Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Hide Savings From DH

237 replies

AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 01:16

First time posting and just looking to find out the general consensus please.

Question: AIBU to hide my savings from my partner?

Back story: Got married far too young and it was a disaster. Ex husband was horribly abusive and had a gambling addiction. He racked up thousands of pounds worth of debt in my name without my knowledge. I only discovered the full extent when he moved out and I started getting the letters that he had previously been intercepting. I was working full time in a good career whilst supporting him because he couldn’t hold a job longer than a few months. I filed for a divorce before my son was 6 months old and we settled that I would take on 100% of the debt providing he didn’t try to gain access to my son. Him being the absolute prize he is, accepted this without question.

I then spent around 5 years trying to get myself back on my feet. It was very very difficult financially. I was still working full time for a good rate of pay but the debts, childcare fees, normal bills etc were absolutely crippling and at times I’d genuinely be counting change to put a few pounds of petrol in the car to get to work. I got myself out of my dire financial state and swore I’d never be in that position again.

Current Situation: Been with my partner now for 10 years, not married but long term engaged, moved in together 6 years ago. I have my 14 year old from my first marriage and we have 5 year old twins together.

My partner is a wonderful man. He’s kind, caring, considerate, trustworthy, hard working and just an all round a wonderful guy. I trust him with my life and have genuinely never known anyone like him. We share everything apart from one thing, my savings.

We both work (him full time, me part time) but my salary for part time is roughly the same as his for full time. We don’t have joint accounts so each month he sends me a set amount (around 60% of his salary). The agreement is that I’ll deal with all the finances, pay all the bills, food shopping, days out, clothes, holidays, presents etc and then all he pays from his account is his petrol and 3 mobile phone bills (His, mine, 14yo).

I understand this set up maybe doesn’t work for everyone but it works well for us because I’m far more organised than him. We have family savings that cover holidays, Christmas etc but my question is related to my personal savings. I have around £15k dotted around in both savings accounts and hidden cash. I’ve always considered it my “run away fund” because it’s money I could use to pay a deposit on a rental and kit it out with basic furniture if I ever had to leave with my children in a hurry. It started as a few hundred pounds and over the years it’s grown and I’m at the point I’m starting to feel a bit guilty.

We are in no way wealthy, but I’d say we were comfortable. Partner is aware we have some savings, with set monthly amounts going to each little pot. I’m just struggling with the idea that I might technically be lying to him by not telling him that I have a secret £15k stashed away. Part of me feels like I need to tell him because we don’t have any secrets, I have absolutely no intention of leaving him and even if I did i would never have to flee in fear (the whole point of my runaway fund in the beginning). The worry with telling him is that he might feel like I’ve been lying and he can’t trust me. The other part feels like I need to keep it a secret to maintain my control and independence. Having grown up with my parents in a toxic relationship I always wondered what would’ve been different had my mum not been reliant on my dads income. I’m also very aware that situations can change in a heartbeat, for better or worse.

What do I do????

AIBU - Yes - He should know about the additional savings because they’re his savings too.

AIBU - No - It’s your money and he has no reason to know anything

OP posts:
namestevalian · 27/03/2024 02:51

You're not crazy . We both have our own private savings too . You need it for your own safety.

Anyone who doesn't is deluded / naive

Ladyj84 · 27/03/2024 01:58

Personally I'm not in a marriage where we withold things from each other so I wouldn't be doing this

AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 01:03

KidsandKindness · 27/03/2024 00:20

If you feel you actually want to tell him about your savings OP, why not have a conversation, during which you ask him if he ever saves anything extra from the money he has left over after paying bills etc at the end of the month. If he says he has a couple of grand tucked away, but doesn't make a particular point of saving, and generally spends it on golf, other hobbies, new clothes from time to time, etc. Then at that point you could say, well I've always made a point of putting away a bit each month, it started off as a bit of a security blanket, after what I went through with ex husband, but has gradually grown over the years, and I've recently realised that it's actually quite a decent sum now. Obviously I think of it as our money the same as everything else we've got, but I was quite surprised when I realised that it's actually £15k, so thought you might like to know that we've got a bit more behind us than we'd realised. That way, he knows you have the money, you make it clear that it's there in case of emergency, kids uni, or anything else that you might need as a family, but don't need to put it into joint names as he will know in the back of his mind that it's actually YOUR savings, and that had he thought of doing this with his own money, he too could have saved a similar amount. If you then do split up at any point, there will be no point in him claiming you've been secretly squirrelling money away, as you will have already made it clear that the money you've saved has come from your 'spare' cash at the end of the month, and NOT from your joint money.

