Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel fedup with MiL

61 replies

PennyPolo · 25/03/2024 23:15

I need a little advice and just to rant a little bit about my MiL. It's a bit of a death by a thousand cuts situation and this is such a long post but I'm just ranting to be honest.

I've been with my partner nearly 9 years and we have a ten month old. I've never gotten along with my MiL all that well. We are different people but she for a long long time wasn't particularly warm towards me. I can remember passive aggressive comments right back to the beginning which seems insignificant but builds up.

When I was pregnant we had a disagreement because I wouldn't let her announce on Facebook she was going to be a grandmother (again). I was only 8 weeks pregnant, hadn't told siblings on both sides etc and we are private people, we don't put anything on social media. We wanted to tell people face to face and I was a bit paranoid having taken so long to get pregnant so waited until I was 20 weeks until the MiL could tell extended family. During this time she kept moaning how she couldn't put it on Facebook, couldn't tell her friends etc. My partner ended up speaking to her about it because despite me explaining long time to get pregnant, a miscarriage and under fertility team she just wouldn't stop.

After my 20 week scan we called in to say everything is well, show some photos and let her know she could now tell her friends. She still moaned about not being able to put it on Facebook. She said she wanted one of our scan photos. Didn't ask. Just said she wanted one, the original hard copy. I had two photos. I said I can't give you one of these because if I gave them one and if my parents want one I won't have one. We left then everytime I saw her after that she was standoffish with me and made passive aggressive comments like how I don't clean properly apparently.

They then left the country for 3 months which was a nice break and I actually started getting therapy to help me with my anxiety and my MiL. I told my partner I wouldn't be alone with her anymore but when they came back we had to live with them temporarily (they live in our property and we were having work done on the new house we bought). It was a bit of a frosty welcome from the MiL at the airport after I went to pick them up for my partner who was working.

I had arranged a suprise a private scan for them to come to, my parents already had theirs, the next day. I'd told them what time we needed to leave but they hadn't listened so next morning they're not ready and we very nearly missed the appointment. 34 weeks pregnant me had to run down the street while partner and family parked car. When we got there waiting to go in and explained why we were there and I said she would get to keep the photos from this scan. She said how she'd been upset I'd let my parents have the one from my 20 week scan. My partner stepped in and clarified I didn't say I was giving them a photo. So basically her rudeness was because she'd misunderstood what we said and rather than try and have a conversation she was just passive aggressive.

I'd told my partner I wouldn't be having visitors at the hospital and grandparents and not for the first two weeks after baby was born. I did allow his parents come tomthe hospital in the end (my parents live to far away). Ended up having an emergency C-section. The other two women on my ward had planned C-sections for their own reasons. My MiL was making comments about how some people say it's because they're too posh to push... Time and place...

The next few weeks whenever MiL visits she compares my emergency C-section to her appendicitis surgery or a planned minor womb surgery. My partner was there laying food out for them, making them drinks, washing their dishes while I wanted to scream.

I'd say it was only when baby was about 3+ months old MiL started being the nicest she ever has been to me but still unpredictable. Sometimes nice sometimes random passive aggressive comments. E.g. nanny never gets to see you (has been told she just needs to ask but she never does), said to baby in front of various family at a party has mum not brought you any toys. Another time my partner is on the phone to his dad and brother while holding the baby while I was quickly tidying after her dinner. I then take baby and he's talking to his mum. She said she could hear baby crying earlier so partner explained situation and said now I'm (me) taken over looking after baby to which she replied well I should think so! It was what she said how she said it. It was just rude and even my partner called her out on it. She said it was how my partner had said what he said which was just rubbish.

After that gets better again but she is still so controlling. Bare in mind we see them once a week or less if they're away. Partner works long hours, I look after baby 24/7 and she's still alive, well, very happy. We're out shopping and I notice baby is a bit warm so take a layer off. Me, partner and baby are heading one way, MiL and family another. She tells me make sure baby doesn't get cold. It makes me feel she must think I'm an incapable idiot. I said I know I do look after her all the time. Another time a piece of her food fell on the floor at dinner so I pick it up and put it on the side. She asks if I gave her the food off the floor, I say no. She stares at me as if to say I don't believe you and asks again. Not your bloody business even if I did. The other day me and my partner and eating crisps and she tells us don't eat in front of her (because baby cant have the crisps). Baby is absolutely fine, watching but not upset or bothered in the slightest. We were leaving anyway and as my partner walks in front with baby MiL turns to me and says again don't eat in front of the baby. Another time I comment how we'd been at a party and she'd had a cheese sandwich, is that all?!

