Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't sole beneficiaries of a will share more?

260 replies

malificent7 · 27/03/2024 07:33

I mean in cases where it's clearly unfair. Such as the step mum inheriting all when there are children about or one sibling unexpectedly inheriting everything.
Jusr a bit shocked about inheritance threads ( and concerned about my own stepmum getting everything).

OP posts:
MrsDilligaf · 29/03/2024 07:38

My cousins got nothing following the death of their DM. Their step-father inherited everything (married for around 10 years). My aunt had a substantial divorce settlement, and had a lot of family jewellery, sentimental items relating to cousins but also quite a lot my grandmother's possessions. Cousins were told by SF that they would inherit from maternal grandmother and so they couldn't have anything.

It was very unpleasant, but their mums wishes were clear - everything was left to SF.

VestibuleVirgin · 29/03/2024 07:23

Move to France; step-kids get 5/8ths of fuck all.
That would keep all the 'happily blended' families happy

oprahwindsock · 29/03/2024 07:17

I'm fed up reading about disgruntled families left nothing while a step parent inherits.

Let me explain.

I'm a stepmum, kids were teenagers when I married my late husband 40 years ago. We then had two kids. Both of us worked, my husband supported kids from first marriage through education and uni. And after, when they needed a helping hand financially. This wasn't just his money he used it was ours. I was working too don't forget.

I inherit from my late parents - husband inherits from his. It all goes into the pot.

Fast forward 40 years husband dies and leaves everything to me with Mirror Will in place stating how money to be split in the event of me dying.

Now, suppose instead we split the inheritance while I'm still alive, I have to sell the family home to pay the kids. I have to go on benefits because the money in savings has to be split 5 ways. I am now in poverty. I've lost everything I've worked all my life for. I no longer have peace of mind.

You tell me why the step parent should not inherit totally?

VestibuleVirgin · 29/03/2024 07:10

MissLucyx · 27/03/2024 07:42

YANBU but you’re unrealistic. A lot of step parents are extremely toxic to their step kids. Just go on the step parent threads.

I do't think any step-parent on MN likes their SC. And when you mention inheritance, it's like the start of armeggedon!

NonPlayerCharacter · 29/03/2024 07:04

newwidowtobe · 28/03/2024 21:57

How is that Allfur ?? His wife was sleeping with her aerobics teacher.. he was a contractor away from home providing a very comfortable life which included a full nanny and cleaner for a SAHM ?

She made it clear he was unwelcome when he returned,,,so he left.., when he met me she wanted a meeting,, het first statement was ' our status can't change' 'i don't give a rats arse about who he fucks but he needs to maintain his children's and my lifestyle' .. I left .. she married the aerobics teacher who left her after 3 years so has spent 20 years telling the kids how awful dad is .. which they believe despite evidence to the contrary.

All the evidence you've given - and you're on his side! - backs it up. This entire post is about how terrible the ex is, yet the kids are being punished. His approach to his kids is possessive, transactional, entitled and nastily mixed up in his first failed marriage. Perhaps his ex's decision to stay home wasn't a mutual one and he would have preferred her to work, but with four kids and a husband who was away a lot I can see why it made sense. If he'd got the 50:50 he apparently so desperately wanted, who would have looked after them while he worked away so much? Why does he not seem to value that work at all?

And given he's now weaponising his kids' inheritance because he doesn't feel they deserve it for not giving him enough after what was clearly a nasty split in which it sounds like they got weaponised themselves...Well frankly it sounds as if he and his ex both prioritised money in pretty much the same way as each other.

He's chosen his legacy and he'll be remembered for the kind of father he is: a King Lear who weaponises money, has a possessive, conditional and entitled attitude towards parenting and love, and sees inheritance as something children must earn by pleasing him, no matter what shit they went through in their formative years thanks to the adults' choices. He thinks his children owe him something.

Personally I'd be devastated if that were my legacy, but he's obviously happy with it and so are you. So enjoy the money and be glad he'll be remembered by his children as who he was. It's all his choice and it's what he wants. Be happy!

