Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't sole beneficiaries of a will share more?

260 replies

malificent7 · 27/03/2024 07:33

I mean in cases where it's clearly unfair. Such as the step mum inheriting all when there are children about or one sibling unexpectedly inheriting everything.
Jusr a bit shocked about inheritance threads ( and concerned about my own stepmum getting everything).

OP posts:
DistinguishedSocialCommentator · 27/03/2024 19:28

endofthelinefinally · 27/03/2024 09:52

If you make your will properly and with good legal advice this can't happen.

It will happen and it has happened and that's a fact.
Just look at those going to the High court

Saschka · 27/03/2024 18:53

Yogatoga1 · 27/03/2024 17:11

It’s not just second marriages.

even a first marriage can end up not being passed to the kids. They may spend it all, or need it for care.

no guarantees, even if you leave everything to the child’s other parent. What if they have more kids, splitting the estate further? Even if they leave it to kids rather than a spouse they still may not inherit.

I personally think that if your mother spends your father’s estate on her own living costs, that is one thing.

If your father’s estate goes to your mum, then your new stepfather, then his estranged cousin’s children because he doesn’t have children or siblings of his own and those are his next of kin, and you don’t inherit anything from your own father yourself, I do think something has gone wrong somewhere.

KTheGrey · 27/03/2024 18:45

Outonabranch · 27/03/2024 07:47

I guess the problem with step families is that the kids see the step mother ( using Step mum as that is the case given in the OP) as somehow ‘outside’ the family, and they are then unfairly ‘getting’ family money they are not entitled to.

Whereas the spouse sees the ‘step mum’ not as ‘step’ anything but as their dearly beloved wife and life partner, and therefore as absolutely their family and entitled to all the money and security that a first spouse would get without question.

I think the problem is that leaving everything to the stepmother means you disinherit your own children who aren't hers - and sometimes leaving it to her kids instead. I suppose everyone has a right to leave their money and property as they wish, but I don't think you should disinherit your children. You brought them into the world, and you should do right by them. Family is the only bond that stays rock solid, although I guess that's already failed in the case of people leaving stuff to their kids' step parents.

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 18:39

Spirallingdownwards · 27/03/2024 17:56

I am talking about situations where years on the stepchildren had decided to cut the step parent out not months later.

Irrelevant. If you love someone, you don't weaponise their death and their estate and trample on their wishes for their children because you had a quarrel with them. The kids didn't choose to have you in their lives, it's not for you to punish or reward them based on whether they did what you wanted.

But it happens, a lot, so protect your kids with your will.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 27/03/2024 18:33

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 18:28

The couple that are still married are not seeking to break the marriage so it’s not the same. The person who is dying considers themselves bound by that contract. They often allow their spouse to make decisions for them, they are as one. It’s not up to others to judge that relationship and quantify how married they are.

We'll have to agree to disagree there. A short marriage at the end of life is just not comparable to the relationship with adult children who aren't estranged.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 27/03/2024 18:31

The problem is that only a minority of British people have wills, though. The intestacy law gives effect to what most people would want (roughly), but it's not going to get it right for everybody. A lot of people don't think this through because it means facing some difficult facts, e.g. I'm not going to live forever, my new spouse doesn't get on with my kids and seems to be on much better terms with her own kids, etc etc.

Dreemhouse · 27/03/2024 18:28

One of my relatives left the majority of her money, which was a lot, to a cat charity. I thought bloody good on her. She didn’t marry or have children, but always had cats. Surely the will shows who the money should
go to. If the deceased wants it to go to one person, then so be it.

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 18:28

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 27/03/2024 18:20

Yes, but presumably one reason the courts tell a spouse who's only been married for a few months that s/he isn't entitled to 50% of the other spouse's assets is because they haven't been built up together during their intertwined lives as a married couple. Exactly the same applies to a couple who've only been married a short while, one of them dies, the surviving spouse scoops the pool and the adult children of one or more earlier marriages get nothing. The word 'grabby' has been used on this thread about children expecting to inherit from a parent. It seems to me far more applicable to a spouse of very recent standing refusing to share an inheritance with stepchildren.