She's also a very negative person. Ask her to come shopping with me and baby (olive branch). While out tells me she doesn't like the pram. Later at lunch time tells me I look a less because baby knocked my hot chocolate down my jeans. Says how baby's cousins were happy like her so must be in her genes from her because the cousins only have her in common.

Every question or comment has judgement in in. She tries to tell me what to do and says it's because she's a grandmother and one day I'll understand. My mum doesn't behave this way. She can see how happy my baby is and how I'm looking after baby and knows I'm responsive and she has no concerns at all. MiL is just controlling and is a helicopter grandparent. If they were genuine concerns for my baby's safety and she approached me nicely and explained I could understand but it's not it's just judgement.

I do think she has tried to be nicer recently but because I never know what I'm going to get and what comments she'll make I just feel really anxious around her now. I'm avoiding seeing her at this point and being standoffish myself which I know she probably senses but she hasn't said anything. I know she wants to see the baby more but she never asks and I have said before just to ask. If she asked I wouldn't stop her seeing baby unless we had plans or was sleeping. My partner works six days a week and long hours and I'm not going to take baby round to them with the way she is. I've told partner he can take baby round to visit them when he wants and I won't speak negatively of her when baby is around but after 9 years of trying and being on the receiving end of passive aggression and now judgement I'm feeling done. Partner has admitted although MiL is a sociable person she's very guarded and doesn't let people in easily. I just don't think that's an excuse for how she has and continues to treat me.

Anyone who's got this far thanks for reading. Not sure what to do about our situation really. AIBU?

OP posts:
Coldrains · 27/03/2024 22:10

Yanbu she sounds like a miserable cow. I’ve had enough of my mil now too after a few recent incidents. I’m just going to take a step back but also the information diet sounds like a good strategy so i will try that.

Summerlovin24 · 27/03/2024 21:56

Interfering old bat. See her as little as possible. Dh can take child to see her when u need a break. When u r ready let her look after child without you ef if u need a hair cut or Dr appt or work meeting. So she sees grandchild yet u don't see her. Sorted

Eebee82 · 27/03/2024 21:43

Kitkatcatflap · 26/03/2024 00:40

The Facebook thing would have annoyed anyone but after 9 years in your life, you knew what she was like why would you tell her so early.

Going forward the best thing would be for you to change. She is not going to change but the way you bounce off her comments and respond will make things easier. It's so easy to become hypersensitive to the passive aggressive comments. It gets to the point where you are actively looking out for them and so interpret every little thing.

So she doesn't like the pram - smile - we like it and it's our baby. You look a mess when the baby knocked the drink over your jeans. Laugh it off and say 'Even with messy jeans I'm still younger and hotter than you'. When she makes passive aggressive comments to the baby. 'Nana hardly sees you' I would make put on the same voice and say 'We are worried about Nana's memory as she sees you every week and keeps forgetting'. 'Don't eat crisps In front of her'. I would reply 'Don't panic MIL her will power is better than yours'. She may accuse you of being rude, but seriously I found the only way I got any respect was to fight fire with fire. If you can't think of a quick fire comment. Just roll your eyes and say 'here we go again' or 'I knew you would make a comment'

Take the power back. You have waited a long time for your precious baby don't let MIL ruin those wonderful baby years. Good luck OP.

Spot on. I agree that you're on the alert now, waiting for her next catty remark. Try and have some bitchy one liners ready as she probably catches you off guard so it's hard to think of something in the moment.

Mummaontheedge1 · 27/03/2024 21:33

Talking from experience, go no contact. It will be the best thing for your mental and physical health.

