Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't sole beneficiaries of a will share more?

260 replies

malificent7 · 27/03/2024 07:33

I mean in cases where it's clearly unfair. Such as the step mum inheriting all when there are children about or one sibling unexpectedly inheriting everything.
Jusr a bit shocked about inheritance threads ( and concerned about my own stepmum getting everything).

OP posts:
endofthelinefinally · 27/03/2024 09:43

TraitorsGate · 27/03/2024 09:34

I think some people either don't make a will, don't change it if they remarry and wrongly assume that a second spouse would make provision for any previous children.

This.

Aposterhasnoname · 27/03/2024 09:42

Some do, my DH for a start shared everything equally with his brothers. Some don't, and there’s many reasons why that would be the case. .

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 09:40

Because they don't want to and legally they don't have to. There are times when that's absolutely awful, but those are the reasons.

Think very carefully before marrying if you don't want to complicate your children's inheritance. It may be better not to do it. Sort your will out. Never assume your partner will do as you wish without you having to lay it down. If they don't mind doing it, they won't mind you willing it.

DistinguishedSocialCommentator · 27/03/2024 09:39

OP

Look at it like this and it is purely hypothetical

Lets say in xx years time you draw up your final Will. The scenario is you've been physical unwell for a few years and alone and everyone you knew, in c family stopped visiting you and rarely call you but your second cousin who lives 50 miles away calls you a few times a week and visits you at least once a week to chat, help a little if required. This 2nd cousin has always been a balanced friend/family, sends birthday cards/xmas cards invited you to their events etc. You decide to leave all of your estate to this person

You pass on. Everyone else is upset you left them naff all but all of it to this cousin. Court over-rules your Will even though you made it when of sound mind/e/tc/etc ie legal. How would you feel?

TraitorsGate · 27/03/2024 09:34

FiveShelties · 27/03/2024 09:29

I thought a will was made so that your estate goes to who you chose to leave it to. What is fair or unfair about that?

I think some people either don't make a will, don't change it if they remarry and wrongly assume that a second spouse would make provision for any previous children.

Devilshands · 27/03/2024 09:30

Twiglets1 · 27/03/2024 08:58

Personally I feel like people already know they ought to make a will if they get married again, & want to ensure the children from their first marriage get something.

The reason they don’t is that they are too lazy, don’t care enough or actively want their new spouse to inherit everything. It’s not lack of education.

100% agree.

It's not exactly hard to change a will and protect assets or deliberately exclude someone from inheriting.

And, ultimately, people are selfish. If they inherit everything from their partner and the kids don't get anything then 99% of the time they won't share and anyone with a shred of common sense knows this...

FiveShelties · 27/03/2024 09:29

I thought a will was made so that your estate goes to who you chose to leave it to. What is fair or unfair about that?

RomansTheyGoTheHouse · 27/03/2024 09:26

But once you're gone and whoever you chose to inherit, they can give away what they want though despite your wishes,

Of course they can. It'd annoy me to think they did so in a manner intended to redraw up my will in a way they think works better. But then, I'll be dead so....

I just think honouring a will is about the last act of respect you an show someone who has recently died because it is, be definition, their final wishes.

However, I am unlikely to ever face that problem because my own Dad remarried a women younger than himself from a long lived family and so, assuming nature takes a normal course, she will inherit everything they currently have and may or may not outlive me.

Such is life.

AnneLovesGilbert · 27/03/2024 09:24

How much are you leaving your step daughter?

TraitorsGate · 27/03/2024 09:22

RomansTheyGoTheHouse · 27/03/2024 09:16

My will is what I want to happen. It'd annoy me to think I went to the effort and expense of having a will drawn up only for someone else to decide to do something differently with my money when I'm gone.

It's my will. It doesn't matter one damn if someone thinks it is unfair - it is what I want to happen.

That said, I also strongly believe in communicating what that will holds before death - not leaving it as a shock after I've gone. So, where I have made provisions that might be viewed as unfair, I have already spoken to all those impacted to explain.

