Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister stole my baby name

364 replies

JessMathews8 · 26/03/2024 22:07

I'm really struggling to deal with this, my sister is 10 years older than me and has three children aged between 18 and 15. She was done witn having kids, has said this for years and years. But her new partner wanted a baby.I have a 6 year old boy, and currently pregnant with a girl. When I was pregnant with my son, before we knew he was a boy I had a girls name set and was after my Nana, always said that the next baby if its a girl I will name her after Nana, it took us 4 years of trying to get pregnant again.My sister got pregnant one month before I did and said that I'd she has a girl she will be using my Nanas name and it's her name, she's due first so she has first dibs.She didn't find out what she was having, but she gave birth yesterday, to a girl and has named her after my Nana.I'm due in 3 weeks, and feel so angry and upset she has used a name for the last 6 years I have said I would use if I have a girl, I found out its a girl at 16 weeks when she told me I could use the name as I know its a girl but shes literally just named her daughter it. Am I an asshole for being upset and mad?
My mum has told me I'm being unreasonable and she has always liked the name. Which she may of done but she always said she was done having kids, and everyone knew that it was the name I would use if I was to ever have a girl. I feel so hurt

OP posts:
curlywillow · 27/03/2024 10:24

Yes definitely send a text saying “how cute that we will have Big Alice and Little Alice”

nobody wants their daughter to be “Big Alice”

Hold your nerve, she’ll probably cave.

Hobbi · 27/03/2024 10:23

My husband has the same name as his cousin. They grew up very close friends.

LadeOde · 27/03/2024 10:21

This is why i love my culture. Names are never announced until the day of the baby's naming ceremony. I'm also of the 'no one owns a name' camp, and coincidences do happen. Hopefully, they'll have different middle names and surnames.

As for her ordering @op to choose another name, I'd have just laughed! who does she think she is? give her the name you always planned.

CrappySack · 27/03/2024 10:21

I would reply to the announcement saying "Aww how lovely that our daughters will have the same name 🥰"

If she replied that you'll have to choose another name, I'd say not to be silly, she knew you'd already chosen that name and no one owns a name after all.

I know a few cousins with the same name and it's never caused any issues as far as I know.

Likewhatever · 27/03/2024 10:21

It’s a bit rotten of her to do this to you, so if your AIBU is about being upset, no you aren’t.

You can still use the name though, in fact you should, there’s an excellent precedent, look at the names of the royal girl babies, there’s almost always an Elizabeth in there.

How lovely to have your Nana honoured twice.

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 27/03/2024 10:20

NiceNiche · 27/03/2024 10:12

I’d flag up my intentions to use the same name now, in response to the picture, something along the lines of ‘oh how sweet, cousins with the same first name, yours can be Big Alice and mine will be Little Alice’.

See if she changes her mind. If she doesn’t, then still go ahead. She was very aware of your intentions, and didn’t pay any heed to them. Don’t let her actions stop you from using the name you have always wanted for a daughter.

I actually agree with this, OP.

If your sister's baby was only born yesterday, the birth won't have been registered yet.

Just be matter of fact about it.

"Hi everyone, just to let you know that I am still planning to name my baby Alice. This has been my intention for over 6 years now, as you are all well aware. Whilst there is no reason why two first cousins can't share the same name, if DSis has a problem with this, there's still time to change DNiece's name."

KreedKafer · 27/03/2024 10:18

Obviously nobody owns a name, but I do think that in this particular case your sister has been a bit of a twat, yes.

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 27/03/2024 10:17

Meowandthen · 27/03/2024 10:13

Hardy fair on the second child. A pointless gesture out of spite.

What impact is it going to have on the second child, really?

If my sister pulled this kind of stunt on me I would be looking at reducing contact with her anyway.

Meowandthen · 27/03/2024 10:13

SabreIsMyFave · 27/03/2024 10:11

This is true ... No-one owns a name. However, this also means that the OP is entitled to use it still. Bet the sister will go off on one, but I would DEFINITELY use the name still if I were the OP! As I said, if the sister kicks off, the OP needs to say 'I TOLD you I was using that name. Nothing has changed.'

Hardy fair on the second child. A pointless gesture out of spite.

NiceNiche · 27/03/2024 10:12

I’d flag up my intentions to use the same name now, in response to the picture, something along the lines of ‘oh how sweet, cousins with the same first name, yours can be Big Alice and mine will be Little Alice’.

See if she changes her mind. If she doesn’t, then still go ahead. She was very aware of your intentions, and didn’t pay any heed to them. Don’t let her actions stop you from using the name you have always wanted for a daughter.

SabreIsMyFave · 27/03/2024 10:11

Meowandthen · 27/03/2024 10:07

FGS. Did you trademark the name? No, then it cannot be stolen.

Bit of a dick move from your sister but it isn't stealing. Silly use of language

This is true ... No-one owns a name. However, this also means that the OP is entitled to use it still. Bet the sister will go off on one, but I would DEFINITELY use the name still if I were the OP! As I said, if the sister kicks off, the OP needs to say 'I TOLD you I was using that name. Nothing has changed.'

