Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister stole my baby name

364 replies

JessMathews8 · 26/03/2024 22:07

I'm really struggling to deal with this, my sister is 10 years older than me and has three children aged between 18 and 15. She was done witn having kids, has said this for years and years. But her new partner wanted a baby.I have a 6 year old boy, and currently pregnant with a girl. When I was pregnant with my son, before we knew he was a boy I had a girls name set and was after my Nana, always said that the next baby if its a girl I will name her after Nana, it took us 4 years of trying to get pregnant again.My sister got pregnant one month before I did and said that I'd she has a girl she will be using my Nanas name and it's her name, she's due first so she has first dibs.She didn't find out what she was having, but she gave birth yesterday, to a girl and has named her after my Nana.I'm due in 3 weeks, and feel so angry and upset she has used a name for the last 6 years I have said I would use if I have a girl, I found out its a girl at 16 weeks when she told me I could use the name as I know its a girl but shes literally just named her daughter it. Am I an asshole for being upset and mad?
My mum has told me I'm being unreasonable and she has always liked the name. Which she may of done but she always said she was done having kids, and everyone knew that it was the name I would use if I was to ever have a girl. I feel so hurt

OP posts:
Ramalangadingdong · 27/03/2024 07:05

Op, I hope this isn't really insensitive, but do you think your sister thought you weren't going to have another child so felt free to use the moniker?

Thegoodbadandugly · 27/03/2024 07:05

It's a name, just name your daughter that name,.

Goldbar · 27/03/2024 07:03

Just use it. Tell her it will be fine for the cousins to have the same name as you don't envisage seeing her much going forward anyway.

FlamingoQueen · 27/03/2024 07:02

I’m with you on this one. This is about your sister not caring about your wishes and not being respectful. Personally, I would be livid! (But know my sisters would not have done this to me).
I don’t understand why cousins would have the same name (unless they all go by their middle name)- why would grandparents want their grandchildren to all have the same name!
You are right to be hurt, but could you use your Nanna’s name as your child’s middle name? You may just have to move past this, I’m afraid, just for your own well-being.

Marchintospring · 27/03/2024 07:01

LordSnot · 26/03/2024 22:19

Why should you be the only one able to give that homage to your nana?

Name stealing isn't a thing. The name is still there for you to use.

Op wasn’t saying that though. It’s not an homage, it’s a name the Op liked and chose for her baby.

And name stealing is a thing. Just because someone can still use a name doesn’t mean the idea hasn’t been taken. Just like if you buy a dress and your friend turns up in the same one because she liked it.

NerrSnerr · 27/03/2024 07:00

Just use the name. My brother has exactly the same first name and surname as his uncle and his cousin. It's fine. I have the same unusual name as my cousin too. It's not a problem. Names can be used more then once!

PurplePansy05 · 27/03/2024 06:59

People are totally missing the point, it's not about "owning names" but about respecting your wishes as her sibling.

Pickled21 · 27/03/2024 06:57

She did it knowing you'd be upset. I'd use the name if you love it so much, if not I'd use it as a middle name. People are saying it's her nan too which is true but she knew it's what you would be naming your little girl and you have been calling bump by that name for a long time. It is hurtful but if you call her out on it she will turn ot around on you. I'd just pay no heed, enjoy the end of your pregnancy and use the name anyway.

PurplePansy05 · 27/03/2024 06:57

I'm surprised with the responses. You clearly told your sister this would be your baby's name a long time ago and made it clear again now you're actually pregnant with a girl. She could have chosen any other name or use the same name as middle. She's definitely weird to have done that.

YADNBU.

I would still use the name, as you've planned it. If anyone asks, be honest and say you chose first and your sister used it regardless.

Londonrach1 · 27/03/2024 06:55

Just use the names, maybe change it slightly. Yabu as you don't own names. Your mum is right

Ramalangadingdong · 27/03/2024 06:51

Nobody owns a name.

I would be angry too as it is a typical sibling "theft" but logic tells me that she has as much right to the name as you do.

That said, I would still be furious if it had happened to me.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 27/03/2024 06:46

Shouldgetupearlier · 27/03/2024 06:36

Tangy to be really upset, and I might be tempted to message that I would still use the name, but in reality I wouldn’t. Just think of your mum having 2 granddaughters with the same name a month apart - they couldn’t even be big sue and little sue so would be called sue smith and sue jones within their own family.

Nicknames seem like the obvious solution.

”Alice” might be called Lissie and Allie. Or they may end up being called something rather unrelated to their given names.

My family called me by various nicknames completely unrelated to my actual given name😅 so do many of my friends and my SO tbh.

