Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Hide Savings From DH

237 replies

AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 01:16

First time posting and just looking to find out the general consensus please.

Question: AIBU to hide my savings from my partner?

Back story: Got married far too young and it was a disaster. Ex husband was horribly abusive and had a gambling addiction. He racked up thousands of pounds worth of debt in my name without my knowledge. I only discovered the full extent when he moved out and I started getting the letters that he had previously been intercepting. I was working full time in a good career whilst supporting him because he couldn’t hold a job longer than a few months. I filed for a divorce before my son was 6 months old and we settled that I would take on 100% of the debt providing he didn’t try to gain access to my son. Him being the absolute prize he is, accepted this without question.

I then spent around 5 years trying to get myself back on my feet. It was very very difficult financially. I was still working full time for a good rate of pay but the debts, childcare fees, normal bills etc were absolutely crippling and at times I’d genuinely be counting change to put a few pounds of petrol in the car to get to work. I got myself out of my dire financial state and swore I’d never be in that position again.

Current Situation: Been with my partner now for 10 years, not married but long term engaged, moved in together 6 years ago. I have my 14 year old from my first marriage and we have 5 year old twins together.

My partner is a wonderful man. He’s kind, caring, considerate, trustworthy, hard working and just an all round a wonderful guy. I trust him with my life and have genuinely never known anyone like him. We share everything apart from one thing, my savings.

We both work (him full time, me part time) but my salary for part time is roughly the same as his for full time. We don’t have joint accounts so each month he sends me a set amount (around 60% of his salary). The agreement is that I’ll deal with all the finances, pay all the bills, food shopping, days out, clothes, holidays, presents etc and then all he pays from his account is his petrol and 3 mobile phone bills (His, mine, 14yo).

I understand this set up maybe doesn’t work for everyone but it works well for us because I’m far more organised than him. We have family savings that cover holidays, Christmas etc but my question is related to my personal savings. I have around £15k dotted around in both savings accounts and hidden cash. I’ve always considered it my “run away fund” because it’s money I could use to pay a deposit on a rental and kit it out with basic furniture if I ever had to leave with my children in a hurry. It started as a few hundred pounds and over the years it’s grown and I’m at the point I’m starting to feel a bit guilty.

We are in no way wealthy, but I’d say we were comfortable. Partner is aware we have some savings, with set monthly amounts going to each little pot. I’m just struggling with the idea that I might technically be lying to him by not telling him that I have a secret £15k stashed away. Part of me feels like I need to tell him because we don’t have any secrets, I have absolutely no intention of leaving him and even if I did i would never have to flee in fear (the whole point of my runaway fund in the beginning). The worry with telling him is that he might feel like I’ve been lying and he can’t trust me. The other part feels like I need to keep it a secret to maintain my control and independence. Having grown up with my parents in a toxic relationship I always wondered what would’ve been different had my mum not been reliant on my dads income. I’m also very aware that situations can change in a heartbeat, for better or worse.

What do I do????

AIBU - Yes - He should know about the additional savings because they’re his savings too.

AIBU - No - It’s your money and he has no reason to know anything

OP posts:
MillieIou · 26/03/2024 08:18

ButterflyKu · 26/03/2024 08:10

How about you quote the poster who made the original comment and not me who simply said, ‘I agree’

I am the original poster, there's no point in them having a go at me either as we are all entitled to our opinions on here and my opinion is I'd never lie to my DH that's not how our relationship is and I wouldn't feel comfortable with that. @littlehorsesthatrun The OP has posted here for opinions and mine is just as valid as any. You contradict yourself in saying i need to empathise but then go on to suggest the OP reverses some of the savings and tell her DH about the rest. Sounds like the same outcome to me as "not lying".

Beamur · 26/03/2024 08:15

Fwiw - I don't think 15K is a deal breaker amount - if you were squirrelling away tens of thousands maybe!
I think the advice to have a few months living expenses saved is effectively what you have. It's a safety buffer.

AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 08:15

Fuhjutvb · 26/03/2024 03:30

You earn twice what he does. But he gives you 60% of his salary. No wonder you have savings.

No I don’t. We earn roughly the same, it’s just I work part time??

OP posts:
Beamur · 26/03/2024 08:13

I think as long as you're sharing key expenses it's ok to have seperate savings as well.
I wouldn't have shared savings with a partner. My DH and I have a shared bank account which we pay all of our income into but we each have seperate ones too - I have a side income which I mostly save and he will be in a similar position shortly and I have suggested he has a seperate account for that too.
It doesn't have to be all one way or another. You can absolutely trust and love someone but still want a shred of financial privacy.

AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 08:12

grinandslothit · 26/03/2024 02:18

Does he say and how much does he have say do you think?

No he doesn’t really save, he has a few thousand in his account and he always says it’s mine if I need it for something. He’s aware that I have money put aside but it’s the amount that’s making me uneasy.

OP posts:
Youcannotbeseriousreally · 26/03/2024 08:12

I would 100% stick this money into ISAs for the kids. Job done.

ChangeIing · 26/03/2024 08:11

YANBU to have your own savings.

YABU though to refer to your boyfriend in as your husband in the title of the thread as that totally changes the scenario.

ButterflyKu · 26/03/2024 08:10

littlehorsesthatrun · 26/03/2024 06:48

Have you ever been in a financially abusive relationship? If not, it’s really nice you trust your partner but you could try to empathise with OP who has had the ability to trust severely damaged. OP, could you reserve a smaller amount and let your husband know about the rest? If it were me, I would be thrilled to find out my other half had saved so much!

How about you quote the poster who made the original comment and not me who simply said, ‘I agree’

AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 08:07

westisbest1982 · 26/03/2024 07:48

If these savings aren’t from the 60% he puts in your account for bills etc, then there’s no need to tell him - you don’t know what he does with his all of his 40% after all (reading between the lines), But if you’ve saved from the money he’s earned, then that’s awful, financially abusive behaviour.

No it’s not from money he gives me.

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 08:04

Edited to add:
DP doesn’t have savings as such, he has 1 account that his salary goes into and the left overs stay in the account. I think he has about £2k give or take.

Also to add: Any large purchases also come from our joint savings and I’ll dip into mine if it’s something I want rather something we need. I think I justify it to myself by saying in 6 years he hasn’t had to worry about paying for a single holiday, day out, Christmas or birthday present (apart from mine) Halloween costume, Easter egg, household appliance or decorating.

OP posts:
Ginmonkeyagain · 26/03/2024 07:51

You're not married so it is your money to do as you wish with. Mr Monkey and I are not married. We contribute to running the household according to our incomes and save together for big ticket items but other than that our savings arrangments are our alone.

The only thing you are BU about is keeping is stashed away in little separate pots and even cash. Get it out in to a decent ISA or invesment fund and start earning money on it.

westisbest1982 · 26/03/2024 07:48

If these savings aren’t from the 60% he puts in your account for bills etc, then there’s no need to tell him - you don’t know what he does with his all of his 40% after all (reading between the lines), But if you’ve saved from the money he’s earned, then that’s awful, financially abusive behaviour.

endlessperiods · 26/03/2024 07:43

I'd not want to keep it secret, but I get it. After more than 10 years together my ex husband completely changed personality and became someone I couldn't trust. I had no running away money but managed to leave. I'd never have joint finances with a man again. You think you know someone but things happen. Hopefully your partner will continue being the upstanding man you describe, but you just do not know. I'd continue saving in either my own sole name or into your eldest child's name. However I would also tell him you have some savings but say it's for your child's car/uni/house deposit whatever, and don't call it running away money. Maybe not the exact amount, but just let him know it's a chunk - mostly so that I wouldn't feel bad about keeping it a total secret.

TheDefiant · 26/03/2024 07:39

If you really think your household finances are fair then it's absolutely fine to have savings.

I don't think you should have secret savings.

If you love and trust him the way you do I think you should be honest with your partner.

Perhaps even to the extent of explaining WHY you have/had secret savings.

Then perhaps with his knowledge you could still have and grow a savings account of unknown (to him) amount while moving a proportion of those savings into the DCs name or joint names or doing something with the money (a holiday?).

No need to spend all the savings. Why not split into thirds? One third remains "secret", one third becomes family savings and one third is for a holiday.

It would not be great if a man with family had secret savings.

I really think you need to check that the family finances are fair though. If you effectively earn the same amount but he's paying 60%+ that can't be quite right. Maybe look at all the family finances in total and pro rata them BUT include family savings as one of your budget lines!