But once you're gone and whoever you chose to inherit, they can give away what they want though despite your wishes,

Twiglets1 · 27/03/2024 09:21

RomansTheyGoTheHouse · 27/03/2024 09:16

My will is what I want to happen. It'd annoy me to think I went to the effort and expense of having a will drawn up only for someone else to decide to do something differently with my money when I'm gone.

It's my will. It doesn't matter one damn if someone thinks it is unfair - it is what I want to happen.

That said, I also strongly believe in communicating what that will holds before death - not leaving it as a shock after I've gone. So, where I have made provisions that might be viewed as unfair, I have already spoken to all those impacted to explain.

Yes I agree with this. My Dad has written a new will giving my stepmother a life interest in his property and then it passes to my sister & I upon her death (assuming he dies first).

Thats fair I think - but also appreciate that he told us about the terms of his will upfront so we are not expecting to inherit the property immediately upon his death. Communication is key.

BobbyBiscuits · 27/03/2024 09:21

I've never inherited anything from any of my family, dad, aunts, uncles, great aunts, grandparents...
It doesn't bother me really. It seems a weird thing as a bereaved person to be worrying about.

Yogatoga1 · 27/03/2024 09:18

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 08:50

I don’t think it is “potentially unfair” and the “weird shit” you’re describing is called getting married. It’s a decision to join your finances and life into one. How could it be right to leave your money to your children ahead of your spouse?

Agree.

my dad left everything to my mum, as is expected. I got nothing.

if he had left everything to me she would not have been able to survive on a pension, no house, no savings etc.

so why is it different for a step mum? Kids still get nothing 🤷‍♀️ . Or is it preferable she gets kicked out of her home with no money so it can go to the kids?

RomansTheyGoTheHouse · 27/03/2024 09:16

My will is what I want to happen. It'd annoy me to think I went to the effort and expense of having a will drawn up only for someone else to decide to do something differently with my money when I'm gone.

It's my will. It doesn't matter one damn if someone thinks it is unfair - it is what I want to happen.

That said, I also strongly believe in communicating what that will holds before death - not leaving it as a shock after I've gone. So, where I have made provisions that might be viewed as unfair, I have already spoken to all those impacted to explain.

Outnumbered99 · 27/03/2024 09:16

More to the point why don't people write their wills properly and discuss their contents with close family in life so that there are no nasty surprises?

W0tnow · 27/03/2024 09:16

billyt · 27/03/2024 07:44

Some people, and it seems to be on the increase, are entitled, grabbing bastards.

Why is it unfair when a stepmother/stepfather inherits from their late husband/wife? Do they not have the same 'rights'? If the person dying hasn't specified anything in their will, or dies intestate then tough.

Although, I do think the other thread about a stepmother asking for payment for a family item the other extreme.

Unfair because, if I died, everything that is mine, that I have earned and worked for, goes to my husband. Now, if he re-married and left all of the wealth that I had earned (which of course is now his) to his new wife, then my kids would receive nothing. Clearly that would not be my intention. Now, he wouldn't do that, but it happens.

Do you not see that as unfair? Leaving aside the 'well it's now his money he can do as he likes etcetc', I fail to see how you could NOT think that was unfair on my kids? Or fail to see why my kids might think that was unfair? My parents divorced and remarried. They're both dead now and their respective partners are still alive. I still received a generous inheritance from them, because I am their child.

To be clear, it does astound me that parents effectively write their own children out of their will. Of course the onus is on the will maker to distribute their funds fairly.

Hotpinkangel19 · 27/03/2024 09:16

My parents died in the same year. I was sole beneficiary of the will. My half brothers - Mum's side, were in and out of our lives sonce i can remember. I remember Mum being sad every celebration she never heard from them. So no, i didn't give them anything at all. Funnily enough one cut contact after my Father's funeral. I never heard from him again. I'm not regretting anything.

TTPD · 27/03/2024 09:14

Why blame the stepmum for not sharing, rather than the father for not writing a fair will?

Twiglets1 · 27/03/2024 09:14

SoapOperaFamily · 27/03/2024 09:06

Or because they are a superstitious idiot who has cancer and thinks re-doing his will will cause the universe to think ‘he has written his last will and testament, he is ready to die now.’ 🙄 Yes, this is a real thing.

That’s hard.

But it does sound like they still had affection for one another, despite everything.

Twiglets1 · 27/03/2024 09:12

BMW6 · 27/03/2024 09:07

I don't have children, DH has 2 (age over 30) from previous relationship.

DH & I bought our house together, both worked full time until retired, works out we paid mortgage off equally.

If DH dies before me I inherit everything. I'll need to as if our home had to be sold to give 50% of the proceeds to his children I'll be homeless.

Our property value is around 220k. There is nothing anywhere near my relatives to buy for 110k. I'll be far too old to get a mortgage.

In our case I plan to leave a will leaving 50% of my estate to his 2 children and the other 50% to charities and my siblings (or their children if sibling has passed).

That's fair isn't it?

Yes that sounds fair.

Saymyname28 · 27/03/2024 09:10

Married people are entitled to the resources of their deceased partner. I don't think that's unfair. That's the whole point of marriage. I don't think those children would be complaining had the step parent died first and their own parent inherited it all to pass it onto them.

Often when parents specifically write in their will unfair amounts it's for perfectly valid reasons. You treat someone like shit while they're alive then you don't get their stuff when they die.

I think it's more unfair when people try to make all blood relatives equal and all "bonus" relatives secondary. Not wanting step children to inherit from the family pot, making sure two siblings get the same amount when one calls once a year and the other provides full time care.

BreakTea · 27/03/2024 09:07

I think it depends on your relationship with the person you could potentially share with. There is a possibility thst my dad might leave everything in his will to me and nothing or little to my sister (for no fault of hers). If that happens I will share it freely with my sister because I love her and wish her well. And I've told my dad that I will do that if he tries to pull a shitty stunt like that.

BMW6 · 27/03/2024 09:07

I don't have children, DH has 2 (age over 30) from previous relationship.

DH & I bought our house together, both worked full time until retired, works out we paid mortgage off equally.

If DH dies before me I inherit everything. I'll need to as if our home had to be sold to give 50% of the proceeds to his children I'll be homeless.

Our property value is around 220k. There is nothing anywhere near my relatives to buy for 110k. I'll be far too old to get a mortgage.

In our case I plan to leave a will leaving 50% of my estate to his 2 children and the other 50% to charities and my siblings (or their children if sibling has passed).

That's fair isn't it?

SoapOperaFamily · 27/03/2024 09:06

Twiglets1 · 27/03/2024 08:58

Personally I feel like people already know they ought to make a will if they get married again, & want to ensure the children from their first marriage get something.

The reason they don’t is that they are too lazy, don’t care enough or actively want their new spouse to inherit everything. It’s not lack of education.

Or because they are a superstitious idiot who has cancer and thinks re-doing his will will cause the universe to think ‘he has written his last will and testament, he is ready to die now.’ 🙄 Yes, this is a real thing.

harriethoyle · 27/03/2024 09:05

Outonabranch · 27/03/2024 07:47

I guess the problem with step families is that the kids see the step mother ( using Step mum as that is the case given in the OP) as somehow ‘outside’ the family, and they are then unfairly ‘getting’ family money they are not entitled to.

Whereas the spouse sees the ‘step mum’ not as ‘step’ anything but as their dearly beloved wife and life partner, and therefore as absolutely their family and entitled to all the money and security that a first spouse would get without question.

You've absolutely nailed it @Outonabranch

Why on earth shouldn't your father leave his estate to his wife?! It's so disrespectful to him to suggest he shouldn't and shows a real lack of insight on your part.