Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable to dread visits of my husbands sister

139 replies

JaneMumofTwins · 27/03/2024 15:53

About twice a year we see my husbands sister and her husband. What happens is I get left with her and my husband finds 'manly' things to do with her husband. This would be OK if I found her company remotely agreeable but I don't. She is a stream of consciousness talker and a major hypochondriac. She talks over me continually and if she wasn't my husbands sister I would have no problem in just telling her to STFU, but I am hamstrung by family duty. I find her company so difficult I stop sleeping properly when she is in the house. I am sure she means well but I have endured 3 hours of her tedious boiler story and now she has underfloor heating issues I have completely lost the will to live. I have told husband that if he leaves me alone to deal with her again I will divorce him but I know that it will just repeat itself. How do I get her to shut up without killing her? Am I being unreasonable feeling this way?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
wizzywig · 30/03/2024 10:44

Loop earplugs are your friend here. See if you can get a sharpie to make them skin colored.

godmum56 · 30/03/2024 10:03

Renamed · 28/03/2024 22:01

Well it does sound really horrendous OP and I don’t know if I can suggest anything ore than other posters at all helpful, but if you don’t want to be driven out of your home, could you strategically develop a tooth or ear infection which would mean that you had to stay in your room most of the time, and when you emerged your head was wrapped in a large shawl (with head phones concealed underneath). I’m not suggesting d&v as that would involve a lot of acting and mean you couldn’t eat. Offer SIL a nice jigsaw to occupy herself, or suggest that she joins your DH and BIL to provide a helpful commentary on their activity.

I suspect that laying down the law on this to her husband would magically diminish or completely remove the problem!

godmum56 · 30/03/2024 10:01

I do sympathise with people whose neurodivergence makes such things hard but there should not have to be any reason for refusing to tolerate such behaviour on your partner's part. Phoebe Buffay's response is perfect here "I wish I could but I don't want to"

JaneMumofTwins · 29/03/2024 14:40

Coldupnorth87 · 28/03/2024 18:48

I am nd. I struggle with my sil, I've told dh he is not to leave me alone with her.

And that's a short visit. A week is too long. Definitely too long.

Trapped is not a good place to be.

Yes, it's horrible. Sending hugs.

OP posts:
Renamed · 28/03/2024 22:01

Well it does sound really horrendous OP and I don’t know if I can suggest anything ore than other posters at all helpful, but if you don’t want to be driven out of your home, could you strategically develop a tooth or ear infection which would mean that you had to stay in your room most of the time, and when you emerged your head was wrapped in a large shawl (with head phones concealed underneath). I’m not suggesting d&v as that would involve a lot of acting and mean you couldn’t eat. Offer SIL a nice jigsaw to occupy herself, or suggest that she joins your DH and BIL to provide a helpful commentary on their activity.

Nurder · 28/03/2024 20:51

@cerisepanther73 errr I didn't?

cerisepanther73 · 28/03/2024 20:51

Typo omission mistake words exhausting someone

GG1986 · 28/03/2024 20:50

Someone may have already suggested this but why don't you take her to the cinema or theatre? Will shut her up for an hour or two!

cerisepanther73 · 28/03/2024 20:48

@Nurder

I wish people would stop saying nearly everyone is autustic nowadays all the bloody time,

Certain individuals are just frigging annoying and are are quite self obbessed regardless of whether they are autustic or not.

I find your post way over the top and very judgemental of @JaneMumofTwins predicament?

I can totally relate @JaneMumofTwins in that some people can be just far too exhausted 😩 and intense and emotionally draining to want or be able to spend that much time with them,
i know some like that and i have ended up having blinding banging head ache after spending time a few hours all day with them and they come across as needy and childish too,

Cherrysoup · 28/03/2024 19:53

I think there are options.

2 nights max, at no point are you left as he goes off to do ‘man’ things or you follow him slavishly.
No overnights, they can find a hotel.
You go to a hotel for the duration.

She sounds like my mother, who Whittier’s on continuously, even when going to the bathroom, worse when she’s been drinking (every night). She wonders why I’d rather spend hundreds on a hotel rather than stay with her.

ChubbyMorticia · 28/03/2024 19:40

The solution begins and ends with your husband.

“We’re no longer hosting overnight guests.”

He sticks around to handle his sister.

If he won’t do that, then I’d be unavailable during their visit. I’d book somewhere else to be, an air BNB if nothing else.

Your husband should be helping you with your sensory overload, not demanding you suffer for up to a week to accommodate his sister!

Quizine · 28/03/2024 18:51

I had an aunt like your sister in law. Lovely kind person but boy could she talk. Forever and ever about shite this and that. Honestly that's very hard work for anyone to tolerate.

Eventually I realised that auntie would talk and talk but didn't care if you were listening or not, she would rattle on and on even when I closed my eyes and dozed during her monologues. I once left the room to get tea ready and I could hear her talking to me even though I wasn't there!

The only kind semi solution I could muster was to either fall asleep in her presence, or pretend to, or leave the room and get a bit of respite. It is exhausting trying to be social with someone like this, because they DON'T CARE about your response, or whether you are actually listening or not. I'm convinced that such people cannot judge the social signals at all, so the best thing is to mutter a few umms and aaahs, stick it out for a while then leave the room. And continue to do this over and over with longer spells out of the room altogether.