Victoriancat · 27/03/2024 20:55

I'd honestly just go no contact, MILs really aren't always worth the hassle, I'm very glad mine lives on the other side of the ocean!

Soozikinzii · 27/03/2024 09:55

Just to comment as a MiL myself that's yours sounds awful ! You will have to stand up to her and get your DH to stand up.to her . She isn't going to change . Maybe go cold turkey a couple of months and only let DH take LO to see her or be in when she calls ?Take a big step back . Then gradually reintroduce yourself on your own terms . Go easy on yourself !

XFiler · 27/03/2024 09:30

Completely step away from her, no contact other than through dh and let him take dd alone, just don’t see her

LookItsMeAgain · 26/03/2024 13:11

I agree with the poster that said put this particular MiL on an information diet straight away.
Stop sharing your information with her. Only tell her what you want her to know about.
When she comes out with the comments about not being allowed to see your baby, retort by saying "But MiL you are always welcome to see baby so long as you check with us before making what could be an unnecessary trip. After all, we might be out or have an appointment and you would be left with a wasted trip."
Everything else, while it will be hard to train yourself to this new way of thinking, let it wash over you and don't react to it. Think in your head "That's nice" or "Ah well" but don't react to her suggestions or comments.
Don't ask for her opinion unless you genuinely want to hear it.
Get your DH to do the visiting to her and not the other way around - that way he can be the one to leave if/when he's had enough.

YNBU being fed up with her but only you can change how you deal with her. She isn't likely to change towards you so the only other option is for you to change how you deal with her.

MrsRobert · 26/03/2024 10:07

OH can bring the baby to see her and you can have a break. I'd minimise seeing her because eventually the baby will pick up on the atmosphere and there really isn't a need to subject yourself to this. The woman doesn't want to see you.

Cycleaway · 26/03/2024 09:52

She sounds awful. I would imagine that your OH family have put up with this behaviour for so long that they either don’t notice or excuse it. I agree that you need to stop offering olive branches, but as she is clearly doing this to provoke a reaction, I think it would be far more effective to completely ignore it every time she says something like that. You sound like a kind and loving parent, you don’t need to justify yourself to her. Each time she makes a dig stop, take a deep breath, inwardly remind yourself she’s being a twat, and then carry on as if she’s said nothing, change the subject, leave an awkward pause, but try your hardest not to react. She will either move on to someone else to wind up, or make more unnecessary comments (at which point I then would consider being NC with her) but it will become more obvious to everyone around you how horrid she is being. This isn’t about letting her win, it’s about taking the power from her mean words

PennyPolo · 26/03/2024 09:37

@trousersearch that's awful. That intrusion of your privacy is shocking. I'm sorry to hear you've lost both your parents. I agree with you I'd like to have a good relationship with my MiL.
@MarieJG87 and @rainbowstardrops I probably do feel negative at this point. It's been 9 years of not feeling good enough. I actually would like to get along with her but struggle with the anxiety. I don't think anyone would choose to not get along with their MiL.

OP posts:
PennyPolo · 26/03/2024 09:22

@Footyfandango I will clarify because it's not clear from my post. I'd said no to hospital visitors at all because these days you can give birth and be discharged the same day. Thanks to the emergency c section I was kept in two nights which is why I said they could and did visit in hospital. The two weeks after baby was born was grandparents only so they could and did visit. I set this boundary for me as a first time mum with help from my counsellor at the time not knowing how I would feel and I'm glad I did because the birth was traumatic, the baby blues hit me hard, baby cluster fed solidly for a week and I wasn't fit to see people.

OP posts:
SallyWD · 26/03/2024 07:45

I think you've made a good effort but she's just a miserable, passive aggressive person.
I personally wouldn't cut her out or refuse to see her but I'd stop making such an effort. I'd be courteous but cool. Always polite but never react to any of her passive aggressive comments. My MIL made some comments at the beginning and tried to be the big matriarch but I never gave it the time of day. I was never rude, I never confronted her, I never got upset - I just ignored it and carried on doing things my way. She soon learnt and has been the sweetest person ever since!