Onelifeonly · 27/03/2024 06:42

Similar happened to my friend, in that her sister had a boy first and chose the name my friend wanted for her son, though I'm not sure the name had been discussed between them. My friend just used the same name. That was long ago as the kids are grown now - it hasn't caused a problem.

Personally I wouldn't have done it - there are plenty of other names. Did your Nana have a middle name? Or can you change it to something similar?

334bu · 27/03/2024 06:42

Just use the name. 4 of my cousins are called after their grandfather.

WandaWonder · 27/03/2024 06:39

So your sister wanted to use a name you chose yourself, this could be understandable but they added 'stole' does go into dramatic territory

And seems consistent with posters in this situation I wonder if there is a template?

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 27/03/2024 06:38

BreatheAndFocus · 27/03/2024 06:26

Yes, it’s a mean thing to do, but, seriously, just use the name. If it was what you’ve been calling your bump, use it. That’s how you deal with this. Depending on what the name was, you could hyphenate it or use a different nickname, but use it, and, as a PP suggested, make it clear you’d chosen it first and your sister knew this so you were surprised when she used the same name.

This.

>>oh, you’re naming her “Alice” as well? But Nana was such a lovely woman. I love that well soon have two little Alices.<<

if she tries to go on about dibs

>>dibs?What do you mean? I’ve always said that I’d call my daughter Alice. That was supposed to be DS’s name if he had been a girl.<<

but it seems as if the situation is incredibly strained anyway. So OP may just want to “grey rock” tbh… might be best.

Shouldgetupearlier · 27/03/2024 06:36

Tangy to be really upset, and I might be tempted to message that I would still use the name, but in reality I wouldn’t. Just think of your mum having 2 granddaughters with the same name a month apart - they couldn’t even be big sue and little sue so would be called sue smith and sue jones within their own family.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 27/03/2024 06:35

I understand you’re hurt.

She’s trying to actively prevent you from using the name (as well)! Saying she has “dibs” on it is controlling, petty and unnecessarily hurtful. This goes much further than her simply using the name as well.

And I am honestly incredibly sorry that your own sister is trying to control and pressure you like that. This must feel so raw, especially considering the background of pregnancy loss and fertility struggle. You deserve better! Flowers

But as pp said: NOBODY owns a name. Doesn’t matter that your DSis is the older one or that she gave birth three weeks before your DD. Use the name you want!

If that’s your grandmother’s name, it’s your grandmother’s name.

And try to ignore your sister’s pettiness. Don’t give her any power over you and your decisions.

SignoraVolpe · 27/03/2024 06:34

My uncle and his cousin have the same name.
It was normal in the 40’s because often their dad’s had the same name and dc were named after their dad.

My dc and her cousin have the same middle names.

@JessMathews8 Use the name you want. It’s not as if the dc are going to be close cousins if you have such a strained relationship with your dsis.

vanillawaffle · 27/03/2024 06:34

Oops sorry.

Use the name. It's not a random name. It's your nan's name. So it's understandable for it to be used as a family name

vanillawaffle · 27/03/2024 06:33

Use the name.

Velvian · 27/03/2024 06:32

I would just say. " Congratulations, that's lovely. We will have 2 baby Lilys in the family."

ZekeZeke · 27/03/2024 06:30

Ah look I get why your upset, its as if there was an understanding however, as others have said, it's just a name, you don't own it.
Call your DD whatever you like but don't cause any unnecessary drama .
Can the name be shortened or lengthened to distinguish it?

What is this name anyway?

xsagestarsx · 27/03/2024 06:28

If it's an honorary name, I think it's fine to use it twice in the same family. My cousins have children with the same name after my Dad and I don't think twice about it. I think it's great they love and adore him so much that they both want to name their children after him. It's unfair she didn't consider your feelings but I echo what another poster said, nobody has dibs on a name. Your sister can't stop you from using the same name just because she has used it first, either. A lot of people say they're done having babies when they aren't necessarily, nobody knows what the future holds. Could you have a rethink and find another name you like just as much for your baby? And use your grandmother's name as a middle? I'm sure everything will work out in the end regardless of what you choose.
Enjoy your last few weeks of pregnancy and good luck with your birth x

thesangriapeople · 27/03/2024 06:28

I think your sister has been out of order really. It seems quite spiteful.

I don't think you can call her the same thing as that just seems like an extension of her pettiness.

I would find another really gorgeous name and call her that, knowing and taking pleasure from the fact that deep down your sister has a name she doesn't want.

Swipe left for the next trending thread