My DH was dreadful with money when we first got together, but like you, after a split where I found myself with no personal credit history, because as a married couple previously, everything had just gone under my ex's name. I decided that I would never be reliant on a man again, so as soon as I was in a position to, I started to save what I could, as and when I had some spare cash at the end of the month. My DH likes a few beers during the course of the week, and is a smoker too, so once we'd both paid our share of the bills, mortgage, etc., his money went on his fags and booze, while I spent mine on clothes, shoes, etc, but always kept a bit back in my savings. We're now married, have been together for more than 30 years, and have a wonderful relationship. We still each pay our share into the pot, and anything left over just gets tucked into one of several savings accounts. He still has his booze, etc., I still have my clothes and shoes, and anything left in whatever account, is OURS, as like you, over the years we have built up trust, and I feel safe, but I do still have money in an account with only my name on it, so that if things did go bad for any reason, I would still be able to get my hands on some 'running away money' if I needed it.

This is very helpful, thank you so much for taking the time to write that. I think this is exactly the kind of conversation I’ll go for

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 00:58

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 26/03/2024 23:57

Ye no one has got married in the past four years....

It really does sound like you've chosen a man you can financially control though, even if it's under the guidance of "well he doesn't want to be invovled". He should be involved. You should be encouraging him to see for himself as it were. Again, if roles were reversed then the story would be very different

I’m honestly not getting the whole “chosen a man you can control” thing. It not like we went on a date and thought ahhh you would be easy to manipulate. We were together 4 years before he moved in and when we met he lived on his own. He’s not some man child that came straight from his mummy to me. He has all the bank log on details, he just doesn’t use them because he trusts that I’ve got everything under control. He hates the admin side of life, he doesn’t even open his own mail, whereas I enjoy it

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 00:49

Thank you. We both pay £200 each into the joint savings each month and then anything I put in to my separate account is left over from my salary or a few hours overtime

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 00:46

andweallsingalong · 26/03/2024 13:52

I don't understand all the angst in the comments. I agree with the voting that YANBU.

My reading is that OPs DP has accepted her son as their son and everything has been split 50/50 with both paying 60% of their salary. Any extra after bills are paid goes into joint savings. OP works less hours for her money to facilitate her looking after their children.

Done "joint" expenses are paid seperately, but both are happy as they balance out eg his commute vs her ferrying their children around.

Both are happy.

Out of her 40% OP saves a substantial chunk. OPs DP chooses to save less. All good as this is their set up and both are happy. OP actually pays more than DP as she dips into her savings for emergencies, holidays and trips. It could be argued that this is unfair and both should contribute more to joint savings.

She's not demanding to know what DP is wasting his money on, but happy to contribute extra to the family from her 40% when needed. To me that's the opposite of financial abuse.

Thank you so much for taking the time to write that. You’ve laid it out perfectly. With alot of the comments on here being so negative I was genuinely starting to think I was crazy

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 00:43

Doggydoctor · 26/03/2024 13:20

OMG for the hard of hearing here is what the op said.

She was divorced from a terrible man who treated her v badly was a gambler and abusive. He walked out on her when her son was 6mths with loads of debt he took out in her name unbeknown to her at the time.
Took her years to clear it, on the understanding he would not be in their sons life.

Been in a relationship for 10 years with DP her son was 4 yr old then.
Moved in after 6yrs have 5 yr old twins together.

He works full time comute 7 mls she works part time wfh.
Both have similiar salaries.
Both pay 60% of salaries to household into an account which pays for everything from household bills to holidays birthday gifts clothes Christmas etc.
Both are free to save from their remaining 40%.

