Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't sole beneficiaries of a will share more?

260 replies

malificent7 · 27/03/2024 07:33

I mean in cases where it's clearly unfair. Such as the step mum inheriting all when there are children about or one sibling unexpectedly inheriting everything.
Jusr a bit shocked about inheritance threads ( and concerned about my own stepmum getting everything).

OP posts:
SoapOperaFamily · 27/03/2024 09:04

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 08:50

I don’t think it is “potentially unfair” and the “weird shit” you’re describing is called getting married. It’s a decision to join your finances and life into one. How could it be right to leave your money to your children ahead of your spouse?

And another one without the imagination for the ‘weird shit.’ My dad’s second marriage was to a foreign woman younger than my youngest sibling who openly declared her reason for marriage was to obtain a visa. As soon as that was obtained, she disappeared, had 2 children by another man (leaving her older 2 kids, also by men that were not my dad) living with my dad. She only returned to his life when he was terminally ill, and the one bit of credit I can give her is that she did care for him in his final months, but did not live with him as a spouse.

To the end, my dad (who she had left years before, and who freely admitted he was ashamed by her actions) still thought she was probably a decent person, because of the ‘weird shit’ love does.

SeulementUneFois · 27/03/2024 09:00

Outonabranch · 27/03/2024 07:47

I guess the problem with step families is that the kids see the step mother ( using Step mum as that is the case given in the OP) as somehow ‘outside’ the family, and they are then unfairly ‘getting’ family money they are not entitled to.

Whereas the spouse sees the ‘step mum’ not as ‘step’ anything but as their dearly beloved wife and life partner, and therefore as absolutely their family and entitled to all the money and security that a first spouse would get without question.

This OP.

Twiglets1 · 27/03/2024 08:58

Personally I feel like people already know they ought to make a will if they get married again, & want to ensure the children from their first marriage get something.

The reason they don’t is that they are too lazy, don’t care enough or actively want their new spouse to inherit everything. It’s not lack of education.

SoapOperaFamily · 27/03/2024 08:57

oprahwindsock · 27/03/2024 08:28

Why shouldn't stepmum get everything? She probably contributed to the pot. Kids usually get inheritance when both parents die.

I dislike these grabby threads.

And there we go - proving my point well here! 🙄 On MN, there are always people who cannot understand or imagine the distress a badly written will, or even no will at all, can cause, and assumes that everyone who is on the receiving end of the aforementioned badly written will is ‘grabby.’

In the case I am all too familiar with, my stepmother actually prevented my father from having his will correctly witnessed (his solicitor actually made notes to this effect.) She took far more from my father and my family than she ever contributed, but took the lot anyway. It is not always the case that a child of a deceased parent wants to do a step-parent out of their home and lifestyle. Each case is a separate scenario, but there are just as many wicked stepmothers out there as there are grabby children. And there are a lot of people who are left distressed because of the general ignorance of the law regarding wills, second marriages, and so on.

It is not unreasonable to hope that a parent has a correctly written, signed and witnessed will, and has been open with their intentions and left their paperwork in good order with no surprises for anyone. But you would be amazed how frequently this is not the case.

Chattywatty · 27/03/2024 08:56

if my dad dies first all the money goes to my step mum and when she dies it is split equally between all 4 children. They’ve been married for over 40 years since i was a child. I am not my step mums biggest fan but this is absolutely the right decision. I trust her enough that i will get my share when she’s gone and i would absolutely hate for her to have to have money worries in her old age. Me and my step sister are the trustees of the will, I simply cannot see that we’d ever get left out of it.

SunshineYay · 27/03/2024 08:53

I've read so many sad threads where a man's house and assets all go to the second wife, who then gives that her bio children. It's sad that he hasn't provided for his children in his will.

justtidying · 27/03/2024 08:50

A friend was recently widowed. She is now sharing the (small) estate with the two adult children equally. Her choice as there is no will. However, she now has to start again, aged 50, without a home or a job.

I admire her principles, but I don't think it's fair for her. Her husband's children don't have responsibilities, will inherit substantially from their mother's side and have their lives ahead of them. She is going to have to rebuild everything at an age when she thought she could be comfortable. In her shoes, I don't believe I would be as generous, and I would be more selfish.

However, it isn't about sharing equally but about considering everyone's individual needs, as well as considering the wishes of the deceased.

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 08:50

underthemilky · 27/03/2024 08:31

Hmm. Not always. A new spouse inheriting everything whilst the deceased spouse dc get nothing is potentially unfair. People do weird shit sometimes when they fall in love. We all know that.

I don’t think it is “potentially unfair” and the “weird shit” you’re describing is called getting married. It’s a decision to join your finances and life into one. How could it be right to leave your money to your children ahead of your spouse?

endofthelinefinally · 27/03/2024 08:45

Shoxfordian · 27/03/2024 08:44

It's up to the deceased to make a proper will after remarriage to leave money accordingly

It is, but the level of ignorance about this appears to be huge.

Hoppinggreen · 27/03/2024 08:45

Its not the person who inherits decision to make, they should respect the wishes of the person who made the will

concernedchild · 27/03/2024 08:45

@underthemilky in that case the children are entitled to make a claim against the estate and if they have a good case, they will win.

You need to have maintenance needs to be due something from the estate. You don't just get it by virtue of being their child.

Shoxfordian · 27/03/2024 08:44

It's up to the deceased to make a proper will after remarriage to leave money accordingly

endofthelinefinally · 27/03/2024 08:43

So what happens once one partner is left alone? Will they review their wishes? What if they get married again? Statistics show that men marry again more frequently than the other way round. These things need to be planned for, rather than just left to chance.

endofthelinefinally · 27/03/2024 08:43

So what happens once one partner is left alone? Will they review their wishes? What if they get married again? Statistics show that men marry again more frequently than the other way round. These things need to be planned for, rather than just left to chance.

