Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't sole beneficiaries of a will share more?

260 replies

malificent7 · 27/03/2024 07:33

I mean in cases where it's clearly unfair. Such as the step mum inheriting all when there are children about or one sibling unexpectedly inheriting everything.
Jusr a bit shocked about inheritance threads ( and concerned about my own stepmum getting everything).

OP posts:
Darker · 27/03/2024 14:26

PassingStranger · 27/03/2024 14:08

If people like having money and wealth they need to make it for themselves.

Not rely on getting it from others people's work.

That’s a very narrow, ableist view of the world.

Of course no one is entitled to money through inheritance. But most people would agree that we want a world of decency and fairness.

The problem is that it’s human nature to hang on to wealth once we have it in our grasp. So people who have wealth to pass on need to think this though very carefully and not just trust that the beneficiaries will sort out any future complications or changes of circumstances further down the line.

PassingStranger · 27/03/2024 14:08

Outonabranch · 27/03/2024 07:37

Because people like having money and wealth.

Because life is expensive and that money can make a big difference to them that they don’t want to give up.

Because they can tell themselves it’s fair as it is what the deceased wanted.

If people like having money and wealth they need to make it for themselves.

Not rely on getting it from others people's work.

MumblesParty · 27/03/2024 14:06

Chylka · 27/03/2024 13:38

My friend’s dad remarried a couple of years after his wife died (had been married 50 years and had 5 kids). He then died a few years later, and left everything to the new wife, because he trusted that she would look after his kids. She didn’t. She left it all to her own kids. That definitely is not fair. My friend is unbelievably sanguine about it (and she is not wealthy, even a 5th of her parents estate would have made a massive difference), but she just accepted it and moved on. I’d have been spitting feathers!

I’m often curious about this. If he had specified in his will that his new wife was to inherit everything, but that she should then (in her will) leave something to his kids, would that stand up legally? Or would it just be a request, that she could legally choose to ignore?

BigAnne · 27/03/2024 13:56

SunshineYay · 27/03/2024 08:53

I've read so many sad threads where a man's house and assets all go to the second wife, who then gives that her bio children. It's sad that he hasn't provided for his children in his will.

It's not the man's house. It's the matrimonial home which is jointly owned.

SleepingStandingUp · 27/03/2024 13:48

Well arguably it's the wishes of the deceased, who's money it is, that you want disregarding to benefit someone else the dead person didn't want to benefit. How is THAT fair?

But yes, on the surface if I inherited money from an aunt for example, I'd offer to share with my sister. If parent was generally a narcissist or otherwise abusive and I felt me being some heir was a game play I'd share. But if you're the "new" wife of a decade who's cared for him in his dotage whilst the kids visit once a month and moan about how they really need their money now, then why should you share?

SoapOperaFamily · 27/03/2024 13:44

The wide variety of opinions on this thread alone shows what a contentious issue inheritance is. Most cases of disappointment come about because the person who died did not leave a suitable will. Just write a will.

SoapOperaFamily · 27/03/2024 13:42

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 12:05

And he chose to ignore his wife’s infidelity as many do and stayed married to her rather than divorcing, not so unusual. She cared for him and he honoured his wedding vows. Your take on their marriage doesn’t trump his choice.

If you read my other posts, he made his choice and wrote a will, but due to reasons too complex to explain here he did not have his will correctly witnessed, which meant that although he had written one it was not deemed valid and he was declared intestate. He would have liked to have divorced her, but she threatened to take his family’s business from him in the divorce courts, so he allowed her to disappear from his life not expecting her to come back. Despite writing a will which meant his estranged wife was taken care of with a home and income (and he had conversations with his chosen executors, which included my husband as my dad knew his will would be the subject of scrutiny and he deemed my husband to be ‘a fair man’ in his own words) as well as making sure family assets were kept within his blood family, ie his children, his wife chose to take it all for herself, destroying a family business that had been built up over 4 generations. She did not need to do this, she was not left without a good home and income if she’d followed the intentions of my dad’s will. She did it because she could, and she was greedy. She did not follow my dad’s choices. He was an idiot for believing she would, and an idiot for not making sure his will was watertight in following his choices.

The point I am trying to make, using my own family’s sorry story as an example, is that a person should make sure their will is properly written, properly signed, and properly witnessed, and to understand the issues which can arise if you remarry. There are so many people out there who do not understand all of these issues. My own father thought he would be able to sign his will and get it witnessed once his final days were happening, sitting up with his children all around him, and was surprised by the fact that his final moments happened very quickly. He was distressed in his final moments by the sudden realisation he would not be sitting in his deathbed, compos mentis, surrounded by his children while he bestowed on them his wishes. It’s not a situation I would wish on anyone, but it highlights the scenarios that can happen which people just have not even imagined.

Just get your wills all written properly by solicitors who deal with this sort to thing. That is the best way to prevent ‘weird shit’ from taking place and causing more distress than it ought to have the power to.

Chylka · 27/03/2024 13:38

My friend’s dad remarried a couple of years after his wife died (had been married 50 years and had 5 kids). He then died a few years later, and left everything to the new wife, because he trusted that she would look after his kids. She didn’t. She left it all to her own kids. That definitely is not fair. My friend is unbelievably sanguine about it (and she is not wealthy, even a 5th of her parents estate would have made a massive difference), but she just accepted it and moved on. I’d have been spitting feathers!

PassingStranger · 27/03/2024 13:35

Theitsman · 27/03/2024 07:39

We've been in the middle off this, step family situation. One well off person inheriting a huge amount and (initially) refusing to share with people struggling. All hell broke loose and the family has never been the same since.

Nothing like money to divide a family.
People are not obliged to share, and it's up to the person who wrote the will to leave it to who they want too.

Yogatoga1 · 27/03/2024 13:33

GotMooMilk · 27/03/2024 13:20

Why shouldn't stepmum get everything? She probably contributed to the pot. Kids usually get inheritance when both parents die.

Well exactly. But if parent 1 dies leaving to parent 2 who dies leaving all to step parent who keeps it all or gives to own family then kids will never inherit any of their families estate. And if I was parent 1 particularly I’d hate this.

But that could happen whatever the circs?

i won’t inherit the “family estate” as my mum has spent it all. She’s not great with money, has never worked since we were born, an enjoys a lifestyle not worrying about money.

someone else may end up paying for care and leaving nothing to the kids.

unless you are parent 1 and you cut your spouse out and leave everything to your kids- and as I said previously this means nothing joint, no joint accounts, no joint names on deeds etc, you are taking a risk leaving it to your spouse.

if parent 1 wants the money to go to their kids, they should sort their finances and will do it goes to their kids.

GotMooMilk · 27/03/2024 13:20

Why shouldn't stepmum get everything? She probably contributed to the pot. Kids usually get inheritance when both parents die.

Well exactly. But if parent 1 dies leaving to parent 2 who dies leaving all to step parent who keeps it all or gives to own family then kids will never inherit any of their families estate. And if I was parent 1 particularly I’d hate this.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 27/03/2024 13:14

Hoppinggreen · 27/03/2024 08:45

Its not the person who inherits decision to make, they should respect the wishes of the person who made the will

Depends on circumstances - abusive parent deliberately leaving a child out is very different to leaving everything to one child with special needs to help support them.

Also once it's inherited it's the property of the person who inherited it and if they choose to share it out that's their choice regardless of what the deceased wanted - which is also why you shouldn't rely on promises to do the right thing.

Yogatoga1 · 27/03/2024 13:04

Would anyone here, if their dh died, give their children his half of the assets?

if your dh died leaving his half to his children, should you be ok with that? Even if it meant you selling up once the children were adults to pay them their half of the house

Yogatoga1 · 27/03/2024 12:46

Surely this applies whether family is blended or not though?

even if you have a traditional family, mum dad and kids. If one parent dies the other inherits.

nothing to stop them remarrying and leaving everything to new partner.

to avoid that you would need to keep everything separate on marriage. No joint accounts, no joint tennant on a house.

everything separate so each spouse can leave their 50% to their kids. Possibly leaving said spouse homeless as a consequence.

what if you marry a man with significantly more assets, and you’re a sahm. If he then leaves his assets to his kids, your shafted.

people seem to make this about second families and kids being cut out. Reality is anyone can be cut out. Like I said, when my dad dies everything went to my mum. His estate was large, and would easily be worth over a million now. I will get nothing as she was a sahm who didn’t want to work, so everything has been sold and liquidated to pay living costs. Should he have left me his half, so my mum couldn’t mismanage/spend it all and I get nothing?

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 27/03/2024 12:40

endofthelinefinally · 27/03/2024 12:13

So create a trust now, so that nobody can scam you out of it if you get ill or have dementia. Wills can be changed any time.

Quite satisfied that what I've done (on legal advice and with the benefit of being a lawyer myself) is appropriate for my situation. But this may be a good solution for others in different circumstances so I appreciate the input.

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 12:35

LadyEloise1 · 27/03/2024 12:28

Yes up to a point but some elderly people can be manipulated and either don't get or don't listen to professional advice.

My old fashioned grandfather was going to leave everything to his sons (after my grandmother got what she was entitled to).
Fortunately my grandmother fought hard and he got professional advice also so that in his will his daughters were looked after too.

