Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister stole my baby name

364 replies

JessMathews8 · 26/03/2024 22:07

I'm really struggling to deal with this, my sister is 10 years older than me and has three children aged between 18 and 15. She was done witn having kids, has said this for years and years. But her new partner wanted a baby.I have a 6 year old boy, and currently pregnant with a girl. When I was pregnant with my son, before we knew he was a boy I had a girls name set and was after my Nana, always said that the next baby if its a girl I will name her after Nana, it took us 4 years of trying to get pregnant again.My sister got pregnant one month before I did and said that I'd she has a girl she will be using my Nanas name and it's her name, she's due first so she has first dibs.She didn't find out what she was having, but she gave birth yesterday, to a girl and has named her after my Nana.I'm due in 3 weeks, and feel so angry and upset she has used a name for the last 6 years I have said I would use if I have a girl, I found out its a girl at 16 weeks when she told me I could use the name as I know its a girl but shes literally just named her daughter it. Am I an asshole for being upset and mad?
My mum has told me I'm being unreasonable and she has always liked the name. Which she may of done but she always said she was done having kids, and everyone knew that it was the name I would use if I was to ever have a girl. I feel so hurt

OP posts:
Lisbeth50 · 27/03/2024 09:11

We have lots of repeated names in our family. My sister & my cousin, my ds1 and my cousin's ds, my ds2 and another cousin's ds. Lots of middle names repeated too because they are after relatives.

Dp has 2 cousins who are brothers and their dds have the same name.

Use the name if you like it.

Janch13 · 27/03/2024 09:11

Topseyt123 · 27/03/2024 09:10

Disappointed!! Why? It's a perfectly good name.

That’s the grandparents issue, not OPs. Plenty of families have members with the same names (ie Dad & Sons) and they manage just fine.

Topseyt123 · 27/03/2024 09:10

PutOnYourRedShoesAndLetsDance · 27/03/2024 09:03

I'm with you OP.. I think it's just nasty.. you have wanted that name for so so long..
I real feel for you.
People saying to use it.. l wouldn't.. that would mean their Grandparents having two Grandaughters with same name and that's just weird..
If my daughters used the same name for their sons I'd be so disappointed.
Maybe use it as a middle name and give some deep thought to another beautiful name.

Disappointed!! Why? It's a perfectly good name.

Janch13 · 27/03/2024 09:09

I had a similar thing with my SIL blatantly stealing a baby name.

Use the name, OP. And if anyone in your family queries your baby girl having the same name as her cousin simply say “everyone knows we had this name chosen for years.” If anyone outside your family thinks it’s a bit odd for her to have the same name as her cousin just say “it’s a family name, they’re both named after their great-grandmothers” with a smile.

I actually think it’s quite sweet that your Nana will have 2 great-granddaughters named after her 🩷

Make it your sister’s problem, not yours. Say to her now “that’s lovely but you know I will still be using the name”.

Do not budge. Use the name you longed for. No other name will mean as much to you and you will forever resent your sister and possibly your niece if you don’t get to use the name. Stick with it.

NerrSnerr · 27/03/2024 09:05

PutOnYourRedShoesAndLetsDance · 27/03/2024 09:03

I'm with you OP.. I think it's just nasty.. you have wanted that name for so so long..
I real feel for you.
People saying to use it.. l wouldn't.. that would mean their Grandparents having two Grandaughters with same name and that's just weird..
If my daughters used the same name for their sons I'd be so disappointed.
Maybe use it as a middle name and give some deep thought to another beautiful name.

You'd be disappointed if you had two grandchildren with the same name? That's really strange. In my family my brother had a cousin with exactly the same first name and surname (and an uncle too), I have the same name as my cousin. It's fine. No confusion and certainly no bizarrely disappointed grandparents.

Katiesaidthat · 27/03/2024 09:04

I´m called like my cousin who is 3 years older than me. My brother shares the name with 2 cousins, our father and our grandfather. This is on one side of the family. My aunt Louisa did not get hysterical when her older brother gave me the same name as her daughter. My father always liked the name and just gave me it when the time came. My mum is actually a variation of the same name.
You like it, just name her that. Combine it with a second name if you like. Your sister has done exactly what I am suggesting you do. No one owns a name.

PutOnYourRedShoesAndLetsDance · 27/03/2024 09:03

I'm with you OP.. I think it's just nasty.. you have wanted that name for so so long..
I real feel for you.
People saying to use it.. l wouldn't.. that would mean their Grandparents having two Grandaughters with same name and that's just weird..
If my daughters used the same name for their sons I'd be so disappointed.
Maybe use it as a middle name and give some deep thought to another beautiful name.

Imfreetofeelgood · 27/03/2024 08:58

SuperstarDeejay · 26/03/2024 22:12

Did you have to post this twice? You already have a discussion going in Baby Names.

