Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't sole beneficiaries of a will share more?

260 replies

malificent7 · 27/03/2024 07:33

I mean in cases where it's clearly unfair. Such as the step mum inheriting all when there are children about or one sibling unexpectedly inheriting everything.
Jusr a bit shocked about inheritance threads ( and concerned about my own stepmum getting everything).

OP posts:
Yogatoga1 · 27/03/2024 17:11

80skid · 27/03/2024 17:08

It is hugely unfair in many cases of second marriages where children miss out on their parents' assets because a subsequent spouse house inherited everything. Equally, why should a subsequent spouse potentially lose their home in order to "pay off" children who are not theirs?
Probate must be a horrible area of law to work in, it really can bring out the worst in people. It does show the importance of proper planning and conversations about expectations before the worst happens, and even then relies on trust.

It’s not just second marriages.

even a first marriage can end up not being passed to the kids. They may spend it all, or need it for care.

no guarantees, even if you leave everything to the child’s other parent. What if they have more kids, splitting the estate further? Even if they leave it to kids rather than a spouse they still may not inherit.

catmomma67 · 27/03/2024 17:10

oh gosh.. so my sister had left her husband, had been living with another man of whom she was engaged too, when her 'husband' sadly passed away in a car crash. because there was no will, she was still his next of kin and therefore she got every penny of his insurance, leaving nothing for his new partner or family. He did not write a will

another thing, my ex-husband remarried and he did write a will, sadly he also passed away. turns out his wife had already begun a new relationship before he died (he was in end of life care).. his will left her everything and she handed nothing over to his children.

Legally on both counts, the money was theirs, with or without a will... morally, those women should not have taken the money or should have given something to those you would expect to have benefitted.

With money and wills, you are damned if you do and damned if you don't. Money will always cause upset to someone

Yogatoga1 · 27/03/2024 17:08

SunshineYay · 27/03/2024 17:01

I think the law needs to change. If someone dies without a will, then their assets should be split equally between the spouse and biological/legally adopted children.

What if that requires selling the house and making the spouse homeless?

currently intestacy rules are first £325k goes to spouse, anything else is split. So the current rules do accommodate spouse and children.

bear in mind spouses also get an inheritance tax exemption. If assets are left to children, bypassing the spouse, a large chunk may go on IHT.

80skid · 27/03/2024 17:08

It is hugely unfair in many cases of second marriages where children miss out on their parents' assets because a subsequent spouse house inherited everything. Equally, why should a subsequent spouse potentially lose their home in order to "pay off" children who are not theirs?
Probate must be a horrible area of law to work in, it really can bring out the worst in people. It does show the importance of proper planning and conversations about expectations before the worst happens, and even then relies on trust.

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 17:05

Saschka · 27/03/2024 16:58

Well, if the money came from a high-earning first wife, or first wife’s family money, and first wife then dies, leaving everything to husband. Husband then remarries, and then dies himself within a year or two. It is grossly unfair that some random second wife gets all the first wife’s money, and the first wife’s own children get nothing.

Obviously it’s a sliding scale, and hopefully most second marriages are long enough that the second wife has also contributed. But I have known situations where the first wife’s children end up with nothing to even remember her by, due to sheer spite from the second wife.

When people get married they pool their resources, there is no longer yours and mine. So when first wife died the remaining money already belonged to her husband, when the husband married again all his possessions and assets belonged to him and his second wife. He could have that point given something to his children but on dying surely everything belongs to his widow?

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 17:04

Spirallingdownwards · 27/03/2024 16:35

Yes indeed I am aware of that and that is why the status of relationships is so important. Perhaps if step children were nicer to step parents those step parents would be more inclined to see through their partner's original wishes as reflected in mirror wills rather than change them after

A step parent shouldn't be exploiting their beloved life partner's death to take revenge on their children.

Given that many do, though...always make a will and don't assume your spouse values your children the way you want them to.

SunshineYay · 27/03/2024 17:01

Fairyliz · 27/03/2024 16:47

I don’t think it’s that he hasn’t provided for his children in his will it’s more like he hasn’t actually made a will, so the laws of intestacy apply which generally means the second wife gets it all.
Apparently only 60% of over 65’s have made a will.

I think the law needs to change. If someone dies without a will, then their assets should be split equally between the spouse and biological/legally adopted children.