He didn't want to include his daughters in his will??

KellyanneConway · 27/03/2024 12:29

Basically it’s shit planning ( maybe deliberate) by the deceased before they died. I supposed context and circumstances play a big part. Me and DH both brought pretty much the same to the relationship financially and had 2 children each from a previous relationship. We have made a joint will where if one of us dies the children of the other get a lump sum each which reflects pretty much the equity in our respective houses when we met which was very similar, and if we both die the estate gets carved up 4 ways equally. But I suppose that’s harder to do if one spouse is financially dependent on the other or one brought a lot more to the table. Personally, I was very keen to make sure that my children didn’t lose out when I re married but others might think differently or can’t be arsed putting the appropriate plans in place

LadyEloise1 · 27/03/2024 12:28

TulipCat · 27/03/2024 07:40

"Fair" is subjective though, isn't it? If it's in the will, then that is what the deceased wanted and it's their money.

Yes up to a point but some elderly people can be manipulated and either don't get or don't listen to professional advice.

My old fashioned grandfather was going to leave everything to his sons (after my grandmother got what she was entitled to).
Fortunately my grandmother fought hard and he got professional advice also so that in his will his daughters were looked after too.

MoonWoman69 · 27/03/2024 12:23

Georgyporky · 27/03/2024 12:00

I'd turn the title on its head.

"Why do people not named as beneficiaries expect to inherit something ?"

Exactly! 👏🏻

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 12:21

uhOhOP · 27/03/2024 12:11

Don't underestimate the impact that would have on him. You say he has an income. Do you think that won't be affected by your death? You're leaving "everything" to your child rather than your husband. Does that include the house he's currently living in?

I'd actually be fucking pissed off if my spouse left everything to the kid and made no provision for me. After all, doesn't the kid inherit on his death, so she gets it anyway?

Not if it's all been left to you! Why would she, when it's become yours?

I think this kind of misunderstanding, and assumptions about inheritance, are a huge cause of many inheritance dramas. Sometimes people will exactly what they want to happen, but too often they don't, and then the beneficiary can legally do what they like.

uhOhOP · 27/03/2024 12:21

Maray1967 · 27/03/2024 12:13

Not necessarily- this is the issue. If he remarries he can leave his wealth to his new wife and it can trickle down to her DC not his. Both parents need to protect their DCs’ interests - they should not assume that the surviving one will do it.

Yes, I'd forgotten about that situation. So a couple should make preparations for their estates by discussing now how to protect their children's interests rather than making a unilateral decision (which is how OP's last post sounded) that the child gets everything.

uhOhOP · 27/03/2024 12:17

I just realised that your "I'm leaving everything to my child" comment isn't where you started off, in your OP, which is about a sole beneficiary taking it upon themselves to ensure the estate is divvied up "fairly". So it seems your OP is just you being disgruntled about being left out.

If you make that choice, that's up to you, and your will should be carried out as you wanted. At the same time, though, I think you should consider your husband. Your last post came across as though you would do that out of spite, in a way, like "well, I wouldn't even dream to leave out the children in favour of the spouse". Not sure if "spite" is the right word, but perhaps you know what I mean.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 27/03/2024 12:17

Twiglets1 · 27/03/2024 08:10

Even if people knew about it, what could they do? If it’s the law then it’s the law and people hoping to inherit have to accept that.

You write a new will after you marry
What this poster means is that marriage overrides an existing will.

endofthelinefinally · 27/03/2024 12:13

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 27/03/2024 11:18

Well, I was left out of a will on one side and it appears that all stuff relating to my dad as a kid (it wasn't his will) got either taken or binned by a cousin. That hurt as it wouldn't have cost them anything to give me a bunch of photos and old school reports.

On my husband's side, he was left all the chattels by his parents (pretty wealthy) but is letting his half-siblings choose from the (fairly valuable) chattels that aren't from his mum's side. He's not close to said siblings, but is also not an arse.

I have made a post-wedding will that is very clear about our daughter inheriting my property (separate house in my name) in case I die first. If I survive my husband then I don't intend to remarry or cohabit again. I don't want any nonsense about contested wills or claims on the estate and I am never going to want my stuff to go to anyone but my daughter, even in some horrible future situation where she doesn't want to see me. I'm always going to be her mum and that is always going to be my most important job.

Edited

So create a trust now, so that nobody can scam you out of it if you get ill or have dementia. Wills can be changed any time.

JudgeJ · 27/03/2024 12:13

Counter question....why don't people who write the will ensure more of a share for others?

In the event of remarrying the wills should reflect this possibility by placing money/property into a trust for the benefit of the surviving spouse only for their lifetime, after that it is distributed in accordance with the trust.