OP will buy something she likes for their rental house from her 40% or from her savings or leftover salary and pays for her own fuel and ferries the children around in her car.
DP pays for his own fuel and 3 mobiles from his 40% left. Lunches he buys presume he could take packed lunch from home if he wanted to.

DP could have saved as the OP does but seems he has not, to the same extent as OP does and she brought her own savings into the relationship and continues to save what she can from her own 40% after bills.

Well done OP you’ve been badly burned in the past and are making sure you won’t be again. No idea why your DP hasn't saved much before or after being with you.

Hope I have remembered your details correctly.

Thank you so much for clarifying what so many people on here seem to be struggling to understand. Maybe now someone else has said it they’ll stop making 2+2=7

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 00:39

PlumbersWifey · 26/03/2024 12:08

You said you'd take on the debt so long as your child's dad doesn't see him? I'm a bit stuck on this. So he has zero contact? Really hope I've got this wrong as growing up without a dad is horrendous emotionally, even if you have a step dad.

Yes zero contact now for nearly 13 years and it has been wonderful. My son has an amazing man raising him and for that I’ll be forever grateful

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 00:37

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 26/03/2024 12:55

It's MN so it works as "what's mine is mine and what's yours is also mine"

Everyone should have savings for a rainy day. Male or female.

It does feel like you might have chosen this man because you can exercise some financial control over him though...

That’s nonsense

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 00:35

CoddlingMolly · 26/03/2024 12:07

Wouldn't it make more sense for him to go PT and you FT?

Financially yes and we have considered the option but despite him being very modern in that he does more than his fair share of household duties, looks after the kids equally etc, he still has that little male ego thing where he thinks he should be out working full time so that I have to work less

OP posts:
KidsandKindness · 27/03/2024 00:20

If you feel you actually want to tell him about your savings OP, why not have a conversation, during which you ask him if he ever saves anything extra from the money he has left over after paying bills etc at the end of the month. If he says he has a couple of grand tucked away, but doesn't make a particular point of saving, and generally spends it on golf, other hobbies, new clothes from time to time, etc. Then at that point you could say, well I've always made a point of putting away a bit each month, it started off as a bit of a security blanket, after what I went through with ex husband, but has gradually grown over the years, and I've recently realised that it's actually quite a decent sum now. Obviously I think of it as our money the same as everything else we've got, but I was quite surprised when I realised that it's actually £15k, so thought you might like to know that we've got a bit more behind us than we'd realised. That way, he knows you have the money, you make it clear that it's there in case of emergency, kids uni, or anything else that you might need as a family, but don't need to put it into joint names as he will know in the back of his mind that it's actually YOUR savings, and that had he thought of doing this with his own money, he too could have saved a similar amount. If you then do split up at any point, there will be no point in him claiming you've been secretly squirrelling money away, as you will have already made it clear that the money you've saved has come from your 'spare' cash at the end of the month, and NOT from your joint money.

My DH was dreadful with money when we first got together, but like you, after a split where I found myself with no personal credit history, because as a married couple previously, everything had just gone under my ex's name. I decided that I would never be reliant on a man again, so as soon as I was in a position to, I started to save what I could, as and when I had some spare cash at the end of the month. My DH likes a few beers during the course of the week, and is a smoker too, so once we'd both paid our share of the bills, mortgage, etc., his money went on his fags and booze, while I spent mine on clothes, shoes, etc, but always kept a bit back in my savings. We're now married, have been together for more than 30 years, and have a wonderful relationship. We still each pay our share into the pot, and anything left over just gets tucked into one of several savings accounts. He still has his booze, etc., I still have my clothes and shoes, and anything left in whatever account, is OURS, as like you, over the years we have built up trust, and I feel safe, but I do still have money in an account with only my name on it, so that if things did go bad for any reason, I would still be able to get my hands on some 'running away money' if I needed it.

AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 00:20

x2boys · 26/03/2024 11:28

In cloud cuckoo mumsnet land I'm sure it does not every women can afford to stash thousands of pounds away though.🙄

Because other women can’t afford to save that amount doesn’t mean I should feel guilty about it. I’ve been there. I’ve been the single mum with nothing and I can guarantee there’s plenty of women who wish they’d done it differently

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 00:18

Eyesopenwideawake · 26/03/2024 11:28

If there was no 'back story' would you be doing the same thing?

If yes then YANBU.

If no then YABU - you're looking back through the time telescope which is not fair on your partner.

Honestly, without the back story then probably not but we live and learn. I was left with nothing and I desperately wish I’d had something stashed away back then.

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 00:16

MillieIou · 26/03/2024 11:23

Would he be as happy knowing there was £15k stashed? Hes happy but he's uninformed.

He’s happy for me to take responsibility and I’m happy to accept the responsibility. By his own admission if I passed tomorrow he wouldn’t even know how to pay the electric bill. He’s never once asked what’s in the accounts and I think he’s happy living in his little bubble knowing everything’s sorted.

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 00:10

MillieIou · 26/03/2024 11:20

How do you define which actual crisp note comes from which person into her personal savings?

Eg:
He pays £1000 a month
OP saves £500 a month

OP couldn't have saved £500 even if none of that £1000 went immediately to her savings. She wouldn't have been able to afford to save it.

As I explained a few times already, we pay equal amounts. Without getting into exact amounts the example would be
He earns £2000 - Pays £1200 to joint bills
I earn £2000 - Pays £1200 to joint bills.
From that £2400 that we’ve paid in, £2000 goes to bills and £400 goes in to savings.

From the £800 I have left I might put £150 into savings. It’s not huge amounts and as I’ve said the £15k has accumulated over 10 years, I’m not putting £500 per month away or anything like that

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 27/03/2024 00:04

Yogatoga1 · 26/03/2024 11:19

Why is he working full time for half the money?

if you want to work part time and take the pay cut then you should both be 50:50 as you both earn the same.

if you both have the same disposable income and ability to save fine, but if you are accessing more than your share then no.

if you want savings why don’t you increase your hours and put the extra away?

Did you read the post?
He works full time for less money because I have qualifications and therefor earn a higher rate of pay. I don’t see how me increasing my work hours (and childcare fees) would help with the question I’ve asked

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 23:57

BronwenTheBrave · 26/03/2024 12:05

Didn’t have time or inclination to read the full post.
But it is fine for a woman to hide savings (or a pension - see recent thread) from her DP, but the other way round invokes LTB.
Simples. To help you with other posts, just remember that it’s always the man’s fault.

You ok hun?

OP posts:
ButWhatAboutTheBees · 26/03/2024 23:57

Ye no one has got married in the past four years....

It really does sound like you've chosen a man you can financially control though, even if it's under the guidance of "well he doesn't want to be invovled". He should be involved. You should be encouraging him to see for himself as it were. Again, if roles were reversed then the story would be very different

AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 23:55

crumblingschools · 26/03/2024 10:58

If the man was taking control of the money and the money was being paid into his current account which the woman couldn't access and then he covered bills and then divided up the remainder of the money in the current account to joint savings and personal savings accounts, neither of which the woman could access, and as a result he had accumulated £15k in a pot which she didn't know about, would be interesting to see what the responses would be.

Also as a stepfather he is being expected to help finance his stepchild with no financial input from the dad. That always isn't seen as a given if a woman has a stepchild.

It may not be seen as a given in your experience but thankfully it is in mine. He treats our son no different to our daughters, we’re a family and they are all treated equally. There are many people out there who are horrible step parents and I couldn’t be with a man who said well the holiday is costing £3000 but I don’t think it’s fair to take it all from the family pot because he’s not mine so pay the 4 of us from the family pot and you pay his separately. That’s awful behaviour and it’s sad that you find that normal

OP posts:
justasking111 · 26/03/2024 23:49

AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 23:31

This is exactly it, thank you. It started as a run away fund and probably only the last 2 years I see it more as a family emergency fund. It’s reassurance that if somethings happens, we’re covered. My partner had a medical issue last year (all good now) but the emergency savings allowed me to give him the reassurance that he could take the 2 months off that he needed to recover whilst only getting 50% pay

So you see that money is a safety net. If either of you lost your job that 15k would be a godsend. Leave it where it is and keep saving.

Say either of you needed an operation and the NHS waiting list was long. You could pay for that operation. I'm dipping into mine for two teeth implants at the moment. I'll be needing a new hip one day. Neither of those will intrude on our annual income.

AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 23:46

jacks11 · 26/03/2024 10:41

I think whether you are unreasonable or not depends on a few factors. How would you feel if he had “secret” savings? And do you think he would be upset to find out about yours? If you would be upset/annoyed/feel betrayed if he had saving he kept secret from you, then I think you are unreasonable to keep it from him. If you really think he would be upset to find you felt you needed a secret savings fund, but chose to keep it from him, then I do think you are unreasonable to keep it a secret (I understand how you got here, but it may be time to reconsider keeping the savings secret).

If he is genuinely a good man and partner, then I think he will probably be ok with it, if he understands why it happened. But I think it possible that he might feel hurt that you felt you needed a running away fund (I think i might be in his position, even if I understood the context). It needn’t be a relationship ending thing, but it might sting a bit. Though, generally I think there are issues you need to address- either you as an individual or you both as a couple- if you feel the need to keep significant secrets or lie to him.

Ultimately, it is your money, so yours to do with as you wish (assuming you are not , in which case the legal standing is a bit more complicated than that, I think).

You are absolutely right so thank you for your wise words and taking the time to reply.

I think it will sting a little and that’s why I’m battling with myself. It wouldn’t bother me at all if he had a secret stash (he might have but I don’t think so) but I think it would hurt if he was to say he had it incase we ever split up, I’d feel like he was thinking it was a possibility and planning to leave.

I think I definitely need money aside that he doesn’t know about, purely for my own comfort but I think the amount is excessive and maybe I could split it in half and put the other half in the joint pot. I could put it in joint savings without him knowing because he genuinely has no clue what’s in the joint savings.

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 23:37

HebburnPokemon · 26/03/2024 10:35

He's subsidising your kid and you have secret savings... 🤔

Also, why aren't you married if you've been engaged so long?

He’s OUR kid. He’s raised him since the age of 3 and would adopt him in a heartbeat if he could.

the reason we aren’t married (not that it’s any of your business) is because there was a little thing called A GLOBAL PANDEMIC!!

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 23:36

femfemlicious · 26/03/2024 10:28

Your partner is setting himself up for a rude shock if you ever split up

Yeah that’s probably true but unless he done something really hideous to me I’d never see him go without. We’ve built a life together and although we aren’t married all our belongings are 50/50, including the family savings, so if we split and there was £4K in it then £2k would be his. The only separate thing is my savings

OP posts:
AlwaysNonStop · 26/03/2024 23:31

Highfivemum · 26/03/2024 10:26

It all depends on the intent… if it is so you have a near egg and so you have money to hand if you need it as a family then yes. If it is so you can spend it or intend on doing other things without him then no.
I like you handle all the finances. My DH does not know what he eats as everything is joint. I have a nest egg that I put aside for us if and when we need it. I song lie about it though my DH knows about it but has no clue how much is in it. He trusts me.
in your situation from wot u have said I would keep it as a nest egg.
there if u need it for the family.

This is exactly it, thank you. It started as a run away fund and probably only the last 2 years I see it more as a family emergency fund. It’s reassurance that if somethings happens, we’re covered. My partner had a medical issue last year (all good now) but the emergency savings allowed me to give him the reassurance that he could take the 2 months off that he needed to recover whilst only getting 50% pay

OP posts:
ZetuianRose · 26/03/2024 23:26

I’ve always had my own finances, in this relationship and my previous one.

As long as what you both contribute to the pot is equitable (not “is he happy with it” but is it actually equitable) then what you (and he) do with what is left over is up to you. He’s no automatic right to know your financial details, you said he knows you save your money, so what’s the issue? Even if you told him, why would you think this would be a problem?

I’ve always been a saver, I have a fair bit stashed away, but I pay my bills too. DP knows I save, I wouldn’t have a problem disclosing what I have, but he also has no say whatsoever about what I do with that money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread