she said with impunity. I'm assuming therefore that using "Emma" is not applicable here as social class is not relevant. I may be wrong.

izimbra · 27/03/2024 21:53

"Not sure where ypu have been for the last 300 years but we don't have to live like it's the 18th century any more. Things have moved on. We don't need men to "chasten" young women for speaking their mind, and it is possible to do so politely but firmly. We can even vote and own property now."

You want to frame Emma being told she's been a mean spirited cow, when she HAS been a mean spirited cow, as a feminist issue?

And yup - obviously we're all now entitled to sneer at socially awkward family members we rarely see, and to feel personally victimised by have to be bored by them for a few hours. Up the sisterhood! Hmm

PermanentTemporary · 27/03/2024 21:51

A week?? Jeez. Surely next time you will have a work crisis that means you have to go in after 3 days.

I would plan a lot of lengthy non talking group activities. Dune 2 is 2.5 hours long, for example. Or go and see a Shakespeare play. Or go for a long walk together? I find boring conversation is much more soothing when in motion.

Send them off to some sort of activity for the day and meet for dinner in the evening? Plenty of alcohol then plead exhaustion and an early night. I think most of my family believe I go to bed at 9pm and get up at 10am. Or learn to play bridge - you're not allowed to talk during the game AFAIK.

Applescruffle · 27/03/2024 21:45

izimbra · 27/03/2024 21:04

Do you remember the picnic scene at Boxhill in Emma?

Emma is musing on one of the elderly widows in the party being tedious and makes a quip about how dull she is, which deeply hurts her feelings.

Later on Mr Knightly takes her to task for being a mean spirited and ungracious biatch.

He's right of course, and Emma is chastened.

OP - take note.

Look, I love Jane Austen as much as the next person but behave.

Not sure where ypu have been for the last 300 years but we don't have to live like it's the 18th century any more. Things have moved on. We don't need men to "chasten" young women for speaking their mind, and it is possible to do so politely but firmly. We can even vote and own property now.

Applescruffle · 27/03/2024 21:38

God, this sounds horrendous, OP. You poor thing. Who the fuck talks about their boiler for three hours? I would die.

Your DH is being really out of order. Stop letting him bugger off and leave you with boiler-bore while he has his man fun with his mate. You do things as a group or she doesn't come. Clearly he knows how annoying she is or he wouldn't be leaving her with you. It's absolutely not on that's he's doing that to you.

PassingStranger · 27/03/2024 21:35

Perhaps she dreads visting too.
Take some of the pressure off. Put on some music, or a film. People dont just sit there talking all the time do they.

tttigress · 27/03/2024 21:31

I assumed you only had to see her for 1 day twice a year. In which case I was going to say yabu.

But 4 days to a week, twice a year is quite a bit. Why do they visit so often?

I think you should at least reduce by about 50%

Leeds2 · 27/03/2024 21:27

I would make sure that DH planned activities that were suitable for all four of you to do together. Or think of some yourself, and book them up.

Shinyandnew1 · 27/03/2024 21:25

4-7 days for a visit is far too long! How far away do they live?

What happens is I get left with her and my husband finds 'manly' things to do with her husband.

Like what?

Walkingwashingmachine · 27/03/2024 21:23

izimbra · 27/03/2024 21:04

Do you remember the picnic scene at Boxhill in Emma?

Emma is musing on one of the elderly widows in the party being tedious and makes a quip about how dull she is, which deeply hurts her feelings.

Later on Mr Knightly takes her to task for being a mean spirited and ungracious biatch.

He's right of course, and Emma is chastened.

OP - take note.

Disagree. People should have some self-awareness. If they button hole someone and talk at them relentlessly about subject only of interest to themselves and show no interest in the other person at all, thats bad manners. So many people do it and I always think why don't you ask the other person a single question about themselves. If you're not interested in them why do you assume they are interested in you.

m00ngirl · 27/03/2024 21:04

I'd just drink through it tbh

izimbra · 27/03/2024 21:04

GalileoHumpkins · 27/03/2024 16:51

She sounds like a Jane Austen character!

Do you remember the picnic scene at Boxhill in Emma?

Emma is musing on one of the elderly widows in the party being tedious and makes a quip about how dull she is, which deeply hurts her feelings.

Later on Mr Knightly takes her to task for being a mean spirited and ungracious biatch.

He's right of course, and Emma is chastened.

OP - take note.

izimbra · 27/03/2024 20:59

Maybe she gabbles because she senses your contempt for her & she's nervous.

People generally know when you don't like them.

She's probably dreading the visits more than you.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 27/03/2024 18:11

JaneMumofTwins · 27/03/2024 17:41

They stay for 4 days to 1 week.

Leave the country next time they're due to visit.

A WEEK???

JaneMumofTwins · 27/03/2024 17:41

Talipesmum · 27/03/2024 16:08

Basically this.
How long is this for? A day, a week?

If it’s longer than maybe a day, then yes I’d possibly be busy for some of it.

They stay for 4 days to 1 week.

OP posts:
ViciousCurrentBun · 27/03/2024 17:17

Your DH needs to stop going off doing manly things whatever they are. Cheeky bugger that he is.

I must admit I have a very old dear friend who has become a bit like this. I have known her for decades and was delighted when she met a man mid forties and married. That’s what she had always hoped for. He is the most tedious dullard and she has morphed in to a version of him. She sends me very long messages about x that take forever. She went on about ham once for three whole days.

Marine30 · 27/03/2024 16:56

This is your husband’s sister. He needs to step up. Why is he off the hook and away with the husband all the time? That is rude on his part and unfair to you. DH needs to get more involved in this for the next visit. Perhaps you should hang out with the husband and DH can have some special time with his sister.

catmomma67 · 27/03/2024 16:54

it seems a little unfair that your husband choses to spend time out of the house with his brother in law leaving you to deal with his sister. surely activites sould include everyone, otherwise whats the point of her coming to visit. i wouldn't stand for it, its HIS sister, HE should be present to deal with her.

GalileoHumpkins · 27/03/2024 16:51

She sounds like a Jane Austen character!

Walkingwashingmachine · 27/03/2024 16:47

Why do people feel its appropriate to bore the f out of people with their relentless crap. Your SiL is the one being rude to you so you are perfectly allowed to be rude back by saying that you have to do something else rather than talk to her. You might be doing her a favour by giving her a hint that her chat isnt up to scratch. And I bet your DH and her husband know how boring she is too and that's why they both do a runner as soon as they can.

toomanyy · 27/03/2024 16:42

Fulshaw · 27/03/2024 16:19

All these posters suggesting the OP be busy or make other plans. Bit rude when you know they’re coming to visit!

Why is it ok for the SIL to be rude by dominating the conversation and showing no interest in OP and for OP’s DH to dump his OWN SISTER on OP, but it’s not ok for OP to absent herself?

The sister should be coming to see her brother. The brother shouldn’t be running from his own sister.