Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU with being angry with the school?

131 replies

RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 18:04

Back story:

DD, 11, is in year 6 at school and has autism and adhd.

At the beginning of year 6, it transpired that a child in her class had been repeatedly slapping her around the back of the head. The other child was spoken to, told to apologise, and no further action was taken, which I was annoyed with.

On Friday the same child punched DD in the arm. I was on the school premises at the time, and they did not inform me. I only found out when I picked DD up, who was crying.

DD said that the school had told the other child that they must not do it again, but had not received a punishment nor an apology.

I rang the school immediately and asked to speak to the head, who had spoken to both children. Instead, the class teacher called me back and said "the child said she was joking so no further action is required".

I said that this was unacceptable, and I wanted to speak to the head.

It is now 18:02 on Tuesday, and nobody has contacted me despite me calling and emailing. I asked to speak to someone in person when school finished today, and was told nobody was available.

AIBU to think this is completely unacceptable and well within my rights to email the governor 30 minutes ago, or am I just being a Karen at this point? AIBU to expect that an 11 year old be punished for this?

I'm that furious I feel like punching the head to see how she likes it if it's so funny! (Obviously I wouldn't!)

OP posts:
RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 20:58

singingthypraises · 26/03/2024 20:56

YANBU to be annoyed with the school, their response has been less than satisfactory.
YABU to use the name Karen when you meant the word cow or similar. Note- I don't think you were being a cow in any way. Just have a bit of consideration when throwing around a name to make your point.

So many people have said this, and I will certainly take this on board!

OP posts:
singingthypraises · 26/03/2024 20:56

YANBU to be annoyed with the school, their response has been less than satisfactory.
YABU to use the name Karen when you meant the word cow or similar. Note- I don't think you were being a cow in any way. Just have a bit of consideration when throwing around a name to make your point.

RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 20:52

43ontherocksporfavor · 26/03/2024 20:15

I work with this age group and the word ‘punch’ gets used when actually what happened is that someone accidentally had contact. Honestly, it happens all the time. Try to be calm . Are there any marks that would indicate an actual punch?

Yes she has a bruise on her arm.

OP posts:
RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 20:51

You start by informally approaching the HT if you’re unhappy with how the class teacher has handled the situation.

It was the head that dealt with the incident.

OP posts:
RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 20:50

It’s reasonable to pursue this and want your child to be protected from bullying. But you’re going 0 to 60 wayyyy too fast.

I appreciate it may seem that way, however I have my reasons based on the schools previous conduct. Unless immense pressure is applied, my daughter will still be at risk. What the school, and the head, has a tendency to do is try and push things down the road in the hope you will forget about it.

I'll give you a specific example. In reception, my daughter was touched in her underwear by another reception child in the classroom on multiple occasions.

It took 3 WEEKS for the head to return my calls. They did not consider the fact that this may have been learned behaviour, and did not view it as a safeguarding risk.

There was allegedly a bar on them being in the same class, until they decided there wasn't, and put the 2 children in the same class the year they went swimming. I found out about this in the July, I did not get to speak to the head until the November, at which point it was too late to move my daughter classrooms as she would be unsettled.

There have been many other incidents which have never been dealt with properly, and I am a little sick and tired of it.

OP posts:
Pogointospring · 26/03/2024 20:42

It’s reasonable to pursue this and want your child to be protected from bullying. But you’re going 0 to 60 wayyyy too fast. This is nowhere near a governor issue yet. Nor is any consequence for the other child your business - you don’t have a right to know details of punishment, if any, that child received. Your concern needs to be solely your own child and how school is keeping them safe.

You start by informally approaching the HT if you’re unhappy with how the class teacher has handled the situation. You give them a reasonable amount of time to respond (which is not instantly), and if you’re still unhappy you make a formal complaint to the HT in writing. You then give them the specified time in the complaints policy to respond - at my school that’s a minimum of two weeks and potentially four if it’s not straightforward. Only once you have received a formal response from the HT, if you are still unhappy, is it appropriate to make a complaint to the governing body, which you should do in accordance with the complaints policy - which probably specifies to email the Clerk or similar, not individual governors.

I’m a school governor, I have occasionally had parents try and get me involved the instant they’re unhappy and all I can do is point them to the process. It is in place for a reason and getting governors involved too early potentially prejudices things further along. Plus it’s simply not a governor role, it’s very much for the HT to address at this point.

redalex261 · 26/03/2024 20:40

I would feel its reasonable to give the head until the end of the week/Monday. If I was you I would send an email tomorrow stating I expect the other child to be spoken to and told clearly to have no physical contact your DD of any sort - jokey or not it is not welcome or necessary and in their interests not to touch DD at all if they don’t want further complaints or allegations of bullying. I would also push to have them separated in class and both of them told to keep away from each other in the playground to minimise the chance of any further incidents.

Obviously you can’t be told about any punishment, and I would not give a toss about an apology - compelled apologies are never sincere.

In a similar situation my daughter was expected to shake hands, participate in a mutual apology (!) and become friends! I very firmly told the head no, my child had been instructed by me not to interact in any way unless necessary inside the classroom - that way the bullying could not be called “joking” and ignored by the school.

43ontherocksporfavor · 26/03/2024 20:15

I work with this age group and the word ‘punch’ gets used when actually what happened is that someone accidentally had contact. Honestly, it happens all the time. Try to be calm . Are there any marks that would indicate an actual punch?

Cheesetoastiees · 26/03/2024 20:10

Your head teacher sounds rubbish. Put pressure on them to deal with incident property.

By the way totally unnecessary use of term Karen. I know plenty of nice ones who are sick of their name being used in this way.

bobotothegogo · 26/03/2024 19:59

As a classroom teacher, I'd urge you to complain to the headteacher and ask them to clarify how they plan to ensure your child isn't injured again.

Teachers are on their knees, begging for support at the moment and nothing will change until parents kick up a stink.

RainbowColouredRainbows · 26/03/2024 19:57

YANBU to expect a harsher punishment and be taken seriously. But YABVVVU to expect someone to reply to you instantly. Very arrogant and entitled. The head might be in meetings, teachers might have had meetings and then dash off to pick their own kids up. If you want the time and attention that this deserves to be dedicated to the case, you need to give them time to read over and evaluate it properly. Anything done in haste won't be done properly and just a waste of everyone's precious time.

Curioushorse · 26/03/2024 19:53

@Applesan you're right. I hadn't seen that but when I posted.

OP- on the basis there's a bruise I'd be taking a picture of it and sending it in. That should make things more clear.

I hope things are better for you and your daughter tomorrow. It's a particularly fraught time for Year 6 at the moment.

WeMustGetOffTheMountain · 26/03/2024 19:26

RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 19:23

Can disabled people not be aggressive?!

What do you think I'd be able to do exactly? How am I a physical threat? I've already explained, I don't shout, I don't swear, I'm very polite to staff at the school. Being abused is not part of their job distraction.

Being aggressive is more than being a physical threat.

RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 19:23

Can disabled people not be aggressive?!

What do you think I'd be able to do exactly? How am I a physical threat? I've already explained, I don't shout, I don't swear, I'm very polite to staff at the school. Being abused is not part of their job distraction.

OP posts:
Thegoodbadandugly · 26/03/2024 19:21

OrchardDoor · 26/03/2024 18:32

I remember one of the reception staff writing a fawning post on the school twitter page about the bully. I had to sit on my hands to stop myself writing a less complimentary reply about her!

You'd really label a reception child a bully?

Applesan · 26/03/2024 19:20

Curioushorse · 26/03/2024 19:10

See, I mean, it very much depends on the context. I could imagine a scenario where the other child had gone home crying because your child made unwarranted, unwelcome comments about their appearance- which your child has done.

There's a difference between a playful, jokey punch, and 'a punch'- and it is exactly that nuance that an ASD girl would have problems with decoding. Similarly, the slapping in the back of the head (which may well be negative behaviour- but may not fit the definition of bullying).

It might be worth going in, yes, but be prepared for this to be a misinterpretation of the intentions and situation.

I agree with the earlier poster who suggested asking the school how they're going to guarantee your daughter's safety- as a better approach. If something has been done to punish the other child you also won't be told about it.

Please ignore the usual nutter who suggested going to the police.

Her daughter has a bruise though - that's a bit beyond a "jokey" punch

crumblingschools · 26/03/2024 19:12

Please don’t use the misogynistic term Karen, minimises your argument

Curioushorse · 26/03/2024 19:10

See, I mean, it very much depends on the context. I could imagine a scenario where the other child had gone home crying because your child made unwarranted, unwelcome comments about their appearance- which your child has done.

