Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think ski school for the tiny ones is fairly barbaric?

86 replies

Nurder · 27/03/2024 07:50

We have just gotten back from a week skiing in France and I spent a good deal of time on the learner slopes with a friend who is just learning. The amount of 3/4/5 year old children wailing in the snow and being terrified was just upsetting. The ratios appear to be really high with not enough staff to remotely cover what the kids actually need.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wonkypictureframe · 30/03/2024 11:19

My kids all learned to ski in Austria, at a ski school attached to a Kinderhotel. Kids start at three, on a private nursery slope next to the hotel. Parents can watch throughout, and some did (I did, as I can’t ski myself), but most watched for the first day or so before heading off for their own skiing once they knew their children were settled. The youngest kids never went up to the main slopes. The 4/5 year olds would start off on this slope and then go to the main ski school area up the mountain after a day or so. The tiny ones had breaks for hot chocolate and Haribo and games. They learned to use a magic carpet and by the end of the week were pretty proficient for three year olds! The instructors were lovely, all English speaking but the groups were usually mixed in language.

The only time I ever saw an unhappy child was a single kid who just did not want to be there and would sob throughout every session - his parents were dropping him and heading straight off each time. He ended up crying and crying and the poor instructor would be clearly stressed about it. The parents who hung around ended up trying to comfort him and in the end confronted his parents as they were dropping him off and told them quite frankly it wasn’t happening, and he didn’t appear again. Other than that, I only saw children having a great time - the ones who didn’t enjoy it much ended up not coming and probably tried again when older.

StormingNorman · 30/03/2024 09:54

Nurder · 27/03/2024 07:50

We have just gotten back from a week skiing in France and I spent a good deal of time on the learner slopes with a friend who is just learning. The amount of 3/4/5 year old children wailing in the snow and being terrified was just upsetting. The ratios appear to be really high with not enough staff to remotely cover what the kids actually need.

I loved it and that was back in the ESF days when the instructors barely spoke any English.

I remember going down the couloir in courchevel in a class of about 12 kids when I was maybe nine or ten years old. That’s just madness. I’m sure it wouldn’t be allowed now.

LoudSnoringDog · 30/03/2024 09:36

Mine learnt to ski in Austria and had an absolute blast. They loved it

Notamum12345577 · 30/03/2024 09:35

Nurder · 27/03/2024 12:06

It was ESF that I witnessed. One little girl who was maybe 5 was absolutely terrified of the chair lift. They were sending them up one child at a time with 3 random adults and hoping the adults help them off at the top. She was properly hysterical and screaming no. They manhandled her to the front of the queue and put her on the chair lift with 3 men she didn't know. They told her to stop squirming and screaming or she'd fall and off she went. It was truly upsetting! I can only hope the men on the lift with her were kind. That was the worst of what I saw but plenty of tiny kids crying in the snow being left behind as well. The ratios are bonkers for kids that age. How can you have 12 3-4 year olds on skis and only two adults?

Well most men would be kind to a crying child. I wouldn’t worry about that.
But yes, it does seem a bit wrong of the ski school!

Mimimimi1234 · 30/03/2024 08:52

Our last ski holiday my youngest was 4, he hates ski school. After day 1 he said he had had enough and that he could now ski( he went down a small slope once.) So he didnt go back to ski school. Other kids loved it tgere were lots of tears. I wouldnt leave them that young in ski school without watching, but some people ski so reguarly like 4 times a year its pretty normal for them

dameofdilemma · 28/03/2024 14:30

Incidentally I've seen plenty of young kids bawling their eyes out with their parents/families on then pistes too!

dameofdilemma · 28/03/2024 14:29

Ski school/young children isn't the problem - its ESF.

ESF instructors have to do mandatory kids ski school as part of the job - these are often instructors who have no interest or experience in young children. They're not much better with beginner adults tbh.

We used to use Esprit who were fantastic. Also had a good exp with New Gen.
It really depends on the instructor and the child though.
Some kids can't wait to be in the snow with other kids - some want to be with their parents.
Some kids are good at taking instruction.
Some like the snow and don't mind the cold.

InTheRainOnATrain · 28/03/2024 07:38

blue345 · 28/03/2024 06:37

Even if it's 8, it's still twice as many kids as you get in some of the British ski schools. We've also had group ski lessons they've still chosen to run just for my two kids.

Unless you're trying to improve your children's French or save money, I can't really see why you'd book ESF ski school over one of the other options. All the ski schools teach the kids to ski well. Every time I've seen ESF lessons at different resorts, the instructors really haven't been very nice to the kids.

Agree. And the standards to qualify as an instructor in France are some of, if not the, most stringent in the world. There’s never any doubt that the instructor at any ski school in France knows their stuff when it comes to skiing. So unless you’re on a really tight budget then may as well go for the ones who aren’t shouty, actually seem to like children and who do smaller groups i.e. not ESF.

Bandol · 28/03/2024 07:32

At the ESF we use (go to the same place every year) it's 12 per group during the winter school holidays (Feb / Mar). The place we go is very French and ESF is overwhelmingly the largest ski school. There is Evolution and ESI but they are on a much smaller scale.

blue345 · 28/03/2024 06:37

Even if it's 8, it's still twice as many kids as you get in some of the British ski schools. We've also had group ski lessons they've still chosen to run just for my two kids.

Unless you're trying to improve your children's French or save money, I can't really see why you'd book ESF ski school over one of the other options. All the ski schools teach the kids to ski well. Every time I've seen ESF lessons at different resorts, the instructors really haven't been very nice to the kids.

Rainbowshit · 27/03/2024 22:22

Nurder
@Needanewname42 Happy to post pics as proof tomorrow. They are closer to 12 in a group.