The couple that are still married are not seeking to break the marriage so it’s not the same. The person who is dying considers themselves bound by that contract. They often allow their spouse to make decisions for them, they are as one. It’s not up to others to judge that relationship and quantify how married they are.

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 18:23

I don’t think the law needs to change. I think that people should be able to leave their money exactly where they want to. The idea that you would be forced to leave money to anyone is awful.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 27/03/2024 18:20

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 18:16

But we’re not talking about people who are seeking to break their marriage. That’s a very different situation. We’re talking about people who die whose wives continue to own their joint assets.

Yes, but presumably one reason the courts tell a spouse who's only been married for a few months that s/he isn't entitled to 50% of the other spouse's assets is because they haven't been built up together during their intertwined lives as a married couple. Exactly the same applies to a couple who've only been married a short while, one of them dies, the surviving spouse scoops the pool and the adult children of one or more earlier marriages get nothing. The word 'grabby' has been used on this thread about children expecting to inherit from a parent. It seems to me far more applicable to a spouse of very recent standing refusing to share an inheritance with stepchildren.

coldcallerbaiter · 27/03/2024 18:16

The inheritance tax system is skewed towards leaving it to a spouse due to allowances.

A step parent in theory can inherit from their first spouse, their own parents and then also the new spouse and the new spouses deceased family too.

We seem to accept this in the UK, but the rules are different in many Euro countries, dc are protected.

The law needs reforming.

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 18:16

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 27/03/2024 17:32

That's not, I believe, the approach taken by the courts if a married couple get divorced. Assets are considered pooled in a long marriage, but not in a very short one.

But we’re not talking about people who are seeking to break their marriage. That’s a very different situation. We’re talking about people who die whose wives continue to own their joint assets.

Spirallingdownwards · 27/03/2024 17:56

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 17:52

The step parent can't have loved their partner that much if they are willing to exploit their death and ignore their wishes (which I agree should be put in a will for this very reason) just to cock a snook at the kids for their money. That being the case, I'd think it likely the kids had good reason to dislike them.

I am talking about situations where years on the stepchildren had decided to cut the step parent out not months later.

Stickyricepudding · 27/03/2024 17:55

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m001xmd4

You need to listen to today's radio 4 programme on wills and the different types available for different circumstances.

BBC Radio 4 - Money Box, Money Box Live: How Do Wills Work?

More than half of us don't have a will, so what happens to your estate if you don't?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m001xmd4

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 17:52

Spirallingdownwards · 27/03/2024 17:23

Exactly and I agree rhe original parent shojld consider potential issues and take legal advice. But often you see the stepchildren in these cases just ghost the step parent and not treat them well after their parent has passed but then get pissed off when the step parent too has moved on after a number of years and moan that the step parent has revised their will

The step parent can't have loved their partner that much if they are willing to exploit their death and ignore their wishes (which I agree should be put in a will for this very reason) just to cock a snook at the kids for their money. That being the case, I'd think it likely the kids had good reason to dislike them.

Tracker1234 · 27/03/2024 17:41

I believe just under 50% of people have wills. It might be less... thing is some people just never get round to it, some have a feeling that whatever is in their head is automatically translated once they have passed and honestly - some are just plain daft and havent got the time, knowledge or energy to sort one out.

With step families it is really really important to get one sorted. Your previous will is invalid if you remarry and you do need to review your will say every 10 years or so. You also need to state you have one in the first place and where it is to lots of people. Would recommend a will register.

My late parent had a funeral plan. Very luckily despite the chaos they lived in they did have the paperwork and told key people. Apparently its rather common for the deseased person's family to arrange the funeral without knowing about any funeral plan!

Ihavehadenoughalready · 27/03/2024 17:37

Your father is entitled to name whom he wants as the sole beneficiary. Has he named you and siblings as contingent beneficiaries? Has your step mom named her stepchildren (you and your siblings and possibly her own children) as contingent beneficiaries to your father?

It's really out of your control, and if I were you I wouldn't say a word of complaint. If stepmom is named, you have no right to the estate. My opinion is that nobody should ever assume they will get an inheritance, but great bonus if they do.

When my father-in-law died, one of his sons got nothing, written quite clearly in the will. The other siblings split the rest. Was this fair to the son who got nothing? Yes, yes it was, because it turned out he had gotten tons of money and support through the years that the other siblings had not. Still he complained, but the executor knew the situation and put his foot down and followed the edicts of the will.