IvorTheEngineDriver · 28/03/2024 22:30

Why should they. My G/father's second wife got the lot. Shit happens.

newwidowtobe · 28/03/2024 21:57

How is that Allfur ?? His wife was sleeping with her aerobics teacher.. he was a contractor away from home providing a very comfortable life which included a full nanny and cleaner for a SAHM ?

She made it clear he was unwelcome when he returned,,,so he left.., when he met me she wanted a meeting,, het first statement was ' our status can't change' 'i don't give a rats arse about who he fucks but he needs to maintain his children's and my lifestyle' .. I left .. she married the aerobics teacher who left her after 3 years so has spent 20 years telling the kids how awful dad is .. which they believe despite evidence to the contrary.

Allfur · 27/03/2024 21:32

newwidowtobe · 27/03/2024 21:24

They are all adults now and want nothing do with hi mm because he left their mother (nothing to do with me I was long after !... ) but should leave his estate to children who couldn't even say happy birthday.. the fifteen years they spent with us under court order .. laughing, having fun, (making keepsakes all saved) ..no ! They have made their choice .

A situation he created

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 21:30

newwidowtobe · 27/03/2024 21:24

They are all adults now and want nothing do with hi mm because he left their mother (nothing to do with me I was long after !... ) but should leave his estate to children who couldn't even say happy birthday.. the fifteen years they spent with us under court order .. laughing, having fun, (making keepsakes all saved) ..no ! They have made their choice .

Well, he's chosen his legacy. I think he's made a terrible choice but from the sound of his transactional attitude towards love, money, parenthood and the realities of child rearing, it sounds as if it's the one he wants. It definitely reflects his priorities and values.

newwidowtobe · 27/03/2024 21:24

They are all adults now and want nothing do with hi mm because he left their mother (nothing to do with me I was long after !... ) but should leave his estate to children who couldn't even say happy birthday.. the fifteen years they spent with us under court order .. laughing, having fun, (making keepsakes all saved) ..no ! They have made their choice .

catmomma67 · 27/03/2024 20:54

80skid · 27/03/2024 17:15

I would like to think that in that situation, I would do the right thing and accept that the will should have been updated but hadn't been. Imagine leaving someone's kids without when you've both moved on! There's legally right, but there's also morally right and sometimes they do differ.

oh i agree... i personally would do 'the right thing' but when vast sums of money are being handed to some people, greed simply takes over! I have learned from this and i have amended my own will, and have made sure my daughters are fully included no matter what happens

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 20:53

newwidowtobe · 27/03/2024 20:16

IF your kids deserve it !!

My children don't need to earn their inheritance from me. I'm their parent and I want to do right by them; it's not a reward for living as I tell them. And they sure as fuck shouldn't have to earn it from a step parent whose presence in their lives wasn't their choice. My love for them is unconditional. They don't have to love me back, although of course I'd be devastated if they didn't and something would have gone wrong. But their inheritance isn't payment for their love. I'm not King Lear.

But that's why, if I become single, I'll never marry again. I don't want to complicate or risk their inheritance.

Allfur · 27/03/2024 20:49

newwidowtobe · 27/03/2024 19:39

I'll tell you why. In my case, I'm married my DH after he had four kids with his ex-wife. We had those children every other weekend without fail through illness, sickness and trauma. We wanted to have them much more, but their mother was adamant that she was best place to look after them. Massively helped by the amount of £1500 worth of child maintenance paid every month on the dot plus the mortgage of the Michael home. The mother never worked. She felt that giving birth to the children entitled her to this.

They were absolutely and completely poisoned against my husband. At Age 16, they stopped coming. Although they continue to text and send kind messages to me and their dad for the next six years (the cAO expired at this age) , but they told us they could no longer visit because their mum got so upset And they felt obliged to take her side by this point, they had been divorced 20 years...