Meowandthen · 27/03/2024 10:07

FGS. Did you trademark the name? No, then it cannot be stolen.

Bit of a dick move from your sister but it isn't stealing. Silly use of language

dutysuite · 27/03/2024 10:02

If you still used it she’d get a taste of her own medicine!

SabreIsMyFave · 27/03/2024 10:01

I'm in the 'no-one owns a name camp' sorry @JessMathews8 You really should not tell people what name you're going to use for your baby. Too late now of course. However, YANBU to be upset/miffed about it.

As a few others have said, just use the name anyway. I would.

There were 2-3 Davids, Pauls, and Roberts in my extended family. I had 2 cousins called David and 2 uncle Roberts! And there were 3 Pauls.

It's not against the law to call your child the same name as the one your sister has called hers. If she is annoyed (and she will be,) just stick to your guns, and say (firmly,) 'I TOLD you I was having this name for my baby. I have not changed my mind.'

If she whines and get miffed about it, then tough shit on her. So, there will be 2 cousins in the family both called Hannah/Emma/Charlotte'Lucy/Katie or whatever..... Big deal. As I said, multiple names have occurred in my extended family, and on reading some posts on this thread, it happens in a lot of families.

I am sorry for your TTC problems.

Good luck! Flowers

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 27/03/2024 10:00

Did your nana have a middle name you could use? Or use another version of it?

It does seem a bit strange that out of all the names out there, your nana's is the only one you wanted to use, to me, you can use your nana's as a middle name or use a variation of it as a first name.

nimski · 27/03/2024 09:59

Just use the name (bet she changes it then when she realises you aren't budging!)

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 27/03/2024 09:57

Your sister didn't't steal anything, she just happened to get there first. There is no property in a name and no law against you using the same name for your child.

Whereinharrogate · 27/03/2024 09:57

I think your getting some unfair responses on here op. I know no one owns a name etc etc but it does seem pretty weird to me that she's done this - and that knowing all the background etc that she just stuck a photo in the family chat with thr name on it and didn't have thr balls to explain to you beforehand. Agree with pp though, just use the name if you want to. I think if you don't, you'll always think of your dds name as second best even if you choose something lovely. Focus on yourself and your baby not the wider family around you, as hard as that is

RedMark · 27/03/2024 09:56

Call your baby the name anyway. Is it a name you can have different nicknames? Maybe that could work. Otherwise, I'd use it anyway.

FartSock5000 · 27/03/2024 09:54

@JessMathews8 your sister is a dick. She wanted the attention that comes from naming a child after a beloved relative and now she's getting it.

Your feelings are valid. She IS an arsehole and she knew what she was doing.

But at the same time no one owns a name and despite the meaning behind this one, she has every right to use it if she wants. It was her Nana too.

Either use the name or don't but process your feelings and move on. You know what she has done was probably another attention seeking on-up-manship move that she probably has form for pulling on you over the years.

Next time, limit the info you share with her. She has proven she can't be trusted and doesn't care about how you feel.

Fizzadora · 27/03/2024 09:50

I haven't read the full thread and the first page is full of responses saying don't be so precious, you don't own a name, but oh @JessMathews8 what a horrible thing for your sister to do. And your mother thinks you're the one being unreasonable?
I can guess the dynamic in your family while you were growing up.
i think you would be perfectly justified in throwing a hissy fit and telling them both to fuck off.
Anyway you have two choices. You can use the name anyway if you feel comfortable (I would and would spend the rest of my life explaining to people who asked, that my entitled sister knowingly stole the name I had decided on) or you can choose something else and perhaps have it as a middle name.
I am a very much live and let live person but would not forgive this. Your sister and your mother are showing you what they think of you.

tkwal · 27/03/2024 09:48

I'd always wanted a particular name if I had a daughter. (Before I even met my husband)His sister already had a little girl with that name. I gave my daughter the name anyway. Then she chose to use the other name she was also given. Its less of a (thing) when they get older (still think your sister was out of order, even if she'd been as close to your Nan as you were)

SpilltheTea · 27/03/2024 09:47

Use the name. There's no reason why you shouldn't.

Viviennemary · 27/03/2024 09:46

Go ahead and name your baby as planned. If folk don't like it then tough.

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 27/03/2024 09:44

I'm usually the first to say no one owns a name, but it sounds like your sister did this deliberately to upset you.

It's up to you whether you want to still use the name or not. You're perfectly within your rights to still use it if you want to. If anyone comments, just say that everyone, including your sister, knew that this was what you were planning to name your baby girl, it was really important to you, and that you weren't going to change your baby's name just because yous sister decided at the last minute to use the same name she knew you had chosen.

No one owns a name, but the flip side of that is that your sister can't expect to have exclusivity over this name either.

Swipe left for the next trending thread