HeraSyndulla · 27/03/2024 17:34

Where there’s a will, there’s a relative !.

MississippiAF · 27/03/2024 17:33

What is ‘unfair?’

Wills should be split exactly how the person intended. No one involved can have an objective perspective on what is ‘fair’

Darker · 27/03/2024 17:33

ItsNotAPoolBasedHoliday · 27/03/2024 17:23

I think the law needs to change. If someone dies without a will, then their assets should be split equally between the spouse and biological/legally adopted children.

My auntie had two teenagers when her dh died and the two boys inherited one quarter of the family home each.

As soon as the oldest was eighteen he took her to court for the value of his quarter and she was ordered to give it to him so she had to sell the house and move in to a one bedroom flat with her sixteen year old son who had to sleep on the sofa whilst his brother spent all of the money on Golf GTIs and going to Ibiza.

Twenty years on she never recovered financially and has had a difficult life since then and she and her younger ds have no real relationship with the older one.

I'm fairly sure that is not what her husband would have wanted.

This is very sad… easy to say in hindsight but it would have made sense to say that the money couldn’t be accessed until the child was an adult - 25 or even 30.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 27/03/2024 17:32

TomeTome · 27/03/2024 17:05

When people get married they pool their resources, there is no longer yours and mine. So when first wife died the remaining money already belonged to her husband, when the husband married again all his possessions and assets belonged to him and his second wife. He could have that point given something to his children but on dying surely everything belongs to his widow?

That's not, I believe, the approach taken by the courts if a married couple get divorced. Assets are considered pooled in a long marriage, but not in a very short one.

Tara336 · 27/03/2024 17:24

We are in the process of writing wills and it is a minefield. Second marriage 3 children from previous marriages. One SD estranged from DH for over 10 years, DH does not want her included in any will, we have been advised that as important as it is to include beneficiaries its also important to clearly exclude people as well.

ItsNotAPoolBasedHoliday · 27/03/2024 17:23

I think the law needs to change. If someone dies without a will, then their assets should be split equally between the spouse and biological/legally adopted children.

My auntie had two teenagers when her dh died and the two boys inherited one quarter of the family home each.

As soon as the oldest was eighteen he took her to court for the value of his quarter and she was ordered to give it to him so she had to sell the house and move in to a one bedroom flat with her sixteen year old son who had to sleep on the sofa whilst his brother spent all of the money on Golf GTIs and going to Ibiza.

Twenty years on she never recovered financially and has had a difficult life since then and she and her younger ds have no real relationship with the older one.

I'm fairly sure that is not what her husband would have wanted.

Spirallingdownwards · 27/03/2024 17:23

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 17:04

A step parent shouldn't be exploiting their beloved life partner's death to take revenge on their children.

Given that many do, though...always make a will and don't assume your spouse values your children the way you want them to.

Exactly and I agree rhe original parent shojld consider potential issues and take legal advice. But often you see the stepchildren in these cases just ghost the step parent and not treat them well after their parent has passed but then get pissed off when the step parent too has moved on after a number of years and moan that the step parent has revised their will

80skid · 27/03/2024 17:15

catmomma67 · 27/03/2024 17:10

oh gosh.. so my sister had left her husband, had been living with another man of whom she was engaged too, when her 'husband' sadly passed away in a car crash. because there was no will, she was still his next of kin and therefore she got every penny of his insurance, leaving nothing for his new partner or family. He did not write a will

another thing, my ex-husband remarried and he did write a will, sadly he also passed away. turns out his wife had already begun a new relationship before he died (he was in end of life care).. his will left her everything and she handed nothing over to his children.

Legally on both counts, the money was theirs, with or without a will... morally, those women should not have taken the money or should have given something to those you would expect to have benefitted.

With money and wills, you are damned if you do and damned if you don't. Money will always cause upset to someone

I would like to think that in that situation, I would do the right thing and accept that the will should have been updated but hadn't been. Imagine leaving someone's kids without when you've both moved on! There's legally right, but there's also morally right and sometimes they do differ.

Swipe left for the next trending thread