My aunt did this to my DM about 70 years ago - aunt's baby was stillborn. My DM never forgot, but outwardly moved on graciously. From my older DS's perspective it was a lucky 'near miss' 😅. It's upsetting but you'll find another lovely name OP.Edit - didn't mean to quote.

MzHz · 27/03/2024 08:58

Honestly, just use the name or a contraction of it. she has not stolen anything, you can call your child the name you want. You really can.

Brefugee · 27/03/2024 08:56

congratulations on your pregnancy.
nobody owns a name, use whichever you like.

In our family 2 of my SIL had boys within weeks of each other. The first one knew the 2nd one would name the baby after the father - and then used that name anyway because (well they were antagonistic cowbags so who knows, just to annoy probably) and then the 2nd sister got a cob on for months, but still used the name anyway.

LittleMonks11 · 27/03/2024 08:54

Chatonette · 27/03/2024 08:25

Have you been announcing that your baby’s name is Nana since the 16 week scan, for the past 4 months, and your sister gives birth and names her daughter Nana?

It sounds like she's been discussing using Nana's name for years - through several miscarriages. Her sister said yeah go for it. Then sent a pic of her new baby girl named Nava- just dropped it like that. Shitty behaviour whatever.

3luckystars · 27/03/2024 08:54

I agree, you probably won’t be spending much time together anyway so use your name.

WaltzingWaters · 27/03/2024 08:53

In this situation where she told you you could use the name early on and you’ve been calling bump by that name it really does sound quite spiteful. If she’s generally like that I doubt you’d be seeing that much of her. Just use the name anyway.

Tel12 · 27/03/2024 08:53

Just use the name. My ex husband had 2 first cousins who shared the same names of both him and his brother. Never caused any problems. Alternatively use a derivative, put a an in the end or whatever suits. Don't let it get to you.

DriftingDora · 27/03/2024 08:53

It's obviously upset you, OP, and that's sad but no one has the 'right' to a particular name, so I think you have to accept it. Is there a name which is close to the one you wanted, or a second favourite name that you could go for instead?

pontipinemum · 27/03/2024 08:51

YANBU - I know people say 'no one owns a name' well no they don't but still. I also wouldn't go calling 1st cousins that see each other a lot the same name. It will get confusing. Yes it used to be done, but it isn't anymore. But I think you will get sick of your child being 'Young Heather' or '2nd Heather' or 'Heather Matthews'

My sister and I had boys 2 weeks apart - me first. We told each other the names we were going with, even though it was her 3rd and she told no one before with the other two and I told no one but her. Luckily her name was on my list but not my fav so we didn't have much of a discussion but I am sure if she had, had your reasons for my fav name I'd have found something else.

UpsideLeft · 27/03/2024 08:50

Use the name

If anyone questions it just tell them you told your sister you were going to use the name and she decided to use it too

Just use the name

NoveltyFunsy · 27/03/2024 08:49

Just use the name

TiredyMcTired · 27/03/2024 08:49

Rocket1982 · 26/03/2024 22:12

Just use it. No issue with 2 cousins having the same name. In my family my aunt had the same name as her DM, and I have the same name as my SIL. Nobody has 'dibs' on a name.

I think in this case you are definitely not being unreasonable. You made it very clear what name you had already given your baby, and your sister knew this. I’d be upset too.

Tittyfilarious · 27/03/2024 08:44

Honestly just use the name it really doesn't matter , plenty of families might have cousins with the same name and it's not a problem

blabar · 27/03/2024 08:44

This is strange OP because you would think she would have discussed it with you at least, before just sending a photo out. But, as lots of people have said, just use the name anyway. They are cousins, but so what? Look at how many sons have the dad's name etc. I know twins called Amelia and Amelie! Just do what you want regardless.

Dibilnik · 27/03/2024 08:40

"Nana" is a sweet name for a girl. Could you use that instead?

Sass53271 · 27/03/2024 08:40

I've been your sister in this situation but with differences- we never discussed baby names before my child was born so I had no clue that she was thinking of naming a child after our grandma- and also she wasn't pregnant!! But she still didn't speak to me for months and bad mouthed me to everyone! I just said, use the name if you do have a girl- she never did have a girl but I wouldn't have cared if she had used it! Her argument was that I must have known she would want the name but I absolutely didn't- and frankly I wanted the name too - she was my grandma too!

Jinglesomeoftheway · 27/03/2024 08:35

@JessMathews8 I'd be so so hurt! Especially if I'd make it really clear to my sister, I don't understand how people wouldn't be!

In these circumstances although it will create some awkwardness, I would 100% use the same name. Just say you'd already decided on it, you'd made it clear beforehand and that's what you're doing.

The alternative is seeing your niece grow up with the name you'd chosen and feeling resentful every time you see her.

BrothersAndSisters · 27/03/2024 08:33

I wouldn’t be bothered, I’d just use the name.