Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister stole my baby name

364 replies

JessMathews8 · 26/03/2024 22:07

I'm really struggling to deal with this, my sister is 10 years older than me and has three children aged between 18 and 15. She was done witn having kids, has said this for years and years. But her new partner wanted a baby.I have a 6 year old boy, and currently pregnant with a girl. When I was pregnant with my son, before we knew he was a boy I had a girls name set and was after my Nana, always said that the next baby if its a girl I will name her after Nana, it took us 4 years of trying to get pregnant again.My sister got pregnant one month before I did and said that I'd she has a girl she will be using my Nanas name and it's her name, she's due first so she has first dibs.She didn't find out what she was having, but she gave birth yesterday, to a girl and has named her after my Nana.I'm due in 3 weeks, and feel so angry and upset she has used a name for the last 6 years I have said I would use if I have a girl, I found out its a girl at 16 weeks when she told me I could use the name as I know its a girl but shes literally just named her daughter it. Am I an asshole for being upset and mad?
My mum has told me I'm being unreasonable and she has always liked the name. Which she may of done but she always said she was done having kids, and everyone knew that it was the name I would use if I was to ever have a girl. I feel so hurt

OP posts:
ilovelamp82 · 27/03/2024 11:24

Just call her it anyway. If anyone ever asks, just explain the situation, she will come across as the strange one. But it is her Nana too, so you don't have more rights than her technically. The fact that she knew you wanted it and announced it rather than telling you first would have me feeling uncomfortable though.

AlpineMuesli · 27/03/2024 11:21

Ultimately this is a trust issue.

You trusted your sister with the knowledge of your (painful) journey to the realisation of the name. You were honest and open.

She has not been honest with you, and has talked about other names but then revealed the one you wanted at the last moment and indirectly and in a group situation (group chat).

Because of this you have been caught by surprise and you're struggling to process the emotions, understandably.

A name is just a name, but once trust is broken it is very hard to put back in place.

WitchWithoutChips · 27/03/2024 11:19

If baby was born yesterday they won’t have registered the birth yet. Here’s what you do.

Don’t get upset. Visit her as planned with a big smile and a card in which you have written ‘how special that our girls will grow up as Hildas together’. Make it absolutely clear that you are delighted to have inspired her and of course you are not going to change your plan of four years. Won’t it be special for the cousins to share a name? Etc etc. Lay it on as thick as you like.

I guarantee Hilda will have been demoted to a middle name by the time they register the birth.

bctf123 · 27/03/2024 11:08

SuperstarDeejay · 26/03/2024 22:12

Did you have to post this twice? You already have a discussion going in Baby Names.

Lol

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 27/03/2024 11:07

It's not quite the same as sisters but out of four cousins with daughters three of us named our daughters after our grandmother. DG was thrilled that her great granddaughters shared her name.

HROSESATTERS · 27/03/2024 11:06

Use the name anyway! x

60sbird · 27/03/2024 11:04

My mum and her sister called both my cousin and me the same name but spelt differently, Jackline and Jacqueline, no problems ever arose

pu7 · 27/03/2024 10:55

What a horrible thing to do to you when she knew your plans and how much it means to you.

How do you think she would feel if you went ahead and used it anyway?

Also bear in mind that not all babies look like the name you have chosen before their birth.

Don't let this spoil such a special time for you.

vivariumvivariumsvivaria · 27/03/2024 10:53

How nice for your Nana's memory to have two grand daughters named after her.

Mary28 · 27/03/2024 10:51

Just use the name. My name is the same as my nana's, and my first cousin who I hung out with for half of my childhood has the same name. It's not crazy, it's completely doable.

Toooldforlonghair · 27/03/2024 10:48

I can understand your upset but no one has exclusive right to a name and when you think rationally there are lots of ways around this as outlined below:-

Did your Nana have a second name?
Maybe use that or give your child both her names but the other way round eg Jane Mary instead of Mary Jane?

Or give her your Nana's name but use the second name. That way she has a choice. (I choose to be known by my middle name. It has never been a problem.)

Or give her the original name but use a diminutive eg Sophie for Sophia or a variant eg Isabel/Isabella.

Or just give her the name you want. I have a DS and DSiL with the same name. I refer to them each as DD's V or Our V depending on context.

Calliopespa · 27/03/2024 10:43

curlywillow · 27/03/2024 10:24

Yes definitely send a text saying “how cute that we will have Big Alice and Little Alice”

nobody wants their daughter to be “Big Alice”

Hold your nerve, she’ll probably cave.

I was the equivalent of Little Alice all through school as someone in my class had the same name. Then another married into our family and she was extremely short, albeit about 7 or 8 years older than me , so guess what I became! I can confirm no-one likes carrying the “Big” epithet- much as I didn’t mind the little.

MrsClatterbuck · 27/03/2024 10:41

I would use the name. My mum's sister was called after her grandmother plus four other cousins. Both first and second name.