Dartwarbler · 26/03/2024 07:35

Theoriginalmrscillianmurphy · 26/03/2024 04:30

Search for threads where the husband has kept the savings quiet.

Key word “ husband”
but the Op is not married - they’re partners

marriage isa financial agreement, as anyone who’s divorced will tell you. If the op marries, then yes, that £15k becomes a marital asset upon divorce and who gets it depends on legal criteria of “ fair settlement “. So, when you marry you’re legally sharing assets as joint and therefore hiding money is pretty stupid and unethical .

but partnerships do not have any financial legal obligation. Assets remain individual and what is shared, legally, is up,to individuals. You are talking then solely about trust

dont conflate marriage vs partnership in the “ what about the men”. It’s nowt to do with men vs women, it’s marriage vs not married

hattie43 · 26/03/2024 07:34

I'd keep it quiet but that maybe because I've also been so broke I've scrabbled for change and never want to go back there .
I'd also not disclose savings but that's because I'm of an age I wouldn't be able to recoup them if it went wrong

mrsbyers · 26/03/2024 07:33

You need to tell him and then open a new bank account where you both transfer in set amounts , that leaves both of you free to save from your own banks and the lines are less blurred - he could argue that he has contributed half of that £15k so he should know about it.

CommentNow · 26/03/2024 07:25

I'd question why you are engaged. At the moment he has no entitlement to the savings. I think this is your mind saying you've healed enough to go deeper in the relationship.

Either way, you need to work out any entitlement he may have to the savings after marriage or how to ring fence it and decide how you feel about having secret savings after marriage.

I think you feel deep down like you are lying and are ready to let go of the past.

WoodBurningStov · 26/03/2024 07:19

YANBU. You both have your own money and pay an equal amount (dependant on earnings), so it's entirely up to you what you do with what remains in your account. You could spend it on handbags or save it. Your dh has the same option, spend or save. For all you know he may have a similar fund.

The only time I'd say you're in the wrong, is if you are skimming money from the joint bills/holiday fund that he pays into and putting it in an account in your name only.

lilyathena · 26/03/2024 07:19

Totally fine in my view. I get it. I did it. And could have written your post several years ago, down to so many of the specific details, including the details of single parenting, previous difficult relationship, toxic parents and the better partner you have found. I never had plans to use it as an escape fund. My then partner had a good life with me and despite his lesser income did fine from it all. Then a few years ago I needed to split. I eventually had it to buy him out of the house and support my child and our joint children to retain the home stability we had. I am so grateful I had those savings. I would never have expected I wouid use them for that ... but life happens.

Believeitornot · 26/03/2024 07:15

x2boys · 26/03/2024 06:51

This is mumsnet if it was a man who had thousands stashed away he would immediately be said to be financially abusive but becsuse it's a women it's fine

I did wonder that. The OP is telling it from her side - but I wonder what her partner would say?

Soontobe60 · 26/03/2024 07:15

OrigamiOwls · 26/03/2024 07:12

What percentage of your income goes on joint spending?
If you use 60% on joint stuff and have saved this money from the left over 40% then I'd say it's okay. If he is subsidising you to allow you to build up these savings then it is unfair as it should be partly his money too.

Hi IS subsidising her though - she said he pays for her and her DSs phones - that’s a subsidy.

Wakeywake · 26/03/2024 07:14

As long as you both put in 60% of your wages towards living expenses and joint savings, you can do whatever you want with your 40%. If what you're saying is that you save in your name from the joint 60%, that's absolutely not OK.

Believeitornot · 26/03/2024 07:13

You don’t have to call it runaway money anymore by the sounds of it, but you can still have these savings.

I don’t have such a fund because I’m the highest earner with the most stable job. I’m not sure how I would feel if my DH had a secret fund.

If I were you I would tell my partner and explain you’ve had these savings and are saving them for the kids when they’re older. But I understand you may not wish to do that.

Cbljgdpk · 26/03/2024 07:12

Your situation is very similar to mine in that I had bad previous experiences which is why I have my own savings. If DH asked me I’d tell him which I know doesn’t really justify anything but honestly I’ve learnt that people can act in really unexpected ways even when you know them through and through so that’s how I feel safe.