Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable to dread visits of my husbands sister

139 replies

JaneMumofTwins · 27/03/2024 15:53

About twice a year we see my husbands sister and her husband. What happens is I get left with her and my husband finds 'manly' things to do with her husband. This would be OK if I found her company remotely agreeable but I don't. She is a stream of consciousness talker and a major hypochondriac. She talks over me continually and if she wasn't my husbands sister I would have no problem in just telling her to STFU, but I am hamstrung by family duty. I find her company so difficult I stop sleeping properly when she is in the house. I am sure she means well but I have endured 3 hours of her tedious boiler story and now she has underfloor heating issues I have completely lost the will to live. I have told husband that if he leaves me alone to deal with her again I will divorce him but I know that it will just repeat itself. How do I get her to shut up without killing her? Am I being unreasonable feeling this way?

OP posts:
JaneMumofTwins · 28/03/2024 13:27

izimbra · 28/03/2024 11:28

Epic levels of unkindness evident on this thread, and everyone cheering each other on.
😔

Quite frankly I am now assuming you are another one like my SIL.

OP posts:
Whatifthehokeycokey · 28/03/2024 13:10

You need to book your annual appointments in. Opticians. Dentist. Just book them all in and spread them out.

Whatifthehokeycokey · 28/03/2024 13:08

It's his sister. He should be making the effort to engage with her.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 28/03/2024 13:00

and refuses to watch what we all like

Watch what she likes?

LadyAddle · 28/03/2024 12:57

I feel for you - I would be homicidal after four days of nonstop chatter. I'm wondering if you're in the Hebrides or similar, in which case options of carting her off to an art gallery or museum are a bit more limited. I think the frank statement that your health requires a daily rest period might buy you some respite - hard to argue against that.

stayathomer · 28/03/2024 12:47

I can’t stop laughing that this reply: Do you remember the picnic scene at Boxhill in Emma?

Emma is musing on one of the elderly widows in the party being tedious and makes a quip about how dull she is, which deeply hurts her feelings.

Later on Mr Knightly takes her to task for being a mean spirited and ungracious biatch.

He's right of course, and Emma is chastened.

OP - take note. by izimbra

is followed by I'd just drink through it tbh by m00ngirl

😅

thepastinsidethepresent · 28/03/2024 12:41

She sounds incredibly hard work. I'd put a film on and then at least even if she talks through it there's a chance that the talk will be something you can both engage in. And if not, you can tune her out to an extent? May seem rude, but her behaviour doesn't sound all that polite either.

CastlesinSpain · 28/03/2024 12:40

Take her to a theme park? A few rides on a vomit inducing roller coaster should shut her up 😁.
But I do sympathise. My husband has a friend whose wife whitters on endlessly about nothing in particular, but at least I don't have to endure it for days on end. I'd be inclined to at least get out of the house - go to the shops - museum - zoo - at least you'd have something interesting to look at and you could maybe tune her out.

caringcarer · 28/03/2024 12:39

Next time they arrive be out with a friend. Simples.

concernedchild · 28/03/2024 12:35

You seem very dramatic that seeing someone you find boring is enough for you to lose sleep

Nurder · 28/03/2024 12:34

Are you being held hostage? You've made yourself out to be a victim. You're a grown woman. Structure the visit differently. Do activities you can all join in. Tell DH you don't want to host her alone. Have a frank conversation and kindly tell her it bothers you. She sounds harmless and like DHs sister who has raging ADHD. She talks over everyone and can't focus to watch TV. She's completely mortified but can't control it. We work around it because we aren't utter pricks.

Roselilly36 · 28/03/2024 12:26

This would be my worst nightmare, if you met DH sis, you would get it!

Dweetfidilove · 28/03/2024 12:24

Practise nodding off mid relentless crap 🤷🏽‍♀️.

Imgoingtobefree · 28/03/2024 12:21

I had a husband who would do this. Tell me we are invited to a weekend with family, get there and find out it was a cycling weekend for the men. Luckily I got on ok with my SIL.

I think you need to take control of these visits. Find out exactly what the men are planning to do, or preempt them by making plans that you can all do.

If the men just retire together to the shed, be a drip and follow them out there, and stick like glue.

Or do what one SIL did. I got roped into going to some concert (think lift music) with my SIL, BIL and husband. It was all organised by my SIL. When we got there she was the only one absent. I think she was home cooking - nice one SIL!!!

IsawwhatIsaw · 28/03/2024 12:21

One day might be ok, 4 days to a week isn’t.
Your DH shouldn’t be inviting her then basically disappearing off leaving you to deal with her. That’s disrespectful.
Either he steps up and actually spends time with her, or I’d arrange to be out all the time .