TraitorsGate · 27/03/2024 08:42

As a second spouse I would give previous children something, it doesn't seem fair to me that they get nothing. But it's the will that needs updating.

Keeprejoining · 27/03/2024 08:36

We Have mirror will where everything is left to each other. There is nothing for DC. We need the house to live in and savings for repairs and living expenses. We are not going to be homeless to give DC £50k each.

Precipice · 27/03/2024 08:32

If your the sole beneficiary because there was no will you can assume the person who died knew the laws as its not secretive

Knowledge of succession law is pretty poor.

In terms of Scotland, for example, there are now very few claims for legal rights. In testate estates, that is, so analogous to your question: why don't people who have a claim under succession law but are not made beneficiaries get the share they're legally entitled to? (Not in intestate estates, where prior rights will typically exhaust the estate). Probably because they don't know about it.

underthemilky · 27/03/2024 08:31

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 07:36

Most people understand that people leave everything to their partner surely? Anything that trickles down to the next generation is after your spouse has been cared for (so when they have died).

Hmm. Not always. A new spouse inheriting everything whilst the deceased spouse dc get nothing is potentially unfair. People do weird shit sometimes when they fall in love. We all know that.

BloodyHellKenAgain · 27/03/2024 08:30

Outonabranch · 27/03/2024 07:47

I guess the problem with step families is that the kids see the step mother ( using Step mum as that is the case given in the OP) as somehow ‘outside’ the family, and they are then unfairly ‘getting’ family money they are not entitled to.

Whereas the spouse sees the ‘step mum’ not as ‘step’ anything but as their dearly beloved wife and life partner, and therefore as absolutely their family and entitled to all the money and security that a first spouse would get without question.

This with knobs on

KarmaChameleon63213 · 27/03/2024 08:28

Op do you have a will ?

oprahwindsock · 27/03/2024 08:28

malificent7 · 27/03/2024 07:33

I mean in cases where it's clearly unfair. Such as the step mum inheriting all when there are children about or one sibling unexpectedly inheriting everything.
Jusr a bit shocked about inheritance threads ( and concerned about my own stepmum getting everything).

Why shouldn't stepmum get everything? She probably contributed to the pot. Kids usually get inheritance when both parents die.

I dislike these grabby threads.

endofthelinefinally · 27/03/2024 08:25

My grandad's existing will was very clear, but because he married again it was invalid.

SoapOperaFamily · 27/03/2024 08:24

When someone leaves everything in their will to their spouse, without leaving anything to their children, it is because that is what they want to happen. Your issue here is with your parent, not your step-parent. Sometimes, your parent will leave everything to their spouse (your step-parent) with a vague promise from them that they will pass everything to you when the step parent dies but nothing in writing, and this is useless. Your parent believes their new spouse to be a good person who will honour this but once your parent is dead there is no way they can make sure their spouse follows their intentions.

Occasionally, as was the case with our family, the parent who dies does not leave a valid will. Our stepmother had written instructions and a good understanding of our dad’s intentions wrt his estate and how it was to be divided, but the law (intestacy) allowed her to take a far greater share than he had intended to so she did. The only reasons we can come to for why she did this is because she is a complete fucking witch. Our family has never recovered - she locked us out of our dad’s home (which was not even her home at the time) less than 24hrs after he died and we were never got a single photograph of him after he died, let alone any of the collectibles and possessions that he told us (and which were put in writing, just not correctly signed) would be ours after he was gone.

What I have found on MN is that there is a very cold-hearted approach to inheritances. When someone dies and leaves someone bereft it is often stated that you are not entitled to anything anyway, it was never yours until it was passed to you legitimately in a will. The sad fact and reality is that not everyone has a valid will, but complicated family situations mean that valid wills (where the person the will belongs to understands ALL of the implications and repercussions) are more important than ever, as are the often difficult conversations about who will be left what after someone dies. It is not unreasonable for a parent to want to leave their new spouse a home, an income after they have died, possessions that they shared and acquired together during their marriage. But it is also not unreasonable for someone to want to pass family money and possessions from before their new marriage to their children, and it is not unreasonable for those children to want to inherit from their parent. A clear conversation and a correctly written will avoids any of the sad situations where someone unexpectedly feels hard done by.

In my family’s situation, my dad had intended for his share of his family’s wealth, which he had inherited himself from his parents and grandparents, to be passed to his children, and for the portion of his possessions and money he had earned for himself in his lifetime to go to his estranged second wife. His will had been written and not correctly witnessed, so she took the lot, despite it being more money than she knows what to do with, and enough to have supported not only her family but the families of all my siblings too. I hope rots in hell for her actions and greed, but have resigned myself to the fact that she will probably just waste most of it and pass the rest on to her children who she had with another man after she had separated from my dad.

Long explanation, but if you just skipped to the end for the punchline - the reason some people don’t share when they are sole beneficiaries of an inheritance is because they might be cunts.

ItsNotAPoolBasedHoliday · 27/03/2024 08:23

Even if people knew about it, what could they do? If it’s the law then it’s the law and people hoping to inherit have to accept that.

Make a will.

I think too many people don't think about the legal side of getting married. The old 'it's only a piece of paper' line.

endofthelinefinally · 27/03/2024 08:21

Twiglets1 · 27/03/2024 08:10

Even if people knew about it, what could they do? If it’s the law then it’s the law and people hoping to inherit have to accept that.

It might educate people embarking on a second marriage late in life to actually make a new will as soon as they marry, if they want to leave something to their children.