They refuse to visit . My husband is so upset by this but doesn't want to push it. I would absolutely love them to visit.

My husband made his Will last week and left everything to me. He had a large premium bond win two years ago (the children do not know this) he does not want them to visit because he has money. As he says, they either want to see me they don't and the only person in the world who truly loves me is you therefore I want you to have the money. (It's mine anyway, because we're marriage, but that is how it happens.)

That's really sad for his kids, first he leaves them, then he leaves them nothing

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/03/2024 20:49

newwidowtobe · 27/03/2024 19:39

I'll tell you why. In my case, I'm married my DH after he had four kids with his ex-wife. We had those children every other weekend without fail through illness, sickness and trauma. We wanted to have them much more, but their mother was adamant that she was best place to look after them. Massively helped by the amount of £1500 worth of child maintenance paid every month on the dot plus the mortgage of the Michael home. The mother never worked. She felt that giving birth to the children entitled her to this.

They were absolutely and completely poisoned against my husband. At Age 16, they stopped coming. Although they continue to text and send kind messages to me and their dad for the next six years (the cAO expired at this age) , but they told us they could no longer visit because their mum got so upset And they felt obliged to take her side by this point, they had been divorced 20 years...

They refuse to visit . My husband is so upset by this but doesn't want to push it. I would absolutely love them to visit.

My husband made his Will last week and left everything to me. He had a large premium bond win two years ago (the children do not know this) he does not want them to visit because he has money. As he says, they either want to see me they don't and the only person in the world who truly loves me is you therefore I want you to have the money. (It's mine anyway, because we're marriage, but that is how it happens.)

If you believe they were poisoned against him as children then it's a shame they're being punished for it. I'm also a little disturbed that he appears to be so transactional towards his kids after apparently being so desperate to see more of them. The maintenance money wasn't a favour to their mother either, it was their due as his children.

More to the story, perhaps.

LlynTegid · 27/03/2024 20:44

I think that the wishes of a person should be respected, unless there is evidence of coercion or not being of sound mind.

TheSeasonalNameChange · 27/03/2024 20:39

@Yogatoga1 good point. Tenants in common for the house or other biggest asset and lifetime trust as needed.

Dollyparton3 · 27/03/2024 20:37

@malificent7 for context, can you tell us how much inheritance you "expect" from both parents after they've worked all of their adult lives to pay for their wealth and how much a stepmum might be contributing to your father's "estate"? Then we can advise you more clearly on how much you should or shouldn't feel entitled to

Yogatoga1 · 27/03/2024 20:17

TheSeasonalNameChange · 27/03/2024 20:08

This really isn't a difficult problem. Just make damn sure your share of any joint assets are left in trust for your kids.

You'd be amazed at the mental gymnastics people can perform to justify what they want to do as fair anyway, whether will related or not.

If assets are joint your share automatically passes to the survivor.

you would need to make sure the family home is not joint tenants, and bank accounts, savings, or any other assets aren’t joint.

you would also need to make sure your share does not exceed IHT levels- considerably less than passing to a spouse or a joint asset.

it would make marriage obsolete as a major point of marriage is inheritance so the remaining spouse is financially provided for.

if you want to leave your assets to your kids, don’t get married and keep all your finances separate.

also bear in mind that leaving to your kids could mean selling the family home once all are adults. I had a friend who inherited his mums house, and evicted their stepdad asap, leaving him with nothing.

newwidowtobe · 27/03/2024 20:16

TheSeasonalNameChange · 27/03/2024 20:08

This really isn't a difficult problem. Just make damn sure your share of any joint assets are left in trust for your kids.

You'd be amazed at the mental gymnastics people can perform to justify what they want to do as fair anyway, whether will related or not.

IF your kids deserve it !!

TheSeasonalNameChange · 27/03/2024 20:08

This really isn't a difficult problem. Just make damn sure your share of any joint assets are left in trust for your kids.

You'd be amazed at the mental gymnastics people can perform to justify what they want to do as fair anyway, whether will related or not.