LlynTegid · 28/03/2024 12:13

Your DH with your support needs to limit visits, ideally to none at all or just for the day.

I wonder if your DH secretly would be grateful not to have her visit.

Daffodilsarentfluffy · 28/03/2024 12:10

Wear 1 ear bud... And half listen whilst listening to something better?
Have a lie down /long bath /unavoidable appointment /friend in crisis need to pop out /dentist /garden centre trip and lose her. Very easy ime...

areyoutheregod · 28/03/2024 12:08

Could you not at least say, politely, I really have to ask that you stop talking over me? I do have people I kind of have to see that I find a bit painful, but not for the length of time you do. I had an Aunt similar and I always got stuck talking to her, it was so tedious. My partner would just stand up and leave! However 4 days to a week is a long time to be stuck with someone. Can you organise things like meeting friends or something you have to do alone, out of the house, for some of the time? Failing that, 'I feel unwell and need some peace and quiet in my room' is a very reasonable thing to say.

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · 28/03/2024 12:05

Sorry, OP, I missed your post about limited cinema and theatre options, and your own health needs.

I think it would be fair to warn them in advance that you need two hours a day resting alone and in silence in order to manage your health. And that you don't have the energy for x days of visit so it can only be x days.

mindutopia · 28/03/2024 12:04

Just go out for the days and leave him to entertain them. I always find a million errands to do with BIL and partner are here because I tire of them. They come for like a week at a time and park up in our house and want to talk about gaming and I have my limits. I just plan lots of must do activities during their visit and leave them and Dh to entertain the kids all day.

GaryLurcher19 · 28/03/2024 12:03

You have a DH problem, OP. It is his DS and he should stop making it your job to entertain her.

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · 28/03/2024 11:59

Would DH agree to limit to four nights?

At least one day out or evening out needs to be something for just the siblings, so they get a proper catch up.

Do you have some kind friends who could come over one evening to keep everyone together and dilute her talking? DH, SIL & BIL could go out for the day while you cook 😉

Can one evening be theatre? And maybe some kind of guided tour of somewhere during the day? That also reduces the opportunity for being either talked at or left alone with her.

And maybe you can take up a craft - knitting, or sweary cross stitch, or just something you can do when you're alone with her without being rude. You even ask her to bear with you a minute while you count stitches or check a pattern, just to breathe.

I sympathise with you. Your DH is being rude to her and inconsiderate towards you. But as a fellow sufferer of logorrhea, I really feel for her too.

Walkingwashingmachine · 28/03/2024 11:59

izimbra · 28/03/2024 11:57

@Walkingwashingmachine - so people who are boring or have poor social skills are being cruel to other people by dint of talking to them?

I have a BIL who according to his wife (who's a disability assessor) is probably on the autistic spectrum though not diagnosed. He also has a chronic illness and hasn't worked for 20 years. He's quite hard to be around - he's a very intelligent guy who has an opinion on everything, but because of his frustration with his health and his loneliness he often dominates conversations and can be a know it all - which I think comes from low self esteem arising from 20 years of unemployment. As a family we accept that he's quite difficult to be around, but we don't denigrate him because of this. My teenage children are incredibly tolerant of him, seek him out at family parties and do him the kindness of listening to him and taking an interest in his opinions. Because he's a family member and they have compassion. I'm so proud to have raised such nice kids.

No wonder people with poor social skills have such high levels of severe depression, when even family members can't show any generosity or tolerance of them on the rare occasion that they meet.

This whole thread has made me sad.

I think most people make allowances for people with vulnerability like your BIL. I don't get from the OP that this is the case here however.

izimbra · 28/03/2024 11:57

@Walkingwashingmachine - so people who are boring or have poor social skills are being cruel to other people by dint of talking to them?

I have a BIL who according to his wife (who's a disability assessor) is probably on the autistic spectrum though not diagnosed. He also has a chronic illness and hasn't worked for 20 years. He's quite hard to be around - he's a very intelligent guy who has an opinion on everything, but because of his frustration with his health and his loneliness he often dominates conversations and can be a know it all - which I think comes from low self esteem arising from 20 years of unemployment. As a family we accept that he's quite difficult to be around, but we don't denigrate him because of this. My teenage children are incredibly tolerant of him, seek him out at family parties and do him the kindness of listening to him and taking an interest in his opinions. Because he's a family member and they have compassion. I'm so proud to have raised such nice kids.

No wonder people with poor social skills have such high levels of severe depression, when even family members can't show any generosity or tolerance of them on the rare occasion that they meet.

This whole thread has made me sad.

Allfur · 28/03/2024 11:51

Didn't Churchill or someone say they drank to make boring people more interesting? Could you try that?