Agapornis · 27/03/2024 10:37

Give her the name. They might end up with different nicknames. In adult life I see my cousins maybe once a year, so long term it may well be relevant.

Alternatively... Don't name children after others, give them a name that is their own and suits them.

hernamewaslolashewasaslowgal · 27/03/2024 10:36

I'd be really pissed off too, OP. I know in theory nobody owns a name but if your sister knew you were planning on using the name it's really poor form on her part.

LadyBird1973 · 27/03/2024 10:35

I think this was a really shitty thing for your sister to do and your mum ought to have told her, not try to make you feel in the wrong for being upset.

I'd still use the full name - sister won't like it because she thinks she's forced you to pick a different one, but I'd do it anyway and see a lot less of my sister going forward. You can't trust her - she listened to you and deliberately said nothing! Awful behaviour!

Calliopespa · 27/03/2024 10:34

Pippielk · 27/03/2024 09:32

Just use the name if you like it that much too.

I can understand that your sisters actions has hurt you but really you need to take a step back and be grateful for what you have -you are due a healthy baby girl after years of trying. And your sister having a little girl that will be similar in age so a ready made playmate. Keep up a good relationship with your sister if possible.
You’ll look back on this in years to come and realise you were making a mountain out of a molehill.

I agree. Use the name but don’t do it in an unnecessarily antagonistic fashion. I’d try to think of a diminutive for family use and when she starts school just enrol her with your Nans name and switch to using it in full then- when everyone is over the drama.

Cloclo93 · 27/03/2024 10:34

Yeah I'd be pretty pissed if my sister done that! I was mad when my best friend named her daughter the name I was going to call my second child (ttc over 2 years now) you should still call your daughter after your nana

Toquitit · 27/03/2024 10:33

NiceNiche · 27/03/2024 10:12

I’d flag up my intentions to use the same name now, in response to the picture, something along the lines of ‘oh how sweet, cousins with the same first name, yours can be Big Alice and mine will be Little Alice’.

See if she changes her mind. If she doesn’t, then still go ahead. She was very aware of your intentions, and didn’t pay any heed to them. Don’t let her actions stop you from using the name you have always wanted for a daughter.

Love this. 100%. No parent wants their child known as 'big' any name. I reckon she will have a change of heart when she realises you will absolutely still call your baby the same name.

Hope OP comes back to update us if she did use any of these suggestions and what happened!

ZekeZeke · 27/03/2024 10:32

JessMathews8 · 26/03/2024 22:15

It's more I'm hurt as it was what my son would be if he was a girl, it was the name discussed for the 4 miscarriages I had. Its not like she didn't know, even when we was talking to each other TTC again I would our girl name and boy name and she would say so.ething different until she got pregnant. She then said we could use the name as we knew it was a girl so we've have been calling our bump by name, she said she had 5 other girls names. And then she had the baby and just sent the family group a picture with the name on. People say I can't call dibs on a name until baby is born, but i think in this context my sister is a bit out of order but I'm being made to believe it's only me that thinks this

What's the name?

Calliopespa · 27/03/2024 10:31

LordSnot · 26/03/2024 22:21

Or be a grown up, use the name and say your nana was so amazing you both hope your girls take after her.

Yes I’d do the latter. Try to keep it positive but just use it - in the circumstances.

Can we know the name OP and then we can brainstorm short versions. But if, say, it was Elizabeth, ( because it makes the point well!) they could both have the same name and you use Lily and Beth, or Lisa and Betty, Liz, Libby etc everyday. If so, choose your diminutive and announce it before your sister knows what you plan. Then at least you’ve had first dibs on that aspect.

CrappySack · 27/03/2024 10:29

curlywillow · 27/03/2024 10:24

Yes definitely send a text saying “how cute that we will have Big Alice and Little Alice”

nobody wants their daughter to be “Big Alice”

Hold your nerve, she’ll probably cave.

Another vote for this 😁

Hopebridge · 27/03/2024 10:25

CrappySack · 27/03/2024 10:21

I would reply to the announcement saying "Aww how lovely that our daughters will have the same name 🥰"

If she replied that you'll have to choose another name, I'd say not to be silly, she knew you'd already chosen that name and no one owns a name after all.

I know a few cousins with the same name and it's never caused any issues as far as I know.

Another good idea :)

Hopebridge · 27/03/2024 10:24

curlywillow · 27/03/2024 10:24

Yes definitely send a text saying “how cute that we will have Big Alice and Little Alice”

nobody wants their daughter to be “Big Alice”

Hold your nerve, she’ll probably cave.

That's a good idea :)

Hopebridge · 27/03/2024 10:24

I have 2 nephews with the same name. My sister was a bit annoyed but got over it. It really isn't an issue now. They go to different schools, different friendship circles etc. I would use the name if you love it and it's your chosen name. :)