Foxblue · 26/03/2024 07:40

In a fantasy world, I think id do a variation on grey rock with her.
I'd start out for a bit responding 'don't you ever have anything positive to say' and see how that went down (with this type of person it normally means they cry and make a drama and want you to apologise, so you'd have to be prepared to look puzzled and stand your ground and say 'I don't understand, why is it okay for her to say x y z to me but not for me to say that to her?')
Then move to 'that's nice dear'

In the real world, I'd go for a grey rock 'right, okay [name]' and make that your exact answer every single time.

trousersearch · 26/03/2024 07:38

I don't normally comment on posts like this but yours resonated with me because it sounds exactly like my MIL. I think often when people don't have experience of an MIL like this, it looks like you're the problem.
My MIL is very negative, every single thing she says has a negative spin, or if I would say something about my now 11m old, she'd come back with a comment that infers she knows better. For example, I could say I'm using metanium cream and she'd say that's rubbish and I should be using sudocream, the following week I could reference using sudocream and she'd tell me that's rubbish and I shouldn't use it.
Apart from these things being annoying, when you have this kind of engagement from someone it's so negative and wearing. It makes spending time with them SO unenjoyable.
My MIL works in the hospital I gave birth in, we didn't want to tell anyone when I actually went into labour to avoid constant questions - MIL illegally looked at my medical records to see that I had an induction booked and had fish and chips delivered to the induction ward from the hospital cafe...honestly!!!
For various reasons my husband decided to go lower contact and we have taken a step back from feeling obliged to pander to MIL because she badly let us down on something and took no responsibility.

Both my parents are dead, so I found it a really struggle to come to terms with this relationship with my MIL. There's nothing more I'd want than to have a good relationship with her, and treat her like another mum, but unfortunately she makes that impossible

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 26/03/2024 07:37

My MIL used to do this kind of thing. It took a few goes of me just walking straight out of there with the baby and she realised she had to keep quiet. Things are ok now 😂

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 26/03/2024 07:35

She sounds jealous and insecure, you should pity her. And stop trying to cultivate the relationship, just leave it to your DH. She’s probably given “her whole life” to being a mum enjoying the control that brought, and doesn’t know how to handle not having that control anymore.

When she says something minor level rude, reply ‘my goodness, did you mean to be that rude?’

When she comments on your parenting ‘my daughter is quite happy as she is, thanks. I didn’t ask for your advice’

If it’s very rude then ‘I will not have you around my daughter if you keep undermining me like that in front of her, do you understand?’

Easipeelerie · 26/03/2024 07:34

Cut her off.

GoldenDoor · 26/03/2024 07:30

Stop trying. You owe her nothing by. Put her through the friends and colleagues filter. If you wouldn’t accept this for a friend then stop seeing her.

i promise your child will pick up on this being an acceptable way to talk to people. She doesn’t get to be in your life just because she’s a generation above you and related

Maraa · 26/03/2024 07:27

Just cut her off. My mil is the most toxic person I’ve ever met and sounds similar to yours. The drama we had over not letting her put our baby announcement on Facebook before telling some of my family members and friends….. it ended up being a two month none talking period.

but honestly, for your sanity tell your partner you can’t have a relationship with her anymore. I did that and he understood and she became so toxic that we haven’t spoken to her for 6 months now. And life is easy again, she gave me so much anxiety it was horrendous.

I feel for you!

Ihearyousingingdownthewire · 26/03/2024 07:15

Cut her off. Make no more effort. She’s foul.

vanillawaffle · 26/03/2024 06:23

Oh my goodness what IS her problem!

I'd be having nothing to do with her

Nothankyou22 · 26/03/2024 06:18

My ex FIL was like this but I’d have full blown rows with him because I’d laugh in his face at his comments and he’d go crazy, he was a prick to everyone though.

Powderblue1 · 26/03/2024 06:02

She sounds like my MIL. We're now low contact with her.

rainbowstardrops · 26/03/2024 05:59

Sorry but I kind of agree with @Footyfandango. I appreciate that your MIL might be critical or negative but reading your post, I got the impression that you actively look for issues when your MIL might not have meant anything. I'd like to hear her side of the story!

Swipe left for the next trending thread