Saschka · 27/03/2024 16:58

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 08:50

I don’t think it is “potentially unfair” and the “weird shit” you’re describing is called getting married. It’s a decision to join your finances and life into one. How could it be right to leave your money to your children ahead of your spouse?

Well, if the money came from a high-earning first wife, or first wife’s family money, and first wife then dies, leaving everything to husband. Husband then remarries, and then dies himself within a year or two. It is grossly unfair that some random second wife gets all the first wife’s money, and the first wife’s own children get nothing.

Obviously it’s a sliding scale, and hopefully most second marriages are long enough that the second wife has also contributed. But I have known situations where the first wife’s children end up with nothing to even remember her by, due to sheer spite from the second wife.

PotatoPudding · 27/03/2024 16:48

People are money grabbing shits. My sister keeps arguing against our mum going into sheltered accommodation or moving to a manageable bungalow because it will mean less money for her to inherit.

Fairyliz · 27/03/2024 16:47

SunshineYay · 27/03/2024 08:53

I've read so many sad threads where a man's house and assets all go to the second wife, who then gives that her bio children. It's sad that he hasn't provided for his children in his will.

I don’t think it’s that he hasn’t provided for his children in his will it’s more like he hasn’t actually made a will, so the laws of intestacy apply which generally means the second wife gets it all.
Apparently only 60% of over 65’s have made a will.

purpleme12 · 27/03/2024 16:38

I didn't inherit anything from my dad.
Me and my step mum are not close.
However I don't expect anything of dad's to be shared. Because my step mum is still here living. Isn't that the way it goes? If one of them outlives I would think this is normally the case

Spirallingdownwards · 27/03/2024 16:35

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 27/03/2024 12:03

I think sometimes people think mirror wills guarantee that their intentions will be carried out by their widow or surviving partner, but they don't. Anybody can change a will at any time and there's no obligation to tell anyone else.

Yes indeed I am aware of that and that is why the status of relationships is so important. Perhaps if step children were nicer to step parents those step parents would be more inclined to see through their partner's original wishes as reflected in mirror wills rather than change them after

mumpenalty · 27/03/2024 15:59

SoapOperaFamily · 27/03/2024 15:17

I agree with you there, but this is MN and any child who is disappointed that a dying parent chooses to leave them nothing in favour of leaving everything to a person they married 10 minutes ago is labelled ‘grabby.’ In MN-land, once you have a second spouse all previous offspring should fuck off and keep quiet, that bit of their life is over and they should move on.

I suspect it’s the same cohort of people on MN also who think that the youth of today would be able to get themselves on the property ladder at 25 if only they had fewer coffees and stopped buying avocados.

IDontLikePinaColadas · 27/03/2024 15:55

vanillawaffle · 27/03/2024 08:04

Not necessarily. They can be written in trust

That's what I meant by "If you don’t have excellent legal advice, it’s very easy to find yourself in this position".

My DF & DSM have if written in trust, but it looks years to get it right - without good legal advice, I think people can just assume that all their wishes will carry through when their main beneficiary dies, without realising it can so easily be diverted away from those they may have wanted to inherit further down the line.

SoapOperaFamily · 27/03/2024 15:17

mumpenalty · 27/03/2024 14:59

I get the premise “it’s their money to leave to whoever they chose” but frankly it’s pretty shit to have kids and then not want to do all you can to improve their circumstances. Of course having the freedom to choose is a right but that doesn’t negate the fact that some choices (like sideways disinheritance) are pretty abhorent.

I agree with you there, but this is MN and any child who is disappointed that a dying parent chooses to leave them nothing in favour of leaving everything to a person they married 10 minutes ago is labelled ‘grabby.’ In MN-land, once you have a second spouse all previous offspring should fuck off and keep quiet, that bit of their life is over and they should move on.

mumpenalty · 27/03/2024 14:59

I get the premise “it’s their money to leave to whoever they chose” but frankly it’s pretty shit to have kids and then not want to do all you can to improve their circumstances. Of course having the freedom to choose is a right but that doesn’t negate the fact that some choices (like sideways disinheritance) are pretty abhorent.

MumblesParty · 27/03/2024 14:58

80skid · 27/03/2024 14:53

People are strange. My MiL explained that if my DH dies before her (we've been married a long time and have very joint assets/plans) that his inheritance, which much of it he should technically own already due to business concerns and forms part of both our retirement plans, would go to the kids so I don't get it. So she'd rather my theoretically bereaved kids have a tougher childhood than necessary to prevent me indirectly benefiting. I get blood lines and all that, but she would rather we struggle financially and they inherit at 18 to prevent the situation where I could remarry and leave their money to a future spouse and leave my kids out. I suppose there's no right and wrong answer to this, you just have to hope it doesn't happen and make your plans to be reliant on just yourself not anyone else.

I can sort of understand this.
If she gives it to you, then theoretically you could remarry a compulsive gambler who loses all of it in 6 months, leaving nothing for her grandchildren. Obviously in an ideal world you wouldn’t do that, but love is a strange thing and no one knows what they might do.

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 14:53

Tempnamechng · 27/03/2024 14:27

In the unlikely event that I inherited everything from my parents in favour of a split with siblings, would I insist on splitting the inheritance equally between us knowing that if I take the 100%, I could give my DC enough money to buy a small home each outright. Would any of us, hand on heart, share if we inherited everything from a parent or spouse. People general look to protect their offspring first.
When I redo my will, I'll make sure that half of everything DH and I own at the time of my death will be held in some kind of trust for my dc to be inherited on the demise of my dh.

Yes, I would, and I say that as someone who's not particularly close to my siblings. It honestly wouldn't be worth the fall out that could last generations and from which there'd be no coming back. Money is very important, but it's not the most important thing of all.

Perhaps my mother will need care and there'll be no inheritance anyway. I can't assume anything.

80skid · 27/03/2024 14:53

People are strange. My MiL explained that if my DH dies before her (we've been married a long time and have very joint assets/plans) that his inheritance, which much of it he should technically own already due to business concerns and forms part of both our retirement plans, would go to the kids so I don't get it. So she'd rather my theoretically bereaved kids have a tougher childhood than necessary to prevent me indirectly benefiting. I get blood lines and all that, but she would rather we struggle financially and they inherit at 18 to prevent the situation where I could remarry and leave their money to a future spouse and leave my kids out. I suppose there's no right and wrong answer to this, you just have to hope it doesn't happen and make your plans to be reliant on just yourself not anyone else.

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 14:49

LadyEloise1 · 27/03/2024 14:27

@NonPlayerCharacter
No he didn't want to include his daughters in his will.

Why not?

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 27/03/2024 14:30

The thing is about a will is it is at the instruction of the person whose money it is.

so, nothing unfair about the recipient at all. Because that’s who the person wanted their money to go to and that’s kind of the end of it!

if they wanted other people to have a share, they’d say that.

some families are just bitter and grabby.

Dacadactyl · 27/03/2024 14:30

Tempnamechng · 27/03/2024 14:27

In the unlikely event that I inherited everything from my parents in favour of a split with siblings, would I insist on splitting the inheritance equally between us knowing that if I take the 100%, I could give my DC enough money to buy a small home each outright. Would any of us, hand on heart, share if we inherited everything from a parent or spouse. People general look to protect their offspring first.
When I redo my will, I'll make sure that half of everything DH and I own at the time of my death will be held in some kind of trust for my dc to be inherited on the demise of my dh.

Yes I would share with my sister if she was disinherited. My relationship with her is worth more than any money.

LadyEloise1 · 27/03/2024 14:27

@NonPlayerCharacter
No he didn't want to include his daughters in his will.

Tempnamechng · 27/03/2024 14:27

In the unlikely event that I inherited everything from my parents in favour of a split with siblings, would I insist on splitting the inheritance equally between us knowing that if I take the 100%, I could give my DC enough money to buy a small home each outright. Would any of us, hand on heart, share if we inherited everything from a parent or spouse. People general look to protect their offspring first.
When I redo my will, I'll make sure that half of everything DH and I own at the time of my death will be held in some kind of trust for my dc to be inherited on the demise of my dh.

LetMeGoogleThat · 27/03/2024 14:26

Because that's the whole point of making the will. If the person dies without a will it is shared. My family didn't agree that I got more in inheritance than they did, but they also did nothing for the prior 10 years in supporting them, whereas I did. I would have done it for nothing and only only found out about the division after the person died. But, it was their last wish.

Swipe left for the next trending thread