Menomeno · 27/03/2024 19:56

SoapOperaFamily · 27/03/2024 15:17

I agree with you there, but this is MN and any child who is disappointed that a dying parent chooses to leave them nothing in favour of leaving everything to a person they married 10 minutes ago is labelled ‘grabby.’ In MN-land, once you have a second spouse all previous offspring should fuck off and keep quiet, that bit of their life is over and they should move on.

Conversely the second wife could have been married to the man for thirty years, and been the major breadwinner. If the man dies, she should cart herself off to the YMCA so her DSCs can have all the joint marital assets.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 27/03/2024 19:48

coldcallerbaiter · 27/03/2024 18:16

The inheritance tax system is skewed towards leaving it to a spouse due to allowances.

A step parent in theory can inherit from their first spouse, their own parents and then also the new spouse and the new spouses deceased family too.

We seem to accept this in the UK, but the rules are different in many Euro countries, dc are protected.

The law needs reforming.

Edited

Reforming could mean someone in my situation, a similar age to DH's children, losing my home so they can have their share. How would that be fair?

DistinguishedSocialCommentator · 27/03/2024 19:45

endofthelinefinally · 27/03/2024 19:33

I would assume the legal advice was poor. This happened to a friend who employed a very expensive solicitor. The will was wrongly drafted and a huge court case ensued. Absolutely outrageous, but the solicitor, despite charging a fortune, got it wrong. It is a minefield. But I would always recommend using an estate planner, not a solicitor, if you have property or investments.

No
Look at the cases in the papers in the High court - The judge makes a decision as the judge felt x/y/z should have not been entirely cut out

Its playing silly games as its easy to say "write a will properly" and you think those in press where often a million plus was let to one person and even reasons given why others were not included and the judge went ahead and over ruled it

Re "poor advice." Dot forget, if those fighting the case have deeper pockets and the defendant of the Will does not, any good barrister could run rings around a barrister that was not an expert in the field

The sad truth is (read my initial post here) - a dead persons last wishes are not respected. Why should Mrs Dakota Sumerhigh have her will over turned when in the Will it explicitly stated that not a penny to going to money-grabbing parasite, Johnny her son, Adam her second and everything was left to her thrid child, Goodmary as she was that looked after her for years and never tried to chet her out of her monies.

newwidowtobe · 27/03/2024 19:39

I'll tell you why. In my case, I'm married my DH after he had four kids with his ex-wife. We had those children every other weekend without fail through illness, sickness and trauma. We wanted to have them much more, but their mother was adamant that she was best place to look after them. Massively helped by the amount of £1500 worth of child maintenance paid every month on the dot plus the mortgage of the Michael home. The mother never worked. She felt that giving birth to the children entitled her to this.

They were absolutely and completely poisoned against my husband. At Age 16, they stopped coming. Although they continue to text and send kind messages to me and their dad for the next six years (the cAO expired at this age) , but they told us they could no longer visit because their mum got so upset And they felt obliged to take her side by this point, they had been divorced 20 years...

They refuse to visit . My husband is so upset by this but doesn't want to push it. I would absolutely love them to visit.

My husband made his Will last week and left everything to me. He had a large premium bond win two years ago (the children do not know this) he does not want them to visit because he has money. As he says, they either want to see me they don't and the only person in the world who truly loves me is you therefore I want you to have the money. (It's mine anyway, because we're marriage, but that is how it happens.)

endofthelinefinally · 27/03/2024 19:33

DistinguishedSocialCommentator · 27/03/2024 19:28

It will happen and it has happened and that's a fact.
Just look at those going to the High court

I would assume the legal advice was poor. This happened to a friend who employed a very expensive solicitor. The will was wrongly drafted and a huge court case ensued. Absolutely outrageous, but the solicitor, despite charging a fortune, got it wrong. It is a minefield. But I would always recommend using an estate planner, not a solicitor, if you have property or investments.