Count the instructors too.
8 is what they have written in the book.

It's France. You think they go by the book? 😂😂

I know for a fact they are under pressure at half terms to fit way more than the book says in the class.

Needanewname42 · 27/03/2024 22:12

Nurder · 27/03/2024 21:45

@Needanewname42 Happy to post pics as proof tomorrow. They are closer to 12 in a group.

Count the instructors too.
8 is what they have written in the book.

Nurder · 27/03/2024 21:45

@Needanewname42 Happy to post pics as proof tomorrow. They are closer to 12 in a group.

OP posts:
Rainbowshit · 27/03/2024 21:32

Needanewname42 · 27/03/2024 21:27

Sitting with an ESF book in my hands their maximum number per group is 8. I'm sure they sometimes have more but with more instructors.

I've seen way more than 8 per group with ESF.

Needanewname42 · 27/03/2024 21:27

Sitting with an ESF book in my hands their maximum number per group is 8. I'm sure they sometimes have more but with more instructors.

blue345 · 27/03/2024 18:13

We've also avoided ESF at all costs. Too many kids to teachers and I've observed them being pretty mean to the kids on numerous occasions.

Can second the British ski schools such as New Gen etc. Often 3-4 to a group and my kids have loved all their teachers. And they happily skied a black in their first week, you don't have to suffer the ESF way to become a proficient skier.

Radiatorvalves · 27/03/2024 17:45

My Boys have had lessons in both Austria and France, mainly France with ESF. They’ve been fine, although DS wasn’t keen on Piou Piou when he was little. Other DS had a few private lessons aged about 10 as he wanted to board. We go to smaller resorts and all instructors have been nice.

Ive never seen any distressed kids on chairs (except mine having an occasional strop years ago). I do chat to the ones who are put on a chair with me…. I haven’t seen evidence of barbarism.

Needanewname42 · 27/03/2024 16:45

Nurder · 27/03/2024 12:06

It was ESF that I witnessed. One little girl who was maybe 5 was absolutely terrified of the chair lift. They were sending them up one child at a time with 3 random adults and hoping the adults help them off at the top. She was properly hysterical and screaming no. They manhandled her to the front of the queue and put her on the chair lift with 3 men she didn't know. They told her to stop squirming and screaming or she'd fall and off she went. It was truly upsetting! I can only hope the men on the lift with her were kind. That was the worst of what I saw but plenty of tiny kids crying in the snow being left behind as well. The ratios are bonkers for kids that age. How can you have 12 3-4 year olds on skis and only two adults?

Op I think you are mixing things up. Most areas 3/4 year olds their lesson is an hour in the 'snow garden'.

5 yos are ready for the main slopes.
Have you ever been evacuated from a chairlift? You'd never want LOs getting evacuated without some sort of adult with them hence policies are under 125cm must be with an adult on the chairlifts. How else would you get them up a chairlift if not with random adults?

I'd also think the parents should have made sure the child was happy going on a chairlift before sending them to ski school.

My kids have both been on chairlifts since they were babies in slings attached to me. Evacuation was when the penny dropped why they insisted babies were in slings.

Soigneur · 27/03/2024 16:31

FastFood · 27/03/2024 13:57

You never know, you might fall from a plane right on top of the Mont Blanc with a pair of skis on your feet, how do you go back in the valley if you haven't learned how to ski?!?

Joke aside, it's a class thing.
At least in France it is.
When you're a youh adult starting to earn some money, generally the topic of going skiing with friends comes up and those who haven't been taught young can feel a bit left out, it really is a big class divider in France.

The same is true in the UK - our graduate hires at work organise a big ski trip each year and the ones who don't ski always seem a bit left out and unfortunately that "left out" persists once they are back at work.

Wardrobedoorsarewood · 27/03/2024 16:02

As a 31 year old I was traumatized by horrible French ski instructors yelling at me let alone at 5! They were just awful. Had fabulous experiences in Canada, the States, Austria and Italy though.

Our kids learnt in Italy and Austria safe to say and loved it

KimberleyClark · 27/03/2024 15:06

FastFood · 27/03/2024 13:57

You never know, you might fall from a plane right on top of the Mont Blanc with a pair of skis on your feet, how do you go back in the valley if you haven't learned how to ski?!?

Joke aside, it's a class thing.
At least in France it is.
When you're a youh adult starting to earn some money, generally the topic of going skiing with friends comes up and those who haven't been taught young can feel a bit left out, it really is a big class divider in France.

Right so it's a useful social skill in some circles, rather than an essential life skill.

CatherinedeBourgh · 27/03/2024 14:29

Yes, we pulled out ds1 after one day. We used what we'd paid for privates, and then taught him ourselves.

Ds2 we taught ourselves.

Coincidentally · 27/03/2024 14:28

Am a total Francophile and am actually now skiing in France, but when the kids were little I took them to Austria for much kinder lessons and they loved it. We did France/ESF when they were 9/11 and so more used to the much harsher regime.

KalaMush · 27/03/2024 14:26

My kids did ESF from age 3/4 and loved it - they're teens now and look back on it happily. I guess this isn't a "one size fits all" situation.

mrssquidink · 27/03/2024 14:23

My kids also did ESF from 4/5 and were fine, although like one of the posters many of the early years we were with Family Ski who had a helper with the little kids. They always seemed to be happy to go back the next day and don’t seem too scarred by the experience. We also always had English speaking instructors. I think ESF tend to be better in resorts where they know there’s competition

DS and DD are now mid to late teens and went all the way through with ESF up to gold star and have excellent technique.

Swipe left for the next trending thread