I left her magazines, and the TV zapper when I'd leave, but she often followed me out, not to help but to keep talking OMFG! I can laugh about it now as she died recently, but we all said that she must have Jesus's ears bent at this stage too.

Sympathies OP, sympathies.

Coldupnorth87 · 28/03/2024 18:48

I am nd. I struggle with my sil, I've told dh he is not to leave me alone with her.

And that's a short visit. A week is too long. Definitely too long.

Trapped is not a good place to be.

Twazique · 28/03/2024 18:34

I would have a list of things that are planned that I would have to leave the house alone to do, the doctors, hairdressers, cinema (at least twice), supermarket etc plus a migraine or two as well. I would plan it so it broke the day into tolerable sections, no more than two hours of her company in one go.

TryingNotCrying24 · 28/03/2024 18:18

If you have autism I would say it is a totally unacceptable cognitive overload for you in this scenario. I'm surprised you're not having meltdowns at the time or breakdowns after they leave. Your husband is being so selfish. You need to tell him - "my autism means that the time spent with your sister is impacting my mental health. I am also disadvantaged in that my physical health means I am trapped spending time with her. If you do not change and take the lead in spending time with her, the next time they come to visit I am going to book into a hotel for the days they are here."

IsawwhatIsaw · 28/03/2024 18:17

pavedwithgoodintentions · 28/03/2024 14:46

Just make plans to do something with friends this weekend and disappear. Tell you husband he can host his sister and her husband as it's his family and you're tired of him always dumping her on you.

Make him deal with her, because he won't if you're there. You know this.

Yes, your DH is offering the invite, then deliberately planning to avoid spending time with her. I’d be furious. That’s the bad behaviour, not Op!
Now reverse it, so you’re the one inviting a tricky brother then leaving your DH to deal with him…

Lotsofthings · 28/03/2024 18:07

Maybe fake a bad headache and have to lie in a quiet room (with phone!) Sometimes you can cope if you have some control and a chance to escape.

LookItsMeAgain · 28/03/2024 17:06

GaryLurcher19 · 28/03/2024 12:03

You have a DH problem, OP. It is his DS and he should stop making it your job to entertain her.

100% this.

His side of the family, his job to entertain and not leave you to deal with someone who he freely admits is hard work and/or difficult.

I really would begin to make arrangements to be out for at least part of their visit so that you're not there 24x7 with her. Make appointments and then announce that you are doing X or Y on the morning and DH, BiL and Sis can do something together while you're off doing your thing.

Just because you're a woman and she's a woman doesn't mean that the menfolk get to leave you to your sewing or whatever they used to do in the time of Emma or Jane Eyre!

diddl · 28/03/2024 16:31

So she comes to visit her brother with her husband, brother & husband promptly piss off & op is the rude one?

I'd be holed up in my room reading/watching Netflix/iplayer & eating chocolate!

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 28/03/2024 16:14

I think the only thing you can do is excuse yourself at the earliest opportunity (maybe after you've finished a cup of tea and politely listened to her during) and then go and get your husband with a "your sister wants to talk to you".

Have a raft of excuses ready for if he says he's nipping out to the <wherever> so he can't. Cheeky sod.

BMW6 · 28/03/2024 16:11

Can you not just say at some point "Will you PLEASE STOP TALKING SO MUCH"?

Or stand up when she's in mid flow and say "I've got a banging headache and I'm going ........ for some peace and quiet"?

SoreAndTired1 · 28/03/2024 16:11

I've only read your posts OP, but from reading your posts, it seems you are copping abuse from smug, heartless, narcissistic posters who don't understand how overwhelming it can be for someone like you, with autism, to have to deal with this. It is totally overwhelming and it affects your health. As an introvert, I would have had an emotional breakdown.

I am being very serious now.... can you afford to go to a motel for 4 days to a week? Maybe classify it as a health retreat for yourself. I think it's way past time your husband dealt with her on his own and learned from this. You are in danger of having a really serious breakdown if you don't. Please, just go. Just go to a motel, any motel. Even a cheap one. You need this and you have really well past earned this. My fear is you'll read all this and the thread replies, and not do anything and stay, and put up with it. Again. Make the change, get out on your own. Breathe and just.... be.... You need to take this chance and go to a motel because you known damn well your husband won't change his tactic this time either and he needs to experience this himself for himself. Just do it. Consider it as a lesson to him he needs to experience and you're doing him a favour.

CactusMactus · 28/03/2024 16:04

Drink heavily. And make her drink more.

Lotsofthings · 28/03/2024 15:46

Can you find excuses to go out on your own for a bit, doctors appointment, collecting dry cleaning, a number of emergencies dental appointments for the week.

GardenGrind · 28/03/2024 15:40

I'm sure she'd love to go and see that big isle of man waterwheel - every single visit. Make it her new favourite thing. Go several days in a row, cos it's her favourite thing. Report back how many hours you can clock up before she loses her guest facade.
Xmas presents can be totally big wheel themed from now on.
You can thank me!