Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister stole my baby name

364 replies

JessMathews8 · 26/03/2024 22:07

I'm really struggling to deal with this, my sister is 10 years older than me and has three children aged between 18 and 15. She was done witn having kids, has said this for years and years. But her new partner wanted a baby.I have a 6 year old boy, and currently pregnant with a girl. When I was pregnant with my son, before we knew he was a boy I had a girls name set and was after my Nana, always said that the next baby if its a girl I will name her after Nana, it took us 4 years of trying to get pregnant again.My sister got pregnant one month before I did and said that I'd she has a girl she will be using my Nanas name and it's her name, she's due first so she has first dibs.She didn't find out what she was having, but she gave birth yesterday, to a girl and has named her after my Nana.I'm due in 3 weeks, and feel so angry and upset she has used a name for the last 6 years I have said I would use if I have a girl, I found out its a girl at 16 weeks when she told me I could use the name as I know its a girl but shes literally just named her daughter it. Am I an asshole for being upset and mad?
My mum has told me I'm being unreasonable and she has always liked the name. Which she may of done but she always said she was done having kids, and everyone knew that it was the name I would use if I was to ever have a girl. I feel so hurt

OP posts:
TonyHallintheTardis · 27/03/2024 12:44

Use the name. When they are both little babies it might seem very close but when they are out in the world, at primary and high school etc, it will not matter a jot.

housethatbuiltme · 27/03/2024 12:42

I had infertility for 10 years, had my DS name picked for 20 years... I didn't care who used it that was MY child name.

Turns out my cousin (who is mega fertile a popped out half a dozen kids while I was trying) 'beat me to it'... I still used it because no one owns a name.

Our wasn't even a family name either, I mean its her Nana as much as yours, you have equal rights to the name.

You can NOT control what she does with HER child... only what YOU do with YOURS which means she did nothing wrong putting herself and her child first in her parenting journey and you choices is to A) still use the name or B) throw a tantrum, cut your nose of to spite your face out of anger and pick something else (but thats not her fault).

I never once thought my cousin 'stole' anything, that would be narcissistic.

Children sharing names is MEGA common, in fact in some culture some names (like Mary/Marie or Mohammad) are shared by all the family members.

longingtobe23 · 27/03/2024 12:31

@JessMathews8 sorry im with OP she’s been an asshole and I am sorry
yes it’s different if they aren’t blood and don’t know your intentions or your story
if you tell someone a name they can use it
but she’s your sister and she should have known better
sorry OP

Can you use alternative name / nickname similar to still honour nana? Also keep it to yourself 🤞🏻

NoraBattysCurlers · 27/03/2024 12:24

Everlena · 26/03/2024 22:21

Other option is to ‘go big’ and just use the name and tell anyone who asks that this had been your baby’s name for many months and that you were surprised your sister copied you but you won’t be bullied into changing it. That’d be a big family drama tho. Easier to use it as middle name.

In other words, you are telling the OP to act like a complete twat.

It's completely bizarre that one member of the family would believe that they have dibs, or a greater right, to a family name.

Tengreenbottles2 · 27/03/2024 12:22

Meowandthen · 27/03/2024 10:13

Hardy fair on the second child. A pointless gesture out of spite.

It's not a gesture, it's not out of spite, and it won't affect the children in any way.

OP will just be continuing with her plan to name her daughter after her nana, like she has always wanted to. Plenty of posters in this thread have mentioned family members having the same first names. It's really not that uncommon and usually doesn't cause any problems.

dottiedodah · 27/03/2024 12:20

Witchwitoutchips Brilliant!

OooScotland · 27/03/2024 12:18

It works itself out. And its totally normal for multiple cousins to be named after a much loved grandparent.

If the cousins don’t live in the same house (I’m assuming they don’t) it will be a complete non issue to them.

I think the real issue is that you feel your sister has done this to hurt you. If so I think you should stop focusing on the name and try to improve your relationship with your sister.

Growing up I cared not a jot that I had the same name as my niece. It was still my name. When she was at our house my mum (her grandma) would call me ‘Julie’ and my niece ‘Our Julie’ because that was the tradition in an extended family where there were many reused names and the younger ones were always ‘our’ [name].

My grandmother’s name was Lucretia (I so wish I’d been named after her!). One of my cousins was referred to as ‘Our Lucretia’ by her Grandfather for the same reason.

To my own aunties I was ‘Mabel’s Julie’ and my niece was ‘Maureen’s Julie’. Something similar happened in nearly everyone’s family that I knew. It wasn’t a big deal and as a child I found that having a ‘family name’ just makes you feel more like you belong.

All names unchanged because there’s nobody left alive now to see it and care what I’ve just said.

rainingsnoring · 27/03/2024 12:17

ZoyaTheDestroyer · 27/03/2024 11:37

Yes. Do this. If she genuinely wants the name too then she won’t be deterred and you’ll have a funny story about your girls’ names. If it’s a power play this will deal with it.

This is a good idea.

Dinoswearunderpants · 27/03/2024 12:13

Love the suggestion above. Still use the name.

Tengreenbottles2 · 27/03/2024 12:11

It is definitely a bit annoying of her, and slightly unkind and devious given that she knew how important the name was to you.

HOWEVER, at the same time, no one can own a name, and it was her nana too.

I say just name your daughter the same name. Sod it. It's still your nana's name.

In my family, there are two first cousins both called Peter. I also have an aunt and cousin (who are nice and aunt, not mother and daughter) with the same first name, and an uncle and cousin (again, not father and son) with the same first name. I also knew a Spanish woman who had three daughters all called Maria, with different middle names. Oh, and my Gran's name is Josephine and her sister is Joanne, both shortened to Jo.

So there you go, plenty of precedent, you can still name your baby that name.

PenelopeTitsdrop1990 · 27/03/2024 12:06

Toooldforlonghair · 27/03/2024 10:48

I can understand your upset but no one has exclusive right to a name and when you think rationally there are lots of ways around this as outlined below:-

Did your Nana have a second name?
Maybe use that or give your child both her names but the other way round eg Jane Mary instead of Mary Jane?

Or give her your Nana's name but use the second name. That way she has a choice. (I choose to be known by my middle name. It has never been a problem.)

Or give her the original name but use a diminutive eg Sophie for Sophia or a variant eg Isabel/Isabella.

Or just give her the name you want. I have a DS and DSiL with the same name. I refer to them each as DD's V or Our V depending on context.

Of course no one has any right to a name but it's still a shitty thing the sister has done.

I'd make it clear that you'll still be using the name. As another has said,I bet she will change the name/ make it a middle name.

Wellthatwashardwork · 27/03/2024 12:06

Just name your daughter it anyway. You already said that is what you were calling your child, so it's no big deal that you stick with it. If anyone mentions it just give a big smile and say how much you both liked it and that you think it's so cute they are both called the same in honour of Nana. If you act completely unaffected by it it will soon be all forgotten and everyone will just know the girls as themselves.

Baffy · 27/03/2024 12:01

I totally agree with the suggestion above

SlowlyLurking · 27/03/2024 11:56

WitchWithoutChips · 27/03/2024 11:19

If baby was born yesterday they won’t have registered the birth yet. Here’s what you do.

Don’t get upset. Visit her as planned with a big smile and a card in which you have written ‘how special that our girls will grow up as Hildas together’. Make it absolutely clear that you are delighted to have inspired her and of course you are not going to change your plan of four years. Won’t it be special for the cousins to share a name? Etc etc. Lay it on as thick as you like.

I guarantee Hilda will have been demoted to a middle name by the time they register the birth.

This.

Make it absolutely crystal clear that both babies are going to have the same name and make a little joke out of possible nicknames for her baby so in group settings nobody's confused. Reiterate it's been your plan for four years and you're not giving that up just because of the new wonderful addition.

She's waiting for you to back down and kick off. Don't give it to her.

IncompleteSenten · 27/03/2024 11:47

Still use it.

When she objects you tell her she's known for years you intended to use that name if you had a girl and that isn't changing just because she chose the same name.

ThisNameToday · 27/03/2024 11:43

I like the Big Alice and Little Alice suggestion.

Tell her that and use the name anyway.

I see why you're upset for sure.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 27/03/2024 11:40

Use the name and then tell your sister to do one.

ZoyaTheDestroyer · 27/03/2024 11:37

WitchWithoutChips · 27/03/2024 11:19

If baby was born yesterday they won’t have registered the birth yet. Here’s what you do.

Don’t get upset. Visit her as planned with a big smile and a card in which you have written ‘how special that our girls will grow up as Hildas together’. Make it absolutely clear that you are delighted to have inspired her and of course you are not going to change your plan of four years. Won’t it be special for the cousins to share a name? Etc etc. Lay it on as thick as you like.

I guarantee Hilda will have been demoted to a middle name by the time they register the birth.

Yes. Do this. If she genuinely wants the name too then she won’t be deterred and you’ll have a funny story about your girls’ names. If it’s a power play this will deal with it.

diddl · 27/03/2024 11:36

If you hadn't said anything about the name & your sister had used it-what would you have done then?

Sadly saying that you like a name & intend to use it doesn't give exclusive rights!

Do you think that your sister has done it to be spiteful & try & prevent you from using the name?

UniversalAunt · 27/03/2024 11:34

There are no ‘dibs’ on a name being used.

Several cultural traditions have baby naming conventions - often used as a guide by family historians - about the first boy being named after the father’s father, the first girl after the mother’s mother, the second boy after the mother’s father & so on. Obviously, you will then find multiple occurrences of same first names in the wider family group.

So go ahead, give your baby girl - Congratulations btw - the same name as your Nana & her cousin. Maybe spice things up with a fantastic flourish of a middle name that compliments Nana’s name.

Spirallingdownwards · 27/03/2024 11:31

60sbird · 27/03/2024 11:04

My mum and her sister called both my cousin and me the same name but spelt differently, Jackline and Jacqueline, no problems ever arose

I hope you weren't the one lumbered with Jackline

Spirallingdownwards · 27/03/2024 11:30

It was her Nana too though.

Just use the name if you like it that much.

MrsSkylerWhite · 27/03/2024 11:29

YABU. Just use the name anyway.

EasterEgger · 27/03/2024 11:29

I would just use the name anyway as you picked it first and were using it before she was born.
Lol what are they going to go change the birth certificate.

BringMeTea · 27/03/2024 11:28

She has been a bitch but I would use the name anyway.