There's a difference between a playful, jokey punch, and 'a punch'- and it is exactly that nuance that an ASD girl would have problems with decoding. Similarly, the slapping in the back of the head (which may well be negative behaviour- but may not fit the definition of bullying).

It might be worth going in, yes, but be prepared for this to be a misinterpretation of the intentions and situation.

I agree with the earlier poster who suggested asking the school how they're going to guarantee your daughter's safety- as a better approach. If something has been done to punish the other child you also won't be told about it.

Please ignore the usual nutter who suggested going to the police.

Applesan · 26/03/2024 19:09

RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 18:53

@Thefutureisourownpath she does have a bruise so it was quite hard I would say!

Crikey - have you shown photos of the bruise to the teachers concerned? I am amazed that they are not taking this very seriously indeed.

My daughter was pushed whilst waiting in a queue this week, she was unhurt but was upset. Her teacher was brilliant about it and took it very seriously. The boy in question is neurodiverse and struggles a lot, 9/10 times he is supervised and this wouldn't happen. But no excuses were made and I was happy that it hopefully won't happen again.

WeMustGetOffTheMountain · 26/03/2024 19:08

RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 18:04

Back story:

DD, 11, is in year 6 at school and has autism and adhd.

At the beginning of year 6, it transpired that a child in her class had been repeatedly slapping her around the back of the head. The other child was spoken to, told to apologise, and no further action was taken, which I was annoyed with.

On Friday the same child punched DD in the arm. I was on the school premises at the time, and they did not inform me. I only found out when I picked DD up, who was crying.

DD said that the school had told the other child that they must not do it again, but had not received a punishment nor an apology.

I rang the school immediately and asked to speak to the head, who had spoken to both children. Instead, the class teacher called me back and said "the child said she was joking so no further action is required".

I said that this was unacceptable, and I wanted to speak to the head.

It is now 18:02 on Tuesday, and nobody has contacted me despite me calling and emailing. I asked to speak to someone in person when school finished today, and was told nobody was available.

AIBU to think this is completely unacceptable and well within my rights to email the governor 30 minutes ago, or am I just being a Karen at this point? AIBU to expect that an 11 year old be punished for this?

I'm that furious I feel like punching the head to see how she likes it if it's so funny! (Obviously I wouldn't!)

So the incident happened on Friday and at 18:02 on Tuesday you're already complaining to governors about lack of action? I don't agree with them saying it was a joke so no further action, however I'm not really sure what else they would do for a child being punched in the arm... They will have spoken to the child involved but they will not be telling you the ins and outs of that conversation for confidentiality...

Caravaggiouch · 26/03/2024 19:05

YABU for using the term Karen 🙄 Follow the school complaints policy, it won’t involve going to the governors at this stage.

WeMustGetOffTheMountain · 26/03/2024 19:03

RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 18:52

You do sound very aggressive though

I'm disabled and use a wheelchair. Definitely not aggressive! I can be assertive though.

Can disabled people not be aggressive?!

Shetlands · 26/03/2024 18:56

RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 18:53

@Thefutureisourownpath she does have a bruise so it was quite hard I would say!

I would take a photo of it to show the HT in case it's faded by the time you have the meeting.

Skippythebutterfly · 26/03/2024 18:55

RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 18:50

I have no idea what your child is like. They have adhd and autism....that could mean they potentially have difficult behaviours at school?? It can make relationships difficult. It can make them impulsive and lash out? I say this because potentially they are not entirely faultless here?
But also because the other child could easily have the same diagnosis but perhaps even more severe.

No behavioural problems at school. She does have social communication difficulties. She was punched because she told the other child she had a lot of mascara on. I do not think it was in a joking way. The child is just claiming that she was joking.

The other child has no additional needs.

Never, ever minimise another child assaulting your child. Your child deserves you to think better of them. I minimised the bullying. I let the school deal with it (ineffectively) and it has taken years - YEARS - to get my child’s mental health back on track. I just really wish I had gone in hard at the start. Let the assaulter know that MY child would not be assaulted and they’d have to find some other punchbag. You are not being dramatic. You are not being an irritatant, you are protecting your child from years of assault by nipping it in the bud early.

RMNofTikTok · 26/03/2024 18:53

@Thefutureisourownpath she does have a bruise so it was quite hard I would say!

OP posts: