Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A horrible inheritance one

136 replies

Glasto73lover · 26/03/2024 22:22

My dad died 18 months ago and everything was left to my
stepmother but I did inherit a cash sum. That’s not the issue here.

Stepmother is now selling off some of my Dads possessions including some furniture that belonged to my grandparents and has said if I want it, I have to buy it off her.

Aibu for being really upset at having to buy my own Dad & grandparents possessions? I can barely believe it to be honest. I only want one sentimental piece that I don’t want going to a stranger but the whole thing has really upset me as I know my Dad would have been upset too and horrified,

OP posts:
Fulshaw · 27/03/2024 07:57

I’d offer to make a charity donation in his name. Let her say no to that.

TillyTrifle · 27/03/2024 07:54

Do you know her friends and family? If so I wouldn’t hesitate to broadcast far and wide how upset you are that she’s making you buy sentimental family items after your dad’s death because she’s so cash grabbing. She probably has no shame but it’s worth a try.

pearpporridge · 27/03/2024 07:52

Unless your father was an antiques collector, she'll probably find old items of brown furniture are practically worthless. She may end up having to pay to have them taken away. Ask to be there when the 'expert' is valuing them so that you can have first dibs, then buy whatever it is you want, mentally leave a curse hanging over her and walk away for ever. As others have pointed out, your father could have changed his will and done things differently but chose not to.

rwalker · 27/03/2024 07:51

Pay then ditch her
in her defence ( if there possibly could be one) the stuff with hold no emotional value to her so I can see why she’s selling but charging family is shit

some people don’t think my mum literally threw all my dads stuff away never asked any of us if we wanted anything
I wasn’t bothered my sister was distraught but luckily we got his glasses and watch back from undertaker weeks later as they remove them before they cremate them

Trixiefirecracker · 27/03/2024 07:48

HazelBite · 27/03/2024 07:40

Can I just say OP that at the end of the day it is just "stuff" , inanimate objects. You have your memories of your Dad, yes it's sad if you can't have all those lovely items back to remember him by, and your stepmother is being unfair and grasping, but as PP's said secondhand furniture does not sell well.
The faff of selling stuff, possible auction fees, might end up not being worth it to her.
For the sake of fairness ask her to get it valued!! She might be surprised.
When all is said and done though it is just things/stuff, you still have your memories OP.

I disagree. It is important or can be too many. I was really upset I didn’t get to have the sentimental things that meant so much to me growing up, they were not valuable but were things I had an attachment to and reminded me of that person. It is a tangible link to the deceased and , aside from that, some things should stay in families and have the option to be passed down. I totally get why the OP is upset.

Pinkyhere · 27/03/2024 07:47

We had to sell lots of mils antique furniture when she downsized and it made nothing at auction. It was shocking how low it went for, obviously it depends on the item but if you can hold your nerve, it might be worth buying it from whoever your step mother sells it through.

Also, I sympathise with the ugliness of the situation. It's devastating how calculating and unkind people can be. My grandfather's wife was vile before and after he died. I am thankful everyday that I no longer have her in our lives.

HazelBite · 27/03/2024 07:40

Can I just say OP that at the end of the day it is just "stuff" , inanimate objects. You have your memories of your Dad, yes it's sad if you can't have all those lovely items back to remember him by, and your stepmother is being unfair and grasping, but as PP's said secondhand furniture does not sell well.
The faff of selling stuff, possible auction fees, might end up not being worth it to her.
For the sake of fairness ask her to get it valued!! She might be surprised.
When all is said and done though it is just things/stuff, you still have your memories OP.

Walkingwashingmachine · 27/03/2024 07:37

Glasto73lover · 27/03/2024 05:56

@Alchemistress i know my father would have wanted the bits in question to stay in the family- I don’t think he would have expected her to flog it. I honestly don’t know why he didn’t make a proper Will to be honest - it’s baffling. I guess people don’t account for how mad people go when there’s money involved.

Are you saying he died intestate (without a Will)? Or have you seen a Will. Its a public document. There may be a life interest in the Will which means that there is a trust which owns your Dad's estate rather than your step mother outright. That's the usual way a Will protects children if a parent remarries, if your dad did get any proper legal advice.

Having said that, furniture is not always included.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 27/03/2024 07:37

RogueFemale · 26/03/2024 22:58

Pay. Say nothing. Never speak to her again.

yep.

shepherdsangeldelight · 27/03/2024 07:31

If the item only has sentimental value, then OP's step mother might well let her have the item once she's discovered this.

I am mindful of only one side of the argument here. We actually have no idea about OP's dad's wishes or what sort of terms they were on.

My response may be slightly jaded by the fact that we're currently clearing my MIL's house and the only "sentimental" item that BIL wants is coincidentally the only item actually worth anything. (And on the flip side some items that have actually been willed are not wanted by the proposed recipient!)

ceneta · 27/03/2024 07:31

Your dad did make a proper will but it probably never occurred to him that she would do this.

I'm in the same position. I have a stepson and my DH has left a cash sum to his son and everything else to me. It wouldn't occur to me in a million years to keep all of his personal possessions, I would pass them on, and if there's something sentimental from the family that they want they'd be welcome to it. Offering to sell it to you is disgraceful.

serin · 27/03/2024 07:26

Ihearyousingingdownthewire · 26/03/2024 23:21

She’s a cunt. I’d pay her, take the stuff, tell her she’s a cunt, and never speak to her again.

Do we really have to resort to such misogyny.

malificent7 · 27/03/2024 07:25

People who are saying it's your dad's choice are missing thevpoint....the dad was a massive twat to do that to his own kids and she is an even bigger twat for selling family furniture!

Trixiefirecracker · 27/03/2024 07:24

I had a similar experience but tbh once they had it valued and realised stuff wasn’t going to go for much I was able to negotiate with them and take three things that I wanted. Unfortunately or fortunately second hand furniture and belongings often don’t reflect their sentimental value in market price, especially homemade pieces. I know it’s sucks but maybe she will have a change of heart. Still hurts though.

Cherrysoup · 27/03/2024 07:15

Ilovemyshed · 27/03/2024 07:05

But it was her dad's choice as he didn't specify in the will.

Exactly. We just wrote our wills, no dc, so we’ve said that all items in the house are to be disposed of by two of our beneficiaries because they’re (currently) in the same country. If I hadn’t specified, god knows what would happen to everything. Be very specific when writing wills.

Im really sorry for your loss, @Glasto73lover this just pokes the wound, frankly. Your stepmother is a bitch.

wagnbobble · 27/03/2024 07:07

Think she is in for a surprise at the actual price a valuer will pay for the furniture - my parents collected furniture and paid good prices from antique dealers . However houses and fashions change and what was listed as the value of the item in their insurance and the price we got was far less . Hoping the items you want are “ cheap” for your sake . This is so horrible for you to go though

Ilovemyshed · 27/03/2024 07:05

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 26/03/2024 22:49

To be frank @Glasto73lover I'm quite shocked 1% think you unreasonable. Did you have a poor relationship with your stepmother? If you just want a couple of things she doesn’t it seems unkind to want to charge you for them. I’d pay her, what choice do you have? But remember this is not your dad’s choice. I’m sorry for your loss.

But it was her dad's choice as he didn't specify in the will.

Heronwatcher · 27/03/2024 07:03

Yes she’s being U, but your dad was more U to leave it to her in the first place- legally she’s doing nothing wrong.

Personally I would use some of the cash he left you to buy the best piece/ piece you want most and try to move on. Chances are it won’t be worth much. Or give her a chance to sell it and if it doesn’t sell offer to do her a favour by taking it away- she’d have to pay the council to do that. Then block her.

MorningPink · 27/03/2024 07:02

The mindset is petty, greedy, jealous and socially a bit thick.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 27/03/2024 07:02

Superlambaanana · 27/03/2024 06:52

@MyrtlethePurpleTurtle that's utter nonsense. Executors are not legally obliged to actually sell anything. Just get things valued.

No - executors are obliged to realise the estate and distribute the estate. Their role is not one of a mere valuation channel!

Whether the deceased's principal beneficiary should morally gift items or money from the estate is a different matter

Ramalangadingdong · 27/03/2024 06:57

Wow. That is incredibly mean. I can't understand the mindset of someone who would even think of doing something like that.

So sorry. But at least now you don't have to have anything to do with her.

Superlambaanana · 27/03/2024 06:52

@MyrtlethePurpleTurtle that's utter nonsense. Executors are not legally obliged to actually sell anything. Just get things valued.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 27/03/2024 06:50

Glasto73lover · 26/03/2024 22:22

My dad died 18 months ago and everything was left to my
stepmother but I did inherit a cash sum. That’s not the issue here.

Stepmother is now selling off some of my Dads possessions including some furniture that belonged to my grandparents and has said if I want it, I have to buy it off her.

Aibu for being really upset at having to buy my own Dad & grandparents possessions? I can barely believe it to be honest. I only want one sentimental piece that I don’t want going to a stranger but the whole thing has really upset me as I know my Dad would have been upset too and horrified,

If she is executor of the estate and not the sole beneficiary - which appears may be the case as you, for example, are also a beneficiary - she is legally obliged to do this to realise the estate (other than items of no worth or trivial value).

I am sorry for your loss

GreatGateauxsby · 27/03/2024 06:50

Ilovecashews · 27/03/2024 06:31

I was in a similar situation, my dad left me in a mess with his wife (not my mother). We need to stop excusing the men and criticising the women. My dad knew at some Point he was going to die and didn’t provide for that. Your dad knew that at some point he was going to die and decided to divide up his belonging as he did. If he really wanted you to have them he could have asked you whether that was the case when alive.

Agree with thid.

I read your post and in your shoes I'd feel anger at my father as well.
I see these situations SO often.. inadequate wills left by men who cant be arsed. My father did the same but it wasnt a legal will so overtuelrned and estate was split between his children (not uk)

Honestly stepmums behaviour is unusual and VERY few people would exhibit to this kind of behaviour. Ie. This behaviour could likely be expected by your dad
Also....HE WAS MARRIED TO HER so surely knew what she was like.

Why didnt he make adequate provision?

Practically
In your shoes I'd ask for "prices" for 5 or 6 things so she doesnt know what you really want and haggle her down on all 6.
Buy the one thing you really want once you have "final" prices.

Put the memory in a box, push it to the back and get on with your life.

Superlambaanana · 27/03/2024 06:49

That's horrible of her.

I wonder if your dad was assuming that it would run the way it normally does in families- i.e. one parent dies and leaves everything to the surviving parent, then when second parent dies, everything goes to the children.

But your step mother obviously isn't intending to leave anything to you.

If you think it was your dad's intention that she would leave things to you, I think you should write to her. Writing a letter and posting it might seem old fashioned but putting something in writing has the effect of making people think. And it will be cathartic for you. Don't be rude, be heartfelt,

You have no legal ground to stand on, but you could appeal to her sense of fairness and point out the furniture has been passed down from previous generations and you understood your father wished the same to happen for the next/ your generation.

Second hand furniture has little value and is actually quite hard to sell. Selling directly to you makes it very easy for her. Send a nice letter and then let her deal with trying to offload the furniture as you way of achieving some satisfaction. Then buy it from whoever she sells it to!